High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15951/2024dismissed

Ritu Yadav v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-07-29Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal26 pages

!"#$#

! %!& !"#$#

( ( )" *+) # (

++ *+) # (', ) +

! "

#$ %

& & ' #( )))) $ !

* $(+,(+(, - .

/$$0! 1 '' 2 3 & &#4,# -

5 607

'$,, * 7

2 7 7 2 1 ( 3 2

8/ 2 7 77 -9 :&;

:& :<2& 0 9!# 9 ' = 2 -><0 3 3 & & # % 3 7 ' ' 2 :

! 2 & /7 7 ' ! '

-2- 2 & $+? ! 2 ! !

7 2 !

2 3 2 !

3 !

! $4$$(+(% 7 2 ! !

' !! #!2 ! 7 ' 7 2 1 ' ' !

, 7 !

(($((+($ - .

/$0 7 77 -9 :&;

:& :<2 & 0 ' 8/ 9!# 9 ' = 2 -><03 ' ! (($((+($ ! $@+$(+(( 3 8/ ! 2 (@+$(+(( = 3 & & # ! . Rs.56,16,000/- * 7

7 ! Rs.2,80,800:/3' 2 !

* 77 * $+? * 23 ! ! 2 - .

/$0 A 3 2 '

' 8/

27 ! ' !2 & 8/ ' 2 Rs.58,16,600:/'

A4$4+++:/ * 7

!! ' 2 !

2 ' ' 3 & &#4,7

'$,, * 7 3 *

/ 7 ' 72 '$ -$+? 2 7 0 /7$A+((+((

-3- ' ! +B+%(+((2 !7 7 2 !

2 2 <

2 /

7 C ! ' $A+%(+(( - .

/,0 /

7 2 C ! ! 7 2! 1 *

(D+%(+((- .

/A0 4 ''

2 /

C/$(D((/(+((2 !! ! ! +$+B(+((- .

/403 ' 2 ' C/$B$44/(+((! 7! ! ! 2 ((+((+(% ! 2

3 2 ! C/(A@$$/(+(% ! ! $4$$(+(%- .

/B0 7 7

/ 7 2 / 7 ! 2 2 ! ' > 7 $4$$(+(% 7 / (D$$(+(%- .

/D02 7 7 '! / ' 7 3 7 2 '#;/4%B/(+(, '

7 ! $4$$(+(%

C/(A@$$/(+(% (@+((+(,

2 7

/ ! 7 !

C/ (A@$$/(+(%

27 7

(@+((+(, /

7 '

-4- $(+,(+(,- .

/$$0 1 7 ' ' !

@ E

!! '2 !

)(

B E

' 7 2 7 2

' ! 77 ' .

/$$ !

2< ! 72 - .

/$0

> !

27 2 ' 2 ! ' ! 1 /$ 2 D E

>-$0 2 2

' 2

7 2 '2 ' 2 2 2 1 $+ E

27 7 ' 2 2

)(

( ( $$ !

27 2

7 ' 2

-5- $( E

>-$0 2 7 ' 1 2 !

' ' ! ' 2 2' 2 ! 2 7 $% E

27 ! 7 2

' 2 ! 2 ' 7 ' ! 1 '7

2 & 7 > 5

! " #"

!$ %& " $ " ' ( )*++)*, 1 '7

2 5 - .

! "#"

) -#* ! "( )*'+

-1 #"

) -#* ! "( ),*++)* +(( ( $, C ' '

2 $A 3 2 - .

/$0

>-$0

! 7 ' 1 2 ! !

78/ : 8/ !

' '

>-$0

! / -%%"

"1 $$34$ 5 5 &

$ 5 ""11 " 6

-6- $4 #!7 '!

21 2 !! 2 '!

' 2 3 & 7 > ! ' !

! "#"

!$ %& " $ " ' (-

0! 1 2 :

;

E77

' ' 2!

2 = 7 7 ! !

7 $+?7 2

2 2 3 ! '2 !

! ! 2 ! ' 7 ! !2 < "

! 7

3' ! 1 '7 ! 7 . .

7 =

' 2 3& 7 > ! ' 5

-$DB(0 ( & %4A 5 -$DD40 , & (+B 5 !"# $ $% $ &-(++D04&$@$5' ( # ) * " !"# ) # -$DD+0%&(B+ 5+", $ $ " !"# $ $ &-(++B0$+&4D4 / 2 " $ "&- & "

9 !"

#4 :

-1 9 !"

