Union Of India ,Ludhiana v. M/S Tib Eng. Works And ANR.












 

 

 



 !"

"#$%$&'
(
)*


&$&

&+$
!,-./,
 --$%&
&/$&""-*
0.+,$ & 11"22 &!

3"-%.%

4%
$5
&/$&""-$&/
6-7%*
8  +*
95 2
 &!!

&!,"-  "%1&+"&!%  



 !

!

"#

$%

 6,"!,"-
"1-!"-%

2# 2
1 1"-%
9 (
5"
22:"+
!
%""
!,"
;.+/9"&!<  
5"
-""--"+
!
!,"
"1-!"-%
-
&!<  6,"!,"-
!,"
;.+/9"&!
%,.2+
5"
-"1-!"+
$&
!,"
$/"%!<

-"%"&!'

-%,:$&$"
=.9 -
 &% 2*
+># !"* -
!,"
11"22 &!

-3$; (
2*
+># !"* -
-"%1&+"&!
 ?????







































!

"#

 &'( 
@AB



-
!,"
-" %&%
9"&!$&"+
$&
!,"
112$# !$&*
:,$#,
$% %.11-!"+
5(
&
$+ >$!*
+"2 (

@
+ (%
$&
$2$&/
!,"
11" 2
$%
#&+&"+ 
%! &+%
+$%1%"+





 11"22 &!B &$&

&+$
$%
//-$">"+

!,"
-";"#!$&

!," 5;"#!$&%
$2"+
.&+"-
8"#!$&


!,"
-5$!- !$&
&+
&#$2$ !$&
#!* ))
-
%,-!
C))
#!D
%""7$&/
%"!!$&/
%$+"

!,"
: -+
+ !"+ ))@

-%,:$&$"
=.9 -
 &% 2*
2" -&"+
#.&%"2
11" -$&/
& 5", 2

!,"
11"22 &!
, %
#&$&"+
,$%
1- ("-
!
!,"
: -+$&/

2 $9

A*
:,$#,
##-+$&/
!
,$9*
$%
&!
$&
#&%& &#"
:$!,
!,"
1->$%$&%
 2 .%"


!,"
#&!- #!4 /-""9"&!
"
.-!,"-
%.59$!%
!, !
!," -"9"&!$&"+
#2 .%"
1-,$5$!%
!,"
#&!- #!-
!
2+/"
&(
#2 $9
$&
-"%1"#! 
#91"&% !$&
!,"-:$%"*
$!

$%

9 !!"-

-"#-+
!, !
!,"
#&!- #!
: % /- &!"+
"E!"&%$&
-9
!$9"
!
!$9"
&+
&"

!,"
"E!"&%$&
$%
&&"E.-"

#&! $&$&/

#2 .%"
C $& &#$ 2
""#!
0D
,"
-"9"&!$&"+
"E!"&%$&* :,$#,
$%
+.2(
%$/&"+
5(
!,"
#&!- #!-*
+"%
&!
1-;"#!
&(
"E #!
$& &#$ 2 "E1"&%"%
$&#.--"+

&+*
!,"-"-"*
F. &!$$# !$&

2 $9
A
: %
5 %"+ .1&
!,"
%.-9$%"%
&+
#&;"#!.-"%

-" %&$&/
, %
5""&
%%$/&"+
5(
!," -5$!- !-
$&
-9$&/
&
1$&$&
!, !
!,"
#2 $9
+$+
&!
 22
:$!,$&
&+$!$& 

 6B)
&+*
!,.%*
.-/"%
!,$%
.-!

!, !
!,"
: -+
.&+"- #, 22"&/"
$%
&!
$&
#&-9$!(
:$!,
!,"
1->$%$&%

%.5B%"#!$&

 8"#!$&
@

))
#!
!
$%
&!
&"

!,"
/-.&+
-
%"!!$&/B %$+"

!," : -+

-3$; (
2*
2" -&"+
#.&%"2
11" -$&/
&
5", 2
 -"%1&+"&!

