← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23737/2014allowed

Jaswinder Singh v. Punjab State Power Corp Ltd & ORS

2016-12-14Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh8 pages

Pooja Sharma 2016.12.20 16:31

  

   

  

 

 !"# $% "&& "# '"#

( ) *& &" "##+ ,&!-#  ."



      #"

" &/ 0# !""+ !%

1!23 &"

#&%"+"&& "# 0#45%(66 #1!23 &"

##"

 &    %"+# 8"# &%"+#"

" &+"&& 

3" #& &%"

&(#" 3"#&# # #9(

% $ #!"#!

&"!:

12!" %3%1&%"

 +"#! &%"+"&& "# :

 

 

&:

<%

*"" &#"

=  #> + 8=+"#!*8 &#"

& $&%"

;"

 !(&8+"#! (#&%"#+# 8"#%

*"" ;

!" #

( $!#"3& &#"

 & &#"$(6 #?"&%" "#23"+"#!

&%"+"&& "# "  :

*8&#"

& $&%"

#"

!+"#!

!(&8+"#! !&$# 663 "9(" & 6*" "

 36(! $ 3#";" & +#;& !&%"# "#23"*" "

 2"

6 &%"+"&& "#  3#;

63

"*8&%"&# 6(#&2!"& )(!$;" &!

&"!@<

 A#"

68&%"

3& &%"3

;

!"(& &%"+#"

" &+"&&



#"&% &&%"+"&& "#

++ &"!

, ";

 &%"6"3&#3&8A #! +(#&% %"#"

&"#1%"

+#;&"!



&( # $ ""#

 $2" &%" 3% #$" ( # $ ""# ! #";

 "! + &"! 

"#" &+6 3"

 (# $% "#23"1%"3 !(3&"! +"3&   266 $"

.

6% !!(# $&%"3(# " +"3& 1%"3 ($%& *(&

+"# &%"266 $"#"!% !"!1 % "#" 262"! &%"

& "6"3&#3&8 (& +"# 1 "+"#  1 ;"681%8  $% %

% 2 $ $#(!$" % ; !$&&%"+"&& "#;+63 &"!*8&%"'$6 3" 3

*"

# $. !

:

( !"#"3&   #"2" &  ##(+& 3& &63"& & '$6 3"A(#"

(1;#&

#1  &%"*

&";" &;

!"*8 "B(#;

6 $%   %8  $% C6&;

&"681&%"+"&& "#

+6 3"!( !"#  !(# $&%"+" !" 38 3#;

63

66 "#23"*" "

&%"+"&& "# 6>" 3#";" & +#;&  "#" &%%"6! 2" &%")( # &&%"+"&& "# "#" +#;&"!!(# $&% &+"#!(* "9(" &681&%"+"&& "#

39(&&"!

&%"3% #$"*8&%"&# 6(#&2!"& )(!$;" &!

&"!@<

! 

$

&&%")(!$;" &

6"!*8&%"& &" ( ) * %"  +"&& "#    6  ;

!"  #"+#"

" & &  &  &%"  #"

+ !" &/ "+ #&;" &  !  #"9("

&"!  &  $# &  66  *" "

 *8  &#"

& $  +"#!  

 !(&8  +"#!  *(&    3& 

 & >"  &%"#"(+    %"

+"&& "#*8

8 6 $&%"+#"

" &+"&& %

3% 66" $"!#!"#!

&"!

:

1  2!"  %3%1  +"#!   #;  :

 &

 

 

&:

<%

*"" &#"

=  #> + 8= +"#!*83 !"# $&

 !(&8+"#! ,"

# "!3( "6 #&%"+"&& "#3 &" !

&&%"+"&& "#

"68;+63 &"! &%"3

!(6&;

&"68

39(&&"!

