High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26390/2013dismissed

Gurmail Singh & ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-02-09Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri5 pages

! " # "

"$%&'$'() *+,&-&(./,(',(0/$ $0&0&($1 21 0,0$3,4,(,,('0/$1 $15('$(01

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

/00,A$2$0/$%/,.$30/$1%&$04,1,-1 &01$%'1 ($/*('$',('$&./0%,1$1:$$3&-$'<$3$0/$ 11&10,(0 $.&10, 5$,0&2$%&$04 /$$&(,30$%,--$',1= =3$33$%0&(.$%2$430/$ <:$',+*(03+0/$<:$1(0/$5%$115$+&11&(:,1,-1.,(0$' 0-'.

/$5$1$(05$0&0&($,-(.:&0/($ ,2&('$8,*7:/:$$,-1 '$51&0130/$1%&$043&-$',5$0&0&(*('$$%0&(1 C 30/$ %0 %-,&+&(.0/,0/*'/&!,(1,-70/$5$1$(0$15('$(0($%$&2$',(,+*(0 &(@*$10&(*('$0/$(,+$,('104-$30/$1%&$04(1/0+&1,555&,0&(,(' $+<$DD-$+$(0:$$0/$%/,.$1,.,&(100/$1,&'$15('$(0( 5,4$:,1 +,'$0/,0,:,'<$5,11$''&$%0&(./&+0$3*('0/$3&E$''$51&01,-(.:&0/ &(0$$101%$$'&(.1:$$&(&0&,0$'<$3$0/$ <&0,0:/5,11$',(,:,' ( 3,(,+*(03 1 >7 7 C,15&(%&5-$,-(.:&0/&(0$$10F

>G5$,((*+0<$5,&'<4/*'/&!,(1,-&(3,2*3/*+,&-&(./ ,('+0 ,2&('$8,* '&$%0&(:,1&11*$'00/$ +<,-,0$E$%*0$ ,:,'*('$$%0&(

30/$ %0 /$ 5$1$(0 $15('$(0 ( +2$' ,( ,55-&%,0&( <$3$ 0/$

$.&10,5$,0&2$%&$0&$17,4,(, /$$&(,30$%,--$',1= 31$00&(.

,1&'$0/$$E5,0$,:,'',0$' 10,0&(.0/,0/$:,1&(%*10'4,(':,1 $-$,1$'(<,&-&( $<*,4 /$ 2&'$&01'$',0$'

'$$'0/$/&$3 *'&00'$%&'$0/$+,00$,3$1/,30$.,(0&(.,'$@*,0$ 550*(&043<$&(./$,'0$15('$(0(/$%,1$:,1/$,'<4 *'&0( 2,&*1',0$1(0/&15%$$'&(.70/$5$0&0&($+2$',(,55-&%,0&(<$3$0/$

:/0A*50/$+,00$,.,&((

,('$%,--$'/&1$,-&$'$ ',0$'

"$15&0$0/&1,('$',0$' B

:,15,11$'1$$A&(.0 ,00,%/ C '1,-,43/*'/&!,(1,-

$15('$(0(0/$(3&-$',$2&1&(5$0&0&(*('$$%0&(

3 0/$ %0%/,--$(.&(.0/$'$1',0$'? > BHB > B7B > >,('

0:*-'<$$-$2,(00$E0,%01+$50&(130/$D&+(&'$1 5,11$''*&(.0/$ %*1$3/$,&(.$1*-0&(.&(00/$.&$2,(%$1,&1$'<4 $15('$(0(<$3$0/$ <&0,0$2$(0*,--4%*-+&(,0&(.&(0/$'$30/$ ''&0&(,-/&$3$%$0,402$(+$(03,4,(,&+5*.($'/$$&()

$%$&

'( )'* !

# "

- " #

)'*

- "

. / 0%

'( )'*

- "1 0&15$0&($(00+$(0&(/$$0/,0$15('$(0(:,1&(%*10'4 :$3 > >0 ,('/$:,1($2$&(&0&,0$',<*00/$5%$11$2$( 0/*./0/$5$0&0&($1$2$',(&(0&+,0&((/&1%*(1$- /&1&1($30/$.&$2,(%$130/$$15('$(0(,1(0&%$'&(0/$ &+5*.($''$0/,01$2&%$30/$5%$$'&(.1/,'0<$$33$%0$'&(0$+130/$

"#$#75,,1,('30/$

*-$1,$$E0,%0$'/$$<$-:)