);<* - =

-7- 5

" 1 $$ " 8 /" $

1"$&

$$ 1 "& %5 ""

% " "

$ " $ "& 8 " &

$ &$$

/5 1 $$ "

1 " $$ $

" "

" 5 " ?""

$$ $ & &

$ 5 " " 5 ""

4$ &$ $

7 7 - / 8 &7 /

1 7&1 "

&&$ "75 "

7 $$ " &

" 5 $ 1

/ $ & " $$ " ?$ 1 & @

$& """$ 5& / $$ " "5 5" /& "

$$ " "

$& @

$ & 8 & 1 "

&&$ ""7 & @

$& "75 / $$ " %& $71

$ " 7 & . "$ % / "

& $ ""&&"

" """

/ $

1 & ""$& 5" "5

1 & $ /7 "

$ &"$& 7 "

&&$ "&$ & & $$ " % "

" 1

1"$&7 $$ 1 "

-8- & "

$ " %& /

" 5 $$ $$

" & /

" 5

1 " $ & 7 " &5

1 " & $ "

"@ "

$$ $ & & " & $$ $ " " "& /("& $$ "

$A6 < %'

9 !"

- 9 !"

);;=* , - <7 "

" 5

"$ & $ $ $5 $

$ "1$ &$& & 71 $$ " "

" 5 > 2, &

. $ "&

& ""& &"

$5 B $ "

$ & 5 " 7

3 & & " $ & 5 " "&&$5 "2& & &1 $& &

$ & " $$ 6 7 "

$& 5 """

" " B"

7= > 2 $$ $& " "

: &8 ""

= 8 ""

""& 1 4$

" 8 " .1 " "

1 . $. " $"&

& : & 8 "" 1 1 $$ $ 4$ & "

1 "

" :& .1 $" &1 "

-9- $$ 7& "

." $. " 7

" "5 " & "

&& 8 " 6 C &$ &"

$ "7"

& $

$ " 5 " " 7 1

$$ $&

$ "&

$$ $$

$$ $ & " : &8 ""5 " 8 "" 1 "&4$ " "

1 & " $

$" $ ""&8$

- &!""

);* - 7- &!""

D "5 );*- =7 &% :

- + );=;* -,=

- & #4 :

-1 );<*- = %

$ - 5 1& $ & " " $$ " $$ $& " ""

4$ $ "& 1 $

$ 1 & "

" ?

$? 5 &&$ " 5 "

" % " $ " 1

$$ " ""& " " + ,) * $ "& "

& & $

$5 6 ;

""$ & 1- "9 ) ;*=-7 "

" 5

"1 & ?$&& $ "" & & 1

1 4$ " "

-10- 2 8 " $ 1 $""

1 ?$ 1 @

& &

& $ " && " "" "" $ 1 " " & &

! $ $

1 " $ " & ?$ " 1 7 "1 "& & $ $ B " &1 ""

1 " & 1 "

"" " $ "&$" &"

1 "

????? ;

" 1 $$

" &

" 7& ?"1 "

&&$ ""7"

" "1 . $

(" $ $$1 & "1 " & & "" & " 6

+ $

" $

&& "

$"& " 03"

- E""9!"

% " & 0

' 9 !"

);; * - < 8 " ? $

> 2 %$"7 4 5 & "

"$? " "$15

1 " & 4 "$ " 1 ? - $ " $1 & " " " -

" "$ $$ & 1 $ "$

.1"

15 7 " . & $ ?$ @ " " 14 "&1 1"$

-11- $ 5 1 & $ 1 FG " $"" $ 1 & "" & ?$ $" $ 1$ ""&4$& "&&"

& " 1 " ." & "" & $" $ ""

" $ $G "$" $ $ $ " $ & $$ '.1 & "" "

& "

$ " & 4$5 $ "" " "

4 $""

""&05 7 &7$ ""& $$ $7 7

5 "&&"& @ " 4$ "" "

&&$ $ " &

$ $ $$ " "" "$&$ 4 "&$ " 6 B

" "" &4$& 5 @

" " $ " " "$ "" $""&

" " $

"& &&

+ $

" $ $"& " H +

) <* -=;=5 "

" 5

" 5 " 4$ 5 ""11 " "$ "

$"5 " " 1 "" 5 " $" % " $ "5

"& &

" 5 $"

5 "7

" $ & " " 5

" $ % " $ " 1 "$75 " "

&$ $$ "

%0 -1 / 9 8 & E$ ""7B5 9!"

