Harpal Singh @ Rinka v. State Of Punjab And ORS













 






!"#$%&!"'

()!)!"(

*( +,+ ) )( ,"- . "/)$( + &(+"/(")+ 


 
 
 

    (+(")0  "-((2$

4/25 )(

/!)6 $

/ 474,"- . 
  
 $(

6( !")$( (+(")()!)!"!+ !++, /!

(5)!"+) )$( (+"/(")+)#

")+!9:(('+

 ())$(()!)!"( )3(()$!+

3! 6 3(3.( (5)!" / )$(,"- .7/
"/,5) + (3

6&( ( +(5)4;

$( (!"

(/) +<)$(5)= & > ,"/( (5)!" ?

>?

;  5)  "/  (5)!"+  ;04  @4
? ? 0@  
 )   !5(  ) )!"  
4 3

 :

(#!+)( (/  # !"+) )$(  ()!)!"(  ( :

+  5"2!5)(/  +(")("5(/  )  ,"/( #  &     6(

+  :!)$  !"(  2!/(  -,/#3(")  /

  ++(/.6//!)!"

(++!"+A,/#(43

 ## !(2(/.6

(+ !/-,/#3(") 5"2!5)!" "/ +(")("5(4)$(()!)!"( ! (/

" .( ()$!+
, )4:$!5$!++)!  ("/!"#

/3!++!"2!/( )(/  :

!))(" (B,(+):

+3 /(.6)$(()!)!"(

#

+!9:(('+

 ()3(()$!+

3! 63(3.( +")$(# ,"/)$ )$!+

)$( +/!(/ "/3)$( !+ /$( (

():3!" 5$! / (" "/" 6

  )$(:!

(!+)$( () '

)$(3  C(

"(/5,"+(  5")("/+)$ )5 !3 )$( ()!)!"( +.((" (-(5)(/")$(.

) 3

 C(

"(/5,"+(  )$( 5")("/+)$ )50 55,+(/ 4"

3( 64 ++ !"#$%A ++ +

5$(/)$!+
, ).6:

! !"#
&

   

") 

 (4:$!5$:

:(/2!/(

  " (+"+()")!5( 3)!"4 ( 6$ +.((" ! (/4:$!5$!+ " / C(

"(/) )(5,"+( ")$(.

( 6$ ++(/)$( +,.3!++!"+3 /(.6 (

"(/5,"+(   (+,.3!)+)$

!( +)$(()!)!"(  !(/

 ( $!+$,+( "/$!+ +(:

+!"!)!

)(/))$(!+)

)(43

2!/( ())(  > "/ (533("/ )!" :(2( 4)$(!+)

)(4 3

2!/( ())( > > )(/),( !")("/(")4
(")

A ! 4 3

))$(()!)!"( 3 6!"/, #(!"/ ,#+, 6.63 '!"#5") 5)+ :!)$.

/( (3(")+!"5 +($(!+#

")(/

 (")$(.

)

!+)

)(43

4)$(5 

 ( (-(5)(/ ## !(2(/.6+ !/ 4)$(()!)!"( ! (/
 !) ()!)!" > >4:$!5$:

+/!+3!++(/ +:!)$/

:"2!/(

/

   # !")$(()!)!"( +,.3!))(/$!+ "5$ )"

#

 ()3(()$!+

3! 63(3.( +!")$(6(

  "/$!+5 +( (533("/(/ "/!"!)!

)(/)!+)

)(43

"/ (533("/ )!" "/, )!3 )( 6)$(+ 3(:

(-(5)(/2!/(

>  ")$(# ,"/)$ ))$(/() ! +3(")!"(/!")$( "5$ )"

+,.3!))(/.6)$(()!)!"(

 (:( (") ,"/).(5

(5)

 

/  )$( 

#,3(")+  /2 "5(/  .6  (

"(/  5,"+(   )$(

)!(+ "/$ 2( +#"()$ ,#$)$(/5,3(")+ . (")$( ! ( /3!))(/ 6450 55,+(/ 4"

3( 64A ++ !"#$ %A ++

5$(/)$!+
, ).6:

! !"#
  

 (4:$!5$:

:(/2!/(  $(

( (2 ") )!"  !+ /,5(/ 0 D(  $ 2(  ) '("  !")  5"+!/(

)!"   )$(  .2(  + !/ 5!

