← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1405/2008allowed

Sukhpal And ORS. v. Chhattar Singh And ORS.

2020-01-15Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal13 pages





 !" #$% &  % 

 

 '()*+), -------**++  )),./)), ------* 0 

 '()*+), -------**++ 

,1),'/))++,2 ',/), ------* %3..4--  

4

5$6 -#  67

"6

  





 ! "# $ %"

& "#   

 '"

($)*+, ++- 

  !

"./0

($)*+, *+1 ++-""

/ 0    00  ./0

  &!     2"       3"



  " 4  

"

/

&



 &  "

!"  &!00 ./0

5

 ""%

" %"

/ 6 %" 0"

 7   

       

                  

  

     !  

"# $%&#      

 #  

  

     '

" "

 %

/"

./0

  +  ++8    &!     3"  

     % " "

./0

  ,  ++' &!  2"  !4

" ""

 "0"

!    %   "

  

  "

     /%"

0 

+  

9

':,

  

 0

"



 0

 ,; 1+"   ;88&! /" )  6

0 ,;1,;81++1+81+1181111     '1;;-  +8;;-  '8;;-  88;;-     ,8;;1   % /"/ "&"

""

 " &"

/

"/



" 

+  

0

"& & ""

"%./0

  ;,;-,"

"""

 , "&!$&</3" / %"

 0

.   "

/

' ;=>0

"

/"

%   "

" 0

 ""



 0"

  ! 3 % "  !

" 



 (0."4 

 0 //    !"

"

 

9"0 !++!&

""

/

  :,

   0 // %/

0&!

% "

!;1* ;1-2   %"

/! "0 ) ;' $  0

"" ! ""

/4

"

/ ;8 = "

  

? ;8 ?> 

"  % %6" &0"

 "

"     "

/  "  0 

0""&    %"

  "0

"& (0."4%% 

 0

0""& 2 

!" 6"  $ ;

 ;8 &

 /"  

"  0"

/11# 0"

 (0."4 

  0"

/8'# 0"

 :

%&"

/ & &!

""

/= "

    > 

"

    "

/  0



"/"&  %"

"   0

 0 &0"



)' -"

!;8;5

"





 0

0



 !

&

"



/ @9 ' * ,

1"



);=> ;=>"

!;;-

"  = "

>  "    ""  "

  ,    ;-'  

,,;-'&!"0 "

/ "/"

% = (0."4> %

' -="

"

>

5

""

"

%"0

" 

;  +

" "

"

 &0% 

 &!

9 "0 "0

0 //   !  ! 5

""



  "

&"/  % 

' -="

"

>%

/"

9 2 ""

%  ;,;-, % "  /

/        %"

    6

"  "  

0

. 



" 

; +"

""

% "

   

 -"

""

 "/

"

"

" 6

   "&

""

"



 ;;,%"

" &2 ""

& 

 &!



);=>=&> =>  0





 ! 

)+   0"

"0

" !"

/

$  ! "

)   "   



4 2" 

" " 

"&!

"% 

  "

./0

 &!

2"  "

" "

 %

 4



%"

/   "

./0

 &!

2"

 "> (0."4

"/"

% =&"/ % >  ""

"

"

/&

      "">             &  

  

  )  '    -   

"  "

"

    2 !    "

0

 & "

0 """>   ./0

         ;,;-,  " 

&"

/

"/



)  "$  0

"" ">  "

 "6" &% /"

"

!   ".0& "=  >  ! 9

 @9 A >  

"       /

     ;88 ">  0

"

!0 # % 

 "

!;88" &"&"

&  & "">   "

 "  &    B   (      

""

""

!;-'%""

!;-,

""">



)  " " !&.

/"

/0 //% "

/ 0"

  % / "9>

" 

)+  

% "

% "0 0 // 9> "&!

"" !&&!

"0"

9"> "&!

"" 0"

&

"6" "9  B ( '   9""> ."" "" "& $

1

 ;8  "             

"

/   

     

/  $     !     

  "  

     %"

"  &  "     /  

/

./0

&!

&%

 

 

&

"  90"





 /" &!

"

 &"0 

"

 



)' - "

  ;,;-,"

" 

+  &% "



9

':,

 

" "

/

)' -%

 /"

 9    

! "     

  2 ./0

&!

 "9 "" &"

/ ./0

""

" "&! 0

."" 5 0!

& 

 

 

" %



./0

 ;,;-, &

  / "  /"

"%

" 

"  /%"

0

!& % "

  )%      90"

 

     /"  &!     "



"

./0

2"

 "> 3"  "/ &!

 " 

"



)+  %

"

  /" "%

"

/   % /$ ='>

 ;8 0 

&"

"C"

  "

/ 0

 0""&   &

   



 % &!/"   $&((-

 ! ""

/ 4  "

/(;8'= "

  

?(;8'?> "

 0

 "

305 & 

 % 

0 //%"

"

&!/"    5 

%"

"0 !