);<*-, 7 "

-12- 5

5 " & $ ." 7 " "4 1 """ $ &"

"" "

& && 5" "

"> 2< "$ @

5 " & $ ." " $ 1 "7 " " 4 1 "" " $ "

"" "

& && 5" ! 5"7 11 7 $" $

$$ & $

171 1 " 5 " "&:"7D /

4 %+;- => 2 $ "7 $ 7?$"& "

$ $" 1 & ? " "@ 1 &&$ .1 &5

7&5

5 " " 75

$ " $

$ &&$ &&$ $1" $ $ & " 5 "" " $" 4$5 &$ 1

1 " "& ! " . 5$1

" 15 6 " " & &"

57 " $ " ""

4$ & "

" &&$ ? 8

" 4$ & " && "

$&$"

5 $ & $$

4$$ 1 7 "

"& "

$" " " $ "

5 "$"$ "7 5 $ &? 1 & 5 1 %5 $ "&

$&1$$

-13- 5

1 &;

! "$& "

5 " &5 & &?

& " 7 " " $" & " 5 &?

" " 5 $ 7 " $" 1

1" ." 7&5 & " 57 & " 5 &&

" $ " $.

" 7 $ $ 1

" 5 1 5 5 $ "

"7 $1 $$ " $" $" 1 "7 "

. $"4$ "& &&

""? "

C &" "&- &

7 1"5

$" $

$ &?1 "$ " $ "

"$ " & " $ " B && " $ 1 &5 $ & $ "5 B& &&$ "&

! """ I 4 .1"

5 5 "" 5

$ < " 5 $$ 5 -$ ;7 / 1 7 5

1 $$ $?7 &"

$ 5 "1 """1 "

, &&$ $ & 4 $7& ""

$ & 5 & $ & " % "$ && $ & 1

& "

&+"

$"7 "1 &"

$ &&" $ $ && $ "& &&" $ " $ &5 5 "& 7 "

7 " 5 8 4 1 $ "" "" "

& &"

$ " " % & $" $$ " $" &

-14- "75"$""&+"

" &&3" " " > ' .

" $ "( & C +"

" - E"( & C 5 &5 "& $@ 7

2 / 9 - .

! "#"

) -#* ! "-

27 2

& %B

7 ₹$B@DD%++:/< 2 '' 2 7! !

7 '

' 2

8/ ! ! ! 2 ' ! ! !! 2' ' 2

' 2 '

22 ' 7 773 ' '7 ' 2 ! 1

(B ! 2'

1 /$2! +@!

! .7 !

! 7

7 '

/ 2, "

" "

$$5 5 1 " "

$$ " 5 "

1 " 5 "

8 $ "

1 & $" &"

" " $ % & $"& $ " " & " $$

$ $$ &$5 "

-15-

" "

8 1 & " $

? " " $"" 5 . "

5 $ - 5 1 &

$& " " $$ "

&$ " 1 $"" &

J- 8$

$ - &!""

);* - > %+ );* -

> - & !""

D "5 );*- => %+;-<=G &% : - + )"$*7);=;* -,=> %+ ;-; - & #4 :

-1 );<* - = - 55 " . ":$ & " '

?B #"

7- &

) ;*++ )*= = $ " $ " "1 "

$$ $& " "" & $$ $ $

1 $ &$ 5 " " " 1 &

"<& E

$$7" 5& & $" 5

$ "& ""

& $7 @ "5 1 & "5

" " $

$"& 1 & $"

$ """

"" &?$& & $7 $" $

"<& E

$$1

$$ $ 4$ & $

5 & 5.1 " & &

$ - "&"

@ " "5 "

5 " $5 & $ . 4$

" "

& " " $ " 11

$ 5 " 5 4$ & $

.1 & $"

" < & & "

-16- " $ . & $$ $ $ & ""

& $ - - " E

$ $""

1 5"5 $ $" < % & $"& "$ " "$&

$ 3 &$1 $$ $ & "

" & $

7 $$ $ $

$1 ;

% &$" %& " $ ' #"

B 1 0 + $ ' ) =* =7 - <<7

J- $

&$ $" .1$""& $

$$14$1 & " "" & $" .1 $"" " & " & " '.5" &$ "

" 5 5 "" " 5

$$ ""

$ "

$"5 ""

$1 " $$ $5 5 $

% 5 " $" .1$"" $""

" &

$$ &

& $"& "$ " "

1 " $

" 5 5 &&$ "

"" " $ " & 1

" 1 " "

1 & 1 " & 1 " " " $ 5 % E

$$ = = ) ?