5,3+) "5(+  "/  3 /(  "  ))(3)  )  +) !'(  )$(  .

"5( .():((")$( ++,

"5(#!2("""(+!/(.6)$(3(3.( + )$(  "5$ )  (#

/!"#  )$(  5"/,5)    )$(  ()!)!"( "/  )$(

($("+!"+ )(:!)$,) "6.

+!+ "/$ 2(

!2(/

))$(5"5 ,+!")$ )!)!+)$(. !# )!" )()5, !3(.6+) !5)2!#!

"5( "/+,( 2!+!"4(+(5!

62( )$( +"+:$

( !'( 6)!"/, #(!" "6 5)!2!)6,"/(  5).,)+!"5(/(+!)(#!2!"# ),"!)64"3 +.(("

5(/" /")$(.

:$!5$)$(!"!"$ /.(("

3(/  (#

/!"#  )$(  ()!)!"(  !"/, #!"#  !"  +3,## !"#

5)!2!)!(+ )$("

5)!5+()54:(/") !"/ "6.

+!+) ( 6 ,"  )$(  #("(

!+(/ 

($("+!"+  $(    / >  ""(9, (0!+)$,+ !

. ().(+() +!/( +!)!+ 2( .

)!3)$(+ 3( +)$( )(/ > >:$!5$ +(

!( +() +!/(.6)$!+
, )!")$(:

!)()!)!"(

!(

! (/.6)$(()!)!"(  $(:

!)()!)!"!+ :(/3,#"(/ )(/> !++() +!/($(()!)!"( :, /.((")!) (/)#

 (

+( $!++) ),) !#$) +)$(

($("+!"+

 #,( "/:!)$,) "6 ,"/ )!" :(2( 4!")$(!")( (+)

-,+)!5(4) '!"#!")5"+!/(

)!")$(

($("+!"+

+4:(/((3!)

)()#

")5"5(++!"

 ())$( ()!)!"(  +,.-(5)  )   5"/!)!"  )$ )  $(  :, /  "!+$  "

,"/( '!"# "/+, ()6))$((

(5))$ )$(:! ")!"/, #(!"

+!3!

5)!2!)!(+ :$!5$$($ +.(("5"2!5)(/ "/

5!"# +(")("5( "/!"5 "6+,5$(2("), !)64)$(( 3!++!"

(#

/!"# 

 (  :, /  5( +(  )  (9!+)4  )$(  33(")  )$( ()!)!"( !"/, #(+!" "6+,5$ 5)!2!)6):!  6+.(("

))$() ,)$ !)!(+)$ 2(5"+) ")2!#! ")$(5"/,5)

)$( 
()!)!"( (#

/!"#$!+3 !") !"!"##/.($ 2!,

"6)$ )))$(+(5, !)6 )$(5,") 6 $(

 (:! .(#

")(/))$(()!)!"( :!)$!" !/

"(3")$ "/!):! .(5"/!)!"

+ (/$( (!"

.2(E ( ,+ /5,3(")+ . (")$( ! (!"5 ,/!"#)$(

) )$(!+)

)(43

"/)$( ( 6 ! (/.6 (+"/(")0 ) )(4!)!+5 (

)":$( (4!)$ +.(("3(")!"(/ +)$:)$ )!+)$( ))$() )((5, !)6 "/))$(1 ,. !5 !"5 +()$( ()!)!"(  !+  ( ( +(/  " 

 ( 2("   +!"# (  +"  $ +  ")  .(("

3(")!"(/:$! (/(5 !"!"#

 ())$(()!)!"( $(()!)!"( +") 533!))(/ "6- ! 

("5( "/$ +")3!+,+(/)$(5"5(++!" .

/, !"#("/("56 )$() 5((/!"#+ $(5"/,5) !+

( (2 "):$! (#

")!"#5"5(++!"

 (3 +.((" 5(/ " /")$(.

:$!5$ "!"!"5 ".( 3(/)$ ))$(()!)!"(

6!"/, #(!" 5)!2!)!(+ 

5)!5+()5 !3!

B,(+)!"5 3(, $(

!"#.( ()$(!2!+!"@("5$

> )$!+
, )!"



