Iqbal Arora & ORS. v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

 
    
   !"

#$% &%'()(*+!#, - . /0#122##*&$3%2) 
 4
  

      
!+

 
 

  



 2%)%*$+ 32(3#25#-&4'#$% 2 32( 6%)3%1-&4'#$%- 2$3%7%$($(*%2) !)8(2$((*63- %79$,     
   
   
       

   
  



            

  

   

 

  

  2#1"+ *$3%72%)%*$:2($7%$($(*9*&%22$('1%).#*&  $3%
*)$($9$(* *&(#-$3%7%$($(*%2)3#4%79$$'3#11%*6%$3%2%)957$(* 2&%22(6(*#11,())9%&*

**%;92%< "#*&$3%2'*)%/9%*$ 2&%2)-)#1)$3%5%5(*$3%5#$$%2 2%)957$(* $3%'55%2'(#1)($% $3#$:#)#11$$%&$$3%7%$($(*%2) 
 3%  7%$($(*%2)  3#&  7#2$('(7#$%&  (*  $3%  7%*  #9'$(*  2 '55%2'(#1)($%(*#*'3=91##*&:%2%$3%)9''%)) 910(&&%2) 2


 -%'$2-#*'3=91# 2#* #59*$  )-.- -

><(* $3% #9'$(*$3#$:#)'*&9'$%&*. 

?#4(*60%%*)9''%)) 91(*$3% )#(&#9'$(*-$3%,&%7)($%& @ $3%#9'$(*#59*$-(%-)-.-

>< :($3 3%#9'$(*:#)#7724%&#*&$3%1%$$%2 #11$5%*$&#$%&



?:#)())9%&(*$3%(2 #4923%2%:#))'3%&91% 7#,5%*$$3#$ :#)7901()3%&0, -:3('3:#)$0%)$2('$1,#&3%2%&$ $%2&%7)($ A@#59*$#)7%2$3%71(',-$3%7%$($(*%2):%2%6(4%*$3%7))%))(* $3%)($%*

?- '92)%-)90B%'$$$3%7#,5%*$ $3%0#1#*'% #59*$ $   3%7%$($(*%2) :%2% 9*&*$ $ 3#4%5#&%$3% 7#,5%*$ 25$(5%$$(5%#)7%2$3%)'3%&91%#*&:%2%())9%&*$('%)&#$%&  

#*&A

$5#=%7#,5%*$ ) ?.

1#')2%1)%$3%2% :91&0%2%)957$(*72'%%&(*6)   7#))%&  #*  2&%2    2%)957$(*  *  

   3% 7%$($(*%2) (1%&'(4(1)9($(*$3%'(4(1'92$ 3%'(4(1)9($:#) (1%&*



:3('3 (*#11,'#5%$0%&%'(&%&*  #*&$3%1%#2*%&
(4(1  9&6%  9*(2  (4()(*"-  #*'3=91#  3%1&  $3#$  $3%  )9($  :#)  *$ 5#(*$#(*#01%(*4(%: $3%0#29*&%2%'$(*A" $3% '$* #77%#1-$3%1:%2#77%11#$%'92$'* (25%&$3%)#(&B9&65%*$#*&&%'2%% 2%691#2)%'*&#77%#1:#) (1%&(*$3()
92$09$:#):($3&2#:* 3% 7%$($(*%2)$3%* (1%&$3%72%)%*$7%$($(*:($3$3%72#,%2)-#))$#$%&#04% *  )9772$    $3%  :2($  7%$($(*-  1%#2*%& 
9*)%1  2  $3% 7%$($(*%2))905($$%&$3#$$3%7%$($(*%2)5#&%5#B27#,5%*$)$  #*&  $3%2%  :#)  *  2%#)*  2  $3%  #9$32($(%)  (*    $  &%72(4%  $3% 7%$($(*%2) $3%4#19#01%727%2$,:3('3$3%,792'3#)%&(*$3%7901(' #9'$(*0%(*6$3%3(63%)$0(&&%2)3%7#,5%*$):%2%5#&%-$39631#$%-

