High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22984/2015disposed of

College Of Nursing Sigma Nursing Training Institute v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2016-10-22Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari10 pages

! "

# $ %"&'&" ( ")*""

% % )& +,&- &.

+ -&/

# %& &/-"% 0)'&" ( !* "

)*"" !""+"!2! " ( !!+& ( ..

+,/ !"!"+ "!(")( !"3& #+ !& !"+ "!

(")( !"3& #+ !&!* ").!"4

!5( ") 617/&")& ( * ,!! "&**& ")8&, !"/ ). 9 7( ")( !"3& (")#+ !

" ! * " " " , " ) ")&" ' &" :

7;).!!+ 0 "(," 2* ';")(&"

")&"";(")8&,!; &. &3' & ") ";; "!"& " * '! &. &,!! )&/ 0 & """) !"+ "!

!+/-""")( &.! (")*""

" ;&!&.!*+"")&"

&!") ;&!& 3 &., " ")*& "(")*"" !""+"

8,*.& 3!"!&*& "( ,") &!"!"*!;+./"&2 &0& !"

")!&*"" !""+"/3")!+ "

) " , )&/

*&!!"* """) " !"(")!"+ "!;);+.)&' 0)"

(<+"3 )!"+ "!; * ,"""!" ")8&, !;)) ; ""&2*.&( ,") 8"&3 ;& !

)!& ;&!&.! *&!! ")* ! (")+ !.( !* " 1+ ./3

" 0")&"")!"+ "!;); (0+ ") !)&/

0 & "&,"& /+"") !"+ "!; "(0+ ") "!*.&&!(")*"" !""+"!")&"")& 0 & "&,!! "!"+ "! ")#+ !& 7!"+ "!

# + ! &! * * '! &. * ,!! &" 6

"5 ( ") !!! 617 0' /3 ") !* "1 + "!&.!&!(")*"" ")&"")&!/ ,*& " " & 0=+&" ! ")3& ::61:7& ;&!!"&/.!) ") 3& :99 )*"" !""+")&&,""77!"+ "! ")!"

3& (#+ !& 7!"+ "! ")!"3& (#+ ! /( ")+"((&" 7 64; 0.3*.&&!75 0.3")&,!! ( ,!(&..")!"+ "!( #& #+ !!; ! """) !* "1+ .& ")&"

; +.3 ' ' ."" ! &" 6 & 6 6 4

8+ ! =5 4..35 & ") ,& &("! )&' / +.3 &!) !* ")&!(")*"" ") ; >?!"+ "!

")( !"3& (#+ !& !"+ "! ( !"3& (# + ! " +!"+3 0& 9!"+ "!(#& >!"+ "!( # !*"'.3 )&' &/& ") + ! )"&.! ; 0'

!4..35 "!&!(")*"" ")&" !* " )&!)(" "") . ,")((+ " &" ""),& +&.,") (* &" !& & 0.3.!"(.0/.!"+ "!;&!+*.&

") ((&. ;/!" ( ") !* " + . * . 7

!+."& ".377!"+ "!(#+ !& ?!"+ "!(# + !; !);

").!"(!"+ "!+*.&/3") !* + .&0& !"")*"" !""+"4

8+ =65 +"(""&.77 !);

( #+ ! .37!"+ "!(")*"" !""+")& / !);

& !" )& " / .. ;") ") !""+"

!+."& ".3!"+ "!(#+ !;); &"+&..3!"+3

")*"" !""+")& "/ !);

").!"!*"") &,!! &!;..&!8&, <+ , "!)&' 0/ ,*."

%,.& .3( ")#+ ! .3!"+ ")&/ !);

& ,& 0;); !);

; ' ..;")")*"" !""+" !"+ "!;); &"+&..3!"+3 ") *"" !""+"; "!);

").!"4

#54..35

!+."& ".3";&!& 0+")&"!"+ "!(")# + !)&'/ ; 0.3.("+"/3") !* "1+ .!*" ") &"" 0.&!!!

&3, "(8&, (;)))&/

,& :

7';))(( !

7??7=1( 77!"+ "!(!"

3& #+ !& !

7?7=1( 7!"+ "!(!" 3& # + !+.3 '/3") !* "+ .4

$54..35 ;&! ( " %,.& .3!"+ "!( #+ !)&&.!/

; 0.3.("+"

!+."& ".3")!+ ")&/ &** &)& &

" , ;&! *&!! (&'+ ( ") *"" !""+"

7&! " "!")+!,&"" ((&"")&"!"+ "!(")*"" 1 !""+" *+ !+& (") " , )&',*."&.,!"& 3& (")+ !+ ") (")!+ "& &!* ").&,( ")*"" ")3)&'!"+&3& & . &.!

