High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23212/2015dismissed

Harsh Yadav & ORS v. Panjab University & ORS

2016-12-09Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari13 pages

!"## $% !"&#

'" ()'

***)

! "

$ %

&'!&(

&) *%

*+ $

$ &, *- . .! "

$/ ! "

$ %!' (0 / ! "

!# 11/ ! "

!# ,0 2345 **+! ,+-+.%+ / 6

#

*+

6 # $ '07..8 ! 2

3 5

4 "

:2354; :# 9 6 #3 5

4 "

;! !

<5= > <# 9 2

85:3 ;6 8 0

#

"

9

#( 4

#

85:3 ; 9 #

# 2

# 5

"

:254;0 (! 0 ."

'?%-'-%(:

= ';! 6" 6

.

%(%''-%(:

= ,;

$ ' (

6" "

0 !

#85A8 #+ " 9

9 6 #"

# 9 "

'-%, 9 3

! # 9 " :

= %;2

$ ( ## 853 ?## "

#85A8 9 ! ' ## 85 3 5

B

4 "

6 #+C

85:3 ;A8 4

" D 69 + 9 85 4 (! '-%(! 9 <5= > < "

9

(

2 3 " # 4 "" 5" :

2345; 99 6

9 !6" 6"

99 D

9 ''-)'-%(

7

(!6"6"

."

'?%-'-%( <5= > <

4 6 9

9

857

( 2

9

$ ( 9 6 " 6"

"

""

!

-)-)'-%+%--)'-%+:

= (+;4! " 9 #

!"!

! 9

9

!

%( 3 #2!6

6 ##

! 3 6 "

<5= > <6 "

( 6

# 0 ! !

$ ' # 8 "" #85:3 ;!85:B

"

; 5:3 ; #

"" !8

6 # 9 2345!

2345 =

2 6

6

9

"

#"

9

#"

#"

9 ( 85A8 6 9

4

6 7

!254 9

"

03"

9 6# 6

."

" <5= > <

4

#85A8 6"

254 9

9 "

'-%( '02

6

85:3 ;A8 "

'--*0-) 2

!# 6

#

( ! 6 6

5

"

9

# + 2

"

!

85 :3 ; 6 8 6 6 > 9 6" 6 9

!

6 ! !

# 85 8 3

6"

# 6 #

9

'--*

'-%' '"

#"

#

"

9

#%-

99

! 9

# 9'-%,

6 6 ' "

#"

#

"

9

# %%

99 :B 2

85 :3 ;6 8 "

+C 2

85:3 ;

6 8 ;

" #

( ! 6" 6 "

# 9 '--*! 9

6

'?%''-%, 39 7 2 "

6 .

" +

"

4 3

6 # # .

9

''-''-%(

9

9 " 6 9

"#

( #"

!'-%(4 2

#"

! /3

#"

# 9 2 .

" 9

+

85 :3 ;6 8 '

# "

"

2

6 # "

2 6#

"

#

(

9 +

6 6

9

9 ( "

4

9 + "

"

#

( 4 9

6

6 2345#

8

"" !

7 "

!

%%-&'-%?!

6 #"

(

9

! 6

"

6

9

"

."

!# 5

! 6

."

"

> 66 9 6##

(+C "

! 6

9

#

9

6

# 9

9 6 9

?

#6"! $ '(6

4 6

6 9 6 99 ## 6

*

) %-

6 D

8 6

5

,%-&'-%?! 6

""

! 6

6 #"

# 8

"

##"

"#" 9 6

9 D " 30%,')%03@0'-%? 6 9

."

'?%-'-%(!

9 6" #"

6

'# 9 5## 6 9 #

"

#9

#! 9 ##"

6

6 6

$ '! 6 '#"

9 9

' ##

39 72

! "! '?%''-%,! E

9

7 9 '?!'-%, 33

#6

#5

85:3 ;#

(0

" %7 2 "

3 '7 B"

#5

4 "

,7

:

3 !2354;

( #13 18

9

" #6

#5

#85 :3 5 ;6 8 :+0

;#

(0

"

.

9

?%''--* FG22: 30?; 6 5

B"

9

-,-('-%-:"

;

6 .

"+0

85:3 5

;6 8

"

6 !

