Manjit Singh Sood v. Financial Commissioner (Revenue) & ORS.
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
--
2&&( ------ %$*$*&,%1
3%1+/+
*,#,)*#4
%6%,/%7 /,8#9 &1+-------
%+0&,(%,$+ -
#,8*$ 2&&( ------ %$*$*&,%1
3%1+/+
*,#,)*#4
%6%,/%7 /,8#9 &1+-------
%+0&,(%,$+
; <
2 2
1%+%,$ 13#,%%$ .#=/17 (6&)#$%
1- -22%%5#17 (6&)#$%
0%$*$*&,%1
1%+0&,(%,$ &-
+- ->- /,(#47 (6&)#$%
1-
-!-
#$$%?#47 (6&)#$%
0%$*$*&,%1
1%+0&,(%,$ &- 1- -2- #4*7 ((*$*&,#4 -- /,8#9-
12/,,@ >- 2*,:4#7 (6&)#$%
1%+0&,(%,$ &- 9&$.
)#+%+- - - 2
.*+ +.#44 (*+0&+% #9&6% 1%'%11%( $?& 0%$*$*&,+ *-%-
9&$.
)*6*4 0%$*$*&,+ 1%4#$% #00&*,$5%,$ #4&?#47 %.+*4 #4#).#/17 !*+$1*)$ 2.#.%%( .#:#$ #:#1
+.&1$ B2 2 #:#1C-
- 1#@%1 '*4%(
/,(%1 1$*)4%+ &,+$*$/$*&, ,(*# *+ +%$$*,:
#+*(% --
,,%D/1% A7
&&0,#:#1 !*6*+*&,7
&&0,#:#1
+.&1$ ;<(- &55*++*&,%1; A- -
,,%D/1%
*,#,)*#4
%6%,/%7
/,8#9
+.&1$ ;<(-
*,#,)*#4 &55*++*&,%1;-
/1$.%1 01#@%1 .#+ 9%%, 5#(% /0.&4(*,:
-
,,%D/1% 7 &44%)$&17 2 2 #:#1
+.&1$ ;<(- &44%)$&1;-
-
1#@%1 '*4%(
/,(%1 1$*)4%+ &,+$*$/$*&, ,(*#7 *,$%1 #4*#7 *+ *++/#,)% # ,#$/1% )%1$*&1#1* +%$$*,:
#+*(% -
,,%D/1% 7 &44%)$&17 2 2 #:#1E --
,,%D/1% 7 #4+& A- -
,,%D/1% A7
*,#,)*#4 &55*++*&,%1-
-
&1 91%6*$@7 '#)$+ .#6% 9%%, $#=%, '1&5 - 1*%'4@7 &, (%5*+% 2.1*
#,8*$ 2*,:.7 01%6*&/+
%,%1#4 #4&?#47 %.+*4 #4#).#/17 !*+$1*)$ 2 2 #:#17 01&)%%(*,:+ ?%1% *,*$*#$%( '*44*,:
/0 6#)#,)@7 ?.%1%*, 2&&(
0%$*$*&,%1 E #,8*$ 2&&(
1%+0&,(%,$ &-
0%$*$*&,%1
1%+0&,(%,$ &-
#4+& 1%+0&,(%,$ &- ?%1% )#,(*(#$%+-
- $ #00%#1+ $.#$ 2/9 #:*+$1#$%7 #4#).#/1
+.&1$ ;2!; 1%)&55%,(%( )#,(*(#$/1%
#00&*,$5%,$ 6#)#,)@ 04#)%( 5#$$%1 9%'&1% &44%)$&1-
- <%#1,%( &44%)$&17 6*(% - 7 #00&*,$%( 2&&(
0%$*$*&,%1 #4&?#4- - <%#1,%( &44%)$&1;+ - )#5% ).#44%,:%( 9%'&1% '&/1 )#,(*(#$%+7 ,#5%4@7 2*,:.7 #48*,(%1 >/5#17 #,8*$ 2&&(
#,9*1 '*4*,:
$.%*1 +%0#1#$% #00%#4+-
'&/1 #00%#4+ )#5% (%)*(%( 6*(% )&55&, -- 7 ?.%1%9@ #00%#4 '*4%( #44&?%( .% #00&*,$%( ,%?