(

,('$:,15,11$'<40/$ ,%%$50&(.0/$ 5,4$ 3 0/$ $15('$(0 ( $.,'&(. , /$,&(. A$$5&(. &( 2&$: 0/$ 5%$$'&(.1,.,&(10/&+:/$$&(/$:,1($2$1$2$'/$ 2&'$0/&1'$ $+,('$'0/$+,00$<,%A00/$/&$3 *'&0*<1$@*$(0-40/$1,+$33&%$ (%$ ,.,&( 0A *5 0/$ +,00$ ( 0/$ 2$4 1,+$ ,55-&%,0&( :/&%/ 10' %(%-*'$' 2&'$ '$ ',0$'

,(' <4 2&0*$ 3 0/&1 '$ ',0$'

(0&%$'0/,01&(%$$15('$(0(*'/&!,(1,-:,1$5$1$(0$'<4 /&1%*(1$-/8 ..,:,-7/&1'$3,*-0:,1&(0$(0&(,-$70/*17'&1+&11$'0/$ ,55-&%,0&(0&1,.,&(100/&1'$0/,00/$$15('$(0(5$3$$',$2&1&( 5$0&0&(<$3$0/$ ''&0&(,-/&$3$%$0,4:/,%%$50$'0/$1,+$<4/-'&(. 0/,00/$ /,'(,*0/&04&(-,:0$2&$:/&1:('$(%$/,2&(. %++$(0$'*5(&0&(3,2*3$15('$(0(0$+,('0/$+,00$<,%A00/$ /&$3 *'&03/$,&(.,3$1/,30$.&2&(.,'$@*,0$550*(&043<$&(./$,' /$ ''&0&(,- /&$3 $%$0,4 2&'$ &01 '$ ',0$' > ,%%$50$'0/$5-$,<4($.,0&(.'$',0$'

5,11$'<40/$ ,('

$10&(.0/$$,-&$'$:&0/0/$3*0/$'&$%0&(00/$5,0&$10,55$,<$3$

$.&10,5$,0&2$%&$0&$1( B /&1&10/$%,*1$30/$.&$2,(%$130/$5$0&0&($

( '*$ %(1&'$,0&( 3 0/$ +,00$7 ,+ 3 0/$ 2&$: 0/,0 0/$ &+5*.($''$&15$3$%0-4J*10&3&$',('0/$5$0&0&(1,(1,(4+$&00'$1$2$ '&1+&11,- /$( 0/$ 3,%01 ,$ 1$$( &( 0/$& 00,-&047 $15('$(0 ( :,1 %+5-$0$-4'$5&2$'3,(550*(&040%(0$10/&1%,1$1&(%$/$:,1&(%*10'4 ,('0/*1<-&2&*130/$5%$$'&(.1/$ $+&00$'0/$+,00$<,%A0 /&$3 *'&03'$%&1&(,3$1/:&0/,'&$%0&(0.,(0/$,&(.0$15('$(0 (/&1:,1&(%+5-$0$%(3+&04:&0/0/$5&(%&5-$13 % :,,(0&(.0/$,'/$$(%$05&(%&5-$13(,0*,-J*10&%$0&170/$$,30$7 0/$ 3$--&(.,2$$<4$2&$:&(.&01:('$,(''$%&'&(.0/$1,+$ ,55-&%,0&(:/&%/,-$,'410''$0$+&($'/&1:,100,--4&+5$+&11&<-$&( -,:3,(430/$5,0&$1/,',(4.&$2,(%$,.,&(100/$'$30/$ 5,11$'

$,-&$(

$+,('&(.0/$+,00$3,3$1/'$%&1&(70/$1,+$%*-' /,2$<$$(%/,--$(.$'<$3$0/$,555&,0$,*0/&04&(,%%',(%$:&0/-,:<*0 *('$(%&%*+10,(%$1%*-'0/$1,+$/,2$<$$($2&$:$'<40/$2$41,+$ 33&%$(0/$1,+$,55-&%,0&(:/&%/,-$,'410''$0$+&($'/$'$<$&(. 5,0$(0-4$($*1:,1&./0-41$0,1&'$<40/$ ''&0&(,-/&$3$%$0,4

0/$,3$1,&'$,1(17'(03&(',(4$,1(+*%/-$11 1*10,&(,<-$,-10&(0$3$$&(0/$&+5*.($''$ /$5$0&0&(&170/$$3$7'&1+&11$' &#&''&"$

()!*+(!

,-(