,* "

5 "

$ $"" 5 " 3$ 5 " " 5 1 $ " & 1 - $

" " $ " 1 & " E

$$5 "

"""

" "

"7"

" E

-17- 5

$$""5 " "

4$ & $" " $ " 8 "$

"75 "$&$ @ $ " " 5 1 "3"" 5 "

4$ & "

$$""5 "

$ 7 5 " 1 " 3"

$ & 1 K 8 """ 1 ""

5 & "" $ $ " " 1 " "

1 1 $ &1 C ""$ 7 5& " 5 """ 6

!! 2 / 9

-1 #"

) -#* ! " -

0 !! 2< 8 ? " !$ %& " $ J" $ " )"

& $$& " $$ 4$ " ""

5 5 1 1 1 4$&

$ "

&&$ "" $ " &

" "" $$ & $ 1 7&$"

"> 2

C"7 5 ?

@ " 5 1$$ $ $ "$& $$ $& ""

$& 7 "

$ "

& $ & 4 $" && &&

" &

4$& 5 "1 0

7 && $

$ & $"@ 4 $ & ""

$ & & & 5 ?$"1 4 5 $

$$ 8

-18-

$$ $$

% 5 " $ " & $ & &1 $$

" ""

" &&(" $ "

" 5 " @ 5 5 & "

5 $$& " 7

$" & "

"7 $

4$ & " 5 " 1 7 && $

$ $"@ & & ""

$ & 8

" "

7 & 5 " & 7 5 " &&" 5& & $

5 "$$ $ $

"$& 1""

&&75 "@

&&1 $"

, % " " 5

" " 1

$$$ "& / "

$ 5

$$ 4$ " " & $ & $"

5 " 1 $@ " 1 $$ & & &&$

" " 5 "

" L& "+1 =)*& +1 "&;<7

"""

$$ $& & " 5

" &7 "

$$""&

" " L& % " $ "

"""

"+1 =)* 5 & $$ $ & 8

" 5 " $$ $ $ +1 =& +1 "&;< "? $ > 2= - & "& 1

$ )* % $ " & "

$7 $3 $

1 "

" $3

.1 $" " & $" " $ "

-19- 1 )* & +1 , "

& 1

$ )* $& " "

" " $ "& & "$& "

1 )* & +1 "

$$""& "

CM(M%%(1" " $ & $$ "

$$""& 7 $ 75 " & & $1 $$ $& & " G & 1 5 $

" "

" &&

$$""& "

$ 1

$ ) *8 & $& $3 7 &"$

1 $&""

" "

1 ")=* )* &+1 ),* 8 1 " $ " &

" & & " & $ $ &

$ " 6 && 5 $" & "

"E #.

" "

9!"

! .

) *-<7 @ "" " &"$"

>5 " " 1

&&3 " $$ $

@ "K 0 $

" && " " "1 L & 5 1

& "

" $$ $ $ @ "G 5 &&$

-20- "$& $$ $ $K" 1

@ ""7 "

" "$ ""

% "

& "

"7 - " & & 7 0 + ."

" $ $ $"& " - & #4 :

-1 );<*- = - "

"1 $ $ 1 & " + "

"1 : $ " ) *-,5 >)- ,< 7 ;* 2;

"1 " 1 "7 "

$@ 1 $

$$$ " & $ 1 5 ""

1 $ & $" & " """

1 & $ ""

& $ 8 $ 1 ""

$ & & $

$& &

$ & & " 5 " & $& 6 ?????%- &!""

D "5 );* - = $ "7 1 & 5 > )- ,,,7 * 2

?????8 "$$ $ $ "

$$ :& 5 $$ $ $75 " "5 5 ")"&% :

- + );=;* -,=* :11 "7 "

$@ " 1 "

6 )

"""

*?????

%5& 5 5 "

$""7 - "0 + ."

"1 $ $ "

& $ "& &" & 75 5 $ 1 5

$@ 1 " 1

" $$ "& "$&

-21- @ "$

" " " "

" L& " 15 " 5 : % "$ &

$$ $ & && && $

& &" & 7 " $$ $ $ "$& @ "7 5 " &" =; <;5 &

4$ " && "

5 "& 5 & &75 " " & $ " " "$ "

""" "1 "" 5

$ $ $

$$ & && 6 "

"$& $$ $ $5 ." $""

$& 7"

$ "

" " " 1 && 5 & $

"7 5 .& &"

$"7 "$ & $$ $ $7 "

$ & 4 $ % &$1&$ $ "$ & = % 1 & &"

"$ ""7"

"$ & $$ $ $7

"$& $$ $& " 7 && 5 " 5 "$$ E &

$$ $ & 5 " $

7 $

5 $$ $

0 1 1 $ 5 5 ""

4$5 "1

7 & & & 4 $ $

1 7 ""&& 1"$ 7""

7 " 5 $$""

&5 $

-22-

I & " &" $$ $7& "@ 6 ;

% " $ "7 5

$ & $ " 1 1 "1 ""

5 $ $ &

. $ & &5 1"

5 "?

