← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22241/2016dismissed

Raghbir Singh & ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2020-10-01Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary,Mrs. Justice Meenakshi I. Mehta18 pages



         !" # $ 

% &

"'()*+, '(" #" -(.+ 

,-"-. "+/" "" #-(.+0  

      !" # $ 

%1 & "2", '( 

,-"-. "+/" "" #-(.+0  

      "-. .30 4   4 56 , ,   56 , ,7, 4  

 

  

 

 

               

888   9   

    !         "

     

 !

!  ""   "    ! #$ "%& '()*+(+( %,& +++-*+(*.



    %,& +++-*+(*.!

%   

" /  #           (+ (* +((+  0$   -1         - !  +- *+ +((+0$ )1 

 .    +* *+ +((-0$ .1

 ** 2 / *3'-

!"

!                  +-0+1       4 #     5  %"  6   2 / 4

!

  4"+(*70 89 +(*7:1 "  & "  +) *( +(*.      ;    # "

     "

   ! #%& '()* '()' +(+(

!"   %,& +++-* +++-< +(*.   !   

!   #   *(* +(*7   #    

 

  %  

 !"



 "

!   

    !  

!  #   *(* +(*7 #     "

  %,& ++'-3+(*-+**)+(*.).)+ *)+'< +(*<  7+<    +(*3    ).'    +(+(       !"

  

   "

 "!

%     !    !    



2     !"



 *(* +(*7 "!   ) 4 # 

%"  6   2 / 4

!

4"0  ""1+(*<0 89  +(*<:1 ! #      /     =! =

  /  2 / *3'-!"

! 

   *(*  +- () +(*3!     

!""

(* (* +(*- 

     +(*.

 !"



  *(* +(*7  ! "

  -3 2 / *3'-0 89  *3'-:1!

        -3  *3'-       /  # !  "    

!



 *.*<0*1    *(* +(*7 

      

!

 !



  "" "!   

   *(*      

!

  ! %    ""

"!   ! $    "!

 " "  " / 

 *(* 

!  "

   6  "

 ! 

 *(* +(*7   

!



   

#   2   % !"



 ! ! ##  "

   !  !" # 

 # !   *(*  2  % !"



   ! #    

  

    ;"  #  > "! 

!

!#                     

 !"





!;    #      "

  !

#  # !    !"



    

 !!?! $% ;#"  

        

    !"



%,& +++-<+(*.  !  

 "  #*+!

#

 /  !   "  @   

 ""

  ' 7+A77B  !     +* *+ +((-                  

     4  4@ "

& +.7 +* *+ +((- 6  

  "     

                  

""    %,& *333<+((-

# # /  # 

  # " *7 *+ +((-     6  

  

 

   (' (' +((3  !!"

                         "

/  #  / !"



         

"            ;         (7 (3 +(*+

 !/

#!  !   #%,& *('.+(*7

  "

  ! 

 

"

  "  

/ ! %  4# 5    

" "  #

% >

 

  

 "  

        

"         "  

# #  

/  #      

%!  # %,& '-3-+(*7

  "

+* () +(*7 2 

 !"



      %, & +737++(*-

"

# !   +-0+1 +(*7

     (< *( +(*)          6 

"   ;  (' (3 +(*. 6    

   2   !"



! #%, & +++-*+(*.  

   "!      !"



   ! 



    !   

!   #   *(* +(*7  #"     ,



 " 

!    " 

         6 

!"

  "         "

  #  !"   *(* +(*7 5  !    # #         

 

!;     # "

 

 #       /     "

  !    !     #  # !   

 #   *(* +(*7   "     

 

  !! $ %    ;#"      

    !    0  # !?! $%

  #   +-0+1 +(*7 !  #

#    #      +-0+1 +(*7               ;#"   !

#     #    #      +-0+1  +(*7 "  $

 C



"# $%& & "#      

         

 !

   "         #$%& '$(&)  '&*+%  

   "'# %  & &  "&#      , - 

    #  $%$  

!     , -  ,- !   .

   #$%$ '$(&)/          

 !   !!! '"

 

 / !     "

 /"!    

  #!  "!  "

 

/     "

# %& &"(#    !      #)&&'&*+%" !  !.

     #$%$ 0 !   0     !                 

! 

 !   #)&&1   

!       ! " !.

    

 #$%$'$(&)    

!4  D  "



 "

#   



 

#      "

  !    +-- +-) ;#"    

   !  0 1  

$

 C



"# %

#&2'&*+%  

 ! /

#3  ! 

        !  !

 #3  ! #!      !   #&4&  5

6 

'&*+%"   #$%$'$(&)" 

5

 

6



! ! /  

    

 

 !   #$%$ .

    

 

  /"

   !7#

.

    

"  # 3  !  !  !

      #      

"           

"

  "      

   

  #  !  !

  ")# %   (    .

              

   / 

   '&*+%  

5

 

6

#$%$'

!  "      !       '    &*+%" 

 /  

! 

 

 /  

  '$(&) 

! /  



 7#3  !.

      !!  !/

"!  / 

 

 8   /       .

 "3  ! 

   !      

        



   

.

 3  ! 

       

  

 /

  .

    

   "

       0  !   !

            

""

!   

  

# 

  

  

    



  #3  !       

"          #     !    /  

   +- +(*7    ;#"  

   ! 0 1  "   & 7)' 7.70'1  C

"*# %&(7   #$%



     !

   

.

 

#$%'$(&)    #$%  9 !     "    !

