← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22995/2015disposed of

Mahesh Kumar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2019-04-30Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

  



      

  !"# $#%&'&()* !+#'+,-.!/ 0#"&"&(#/ 1#/'-' 2"!"# !/3!(!!($"+#/' 0#'4($#("'           /#'#(") /!.'+#$+.#$5$6%!"# /"+#4#"&"&(#/ / !/&'+!"+##52/ 5 !/3!(! 777       89

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

"#/ +!6&(< 4!''#$ 2#(&/ 2#%($!/3 ?!.&(!"&( &( #%#.;#/5  /. "+# !/$   2%+: $-%!"&(5 !/3!(!5 !' !:' &4:.! &( :-.;&(< /. "+# #4!/".#("   ($-'"/&!: /!&(&(< !($ 1%!"&(!: $-%!"&(5 !/3!(!!4!/" /.+!6&(<'#/6#$!'!(!44/#("&%#&(

 89 "+# -(&%&4!: /4/!"&(5 !/&$!;!$ / ! 4#/&$   "= 3#!/' &# /.  *"***5!44:&#$&(-(# /!44&(".#("""+#4'" :-.;#/&(, '4&"!:5!/&$!;!$(%("/!%"-!:;!'&' /!4#/&$ '&?.("+'(/#'4('#"+#/#"5"+#4#"&"&(#/=!'

#/#$!44&(".#("( %("/!%";!'&'!':-.;#/&("+#, '4&"!:5!/&$!;!$( &?#$'!:!/3!' 4#/  /!"#'

/ ! 4#/&$ '&? .("+' / "&:: /#<-:!/ !44&(".#("F-"'-/%&(<=!'.!$#;3"+# !/3!(! 6#/(.#("=+&%+#6#/ =!'#!/:&#/2#/6&%#</##.#("((#?-/#@A$!"#$A=!'!:' #?#%-"#$;#"=##("+# 6#/(/ "+#2"!"# !/3!(!!%"&(<"+/-<+"+# 

&%#   "+# /&(%&4!: #$&%!: 

&%#/ !($ "+# 4#"&"&(#/ =+#/#;3 "+# '#/6&%#' "+#4#"&"&(#/=#/##(<!<#$;3"+##4!/".#(" /!4#/&$(" #?%##$&(<'&?.("+'5;#'&$#'5%("!&(&(<"+#/%($&"&('&(%:-$&(<"+!""+# 4#"&"&(#/=-:$("+!6#!(3:#<!:/&<+""%:!&./#<-:!/&>!"&( '#/6&%# #"% 8*9

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

&%#/5 , '4&"!:5 !/&$!;!$5

#!:"+ #4!/".#("5 6"  !/3!(! %#/"& 3&(< "+!" "+# 4#"&"&(#/ +!$ =/G#$ /. A " 5 B* "   !($

 89 * "&:: $!"#   &''-!(%#   %#/"& &%!"# &#   !($ "+!" +&' =/G!($%($-%"=!''!"&'

!%"/3 9 ( AC =+&:# !$E-/(&(< "+# %!'# / !/<-.#("' " *C &" =!' /$#/#$ "+!" &( "+# .#!(=+&:#5 "+# 4#"&"&(#/ =-:$ ;# !::=#$"%("&(-#("+#4'"!<!&('"=+&%++#+!$;##(=/G&(< /"+# 4!'" &6#3#!/'("+#'!.#'"!"-' 8C9 H#!/(#$ %-('#: / "+# 4#"&"&(#/ '"!"#' "+!" "+# 4#"&"&(#/ &' %("&(-&(<&('#/6&%#(%("/!%"-!:;!'&'#6#/'&(%#5+&'!44&(".#("&("+# 3#!/=&"+("&(!:;/#!G'H#!/(#$%-('#: -/"+#/%("#($'"+!"&"&' =#:: '#"":#$ "+!" ! %("/!%"-!: #.4:3## %!((" ;# /#4:!%#$ ;3 !("+#/ %("/!%"-!:#.4:3##!($!%("/!%"-!:#.4:3##&'#("&":#$"%("&(-#&( '#/6&%# "&:: /#<-:!/ !44&(".#(" &' .!$# H#!/(#$ %-('#: /#:&#' ( "+# $#%&'&( ! @/$&(!"##(%+ "+&' -/"&( 

