← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3781/2007allowed

Krishan Lal Arora v. Barkha Ram And ANR.

2025-02-18Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

     

    

!"

#$%$!&'

( ( )    



   

  '

*+ ,( , ,  ,    





   !" 



 #

$  #

% !

& '   ('

)))) ,  , (

+

$ ( '&* $+ ,% %,,-

     $--    



 $.//'!   

0 ('

'   2(' 34  

 &  

5

   $ +, ,,,56 

&*

+8 

 '!

     



 $.

,+ %,,% %



   



9

 *'! ('

 

       

' !

,,,,   +

,+,   , :

( 

 

5





 '! ('  

* ;



* &     *&& $, ,,,56  <  

5

*+,! & 

 ;

6 4 (

=> 0& >

  *   4 (       &      &   

&    &  ?

  ? 

* (  ! '

*

 '    * @  

  

       *   !&   *

  

 '!  ('

& !' & 

5

  (  !   

+ >  

 *

 

   -

 * * 

* 

! * &!&  *  * !

 & ' 4 (

 6 &

  * & &

* ''!$6$5%

      &      &      (      ' ! 



 ? %,8 *  

 

A?

6:

4 (       &      &   

&    &  ?

  ? 

*  (  *9 &    ,+

+-  , ;

3'

 0   *&&&

 *  ' !

( ?0    .

/01 3%( .

/01

&5 &!6 2

 ,072 1 !02  % % 8

 6          

 

   

    

  !"#$%#!  

 #"   $#& ""'#&      

   " 

$%  !" ("(  (

" #" #    !

(  "

      

&    "

         

$ "'#$

  # $#  "( $% & " #"

"

& #

 & #( 

% #! 

 # "$&  "

'#   $  





& $ " &  %#&$#    ! #"# #  %#&    $ "  $& "#  $&  % & 

 ! !

#"

 % &"$#  %# " $&  #  #"   #" "

)* + )#$

 ,&  +#  # -,./0)#* #1/2.

4 (" *

  , " 5"

  )**

 "

6  7 #($&/0*82/

  "  # "  !  

   !""  



 %#&   ! (9        

 :    (        ;

  "     



# (

" "  # "#

 5   ( " (  !  %#"!

#"

""

$  %#"  (9

5   ("# ( "  <

$  5     ##   ( 

  #      "$&

 =##"   -

> # &"( ?  3(

 3(  # ( "#

'#   %#

 5    "@      (

 5   

   ( 



(&

,  # 

 %#& 

!$!""

&# ""  

 " 

,

&  #  %#&!  " "   $  ( "    

!$( "# " & " 

$      "   (   ##  ( 

  #        "$&  ##  "       "@      (

"   

        

   

 !

 %#

 "$ (  %# "

#    (  &

   (  "$&!   ! $ "& 

 

$#" $  (    (  &  #" &  (  

 (  &

  (  "$&   ! !$# 

$ " 

#"  (    (  &   (  "$&

 "

! "  %#">   !  "

#$'# &    "$&  (  "  

&    ("          "$&    (  &  (! $"$&$# !  " 

&

         "$&  &  #    "   (          (   &    "   

 " " (#

 #  

 #

% $( "# 

 "    "#$ 



 %

%%  

& 

%  

% '

 ()(9 %#"!

  !("10& "

 (. 1000@>

  "    "        "$&      $    

'#        %#&  !  20A   "   

'#   "$& 

!'# "10A  

 (  & !"$&$# 

$ " $ #  

 #"

)

 & $#  !(" * #



!$  !9  

#

$  " 9. 12000@> $ 5  ## (

#

 A  

#

9 . 800@>

# $!  (9/ "

5  ## (9

800/ 9 . 00@> '

 (*(9 %#"!"("10& ( . 1000@>

 4 "#" " "$&"20A 4! " % $   #" 

 

(  "  4       ( (   &    & !$  " (  &% $&!  & $ $#  "  ## (  &/ * #



! $  !9 

#

   " 9. 12000@> $ 5  ## (

#

/ A  

#

9. B/000@>

# $!  (9/ "

5  ## (9 B/000/ 9. 8 000@> '

 (+( 9 %#"!B & " & :

(  (#" #  " ! !

( "!#" "

!  "

 "$ !"/0A  %#"!  " ##     " '#"    #( #  ## (  &! "/0A   #



!$  !9  #

#

!