1 1

$"5 . $ D

7 C

7 && " " - &

$ $$ "

$ $ & "&5 &&?1 "$ "" & $ 3 "3 $"3 1

$$& " "5 " & $ 1 1

$$ ""& "

" $ 5 " . " ""& $ $

$" $ 7 &7 $ $ & "$5 "$ $ $1

"$ """$

1 %" $$ " $"7 & 5 "

5 5 "7

. $"5

5 5 &&$ " $7

$ & "

"$ $ L " & C E" 7

"5 "&

,$ ""75 "

"& " 5 5 5 $ & $ " 5 " $ $ 5 1 & $"7

$ , "$&-$7 %%7 "$ $ C :$ & " - 4 + "

- &

7 ;<, '+ <,

"" & & "1 $$ $ & "

"$" " $ ".& & 5 "

1 $$ $

-23- %""

$$ " $"7 " "

. $"$ " $" & 8 ""7

& 7 &7 $"

" 5 & " " & 0 $

" 5 " " 7 " " 1 ""

""&5 5& "$ ""

&$& &

$ "

1 "

$"" & 4$ & " 5 " & 1 & "&"" 7 &7 &$5 5 "

". & $

1""

5 & $& " 5 5 &&$ & "$5 "&? " " " "

& $

" 5

. 5 "$& $ 1 ""

" & "&? 1 $"""

" & &"5 1"

1 $ - " "

5 " ?

$"$ " $"5 " & .

"" " "

.1 "

" & " 1 ""

. $ 5.1 " " " & $"

" . $ " ""

& &$ $$ 17 5 " " """ 8 $ " 0 . - 5 7 $ 7 & " -# 6 $B 3!

' 2 !

' 2 2 '2 2 7 $D 7 '7 ' 7 !

>-$0 2 >

1 '7

-24- ' '

!> !

7 ' /

+"$&-!)8-"

*B>=,7 1 ,, "@ & %& -$ B

5 &? N+"

=7=7 3 3"

5 E0 & +"

7< 7< 3& $

$ """& 7"

$ " 1" " $ & $

$ % "$ "7

$ 1" " $$ $"

- B =,5 "

$ $ & +"

<7=7 3 & " "

) "1 5 " $ "$ $1&+"

& * 1

$ 7 + "& $$ $& &8 $ & +"

<7=7 3 " " $ & +"

=7=7 3 3"

5 " $$ " 1 "1 $ $ 11 "O" $ " "

" 1, "@ "

$.5 &514 "&$ > P8

$ & "

@ " 5 & &" "" 5 " & $ 11 $" 1 $ &$ & "1 " "

" 1 , "@ " "

$5 & "$ 1 &, ) 1+"

7 3+"

7, 7 3 " "$&+"

7, 7 3"

$$ 17 & "& 1+"

7< 7< 3 <

-25-

+1 1 $$ $34$ & "7 5 $ "7 "

1 5" "7

5 ""11 " 5 5 " "" &

$ " 1 " $$ " "& "$ -% "" 1 " $$4$ " $3"

$5 ""11 " & C 7 :$

$ 1 "&

$ &5 -%% 5 555

" $ 1

$ ">33 " $ ?

" 5 $ " &$ 3" "$ 3R+ $

" % ) * & $

3 $ $ "

-%"

"%"& 1 $$ "

4$ &

4$ "5 5 ""& 1$""$ $3"

$ " 15 ""11 " & 1 $ & & $ $1 &

$ & " "

1 ,, "@ "

$.3 & = " ) ;

* "

" $ +"

=7=7 37"$ &

$"&"3"

" " %"& : &$"& "

$&"

$ 1&""5

1 %& -$B

7 : & &? " $ & +"

=7=7 3 3"

& CS & "" 1 ,, "@ 0"

-26- 1 C 71 1 .$3 & "

" @ "7"&

$ 7 1,,"@ "

$.3

5 $ & +"

7 7=7 3 "@ "

5 " $ " " $ & +"

=7=7 3 "@ "

1 "$5 "."

& "& $ $ " " $

$$ & 5& " ,)$* (+ ' ! 2 !

21 2

2 2 7 ' 7 '

7 ' > ! 7 ! !

2 7 7 '

++. -', ) +.

!"#$#

! %!& !"#$#

%) " - # '

. /'0 - # 1". /'0