"

"  

 

      ;8    "  "   

  0 //  %"



 & %  ! " % " 0! & "

" 0

 +  

" "

"

  "!6"2 

3"

"

0"

"  (0."4

&"/ % %""

0 "  ""> /  "

0!&

 

3"  

      

       &  

  

' -

!  "

"

0

 6

!

& "

 ""%

" 6  0



' -

"   "



0

" "  %6 !

 0"

/"



' - 



   ;,;-, 2 



' -

"  

;=>=&> =>

"0

!"

)%%"

/  )="""> "&"

0!

&

&

./0

  ;,;-,"

&"

/ 

  "$  0

"

""

%"

"&"

/ 

' -

""

 ( )=">/" &!

  !"" &!

" "%

 

 ( )=>/" &!



"&" !"

 

   ;88  &   /&!

"2

  !

"  ( )=">/" &!

 ""

 

 "!"

"%./0

&!

  ;,;-,  %

:

"

&0 & "

# %/



"

!;88 ( ="">/" &!

" "

  % 3" !"

"

 !"  & 0&!

"  &

0"

&""

!

B (    "

/

" "

&

&/

 B (   "

"



""

 

" 0 0"

#

""



""&0""

/&6

"

 0 5

 ""

%" &! 

 

"    

!    &0  %   "

&!9 "0B

!

""0

!%

# %/

;88 

" 



""

"/ 5 "  "

! "%/"

"

+  

/  "!6"  

  "

/  % " #    & 

  0



"

!   /"

 

 ;88%"&"

" &"

/

"/



"     0  

   +       2  &   

0"

&""

! "

 B ( "

"& &"

"  &"

""

% 0   ( )=""">"/ &!

 

 " "

 

"



  

"/"

&"/ % " "&. %"

 





"

/& 0 //%"



"%

6" &/" " $ !6"0

 "  0 //%"

 " $ ='>



  %"

 (  -  = >   

  (    ;8'        

&.   "   !  #  &! 

  &"/     %    5  "   !

6"0

 % "  /

    &  %  &! 

    /" (  )  ="9>    "  &  "     

"!%

" "./0

 &! 0

   ;,;-,"

" 

 +   &% "

2"

"""

  &  ""

&6

"

 "& 0  / !"



! ( )=9>/" &!



" &

    ;88""

"



0 !6"0



 2 

"



!%   " ! #"

/

% 6"0

  /"

/  ( )=9">/" &!



" 

  

"

"

0"

&&

" 0!""

/9

    B    (  '      "

/ 

      ;,;-,5 0!&0



"" 

  

"   /%"

0  

   &0  %   "

   

  

    '    -  %

  "

0"

"

/"

" %"

 6

""  0

.   5  "0  "!%

0

"

"

0 & &!

( 

"

"&

"&#%"

 ""

/ ! "

"

0

$  0

" !

" "

2 "

"&!

0"0"

& "!%  & /



 "

"

/"

"  )% 90"



 )=9"">" .""

"" "& $  1

 ! 4 ""

/ $  1"9     ;. 0-$,3<',...==>) ""   .""  =>

  %"

"

 "" 0 

    % " 

"/

$  0

  

" D =&> 

  "      %"

  !

0

% " " 

" 6" &

 " %"

&!

3"

"00"" 

 

"&

"

! = > )

3"

"00"" 

00""  

  

"& 

"

!0 "

 

"   &"

6 ! E )&

.""

"" "&



" !0

6" &." :" 

 ;;1 %"

"%



"

 &!

  

"

!           "         "

"

 !6"0

"" "

" 0"

& (" "

"/ &  3"</  ./0



 "/ 

3 ,1),>->. 7'?,),;-1=> .&4%(   % "

 &   

     

"  

"

"

  0

" 0 !&

" " &! "& "0"

.""

%"

 ""

/ "

  !

%& "

!    /"

""      " 

     9 !  & 

.""

"" 

 "

  /

""

!/"

!

 &!

    "&    2 "  6  %     /"

 "&!  

$ 0  (

  ) *   

 "

"



"

./0

 "< "% "   

& 0

" % )+, )

-= >0  ""   "   

        "

 % &

$ "  ="

:0"

8 >"

0"



" 0 ).-185 

 =5(;*+ +,> . /"



 "."" " 9&! "" 0#"

""



"

""



"" ."" 90"

  "

    %  

  ""    

"  0 "%"

2 .""



"" !

/"



  &! 

  2"&     $ "  <""  "

"

"" 

  "

"

  . "%





/

."" "" 6

/"

! ""

!



2"& %9 !

&&!

 E  /"

"%

" 

./0

&!





& "

/!

0" "</0

&!

2" "  &



% --  

67

"6 #  # %

 #"

/:  G:)

(  & G:)