#" ( "$  &" :

(  9. 20000@> $ 5  ## (

#

/0A  "

#

9. 8B000@>

# $ &  9 "

5  ## (9 8B000 9. / 2000@> C-   9    (#  "

"    #

     "    &   (# ,#

*  !$"

 #   " 

  "+# # / ;

3'

    0           ,   '   +- .



/0 9

 :

, : ;



*   $-- $-:6 $-/   



 $.// 

*& 6 B      &?    C 14       & &  C

:

&   '  !&  C 1B4  '

& 

    !







  ? *  C 1A4 <        

&           &* 'C 6

! ? !

(     &  6  ! & 

$# ,  #

$(#

 

"

&             

 #   "  #     #" $ .  000 . 80000  " .  000  &    (""

 $  6# #"

$ >    '# #>     7       !

#"  $

"(  # !'# " #"$  "

  ($ && "    #"$ 0A   & 7" "  " $ #!$ (

 &    " .

;

3'

 0   1  .

  1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34 6 F/  ! '#" $ "$& #9 

 %  %(5( 

%(6(<  "  # #(

$ (    B1 && (

  %#"(  

-

, # *  &5"  &) "G B0/  *H  B/00  )*

 ,    82      "  %#"(    *

#

6  &"# " $ #" 

" $   ) )

"G 3  *  

 "

B00*H B )* , (( #  >B &#

$  

(!   (   "$&  " 



&"#"$& "

#  

" )*  

 "#! 

#

# $"      $   "

 /

-

%  

%





   %78 ,          "         "

!" $"  # H("   IGB0*H0 )*  ") " + #% #3 "I

B0/*H/ )*

7  $ !  # H(" #  9 J  ,   (   

 &$    "

  " $$   "

 ! #       &  "$&  

"  $&  

 "      "      !"   

  !"   

 #    

(      ! ( 9

   # (   "  #  # (       " <



5  

 #" (##

<



   $&           "   

   (! <



"   #" (  & $'#" # "  ##< "



  

 J C#"D  "  $ ;" 

%#"(  ) "+ #%  #  ( # "! ( & # " "(&! $" '# &  

# "  "$&#"   " ,  #

#   !  "$&   !"

@ ;





  # #$ "& K& #(# B0 H #&B01  #  %#"$  # # "9 J, % 9

# " ###



 #$ $

 



# " #$ $

( 



 #1"8I  ( "



#$    #(#



 ##



 #$ $

(  7 #" (

"

  

  ! (    #   &          #("$& " #   

" )*  

!



 "  # 6& 

   " #  %#  ! =#$  " 1 ) "  + #%    #    !  & (   # "##  

"    "   $  

"

7## '# & !  

 

  " "

  ! ("   ##    #    $ "      ( "$&1 A '#  



 $ %#"(  -

, # *

5"

 

#    &2  

" ((

 !

#"$ 0A  #&    

 $ 





 

  

    "8 ,    " !"

"

!

 "# ( #  ( A

!      %#"   

#     #" (     H("L  #

G  

(  !

 #"#"$& " #   

" 

 !

 " A  !  "$&* # +0,+-9'0,  #  "& (

"

   #



$&   #  &

!

#" $ "

"  !9 :

)       (   !

. 828B1 @00 . /@> =##     

0   ""

. 80@> "   #" (    (

#  . 8228@>    

    .

00000@>            " (

& .  0000@>   "# ( . B00000@>   . 821@>  !

#"#$ " 

. 821@> "

(! 

A

# "  

" & + $, > *  *  *'!;

3'

 0  '

 &   * $+ ,% %,,-  

& !

(

6

    

 

  66

<

,2( !( 5% !17 &% $!& = 25 5 $   

 ' !

 $ ,, ,,,56 %  ?  +, ,,,56 :

&  $ ,, ,,,56 @ (   &  %, ,,,56 +

0&  @, ,,,56 -

    +, ,,,56    %, ,,,56 / !

> !17 &% $!& %(? ?

@ <( 1!0& = 25 5 A4

2$A0& > %(?) ?

@ $, &6 &# 5

1!0& %( ? ?

@

? ?

?) ?

 $$

            

       '!  ;

3'

 0   

; *.

  

.

<  :  <. 0

 .$ , $ 

+ 

 ) ,072 1 !02  % % ?



6

 &E.8    

&

 

  F $% ( #

$6B       

 

&**(' * 

*     

! & (('

  '  

 

&* 

 

5

 (

5

   '

  ('

$:

&   !

  

,  , 

 

( ( )    G&5 6& &   G '

 H5#