09$:($3(*$%2%)$-#)'3#26%&0, 3%7%$($(*%2)3#4%'*)$29'$%& $3%  09(1&(*6  :($3  $3%  #7724%&  09(1&(*6  71#*  0,        5#=% 2%)957$(*(*$3())($9#$(*:91&04(9)1,:2=9$)%2(9)(*B9)$('%$ $3%7%$($(*%2)#$)9'3#1#$%)$#6%#*&%4%**:$3%7%$($(*%2)#2%2%#&, #*&:(11(*6$5#=%$3%0#1#*'%7#,5%*$$ :($3(*$%2%)$09$$3% 2%)957$(*)391&*$0%5#&%C%#2*%&
9*)%1 2$3%7%$($(*%2)$3%* 4%3%5%*$1,'*$%*&%&$3#$$3%0#1#*'% '*4%*(%*'%()'%2$#(*1,(* #492 $3%7%$($(*%2)#*&$3%,)391&*$0%&%72(4%& $3%4#19#01%727%2$, :3('3$3%,792'3#)%&(*$3%7%*#9'$(*''2&(*6$$3%7%$($(*%2)-$3% #'$(*  (*2% 9*&(*6$3%#59*$$3#$:#)7#(&0,$3%7%$($(*%2)() '*)%/9%*$1,#1)9*&%2'3#11%*6%(*$3()7%$($(*#)$3%7%$($(*%2)#2%*1, (*$%2%)$%&(*$3%727%2$,792'3#)%&0,$3%5(*7901('#9'$(*#*&#2%*$ (*$%2%)$%&(*#*,2% 9*& %2'*$2#-1%#2*%&
9*)%1 2$3%2%)7*&%*$< 77)%& $3%:2($7%$($(*#*&)905($$%&$3#$$3%7%$($(*%2)3#4%0%%*71#,(*6:($3  0,2%)2$(*6$%**950%2 1%6#1'#)%)0,#09)(*6$3%72'%))

$3%'92$ ''2&(*6$1%#2*%& 
9*)%1 2$3%2%)7*&%*$< -$3% 7%$($(*%2)3#4%0%%*=%%7(*6 09),(*$3%1($(6#$(*2(63$# $%2$3% #11$5%*$ $3%71$$$3%5(*$3%,%#2

?3%7%$($(*%2)3#4%$$#11, #09)%&$3%72'%)) $3%'92$ 1#:#*&=%7$$3%2%)7*&%*$< #:#, %#2*(*6($)1%6#11,&9%2%4%*9%)C%#2*%&
9*)%1 2$3%2%)7*&%*$<  (*4($%&92#$$%*$(*$$3%:2($$%*)$#$%5%*$ (1%&0,$3%5(*&%$#(1 #*&)905($$%&$3#$$3%7%$($(*%2):%2%6(4%**950%2 772$9*($(%)$ '1%#2$3%&9%)09$$3%7%$($(*%2)D*1,(*$%*$(*:#)*$$7#,$3%0#1#*'% &9%)09$$&%72(4%  ($)&9%)0,2#()(*6*%2$3%$3%271%#(**%

 2$3%$3%2 25''2&(*6$1%#2*%&
9*)%1 2$3%2%)7*&%*$< - $3%7%$($(*1#'=)0*# (&%)#*&()*$3(*609$#*#09)% 72'%)) 1#: %-$3%2% 2%-72#,%& 2&()5())#1 $3%:2($7%$($(* %3#4%3%#2&1%#2*%&'9*)%1 2$3%2(4#17#2$(%)#$1%*6$3 %3#4%)%%*$3%%*$(2%2%'2&:($3$3%#))()$#*'% $3%'9*)%1 2$3% 2(4#17#2$(%) $()*$(*&()79$%$3#$$3%7%$($(*%2):%2%#11$$%&$3%71$(* /9%)$(* # $%2$3%,:%2%)9''%)) 91 3(63%)$  0(&&%2) (* 2%)7%'$  
  -%'$2-#*'3=91#$()#1)*$(*&()79$%$3#$$3%7%$($(*%2) 3#&04(9)1,#62%%&$$3%$%25)#*&'*&($(*) $3%7901('#9'$(*$ #&3%2%$$3%)'3%&91% 7#,5%*$$3#$:#) (;%&0, :($39$#*, )$(791#$(*2'*&($(* 2$3%#11%6%&**<&%4%175%*$ $3%#2%#2$3% (* 2#)$29'$92%-#)'1#(5%&0,$3%7%$($(*%2) 3%1#:(*2%1#$(*$$3%$%25)#*&'*&($(*)#*&)'3%&91%