/ 8"!

5

B"

"

."

.

.

#85:3 ;6 8 '-%-0'-%% D

6 #

3

5

6 8 #

(0

" 9

.

?%''--*

! 9 9 9

9

0

;4 #853 5 6 8 :+

; # "'--*'--)9 9

5

"8 D " 9

" ;4 6 #5

"9 "

+

85:3 5

;

6 8 "

03"

D

: ; " ."

H.

99

."

: # ;

: #

; : #13;

:

18;

2 "

6# # ."

''-''-%(

6

9 '--*0-) "!6 +

D " 6

!

" 4 6 ! "! 7

H 7 '

"!

23546

6 4 6"

39 '

%+-('-%+ :

= %?;6

, 6

"

#

"

9

(C $

6

9 39 #"

#9 !"!

6

6 4 ."

"

D

''-)'-%( (2

%*-+'-%(!

9 #"

9 "

9

"

853 25446

# 9 D

'?%-'-%(!6"

#"

9 E$>454 ."

9

%*-+'-%(: %*;:

=0FF222;

"

254

#"

! 9 9 85A8

# 9 '-%(0%+ "

853 254I 2"""9 "

!

."

9

(02

8 99 !

"

#" " #5

( 4

9

!

!.

9 !'-%+# 9

!

9

!

9 +C "

85 :3 ;

# 0 6

#

9 # 9 ##

!9 6 D !"

9 #5

6

( 853

9 6 # +C

4

!

!

""

!"! ""

69

! 6!"

9 # !"4 9

."

"

##"

# # (!6

#

" !"!

6 "

##"

5

2

#254

" " !

9 '!6

9

9 2#

6 !"!

"

#"

! 6 6

9

"

#

"

9 #"

!6

#"

9

"

!"

""

5 = (+6

6

"

0 #"

# 9 2# 6 "

=9

# 9

"

#"

# ! 6! " 6

2

" 9" = "

(!"

6 9

9!

##"

" "# 9 9

9

3

3

6 " 9"9

"

9

" # "

!#

6

" "

" 4 "9

"9

!6""

"

# 6 5

6

"

4

#

9

" 9" = 4

# 3

6

# 6!9 # !6" 9

#

3

!6"

""

" 9

9 =

! "# $ !% &!'

() ** !

6 6 0 3 =

"

6 6

6 6 !

" 9" 9

# 9

9

"" = "

= # "

0

0 6 "

"

9I 66! #

!#

+,,- *! , . , ! "#! &!'/0

(

)** =3 1 (/#)"#/# #2#3' (

) **'

= 9 #

# 6 3

9 # #" 9"7

6

= =

# 6 " 9

4

0 E'-2

"

# 9 ## #

5= 3

" #

=9 " J D #" ! = 6

9#

# .

"

2 "

! 7 8 "6

#

9 5=

## = 4 5= 3

#"

" J 9 " "

"

D #" D

6 6

# 6" 6 ""

'%2

"

# 5= 3

# = #

2 " ! =

D #" ! = 6

#

# 6 9 4 7 8 "

9 <

=

#

#.

"

I .9 # ,"# 4 +'

(4+)

( )*3

! 6" 6 " ##9 #550'--?4 7 ""

=

#

! 9

6

=3 6"#

"

#

#

# "

!

4

0 E%)4! ! #

#"

# 9 6

# 9"

#" #

"

6

D

" !

"" 9

" 9"#

"

6

# " 3 6

# #

#

6 :;

#

"

!

K:;9 #

9

" "

K 6

"" "

"" !6 ! " !

"

"

"

! 6 "

"

#"

4

9 "" ! "

9

"

69" !

6

= @ "

"

"#"

# "

" # 9 ! 6"# 9 0"9

!

"

" "" 9 # I 4!

"

"

!

3

= "

+C

9

#

# 6 857

"#

> 6 6

9 6 6

"

8 7

6"

9 6

!

9 #

" 43

= " 9" 2"""9 "

! ""

"9 6"

#"

""

# #

#

2

"

"

6

" #

!! "

9 "6 (

!

6

" ! 3

9

9 !

""

!9 G !

!

#

9

# 9

9 #"

2 =

"

9 " ! # 9 # ' &/# 0**)1 @

H @