%.59$!%
!, !

!,"
1-#"+.-"
+1!"+
5(
!,"
-5$!- !-
: % &!
5;"#!"+
!
5(
"$!,"-

!,"
1 -!$"%
,"
#&!- #!-
%.59$!!"+
!,"
#2 $9 :$!,
-"/ -+
!
!,"
-"9"&!$&"+
9.&!
5(
F. &!$($&/
!,"
% 9"
&+
!," -5$!- !-*

:,
$%
&
"E1"-!*
-9"+
&
1$&$&
!"-
, >$&/
"E 9$&"+
!," #&!"&!%
:,"-"
&+
-$/,!2(
%*
#91"&% !$&
, %
5""&
: -+"+

"
: % -#"+
!
%$/&
!,"
"E!"&%$&
&+
%
:"22
%
!,"
#&!- #!
#&! $&$&/
2 .%" *
:,$#,
$%
/ $&%!
!,"
1.52$#
12$#(
&+
# &&!
! 7"
!,"
5"&"$!

,$%
:& :-&/
&+*
!,.%*
.-/"%
!,$%
.-!
-
$-9$&/
!,"
: -+
&+
%
:"22
%
!," $91./&"+
-+"-

-%,:$&$"
 &% 2*
$&
-"5.!! 2*
-"2$"%
.1&
!,"
;.+/9"&! -"&+"-"+
5(
!,"
&G52"
8.1-"9"
.-!
$&
')*'+, !*+-&*'+.*'(

 */+&01+.* 23++4 5-&/0/

*.*

!*4.'

'*4 *&#

6  .3.( 67 !
#&!"&+
!, !
!,"
!"-9%
&+
#&+$!$&%

!,"
#&!- #!
-" % #-% &#!
5"!:""&
!,"
1 -!$"%
&+
!,"
#&!- #!-
$%
&!
"&!$!2"+
-
"2$/$52" !
#2 $9
#91"&% !$& 
, >"
," -+
!,"
2" -&"+
#.&%"2
-
!,"
1 -!$"%
&+
11- $%"+ !,"
1 1"-
57 2 .%"

#

!,"
#&!- #!
-" +%
!,.%'B C
 



  



 

   

 

     

        

 

2 .%"
#
, %
2-" +(
5""&
1&+"-"+
.1&
&+
+$%#.%%"+
5( !,"
&G52"
8.1-"9"
.-!
&+
!"-
+"! $2"+
+"2$5"- !$&
$&
"E!"&%
.&+ !, !
!,"
#&!- #!-
$%
&!
"&!$!2"+
!
#2 $9
#91"&% !$&
.&2"%%
&+
.&!$2
!," "912("-
"%! 52$%,"%
!, !
!,"
#&!- #!-
, %
#&%"&!"+
!
##"1!
!," "E!"&%$&

!$9"

2&"
$&
% !$% #!$&

,$%
#2 $9
-
+"2 (
,"
"E!"&%$& /- &!"+
-9
!$9"
!
!$9"
, %
5""&
#7&:2"+/"+
5(
!,"
#&!- #!-
%
$% ">$+"&!
-9
&&"E.-"
B
&
>$":

%.#,
%$!. !$&*
!,"
#&!- #!-
#.2+ &!
, >"
%! 7"
!,"
#2 $9

#91"&% !$&
$&
#912"!"
+">$ !$&

!,"
!"-9% &+
#&+$!$&%

!,"
#&!- #! ##-+$&/2(*
!,"
: -+
-"/ -+$&/
2 $9
A
&+
$&!"-"%! !,"-"&
$%
,"-"5(
%"!B %$+"
&+
!,"
5;"#!$&%
$&
1 -!
##"1!"+
&+
!," 11" 2
$%
1 -!2(
22:"+ '8 7#



 !

"  &')-/,

$%