#4&?#4-
-A 00#1%,$4@7 )&55&, -- 7 )#5% ).#44%,:%( 2&&( ?%44 #,8*$ 2&&( '*4*,:
$.%*1 +%0#1#$% #00%#4 1%6*+*&,7
1%+0%)$*6%4@7 9%'&1%
*,#,)*#4 &55*++*&,%1-
- &$.
#9&6% 1%'%11%( #00%#4 ?%44 1%6*+*&, 0%$*$*&, 01%'%11%( 2&&( #,8*$ 2&&( )#5% (*+5*++%(7 6*(% )&55&, A- - A- , #'&1%5%,$*&,%( )*1)/5+$#,)%+7 *,+$#,$ )*6*4 0%$*$*&,+ .#6% 9%%, '*4%( 9%'&1% $.*+ &/1$7 1%4*%'
+7 ,&$*)%( .%1%*,#9&6%- -
%#1(- - , 01%+%,$ )#+%7 &44%)$&1 #00&*,$%( 2&&( #4&?#47 6*(% - 7 &9+%16*,:
/,(%1
A
!
" #
#
$ ! !
% $
% !
#
!
! !
&
' ( #
#
)*
+,-.*
/
+
& # + 0(
+ % 1
! !% # !
# ! # % 1 + #+ % % #
'$
!
#
!
#
% ! #!
'$
#!
'$
2
#
!
'
3
#
1
#
4 -
, #00%#4 '*4%( #:#*,+$ &44%)$&1;+ - )#5% #44&?%( #00&*,$%( 6*(% -- &9+%16*,:
/,(%1 #!
!
!
+ # !
&
' (
#
#
5
+ #
!
# ! #
%
! + # 5 #
# # #
!
%
1
!
# ! % #
#
#
#
#
# #
#
%
% #
#
! ! #
2 #
%
! # !
# ! #
!
#
),-6*-,- # '
3 2 # !
!
#
75 8 "
'
3
#
9 4 -
0%1/+#4 #9&6% %D$1#)$%( ?&/4( +.&?
$.#$ :&$ +?#@%( '#)$ $.#$ *+ &,4@ )#,(*(#$% 9%4&,:*,:
%,%1#4 )#$%:&1@ <#59#1(#1* #4+& 0%1$#*,+ %,%1#4 )#$%:&1@-
, 5@ )&,+*(%1%( 6*%?7 #001&#).
#00&*,$*,:
*+ $&$#44@ 5*+04#)%(-
- $ *+ #4+& &9+%16%( $.#$ ?.*4% #44&?*,:
#00%#47 '*4%( 2*,:.7 (*( ,&$ +%$ #+*(% - 7 &44%)$&1 *$ *+ #4+& ,&$ '&1$.)&5*,:
1%:#1(+ '#$% $.1%% &$.%1 #00%#4+7 ?.*).
?%1% #4+& (%)*(%( 6*(% )&55&, -- -
- .#$ #0#1$7 $.%1% *+ ,& '*15 '*,(*,:
$.#$ &, (#$% - 7 &44%)$&1E # 1%+*(%,$ #4&?#4-
$ *+ &9+%16%( $.#$ # +0%)*'*) #44%:#$*&, .#+ 9%%, 5#(% 0%$*$*&,%1
2&&( $.#$
*+ ,&$ # 1%+*(%,$ #4&?#4 +/00&1$ +#*( 04%#7 .% .#+ 04#)%( 1%4*#,)% &, 6&$%1+ 4*+$ *5# 0%1$#*,*,:
@%#1 7 7 A 7 ?.%1%*, ,#5% *+ 5%,$*&,%( #$ 2%1*#4 &- -
, $.*+ 1%:#1(7 # +0%)*'*) #6%15%,$ .#+ 9%%, 5#(% 0#1# 0%$*$*&,7 ?.*).
