High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23862/2014dismissed

Shashi Bhushan Nagpal, Ex. Treasury Officer v. State Of Punjab And Others

2016-02-29Mr. Justice Darshan Singh9 pages

! !"#$#%&'

(&) *(+, !" # $% & ' # ,- ! "(

($) $)!* + ,-.*/01( & ( - , 1 0 ( 1 '( "1 2( +'"2/

" 13 ( ( 1"( & ( ( 4 ( , $ " ( 5 4 & 4(

& 6

'4 5 7 ( ((

& !89)% 0 4(

"12(+"2/41 ( 4( 5&& (& ( 0( 0 4 !899-9: & 0 (&& 1 5&& 4( 1!8 !89:

1-( .))-$;-<))"

& 0

01 4(0

4 1 "1 = & 4( +5 ->>>/ !8<$ (( & 4( ? )!

!89:>0

& 1 4 0

(=4 3( ( 4 4(& 4 & 1&1 ( 0 &( (( & 5 4 & "

& 0 (3 0

101 &5 4 & 4 & 4( 3 0&1 4 & 5 4 &

( (& 101 (& 1 5 4 & 4( . 2 (&

& ,& ( ( &

&3 1 ( ( & 1 ,;))7- & 1( .))-$;-<)) +5 1( /" 4 1 &4( 4 & !:

!88*

0 04 &4(4 & 1( 0 '(&$* !88$&

4 4 ( 4( 4 & % (( @01 ( & A 0? 1)!

!88<"

& ( ( & 0 &

1 0

4 1& !9 !88*" (

3 (

( 0 * " , & 0( 0 4 0 (1 0( (& ( 4& !;

$)))

1 ( 0 4( 7 ( 0 ( '(&!;

!88:0 ( 40 (1 ,-!9"3 1 ( 0 ( ; " ( 1 ( & 5 4 & 4(

0 & -

( (( 101 ( & &

& "12(1!8

!89:+ ,-$/0(0( 1

& ' 1(( +& / 5 +5 4 & (/03( &1 1 4 & 1"20 &

0> & 4 & 4( 5 4 & 4&

& 1 01 " & &( (4 ( ( " (

( (& 4 & 4( (4&

4 4( ( "2 ( 3

(&& 5&& "

& && 4 & & 1 3 4( 4 "20 ( " ( 1 ( 1 1.!

!89:

( ((

5 & 4 & 4&10 1.!

!89: & "12(

( "4 4 ( 0 5 4 & 4( 03- & "0( 4 (-

#$%$&'

(

)

* +,-$.

! '

(

()

) *

* (

( *

(

1/( 2) (

< $ ( 1 ( 4 1 ( 0 1 4 & 1

& &

1 " &4 & (&1 9 "( & 1

1.!

!89:+ /( 4 40 01 "( (

& > (

, ( ( 0

4 4 3- & 5 4 & 4( > 0

( A (

4( ( 4 & 4 ( 0 "

& ( & 4 & % ( ( 0

& ( 1((& > (

( 1 0 4 ( 4 & 4(

&& 0( 0(( !88*2 ( & &( & (&10

4 5 4 & 4(

4 0( ((

5 4 & (4 :

& $+(/!8<$ 0( & (

& " 4

0- 3 # !'

(

) (

) 2)

4 8 " &1 &

& 1 01 ( 1 4( 4 & 6

0 & ((& ( ( ( (( 4" 0

1 4 &

& " & ( (

0 1 & 0 (& 4( 8+!/ (&&4((1(

& 01 ( 0 1 8+./ 10 (&

1&&4(

1&1( &

& & 4( (1, !) " & 4 !! +$/0(

0- 3 ,, 5 3 * ,%&6,776 (

(

)

!#'

)

(

( !

( !9'

( 1) :::::

!! B& 4 , C 4 & 4(C 4( 6 75 4 &

( 1&

44( 1& >& &1 & 0 ( ( , C 4 & 4(C & 1 4 & 4( 4(6 > 1( 0 < !!0& ? !* !88<0 && !9 !88* & & 4(0 ? !*

!88<

/ !$ " & ** 54 4( &!! ( 1 41 ( 4& !!+$/ **+/( 1 4 & &

10(& &

1 4 & & & 4 & " & 0" 4

0 4(5 4 &

( 1 ( " 4 ,-.1.!

!89: .9 1 & (0 4 & & " (( > 0 3- & 0 4( (& ( 1 (&0(& 4 ( (&& !. 4 ( ( 0 & ( 4&!;

$)))+ ,-!9/

( 1

( &

1 4 & &

1 0 0 ((( & 6 4 & 4 & > & ( 1 (4& (4 10 ( & ( 1&? )!

!89: 4 1 & !9 !88* " ((

& "2010 0(

"20 0.))-$;-<))0 00

1( ..)-;<) 5 4 & !* > ( 1 (

( 5 1 44 ( &" ( & ( 1 &- 4

0 (4 (

1"(1 &5 0!%%#(! 123# % !1 +42235%6+!7!18! 16%6 0!1$4(413# +$)!*/* 55!): 15 5% *< $)).0( ( 0( & ( ((& " 4 1 (0

1 4 1 & '(&$!

$)!$ (( &( &

!;0 & 0( & (( 0( (

10!89:"4 (&

& ( 4 4 ( ( ( 04 0 ( 1

( " (4 4 (1 ( 1 & 0( 4

4 4 0(

( 1 0 ( ( , & 1 ? 5 ( 1 0

' (0& ( D(&& &E" ( ( && " & 1

( ( 1( ( (4 ( ( ((

0 " ( F 4 ((

& 4& :,;