            !

  

"    !

  ! 

 ! #$%  "" !   !"



 /" !        

      

   $%$'$(&) "+# %& &"##$%$'$(&)     

.

       .

#$%     !'$(&)""&&$(&%      !0   !

         .

   !/

    ! !  

    .

6 E ;#"   

   !   0 1         "   !   

   #   !

D!

   

!

 



    

  !    6 #  /  # !

#  " 6 #  #

!    "  *(*  +(*7 !#       & ! 

   ! #  $      !#  #  #      #"   *(* +(*7

!  +(*7!   ""+(*< 

        +- () +(*3    *(*      +(*7   C

:&(&'   07 

 "   .

   1'.

'"&*+% !

  0

 "#3  !        

 "

 !

"   

 #  3  !"        !    !     ! " "



   

 .

;

    .

     <    !

        "      ! ! 

        ! ! " "  !

#3  !: E 

    

   ! #   !  "

!  # 

    

#3  !  /  2 / *3'-  ! 

 

  !  /        2   /     *3'- 

  !"





! 

 #        "  

D    &    

%

$ #   ;       "

 " $    #  

   ##  #      >       !   !    !

!# !  

    #     ! #  > "  #    ! 

 #"

 "   

 "  !  #  " %! !  #   !?2 F#   "  "$ "

   " ""

   %    ! / #

" ""    

#    





   

 !  6 !

  "  $ 

#                #        6 "!!   ; "

    6 ?! "%>

  ;#"



"

 " !    D $        "  "   

"   "

     6 #     " "

 !  





;#"=! $%     , -  - 

 &" #

(.                            "   C

5$4 1                    "    

   "                !    !

         !       

 # 



7 =!

'7  =!

 

        !

  

          !"

  >   "

    !   

     7      

       !!

      #  3  !       #&%(' 

%&+4?

     " "

       #  3  !           

   ' "                 "           "                9"

   

 

    !    /  3  .

    /       /   

!

     

   @ 

 !!

"

  " / !"    !"  9  "

9! "     !"

#A 

     

 

     (       =9           

  



/ 



   5  ?! "%  /,0 1         0    "#  

 &  !  C ,' !!

 

"                                B         #            !        

  

#      

             !    

9    

    9

 A > /%  2             =! $% ! C

5       

  !                                      !  

 .

 

     !!     

  !!

  ! 

       7    9      !     !                   !!          !        "  9  6                 

            ##  # 



    #  "      ;     

  %         !    "   "" #  

"     *(* +(*7 

 #   ! # 

   #  

/   ;       

" G! ?

  / 

!"

! 

 #  #  #     #  ! #

     #   !?!  "%    

   3 0  1 >! "  

?! "%

  #   +-0+1  +(*7

 #  

    

   " "!  >    

# C 5$?%     / C'  '!   8 C8     ' &*+%       #D  !@        >  

 "

 .

   !           !  " #  #    

  /

  !   



           

.

       #%&  

 

        #  !  !

 "  8  .

 "



     0  >    "    

                 .

  8

  /" #  !  !

 E   &2&4".

   

!    3  !   !     

 $??    F         1    F  / ! @ / ! GC8 "       

 ! 

  "    "! 

  !       



; 5)*  5 6  !          

       

      5 6    "! 

    "  5 6      

     

! 



    

   5 6  !  !       "    

   !  "  

     '  5 6    "/   ! 

 

  !

        ! ! "  !"    

" :

:    

 !   !

            

  :

:          !



!   

!                              !

   H   I   C   =  E D !  !

"' &+?4# )%%"= 9# #E' &+42#$2($"

=       F=  ' &+*4# *($"  /

   F  / ! D/ 

&++&# $#$$*"= ! I .

  E' &++?#2(?"#%(%" %&"3 



  '    F<!"       &++2  )  #  $*$"  J  # / !    '    '

   $(((  )  #  %*?"

=        3   @!

  

    !     '  $((&  #  )2)(    #   /3   =     $(&(* #%24K6 $?2

"    



      # &2&4'&*+% 

 /"

        

  

    &2"/     

 "

 "   %"     2"

   +"    &&

          

   !

   !

               F    

 #

   !

   !        

! 

 

           0         !

/        

     

   

 /

#"   

 



  

         $?4'   #"     #8 #    !=    3  @!

C8  

   !

  C' &24"   

  #$$(@!

=     '     

      

   "&*2$214?

; 5* 

 #$$(   

     !

  

         "

.

   !  .

 





 5 6 #$$('L

      214*" 



1     ;14* 5 , -  "  "!



!  !, -

 !     !     

  ,  -  M , -M     

  " !   9 !  @ !

   !  

 @ "

 

, -  !

  

  "

    !    @    , - ! !" !" 

 !  !   "! " 

6 &?7 "  "  5 6!

 " 

   !

 " 

      '6 $?* , -   

     '  

   !     !

       

  8     

 "

 /" $%$

  !               !    #  

! 6     !

 ?! $%

   

  #    

  #    

   /    # 

  !                 #        !     !  #         "      ! 



      ;#" !=! $% $  >  "             %     

  #  !  "   

!#   # !



 !

!#         # #  # #  # !

!#   #!     ! #%& '()*

'()'+(+(  %,& +++-* +++-<+(*. 

   %,& +++-* +++-<+(*. "

 !  !   !  $ 0

%" #

%1 &  "

           "-.#4   7,

  

   ,  

#D C HD& ,   !C HD&