1%#(+ /,(%1
,,
,
*
30 ! "
# #
! 30
! ! ! *--: *-,;
1 1&<:7 8 % + =#
! #
3,
*
*0-,*-,6
)-->*-,;
!?
-A $ *+ *,$%1%+$*,:
,&$% $.#$ 1%+0&,+% +#*( #6%15%,$7 .#+ $#=%, '&44&?*,:
+$#,( 0#1# 1%04@
,,
# "
"
!
"
#
2
"
#
1 1<0 <@4 -
0%1/+#4 ,,%D/1%
A ,,%D/1%
?&/4( +.&?
$.#$ ,,%D/1%
A *+ )&0@ #(.#1 #1( #4&?#47 .&?%6%17 (#$% *++/% +/).
#(.#1 #1( *+ ,&$ '&1$.)&5*,:-
.% &$.%1 (&)/5%,$ *+ 8#5#9#,(*
,,%D/1%
@%#1 A7 (%0*)$*,:
4#,( .&4(*,:
#4&?#47 .&?%6%17 +#*( (&)/5%,$ #4+& (&%+ ,&$ +/9+$#,$*#$% .*+ 04%# 1%+*(%,)% #4&?#4 ,,%D/1%
*+ 1%+*(%,)% )%1$*'*)#$%7 ?.*).
.#+ 9%%, *++/%( &, - - 7 ?.%1%#+ &44%)$&1 &, - -
.% #+0%)$ *+ #4+& 1%F/*1%( 4&&=%( *,$&-
6*(%,$4@7
*,#,)*#4 '#*4%( ,&$*)% *,'*15*$@ -- 7 ?1&,:4@ /0.%4( &55*++*&,%1;+ &1(%17 6*(% A- -
, &$.%1 .#,(7 #4$.&/:.
#00&*,$%( &44%)$&1 9/$ .#( #44&?%( #00%#4 &9+%16*,:
$.#$ +*,)% *+ ?&1=*,:
# +$#50 6%,(&1 %.+*47 $.%1%'&1% .% ?*44 ,&$ #6#*4#94% 6*44#:%1+ #4+& $.#$ .*+ 4*)%,)% )#,)%44%( +%44*,:
+$#50 0#0%1+ ).%#$*,:-
- , 5@ )&,+*(%1%( 6*%?7 #6#*4#9*4*$@ # )#,(*(#$% *+ # 6*$#4 )&,+*(%1#$*&,E ?.*).
*+ #4+& 1%F/*1%( )&,+*(%1%( ?.*4% #00&*,$*,:
# )#,(*(#$% 0&+$ <#59#1(#1- - , 6*%?
#9&6% (*+)/++*&,7 - E -- A- - &44%)$&17
*,#,)*#4 1%+0%)$*6%4@ #1% +%$ #+*(% 5#$$%1 *+ 1%5#,(%( &44%)$&1 '1%+.
(%)*+*&,7 #'$%1 #''&1(*,:
(/% &00&1$/,*$@ .%#1*,:
#44 )&,)%1,%( 0#1$*%+7 #))&1(#,)% ?*$.
4#?-
$ *+ '/1$.%1 (*1%)$%( $.#$ &44%)$&1 +.#44 (%)*(% 5#$$%1 ?*$.*, '&/1 5&,$.+ '1&5 (#$% 1%)%*0$ )%1$*'*%( )&0@ $.*+ &1(%1-
-
%+/4$#,$4@7 9&$.
0%$*$*&,+ #1% 0#1$4@ #44&?%( (*+0&+%( #'&1%+$#$%( $%15+-
- %,(*,:
#004*)#$*&,
+7 *'
#,@7 +.#44 #4+& +$#,( )4&+%(-
.&$&)&0@ $.*+ 04#)%( &, )&,,%)$%( )#+% '*4%-
2
!
--
+8=+ .%$.%1 +0%#=*,:1%#+&,%(
"%+
& .%$.%1 1%0&1$#94% "%+
&