)!!+")+!& !!")&";)") ")!&!"+ "!& ;

"".( ") ( ,&" (")!& ';(")&/'(&"!

& ';(")!"& "&2 /3") !* "+

!* " + . "! *.3!+/,""")&" .3 ( ,!(77!"+ "!(#+ !( ")!!! 617)&/

!+/,"" ;)) ; +.3 *+" ") ;/!"/3") !* + .&!

%";))!<+'&. ""

# .3 8&, ( ,!(#!"3& !"+ "!)&,&");")").!"

(&,""!"+ "!!+/,""/3") !""+"+.3,,+ &" & ")!&,;&!*+" ") ;/!" )") 8&,

( ,!; " .3(( " ") &,(!"+ "!& *& "&0 ",&");")").!"*+" ");/!" ) !* "

+ .)&!!+ .. +,/ !"")!!"+ "!;)! &,& *& "&0 ; ,&") ;") ") .!" !+/,"" /3 ") *"" !""+"")&";&!!);

");/!" ";&!")&!(")+ ")&" *&. ( ") *"" !""+" )& 0' ; " 0

> 7")&"!,(")!"+ "!.("") + !& ") !""+" )&&,""") ;!"+ "!"!.(;) &!*"" !""+";&!

" &+") @ " &," ") !"+ "! &(" ") +" ( &"

7 6 %,.& .3( #+ ! .3!"+ "A! &,)& ,&");")").!"!+/,""/3")*"" !""+"& ")!&, ;&! !);

") ;/!" ;) &! ") ,& 0 ; " .3 (( ) &,!(")!"+ "!& *& "&0)& ",&") ;")").!"* '/3")*"" !""+"& ") &,!)& "

(0+ ");/!" )&"!;)3")*"" !""+".." .3 .. +,/ (#!"3& !"+

"!")+!")&!(") !* "1+ .")&"*"" 1 !""+")&,&, &,!! ! ")#& #+ !! /3 ") !& " !" 0") & !* " ;&! ' ( , ")! 0& ;&!&'&.&/.;")")+ 0& 0")&" &.&,!! !,&& ") .. +,/ !)& / /"& /3") !""+"/3(. 0"); "*""

") *.&" (./3")*"" !""+"&*.&;&!

"&2 ")&"") !"+ "!, " ").!"

#)& ' / ..;")")*"" !""+" )!"+ "!;);

&"+&..3!"+3 ")*"" !""+")& "/ !);

") .!" +*.& ") ;/!" !*" ") &,!! &! ;.. &!

8&, <+ , "!)&' 0/ ,*." ) ( .&, ;&!*+"+* ")+ .")&" &+ "(,!)& . 0") . * !!") )&+ 0& 0")+ "&2 00' /3")

*&. > 7"!!+/,""")&"";&!&* 1; "" ( ,!

& ") *&.;&!"; "8&".3")!&,") ( ";&! ; "" + ,*+.!

B " , &"9 ?

";&! "")&"

"),&"" ;+./ <+ "/3")+ .! ")!*+";&!

( (&"+&. &!*" ( ") 1!+/,!! ( &,!! ( ,! & 8&, ( ,!

0.3&(&"( <+ 3;&!"/ & "! * ";&!"/!+/,""

* " )&! & 0.3 / *.& /3 ") + ";&! .+ ")(&"( <+ 3")&"*"" 1 !""+")&&,""??!"+ "!&0& !"")""&.!& " !" 0") ( )!"+ "!;).("") !""+" ; 6 +,/ !& ") *"" !""+")&!+/,""")8&, ( ,!& (( ")!!"+ "!;); .("' ;")") !""+" )*"" 1 !""+")&&,""") ;!"+ "! .+(")!&. &3.("") !""+"&(" ")+"((&"7 6 !+."& ".3")8&,

( ,!!+/,""/3")*"" !""+")& ",&");")") .!"+*.& ");/!" %,.& .3( ")#+ !&.! .3

8&, ( ,,&");")")!&.!"

?!"+ "!)&.("

") !""+"&(" ") ( ,!; &*"/3")+ .& ..

+,/ !; !!+""),/+"")!!"+ "!)! ""&**& ")8&, & ")3 ,& &/! " ")8&,

* &,!! 0!" ") ,& 2!0' ; .("

!+."& ".3") &,!! * + ;&! "0 + & ") ( ")!*+")& & ! & ") !""+";&!*.&3 0;")")(+"+ (")!"+ "!( "!* ! &.0&

+ !.( ")*"" )&!'), ".3& 0+")&"") 0 &. 4

8+ =65!)+./* +"!););

8+ 16") &,!(")!"+ "!;); "

";") ")*"" !""+"(0+ & ")+!" "( (&+.";")") * + (..; /3 ") + ?