 $!"#$A&(%!'#"&":#$!'2+&6G#'+!($"+#/'6'2"!"# !/3!(! !($"+#/'"%("#($"+!"&('!&$%!'#;3/#:3&(<("+#$#%&'&( !%@ /$&(!"# ;#(%+   "+&' %-/" &(  *C    $#%&$#$ ( *5&"=!'+#:$"+!""+#$#%&'&(/#($#/#$&('!&$=/&"4#"&"&(=!' %('&'"#("=&"+"+#6&#='#?4/#''#$;3"+# &<+ -/"!'=#::!'2-4/#.#

-/""+!"!%("/!%"-!:#.4:3##'%-:$(";#/#4:!%#$;3!("+#/'&.&:!/ !//!(<#.#("!($'#/6&%#' !%("/!%"-!:#.4:3##=#/#";#%("&(-#$"&:: /#<-:!//#%/-&".#("=!'.!$#-(:#''"+#=/G!($%($-%" "+#%("/!%"-!: #.4:3##&($&%!"#$""+#%("/!/3!($"+!""+#'-;.&''&(' :#!/(#$'"!"# %-('#:""+#%("/!/3=#/#("%('&'"#("=&"+"+#$#%&'&( "+&' -/"&( !E(& !:! 1' 2"!"#  !/3!(!5 

 * 2   !' !:' $#%&'&( 

(I;:#"+#2-4/#.# -/"&( !/<-/4/!"!42&(<+1'2"!"# -(E!; "+#/'5A2   

 8*9 8A9 H#!/(#$2/ $#'("$&'4-"#"+#4/4'&"&(#(-(%&!"#$ &( "+# !

/#.#("&(#$ $#%&'&( "+!" ! %("/!%"-!: #.4:3## %!((" ;# /#4:!%#$;3!%("/!%"-!:#.4:3##!($'#/6&%#' !%("/!%"-!:#.4:3## !/#";#%("&(-#$"&::/#<-:!/!44&(".#("&'.!$#-(:#''=/G!($%($-%" "+#%("/!%"-!:#.4:3##&($&%!"#'""+#%("/!/3 #+=#6#/%("#($' "+!" /#<-:!/ 4'"   :-.;#/ &( "+# '4&"!: '"!($' !;:&'+#$ !($ (= ! :-.;#/&'";#/#%/-&"#$"+/-<+-"'-/%&(<!'4#/4:&%3!44:&%!;:# 8B9  +!6# %('&$#/#$ "+# '-;.&''&('   :#!/(#$ %-('#: / "+# 4!/"&#'44&(".#(" "+#4#"&"&(#/=!'&(&"&!::3.!$#(%("/!%"-!:;!'&'

/!4#/&$ '&?.("+'6&$#/$#/((#?-/#@C$!"#$A!($ "+#/#!

"#/5"+#'!.#=!'%("&(-#$ /."&.#""&.#=&"+("&(!:;/#!G' !($ (= +!' ;##( %("&(-#$ -(&("#//-4"#$:3 =&"+ #

#%" /. "+# $!"# 

&:&(< "+#=/&"4#"&"&( 8 9 ("+#%&/%-.'"!(%#'5"+#=/&"4#"&"&(&':&!;:#";#!::=#$" "+##?"#(""+!""+#4#"&"&(#/&'+#:$#("&":#$"%("&(-#&('#/6&%#"&::'-%+ "&.# "+!" =/G #?&'"' !($ +# =&:: (" ;# /#4:!%#$ ;3 !("+#/ %("/!%"-!: #.4:3##'-;E#%""+&'=/G!($%($-%";#&(<-4""+#.!/G =#6#/5 "+#!

/#.#("&(#$$&/#%"&('!/#("";#%('"/-#$!'!;!/"!$#%&'&(& "!G#(;3"+#/#'4($#("'&("#/.' +&# 2#%/#"!/3:&%35!/" 2!:&! *   -$<# !.&" 1.

Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No.

2.

Whether reportable :

Yes/No.