!!"
#$
% &'
 (
#!)"*
  &
& 
 4:$( (!"4!)$ +.(("$( / 0 $()( 3F(5, !)6 )(F,) )$((9 (++!"+ F

"/ F4 "/F,. !5 F!+5"+!/( (/3 (#

2()3

!+(

3:!)$!" ,)+!/()$() )()!+#("(

6,"/( +)/

" 5) ## (++!"

3,)+!/(4 3! !) ") "/)(

!+)+ (

)!"+  ("#!"(( (/  .6  (!#"  #("5!(+  )  5 "  +  .(

(5)(/.6 ++!"# 5 ++!

!(/!"

)!" !'( /5,3(")+4 +(5 ()+43 +()5) (!#"5,") !(+ ,#$,"/(+!

. (

(!#" !"'+" 5):$!5$+(+ )))$() )(
!+).( 5"+!/( (/

(5)!"#)$(+(5, !)6 )(F,. !5 F4  $:(2( 4  !+  +6""63,+  :!)$  ,. !5  +

()6  )  !+ +3()$!"#3 ()$ "3( ( : "/ 2( 6.

5$

5(/(+") ( /),. !5/!+ 1 ,. !5 !+!")("/(/) (2(")#

2(,. !5/!+ 4:$!5$!+") )$(  + 3(  +  3 "5(   :  "/     $(  ))(  !+ 53

)!2( 6    (++(  #

2!)6  "/  !" 

5)    5

+!#"!

!5 "5(" 5):$!5$/(+")

(5))$(,. !5

#(

$ +"!3 5)"!)4!+")).() '(" " 5)

(5)!"# ,. !5 $(/!+)!"5)!".():((" : "/,. !5 !+"( /(# (( "/(9)(") 5$

)$( 5)!"B,(+)!""+5!()6")$(5 .

5$ : !)

(5)+!"/!2!/, +/!

(5) 6!"2 2(/ +/!+)!"5)

3)$( ,. !5

#($!+:, /

!+( : "/ . (3" 6 $() ,()(+)!+)$()(")!

!)6 )$( 5)!"B,(+)!""( 5)

(5)+3(!"/!2!/, "/ 5 +"+:$! ( ")$(

  )$,#$ +!3!

"

), (3 6!3 5))$(,. !5

#("

5):$!5$/!+), .+)$((2(")(3  !

( )$(,. !5

#(

(5)+)$(3 ,. !5 $(+( +(5)+

().( 5"+!/( (/  .6  )$(  5"5( "(/  !+) !5)  1

)(+  53()(") ,)$ !)!(+,"/( 5):$! (/(5!/!"#) (533("/ ")) (533("/)$()(3

( ( "

 (  "/? ++!"#    )(3

6  ( ( +(  .6  )$( 53()(") ,)$ !)!(+,"/( )$(5)$((9( 5!+(!+")).( !#$) 65"/,5)(/ "/)$(5"5( "(/!+)

"/?

)$(53()(") ,)$ !)!(+

()  6)$(!

3!"/")$(.

!",)+ (5(!2(/.6)$(3 (533("/!"# ++!"# "

+)$(5 +(3 6.( )(3

( ( +"

 ( !3!

2!(::

+) '(".6)$!+
, )!"5 +("+)


,)
 !!"
#$
% &'
 (
 #!)"*
 

&
&


55 /!"# 64)$( (+(")()!)!"!+ :(/ "/)$(()!)!"(

!+$( /(")!) (/

 ( !/ )::(('+

3)$(/ )(

$!+ ( ( +(.6)$(- !  ,)$ !)!(++,.-(5)) "!+$!"# ","/( '!"#))$(

(5))$ )$(:! ")!"/, #(!"+!3!

5)!2!)!(+ :$!5$$($ +.(("

5"2!5)(/ "/,"/( #!"#+(")("5( +:(  ++, ()6))$(+ )!+

5)!"

,( !")("/(")4 
(")

 A ! 4  3

  $(  ()!)!"(  !+  /!

(5)(/  ) +,

("/( .( ()$(- !  ,)$ !)!(+"(9!

!/

 (

5$4 -
  .

-

  $()$( +( '!"#?

+"(/ G(+ $()$( . ( G(+