Ram Chand Garg v. Fci And Otrs
!
" #$%$ & $!'$ $ $ $ & $!
&( ) *+
,* ./ !(01( ) (2
+4+ "
)
)(( + !
+
!"#$%&$'(#"($ )(""
, 36(+7 21.$) *(
!(8 +1 (2.7
$) *( 91 74
5:40(.$) *(
+;" <<<< "($ )(""
*%
5(=+ >4(+1 2 )( ?@$
;/5(++ )-= *4 & ."
)(.B
(*
1B
C
-=
-=1 )+*5 (=(41 = )/1(+-
(+) ) = ..@;(
291 )4*
+*( 5(=-=1
+(2 (5 1
= (+91*404( *1(+-
05
1(
+(+ () )?D 5(++ ) -= ( (2 2 & . "
)
)( C
91 -= 95
)-=1
1(+
)+0++ ) % (*+ *(+ ( 1(1
8
)"
)(1 ( (+E"E(+$+++( () ; = ( ?
40( = ) (+ ( (2
1 1 9(+ * .1 9(++ )91(*1(2
+1
)( )?$
;91( ( 2(
1(91
)("
)7 * &+-4
"7&.%161.1
(
91 05 =
(0 =! ( )1.!(0:(( )7: 45(* 00 )5 (2 + *671#::(5
.F !
) 9(+ (55 ) (+ >4= * . 91 ( (6 2
+)
) -= 1 5( + (+ 9 (+ (*+ ( **40+( +*
*4) )1(1
9(+
(+*1(2
5 ) (2( + 10 &+*5 (= (41 = 7
!
2
(( (2 .". 4 8(-91 (2
2911 ) 2+ >4= *
(
01 *1(2 (2( +10) )/$
; $ ((5+ (- 4 = (+.0( 9(+(2(
45-=
( )+1 9*(4+
* )( )@D $
; 9(+ ++4 )
(
291
05 =
+!
5= +1 9*(4+ )( )@D$
;
D9(++4-0 )-=1
.1 .
)
0542
)?@$
;/*
*4) )1(
1(+-
9
2=
( *1(2 +(2( 10 +
0(5(** )42
5 (2 *6*(
- )
).1 .1 54 +10
(+) ( )(-
9(+ 05 ) 45
$55 ( $
; 9(+
5 ) -= 1
- ( (2 & ."
)
)($55 (9(+40( =)+0++ )( ) ?D $
;? * *( ) )
)@G$
;G (
)*
+4-0+1(0542
+( (- - (+) - 24 84+ ). 2(( )(-(= )+*5 (=(41 =
-
( 5 >4=9(+*
)4* ).1 9(+
**(+
(6 451
++4 (2( + +4-0 ) 1( ( (5+ + 0( = = (+.
5
) 2+* 4)
- ( (
!
D
"7(!
+?
>4= 0+ !
/G(+ +54( ) !
D 9(+ *
)4* ) .
+10
+(- (+) +41 +4-0 )1(1
0(
)5 (%161
0
0- ?? (=??G
9(+ 01 %161
/??G
( + 7( 24
9(+ *4+ )( 5())=+ *6
=(- 4+
0
1+7 *6 *(
9(+)
#( 4(=.???(1 +++4(
( ()= +
) ( + ) ( 1+ 0 ( ) 1 +
+1 91+* 05*=.1 .1 *(
- 1 )(-
( =0(
+41 *
)1(
91(+
1(+ 1 (6 2(*
( + 0( == (+745+ 2=(1
*(+.91 9 *1(2 +1
)(
2911
.
1( + -
( )(
(*
1(+-
(2( 0
1(+-
+ 2 4( )*0+ ) +
) 5
E+
5 (2 =9(= 14+.+5(= )1(0542
+- (+) (
)*
+.1 . 4 +() ( 0
+ ( ) +4-0+ 1( *+ 9 9(+ (6
9 1 -8 *
(+ ) $4) !
D5 +1((*
*( -
( 91 4 +( )
+
01(+-
5 +*-
+91*15 1(1 % ()0(=(( =0 *( )+ ( = >4=( )*( 9( = 0() 4
+
.14+.5(=+ 451 ) 21 0542
+ 1( 1 () (
)* 5( +( )2
1 421 1 )+54 ) (* + 1( *1(2 +1
)( ?9(++ )45
911 9 2(*
*1(2 +,;
1(1 +()71! (2.$++ () & 91 9 6 2("7&%1619 ))4 2?? ???