  3% #$"

*8&%"&# 6(#& !  $

6"!%"

+"&& "#

 "&%"#$# 8 3#";" & # 8&%"#*" "

&6>"

+#;& !(# $  &% & +"#!1 %"#"

1 )( # &  %; "#" +#;&"! ,"

# "!3( "6 (#&%"#3 &" !

&&%"+"&& "#

;+63 &"! &%"

&&%" 3"  "%8  $%1 %

3 ($%&#"!% !"!*(&

39(&&"!*8&%"&# 6(#&1&%"#"

#"1%" " &&6"! 66&%"

*" "

&&%"" !16"

# "!3( "6 #&%"+"&& "# (*;&

66 &" & !+(#+

&%"&# 6(#&%

$2"  +"3 3  ! $ &% &&%"3

#"$ &"#"! $

&&%"+"&& "#(& $#(!$"  33( &  & > $  3&  $

&  &% "  +"# %  "#"   262"!    &%"

&  

"6"3&#3&8 2" &%"#"32"#8  &"! &"

 &+#2"! #;&%"

+"&& "# ,"

# "!3( "6 #&%"+"&& "#%

#"6"!(+ &%"

2  A" 3%)(!$;" & (#& 



 ! "# $  % & -DA  

  @  3

" '(

)) '

 ! (( * *+

 #,  (* 

'(%-D

<  < :& &%" (*;

  6"

# "!3( "6 #&%"+"&& "# &% &&%"3 &#2"# 8 % 9( #"6832"#"!*8&%"!"3  

(#&#" !"#"!  ,& *

 !( (-). "# $ %)(-*!  @<

@!"3!"!  @

 ,"

# "!3( "6 ##"

 &%

++ "!&%"

(*;

;

!"*86"

# "!3( "6 #&%"+"&& "#*(&%

 &!

+(&"!

&%"# & )(!$;" &  ,& *

!/ !-0!"1* 2 D"

#!  &%"  #$(;" & !2 3"!  *8  6"

# "!  3( "6  #  &%"

#&"

!% 2" $ "&%#($%&%"!3(;" & *6" #"3#! %" 

3&  #"6 & $  &  6!$ $    .1 

3 $    &# 6  (6&;

&"68*" $ 39(&&"!*8&%"&# 6(#& #" &!

+(&"!%"

("



%"&%"#&%"+"&& "# " &&6"! #$# & *" "

& +"#!

 *8&#"

& $&%"

;"

!(&8+"#!# &%"3 &#2"# 8 &%"+#"

" &3

9( #"6832"#"!*8&%")(!$;" &  ,& *

!

/ !-0!"1* 2

 &% &3

1.

#"$ &"#"! $

&&%"+"&& "# ( !"#"3&  &%"#"2" &  ##(+& 3&1 :<< #

%#&=&%"3&=%"+"&& "# &% &3

3 23&"!*8&%"&# 6(#&

$

&&%"

!)(!$;" & 3 23& 1&%"+"&& "#+#"

"##"!

6*"

#"&% (#&(# $&%"+" !" 38 61&%" " &" 3"

&%"+"&& "#

+" !"! !(6&;

&"68&%"

"!*8&%

(#&2!")(!$;" &!

&"!

!&%")(!$;" & &# 6(#&

"&

!"%"+"&& "# &% &3

>" * 3>  "#23"%"#"

&"# 6"!&%" #&+"&&  &%#"$ #!&&%"!

+(&" #&#"

& $+"#!!(# $

%3%%"#";

 "!(& "#23"

 !(&8+"#!%" #&+"&& 

"! !;+($ "!#!"#

9(

%"!   66 !2"# 3& $2 $ # "&&%"3 " 3& %"#"

"#"!#"3&"!&+

#!"#  33#!

3" &%6

 &%"6$%& )(!$;" &*8&#"

& $&%"

+(&"!+"#!

+"#!

!"";"!&*" +" & !(&8 66 &" & +(#+  36(! $#$%&&3 !"# #+#;&  #;&%"!