7#,5%*$)  ()  :%11  )%$$1%&-  *#5%1,-  $3#$  #9'$(*  ()  #  72('%  &()'4%2, 5%'3#*()5 22#()(*62%4%*9%) 2$3%64%2*5%*$#*&:3%*$3%72('%() *$7#(&(*$(5%-($2%)91$)(*1)) 2%4%*9%$$3%$#$% (5%()$3% %))%*'% $3%'*$2#'$(*)9'35#$$%2)2%6#2&(*6#9'$(*-04(9)1,0%'#9)% $3%727%2$,72('%)2()%&#,0,&#, 25$3% #'$)(*$3%(*)$#*$'#)%:3#$:% (*&()$3#$&%)7($% 2%7%#$%&*$('%) 2%)957$(*6(4%*$$3%7%$($(*%2)-97*$3%(2&% #91$$ 5#=%$3%7#,5%*$)(*#''2&#*'%:($3$3%)'3%&91%-#*2&%2:#)7#))%&0, (*#*'(#1 
55())(*%2  *  

  6(4(*6  #*  772$9*($,  $  $3% 7%$($(*%2)$5#=%&%7)($) $3%&9%)(*$3%6(4%*$(5%#*&97* #(192% $3%2% -$3%2%)957$(*2&%27#))%&0,$3%)$#$%

('%2#*&'* (25%&0,

$3%&5(*()$2#$2-:91&2%4(4%:($39$#*, 92$3%2*$('%$$3%5$() $39)'1%#2$3#$$3%)#(&2&%2&#$%& 

:#)5#&%0,$3%#9$32($(%) #15)$# $%2)(;,%#2)# $%2$3%#11$5%*$#*&:3%*$3%7%$($(*%2)3#& #12%#&,&% #91$%&(*5#=(*6$3%7#,5%*$)#)7%2)'3%&91% *927(*(*-$3%7%$($(*%2)#2%*$%*$($1%&$'#*4#))# 62(%4#*'%$3#$$3%,:%2%*$6(4%*%*963$(5%#*&772$9*($(%)$5#=% &%7)($):($3 3%7%$($(*%2)&(&*$$#=%#&4#*$#6% $3%1%*(%*$ #772#'3)3:*0,$3%(*#*'(#1
55())(*%2#*&(*&()2%6#2& $3%)#(& 2&%2-'*$(*9%&:($3$3%(2'*&9'$ $#=(*6  262#*$%&$*1, $3#$$3%7%$($(*%2) (1%&'(4(1)9($(55%&(#$%1,(*

=*:(*6 911,:%11 $3#$$3%)#(&)9($:#)0#22%&0,1#:#*&$3#$:#)$3%91$(5#$%&%'()(*0,$3% '(4(1'92$'* (25%&0,$3%#77%11#$%'92$#15)$# $%2,%#2)39)$3% 7%$($(*%2)=%7$ %*6#6%&(*'(4(1)9($ 24%2,%#2):3('3:#) *$5#(*$#(*#01%  9$) #2#)#&3%2%*'%$$3%2&%2&#$%& 

 7#))%&0,$3%(*#*'(#1
55())(*%2()'*'%2*%&-$3%7%$($(*%2)&(&*$ %4%*0%,$3%)#(&2&%2(*$3%(2 #49209$:%*$*2#()(*69*$%*#01% &()79$%)3%7%$($(*%2) (1%&:2($7%$($(*)# $%2:2($7%$($(*)(*$3()'92$- #09$:3('3$3%2%()#&%$#(1%&2%71,6(4%*(*$3%:2($$%*)$#$%5%*$(*7#2# #*&$3%2% :3('3:%*%%&*$2%72&9'%#4(*6$39) %&97:($3$3% 7%$($(*%2)D'*&9'$(*3&:(*=(*6 #*&97*$3%2%)91$ $3%'(4(1 )9($ (*#11,(*$%25) $3%2&%25#&%0,$3%'(4(1'92$-2% 9*&2&%2:#) ())9%&$$3%7%$($(*%2)%&*$$3(*=$3#$$3%7%$($(*%2))391&#$#11 0%3%#2&:3%* 25

?$(11$3%2%)957$(* $3%727%2$,#*&2% 9*& 2&%2$3% :#)&%72(4%& ($)&9%)*$3#$4(%: $3%5#$$%2-$3% 7%$($(*%2)&*$&%)%24%#*,),57#$3,22%1(%  25$3()
92$

.

%-$39)- (*&*5%2($(*$3%:2($7%$($(*    ()&()5())%& 2&%2#)$')$) !
"

 !

 "

           #$$%&