( 0( ( (-+ 4 2=( ))
)4= 04*1+ 1
( 91 *4+ )( *6 )42 (*+ 0(5(** )5 (2 121 -=*(4+ 2 A
+ + (2 ++
4
?/;;>+ D?I5())=(4 !+ .. + *6 91*1 0(
) 4 1+ *1(2 )91
9 (=>4)( )@++4 4 +()(-
0(>4( 40 + (2 ++9(+ -+ )
+()71! (2.$++ () & + 14+*1(2 )+5(= 2)+1
+*
)4*.*1 (
1 -=*(4+ 2 A
+ ( *( ++ !+..5+ "%=) 2+ .1
(
/ 5 +
)4*!
+.( )$ "7(!
+?J &+*5 (= (41 = * (= *
*4) ) 1( *1(2
(2( + 1
1(+
-
5 ) (+ 1 1 ) 0)9(=( 9(+
+4-+( ( 1(1 9(+ ( =)+* 5( *= 5())=+ *6++ ) )4 21+
4 (1
(1 1+- 2
1+ ( + 7( 24
421!
D)
5 =+5 **0
0.+ A5 )1(
++(=(*
9 4)-
91
(- )( ((
(0(
(+
++1(0( 9(+
-(++ ( (4) -8 *
!
+0() $
!; -+ (
$4)
($ *(4+
D.+ -+ )(+4 ,;
$ 9 *(+ + 2( 9 2 (-
0(+1 (2 + =( ))+*5 (=(*
( )1( = 5 *4 (= ++9(+
91 5
( (*
*(+ + ) *) ) )4 5 0- ??? 7 5 0- .5
(= =
!+*
= 9 *(+ +9(+05 )(2( (-
0(+1 (2 !+* ) *+
*
(41 =
05 = (-
0(+1 (2 +( ()=5 )9(+
(
5 +
30( 4(91*1+54( +1( = 5 *4 (= ++ * 4) - 0() 0 1
*(+) *= )(
291 5
(=J
+ + =
1+ -(++ 1(
5
) 2+ 9
(6 )45(2( F (
)*
++4 (-
4 ( =
) 91*1 )*( + 5
E+
-=1 )+*5 (=(41 =(1 4+ .(+
)/$
;. - +4 2 0( = 2(= 0=+
)
)1(5 + !
D 5 +1( 91
+5 05 =
( * (4+ 3 K !
/D
1(
(=05 )-=1 + 421 - ).+4*15
(= *(
- 05 ). A* 5( ( >4= 0(
())
!
/G + !
D ()+(+4 ,;
)1(
05 + 2
1( * 2( =
(=+1(- 0() -=1 9 2(41 =4 ++ 05 =
)1(+-
2
(
(-
4 = 0(6 2 ( 5
(
(2( + 1
(=5 )( )91 +5 05 =
1
( + +5 * ) *(4+ + A !
/D
1(
(=05 )-=1
+ 421 - ) ( = 1
( * ) *(4+ +L
+4*1 5
(= +1( -
05 A* 5( ( >4= 0(
())
!
/GJ
+4*1 >4=9(+1 )- 05 +
5
(=-= 9 2(41 =
+
)
( (*1(5
9(+ 01
(%161
/??G71 (2 + *69(+ = (???91
+455=9(+0() $1 2 ).5
()0 )=2( *1(2 + 1+
+4** ++ 7 *6 *(
9(+
*( 4#( 4(=.??? **40+( +. 5
*(
- 1 ) (- ( = 0(
+
( ( 0( (
) )*(
$
2( 2(* +1((1
*(+1( ()0 )=-
( )
(*
1(+-
(6
(2( +1 0( +
(+ 91=1
1(+-
+ 2 4 1+0(
:
5 2 91
(*+( )**40+(
*(+ . 0542
+ )( ) ?@ $
;/ ( ?D$
;?( (+) 5
+.(** ) 2=.( ) "+,) * ./ %-./
+