High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/33924/2023dismissed

Sushil Kumar @ Bhima v. State Of Haryana

2023-09-14Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary9 pages

!"#!

$!! !!%!

&'()*+,)-./.*01 1 23/4.5637'89:4.7' 1111)(.(.*0)8 ;)8/3/ 2('()*+'8<'0' 111)/=*0,)0(/ !>? @"A> B C!>!!

$ DDDD 8)/)0( 81;1:1E*,'8'FG,H*-'()+*8(4)=)(.(.*0)81 81I'J,./4'0-4'0,'FG,,51GEF'8<'0'1 DDDD !>!!

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

!"# "

$ % # & '"

% !"#% %% ''(& )"

" & $$ % & ! ***+ &%", & %(" % & - ,% (

.(%%+ '( / ""

&% ,% & '" 0 !!'& " & - % "'

*% & '"1 ""

&% # &'& & # & )"

" (#"1 & ! , 2 ' '3 & '"1 4 ! /'3 '" *&%' / & , !( !% "

$ %'

( " '% 5 )-21

$ & '& % % / ' '3 /+

6 %% !!'

* % / &1 7 ! ***+ &%", ,& '$ 1 ,' ,& %3 % *&& && $ & *"% # # 0 ''(& & & ' &'&("

&%% # %1 %% *("'& % '%"/ !"# % * %% " " '(& !" % * %% " '% & %% % * %% " & /

!& + #*'% % '& ) '$ "+ & /

'% !"# # & % /

# % 9: 0 *'

!!'& '

%+ $&% & *"

#& &1 ,' '% & **"

& ! & ""

&% & # &("!'

/& % & ' &'&("

&%% # %1 '

" & *'

% ;( # % ! </ 0 2(*"

# ("% % '& != >?@AB= = CDBEF== GHI== CJAJK== ?@== >ALDM== NAOPQ=

2 0 * %% " & + , % ; % $ &% % '* "% ,% % $ &% %

'+ 0(&1 *"+&!" "%!%'*%"+/%# " 2%% '(& **& & % *"+ " %

"( %% '## "' .(%%+ ! '%"/ ,& '$ !"# % '''(& '"

% !"#% ,& '

$ %% % '''(& ,& $$ % /(& && ! & ***+ &%", %% ,( / '# % & -

% /&& !

" # $%& % %" $' !"!"!' ( &' ) * +

(* * +"% $) ,'

" - . / ) .

"!!

! + %" 0 1$

"! " %%'"! 2 $! %2%% '"! ""! + " %%"!' ! $!

+ ! ! + * ( 3 &'

* 4

2% + ! ' + * 3 + *5 3 % ) $! "2 "! $) ""! + !

$%! + *( 3

$ "

+ % + ! $!

* 2 ""!

' "!2%2 "! " "! !

$! "!2%2 "! # * 6 %" ++""% ! $" +

"% ! "

!$% +"!

" " 2 "!' * 6 " "%% $"!' "!2"' !

+"!

%"2 ) + ! $!

"% "! '"! + ""! " 7 " * 6 " 2 ) !"! + " "!' ++! +%"!' + 8 "!

"!' "2"

!* 5* % ! !%!

+"%* #* 4 " " & + ! + !9$% 6 .

"! +:

;<=>?@A=A::

BCD::

EFGH<=A::

I@<F=@::

JK::

L=<MJHNMC:

"! .O

%* #

"" 2"

** ++" "!' +

""% + !"" ) $"% $) ) "' $)$ 2"!' PQ 2 % ! !% + "* Q +"!

! ! ' ! $"% ""! )

# $%

& #'(%& $) $$&

#" ) " # ' #"& *( & & "& $"

#&$ !

# !

+ " & $) $$ " $

! "

# +!%

" "

# $,#&$

( ', *

% " ) ) ( *

#$ && *( "

$ -& ,$(

$ $$ * #

"$ +# ) "$

& # + " +. ,'% "

$ # & $," " " " # ) " "

# & $,

# " & $, $"

")#" "

*!)#"

,$&% +!%

# " $

#"-"

$ #/* ,) ,"

# "

$ 0 123240 73893:300 ;<=00 13>382?00 @A>380 %

) #

& & ",$ B & "

," ' #"

#' ', *

" " $#&#"$ $+$ " " "

& & + $ $$&

# ,$, # "

"( *

' #"& *( " ' ," % " )

##" *

',#& " & " " "$#" $ !* ) #, ",,$ C D#

$$ " $ # ",% " $#&#"$ ) ( *

* " E

' " &

# # #' !$ "

" ) &,

% $

" " )

', #' " ', *

" " ) # #'

# ,$ #""

' #"

"( *

$ " $ # ",

$ #" ( + #"& % +

" !