&"%

)( # "#"+#;&"!&&%"%$%"## > %6"&%"+"&& "#

3 $ &# 6%"#"6"2 &+#&  #"+#!(3"!

( !"#/ E'"

"!    &%" 

#"

!  +"# +"3&2"  &%"  "#23"  #(6"

 

, +6 8!"

"#2"&*" ++#"3 ! #;&%"

+6"

!"! #$(;" & 0#D!

#&3(6 &"68#"

 "! &%"

+"&& &*"&%"3##"3&+ &  6

%" %"

"#& #

 &@E % *2"& 9(&" F;

&3&% ( !"#.(6"  1 B2"# ;" &";+68""*"3;"

!

" &&6"!&

@ 8

3"

 % !

;

6##";2 "#23" .(6" !"

&%&%"+ 8;" & (*

&" 3"

3"&

";+68""+6 3"!( !"#  .(6"  ";+ "# 3;+"&" & (&%#&8&!"3!" #"

+"3&&&%"+"#!

B2"# ;" &";+68"" %#";

 "!!

;

"!##";2"!# 3;+(6 #68#"&#"!#( !"#  (*.(6" .(6"

 1% "2"#1 +"3 668 +#"

3#*"

&  &%""2" &

B2"# ;" &";+68"" %% !*"" !

;

"!1#";2"!# 3;+(6 #68  #"&#"!  !  %

 *""  (668  "F "# &"!1  (+ &";" &1%" 66*"+ (66+ 8

3"

%3% (6!% 2"*"" " &&6"!&1% !%" &*"" !

;

"!1 #";2"!#3;+(6 #68#"&#"!# +" !"!(*.(6"

.(6"    (#&%"#  +#2!"

#  &#"

& $  &%"  " &#"  +"#!  

  +#"3"! $  !

;

61  #";2 6  #  3;+(6 #8 #"&#";" &

+"#! +" & !(&8 66+(#+   3

32"#"!( !"#(*.(6"* #"#"

! $ &%"+#2

3 &  "! .(6"   (6!;

>"&36"

#&% B2"# ;" & ";+68""  %  %

 *""  !

;

"!1  #";2"!1  3;+(6 #68 #"&#"!  #  +" !"!1   #"

&"!  (+  % 2 $  *""  (668 "F "# &"!1&%" %" 66*"$2"  (66+ 8

3"

&

%3%  %"  (6!  % 2"  *""  " &&6"!  &  % !  %"  &  *""

;

"!1#";2"!13;+(6 #68#"&#"!# +" !"!

";

8*" &%"# #!

1&%" *2"9(&"!#(6"36"

#68

+"3  &% &   !

;

"!  ";+68""  %"  #"

&"!  (+ "F "# " &&6"!&*"$# (66+ 8

3"

&

%3%%" (6!% 2"*"" &%"#

"" &&6"!&% !%" &

 *"" !

;

"! "#23"%"#"

1.(6" @ +"3 +#"

3#*"

 &% &    &%"  "2" &    B2"# ;" &  ";+68""

39(&&"!    &%"  *6 ;"  !  &   +#2"!  &% &  &%"  

6=

*6&8  # "  #;  3#3(;

3"

 *"8 !  3 &#6  #  &%"

!"&" &  *" $  %"6!  *8  &%"  3;+"&" &  (&%#&8  &  *"

( )( "!1%" (6!*"" &&6"!& (66

#8E% &  1& *"3;"

*( !

&6836"

#&% &.(6"   &%".(6"

$" "# 6#(6"1 %6" 3

+"# 39(&&"!1& +"3 .(6" @ &%".(6"

(6!*" &&# 3&"!%"6

"66

"&&6"!&% +"3 3.(6" 66

>"+#"3"!" 3"2"#&%"

$" "# 6#(6" !3 "9(" &681&;( 66 &( !"#.(6"

@ &%".(6"

1#"

"##"!& *2"1&%"+"&& "#

" &&6"!& &%" (66* 3>

$"

 &%"# #!