") 0& 0#!"+ "!;&!* +& &* +!&.(")!&,; "!);")&" 0 &. "(&"!(")#!"+ "!( ,! &.

"?4

# 4..35&"*&0:(+ , " ") (")+ &") ")( ,!)&/ +.3!"&,*/3") *"" !""+"& )&/ +.3( ;& /3") *&.(") *"" 1..0 ) ( ;).& 0+, "&!!+)(")+ !.

( ")*"" ! " !* & 3 ( & ")(&"( <+ 3!,!"/-+!"( "!")+!&**& "")&"")!"+ "!;).("") + ! & ") &,!; +.3 +*.&/3") + .<+&"),

&+ "(.&"& 8!!&,!! !,&")*"" !""+" !+0)" &-+!", " ( ")! !"+ "! &0& !" ") ""&. !& " !" 0") "").&!",, "")&!&** &)")!+ ""0"") &,!! 0+.& @ & "&2 & * ,!! " !" ") 8&, !!+/-""( &.!

"! "!*+"")&"( , * .;) ")( ,!; ( !".3+*.&"..+.3;) ")(!;&!

*!"( ")!&+ !! (( ";&!,&/3")*"" 1 !""+"" !* ;")")+ ") 0! "!);

")&"& 3") 0;&!/ +0)""") "(") !* "+ ./3") *"" !""+"")&"") ; ! *& ! ")( ,!& ") .!";));&!+*.& ");/!" "(+ ") 0! "!);")&"

") !!+/!"& ")(&"( <+ 3")&"")!!"+ "!; &,""&(" ")+"((&" 7 6 ) ( ")& 0+, (")+ !.")&"")!"+ "!, " ").!"+*.& ") ;/!"; "&!!&";")")+ !(") !""+"&"&..& ; !" & 0 &!!+)& ")(&+.".!;")") !* "+ .!

"&*"&/.

+ !.( ")*"" !""+"(+ ") !+/,""")&"

&,!! ( ,! (# + !( ")") & &"!& "

&'&.&/. & ") ( "!+/!"& "&")!& 0+, "!

) 8*.& 0' /3")+ .")&"+"!)(" 0(")((( , )& 0& )"#)&."! "" &&/./+"&! "# )&!/ * +

!+) +,!"& !")!+ "!(")* ")&"'

")+0)")!*+"(&"!)&& ! ,&..3")*"" ;+. )&'/ .0&"""! ,3;")")'.+ ""!+/!"& "&" "!&! ;' ! " !"(")!"+ "!! '.'&&'&"

)&/ *+"& ") " , &.! "")&" !""+";+. *&3")!"!!"/,*! &+ "(")* ")&"( ") (&+." ( ") *"" !""+" &+ " ( .&" &,!! ") !"+ "!!)+. "/* &.@ ! "+ ") (")!

+ " ")3 )&' &" .&!" + 0 3& + ! & 0'

8&, !&.! ) " " (")*"" !")&"")3)&' !"+&3& /( *&!! 0(") " , .(( ,")+ ";)) )&!/ (+ !!*+"/3")+ !.( ") !* $* ';")&/'& /&.& (<+"3 " ! & "* """) " !"(")!"+ "!")!+ "!(")*

")&"") " , !.&/."/ ( ,);' !+/-"" !"!;))")*"" !""+";..)&'"*&3( ")&-+!", (")!"+ "!;)))&!/ &**& ".3

0.3")*"" !""+"!/+ ;")") !"!( !

=1* !"+ ";));../*!";")") !* "+ +"(")!&!"!!*!"7C(") !"!;+./ *!"/3")+ .;")") + -&/%"&"D0&.

% '!+") "3)& 0& );) &!7C;+./ "& ;") "!.( &+ " ( ") +

!!& 3 ."0&" * ( /3 ")

*"" "!(+ ") "")&"")+ .;.. !+ ")&"")!& &,+ ";.. "/ ' ( ,")!"+ "!/3")*"" 1 !""+" & 3,&

(+./ ;") (+ ;2!

*!"(")!& !"!")!"+ "!;../ ""." " +;")")+ !& ") !+.";../.& & 0.3 )!"+ "!;../* ,""" &**& ")8&, !"/). ',/ * '! &..3 # $%&'$($)*$+ ,&-.

! E)") !*&2 0= &! != E)") * "&/. !=