+ " " " ' ,"

# ' #"

"( *

" "$#&#"$ D# !

+ "

*!% "

),'#& &$

$" & G$

#$H,# % " G #" I"

$ #"

"& " E $"$%

& # + " +. C $ ,"

# J "&

$0 KA8L844200 1M:N?00 ;<=0 1232400 OA:P3Q0 % &

&& # % + #

$ " "

# + $

#!!&

# "

$ # " * $ & $, $"

")#"

# & *#

& # R,&')#"

# "

$ 0 S563:00 1M:N?0

% & $) $$& " "

# ' #"

"( *

*( *$!

#' " "

))

H, #"

! "

$% "

$ $ $ "

& '()(*+,&& -.)(*&

#/ 0 %$

"$" 1/ $2 4// 2

25 65 78 9 $2 : "

$ !$

: ;2 <"

1#/ !

#$ 55 5 5 = // $

/ "

# /0 "$" "# >85 <" #$% $

$%$0 :

/2$ ! #

6 ?#!

2 %

# #$% !0 #

6 ?#! %$

# "$ $ 2 #

$ 2

" >= " $ 2

$" "

$ $ !$ "

/2$

1# "$2 ?#! 2$ @"$!

/ $$ " "

/2$

#2 %

5 4#22: "

#" " = ! !$ $ $22% 12/# /

/ $$ 1# "$2 ?#! 2$ @"$!

$ 1$%" AB#0

$ $22% 12/#0

C $

22$% //:

"$2 !$% $22% 12/#0 =

2C$% "

/ $$ 1# "$2 ?#! 2$ @"$!5 #"

$ 2

= 2 /

/ $$ 1# "$2 ?#! # !: $#$% #

/ $% ! : !:

$%0 "

/ $$ 1# "$2 ?#! 2 !

/ $$ #:

//: ! B " "

/ /$

!#" "$%"

/$ $ !: 5 = :#

C0 "

22 !

5 = % %

: %

5 E"

= /

/ $$ 1# "$2 ?#! 2$ @"$! # %$$% "$! //: 0 "

F/ $$ 1# "$2 ?#! 2$ @"$!

:$% "

$22 %$$% :# //:

$" "

$$ " :#

$22

2C !

$" "

/ $$ !$2 0 "

$ " =

$22

2C !$2 #

//: 0 =

$22 !

:# $22% 0 "

/ $$ 1# "$2 ?#! 2$ @"$! 2 !

$0 /2

C 0

/ $$

$22 %$ :# //: 5 #"

$ 2

" 75 75 0 =

$22% 12/#

$" !: 1

! #$% &'&( "(%&# % ') '""*%&+ )' '

& , - & &$ & ') % , . " -(' )'

&$ "%& "&&' / %$(

(% 1$ ! 2 % 3 3 . &' "%& "&&' / %$(

#%$ ' &$ %"'& &'( $ &' "* &$ % , 3 . * %(( '""*%&+ ) &$ %#('% &$& ' &$ % *3 $ $ #'

&' 2(( 1$ +&$ &'&( ') "(%&# % (' +&$ '""*%&+ $% /&' # 4$ ! #$ 2(( 1$3 ' % "'(# 2$#( %& ' &$ ' $ 3 ! &''-

* # &' &$ #( &+ 1$

5$ ! -"& $ % ') '""*%&+ %$% &$ #( &' *

' 3 +$ $ (' % % $% # # &' $% # # &' $% 5$3 &$3

&(* &$ "'(# # $&

&$ 5$ +&$ &$ '""*%&+ &$ # ! % # ') $% %#('% %&& &3 #'## % 6

'& #& &$ "(# )'

+$ $ #$% #'2 #'& )'

&$ "%& "&&'## % / %$(

(% 1$ & / ("

(%' '& #& &$ "(#+$$-"&$ #'2 %')'""*%&+ 7$&

2%&&'3 "&&' #'

( '& %& "&&' % %#' )'

%& %& ') &$ "%&"&&'## % %%&((" &(( &8 ! &$ #% & $ 3 &$'

$ &$ "&&' '& ) &$ 9!3 $'+23 %'

% ((&'% ') #$% %(( &':#& % %&#% )& "'# &$ )'

;%&$3 (2(( %& $ < &&* ') #'& "(%&# % #'& , - ') "'""* %&+ $% #'2 )'

$% #'## % 3 ""$ & %"'& % ' %#& )' &'3 +$#$ )((% &$ #&'* ') #'

#( < &&* !& $% ) &$ 2( &$& &$ "&&' '& $ 2'(2 " ( 7$ "&&' $ 2'(2

' # ( #%%3 '

& ') +$#$ %&(( " /"#)# '

& $% (( &' $2 " &' &$

" ! # $ %& ' ! ##% ' $( )

% ' # "! #' !# " ! % * !" #*

* &$ ! + # ) , " - ./010223-- 456789-- :0;<8/=;=- !- 4;>;038-- ?/>;0-

( ) !# % ! '

@ %%#%* ' !