1 &"#;

.(6" @ .(6"

1 +"&& "#= *" $ 39(&&"!1%" (6!*"" &&6"!&

(66

#8

3"

#&%"+"#! ;

6E% & &%"# #!

1.(6"  ";+ "# 3;+"&" & (&%#&8&!"3!" #"

+"3&&&%"+"#!

B2"# ;" &";+68"" %#";

 "!!

;

"!##";2"!# 3;+(6 #68#"&#"!#( !"#  (*.(6" .(6"

 1% "2"#1 +"3 668 +#"

3#*"

&  &%""2" &

B2"# ;" &";+68"" %% !*"" !

;

"!1#";2"!# 3;+(6 #68  #"&#"!  !  %

 *""  (668  "F "# &"!1  (+ &";" &1%" 66*"+ (66+ 8

3"

%3% (6!% 2"*"" " &&6"!&1% !%" &*"" !

;

"!1 #";2"!#3;+(6 #68#"&#"!# +" !"!(*.(6"# .(6"    (#&%"#  +#2!"

#  &#"

& $  &%"  " &#"  +"#!  

 

  +#"3"! $  !

;

61  #";2 6  #  3;+(6 #8 #"&#";" &

+"#! +" & !(&8 66+(#+ "G

 (#&%"#% 3

"&

#!

#"6"

36 ;"!0#D!

#"6"

 A# %;

% !# B(+& 2C    !

H :<   %3%3 ( (668*"#"

"##"!& & + # $# +%#"6"2 &&%"+#"

" &3 &"F&1&9(&" E>""+ $ 2"

&%"

3& &%"3

"&% &&%" ++"66

 "2"# (6"!(+ #!"+ #&;" & 6" 9(#81&% &%"

+# "3(&"! !%

*"" (6&;

&"68 39(&&"!1 ! *" $ 39(&&"!%"

#"

&"!

+ (668

#8 #&%"+"#!3;;" 3 $ #;%

61  !  (#&%"#  &% &  "2"  # &%" +"#!   9("

&  &%"

3 3"# "! (&%#&8%

 &%"6!&% &&%"

%668 )( "!*"3 " I&% &%"

#8 #!"#"!&*"+ !1 #"

&%"+  &% &&%" ++# 3% &%"&# 6(#&

3##"3&

*6"%"6"

# "!&# 6(!$"  ++#"3 & 

3& ( !

&% &&% 3

"  %3% (66 ;( &

#8 %(6!% 2"*""

!&&%" ++"66 & % #"

&";" & #&%"" &#"+"#!"

33"+&&%

&%"3##"3& ++# 3%" 33#! $68

61 "&

!"&%")(!$;" & # ++"66 &"(#&

"66 D$%(#& !#"

&#"&%" " &# 6(#& &%&% ;!

& &% &&%" ;( &!"3#""! 66*"+ &%:J &"#"

&+  #;

&%"!

&" (&&66#"

&%3 &%#($%(&G   2"

   &%" 

3&

 !

3(

"!   *2"  !  &%"  #"

;" & "!  ,& *

!/ !-0!"1* 2&%"+#"

" &+"&&  "!

!;+($ "!#!"#!

&"!:

%"#"*89(

%"!%"#"

#"!#"3&"!&+

%#!"#  33#!

3" &%6

 &%"6$%&

)(!$;" &  ,& *

!0!"1* 2 *8&#"

& $&%"!

+(&"!+"#!

+"#!

!"";"!&*" +" & !(&8 66 &" & !+(#+  36(! $

< #$%&&3 !"# #+#;&  #;&%"!

&"% )( # % 2"*""

+#;&"!%" "3"

#8"F"#3 "*"! " &%  +"#! ; &%

#;&%"!

&" #"3"+& 3+8 &%"#!"# "3";*"# 1

 0  2 +)

  %"&%"# > $I#"

 "!

4"

%"&%"##"+#& *6"