#%% ! # &#&" ( ( A # ) , " - 45BB8;0;>-- 4;3=567;11;- - C82302-- DEF-- 43;32-- GH-- C;8;0;E830;- *

, I* # @ !% #$ ' # #! " &#&! ' # J - ./0<;KE8-- 45678-- 45<<5;-- DEF-- 43;32-- GH-- :/6L;<- *

M ,NIN! #!

O( ) ! %&' ! @ # ! #' " !! "!P ( ) ! # # !%

& #'

!% "" & ' ' %Q #

P () #' # # "R P &( ) #' !+ #S# ! "#

( &( T

& "! #' $ R R %

"#% # ' %

" ( &( U" % ' # ##' #% "% !

% &' #% " #( @@@@@@@@@V

"# !%&'(!

'% () *+)(!&%%+' ,

- , ./012 342 -567282 .579 4:; .0<27=2; 94:9, > 7;?:7?1@, :772<9 ?< : 6:79 .A 67.B2;572 .A 942 ?=2<9?C:9?. 9. <2B572 .9 .1@ 942 672<2B2 .A 942 :BB5<2; 059 <2=27:1 .9427 6576.<2< .D27 5;27 -2B9?. 7 ?< : 2E97:.7;?:7@ 6.D27 :; 942 <:82 4:< 9. 02 2E27B?<2; <6:7?C1@ 342 67?=?12C2 .A 942 672:772<9 0:?1 <4.51; 02 C7:92; .1@ ? 2EB269?.:1 B:<2< 342 F5;?B?:1 ;?<B729?. B.A2772; 56. 942 B.579 4:< 9. 02 67.6271@ 2E27B?<2; :A927 :661?B:9?. .A 8?; :< 9. 942 :9572 :; C7:=?9@ .A 942 :BB5<:9?.G 6.<<?0?1?9@ .A :661?B:9 A122?C F5<9?B2 :; .9427 A:B9.7< 9. ;2B?;2 D429427 ?9 ?< : A?9 B:<2 A.7 C7:9 .A :9?B?

6:9.7@ 0:?1 H7:9 .A :9?B?6:9.7@ 0:?1 9. <.82 2E929 ?927A272< ? 942 <64272 .A ?=2<9?C:9?. .A : .AA2B2 :; 42B2, 942 B.579 85<9 02 B?7B58<62B9 D4?12 2E27B?<?C <5B4 6.D27 A.7 C7:9 .A :9?B?6:9.7@ 0:?1 I9?B?6:9.7@ 0:?1 ?< .9 9. 02 C7:92; :< : 8:9927 .A 7512 :; ?9 4:< 9. 02 C7:92; .1@ D42 942 B.579 ?< B.=?B2; 94:9 2EB269?.:1 B?7B58<9:B2< 2E?<9 9.72<.799.94:92E97:.7;?:7@7282;@ J 9 ?< 8:?A2<91@ B12:7 94:9 :9?B?6:9.7@ 0:?1 ?< .9 : 7?C49 94:9 8:@ 02 C7:92; ? 2=27@ .9427 B:<2 342 .579 4:< 9. 9:K2 ?9. B.<?;27:9?. :11 942 A:B9< :; B?7B58<9:B2< :; :A927 ?9< 598.<9 <:9?<A:B9?., C7:9 ?9 .1@ ? 2EB269?.

:1 B?7B58<9:B2<, D4272 :11 942 A:B9.7< :; 6:7:82927< :72 829 :; 94272?<.6.<<?0?1?9@.A4?8?927A27?C?9426:94.AF5<9?

'% !%M!%#%+'% N '% OP "# Q+ R L !

S 7?8?:1 T, .U 012 342 -567282 .579 4:; .0<27=2; 94:9 ? B:<2< D4272 <27?.5< :112C:9?.< 4:=2 022 :112C2; :; 942 97594 22;< 9. 02 21?B?92;

!" #

%! % $% & '

% % $

& ( % ! " %%&"#%!) *) + $% $ % ,! ! %% !%" # ! % $ &%% % &%,

" & #%! (%!! & $ % , %$% % " !, " !

$& !

#% $ && % % % $) +

& ( ,%( % !%$ -

$ % %

&%% # %! $

% %%&" #%!)

! !" & &%% %

% %

) .) + # ,% % #, !" & &

% % $ & &%% % # /&

% &% % % ) 12324056278629:;0 <78=>0 ?@ABCADBDE0 F G H &G% $I J IK H&#! J IK