High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23235/2015dismissed

Charanjit Rai And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS

2015-10-31Bench- 4,Registrar-Judicial4 pages

!" #

!!! $

!!!

! %&'(&')(&'*+,-'.'/(0&1+2,3')'41)(',5/(&',5-'0(6 '071 8 ! 899 $

--)5':',3;(&',50.500<21=(&'>2<5..<,'3;(&'?)5( 4'(5(51/')0=1)4'/051/<);3'/'=5(0<0<,.500532'(1+/51) 1..50051/',

==5>')0 =1) 0&1)( @

0@" 1= (&' )'-+2<) ).', 1)>'0 </, 1(&') >1/0'A+'/(5<20'):5>'3'/'=5(01/(&'4)5/>542'1='A+<24<;=1)'A+<2?1)B (&';&<:'4)'='))',(&'4)'0'/(?)5(4'(5(51/! !

&' ?)5( 4'(5(51/')0 ?&1 ?')' (&' '.421;''0 1= 10(<2 '4<)(.'/(?')'0'/(1/,'4+(<(51/(1).;10(<2'):5>' =1)0&1)( @@" 5/ )'041/0' (1 1(5=5><(51/ ,<(', C!!C <0 <.'/,', 3; 1(5=5><(51/,<(',!!C><225/-=1):12+/('')0(10'):'1/,'4+(<(51/ ?5(&(&'!&'(').0</,>1/,5(51/01=0'):5>'=1)10(</,'2'-)<4& 1/ <D'((',')01//'21/,'4+(<(51/(1)'<,(&<((&','4+(<(51/1= '/-<-'.'/(?1+2,3'=1) .1/(&0</,(&')'<=(')=1)<4')51,<0(&'5) 0'):5>'0.5-&(3')'A+5)',!&'>1.4105(51/1=50E=)1.10(</,

'2'-)<4&'4<)(.'/(1/,'4+(<(51/</,E=)1.,5)'>(2;)'>)+5(',).; 4')01//'2! &' ?)5( 4'(5(51/')0 1/ >1.42'(5/- <-' 1= >1.4+201); )'4<()5<(51/?')')'25':',=)1.(1(&'5)4<)'/('4<)(.'/(!&';<201 01+-&(:12+/(<);)'(5)'.'/(=)1.(&'5)4<)'/('4<)(.'/(</,(&'0<.'?<0 <>>'4(',3;(&'>1.4'('/(<4415/(5/-<+(&1)5(;! !

&'42'<1=(&'?)5(4'(5(51/')050(&<((&';&<,3''/B'4(1/ ,'4+(<(51/=1)<31+(21/-;'<)0?5(&1+(0''B5/-(&'5)?)5(('/>1/0'/(=1) >1/(5/+5/- 5/ 1/ ,'4+(<(51/!&';<201 >1/('/,', (&<( (&';?')' ><));5/-1+((&'0<.'*13<0(&<(1=(&'5)>1+/(')4<)(0)'>)+5(',,5)'>(2;3; ).;</,(&')'=1)'(&';<)''/(5(2',(1(&'0<.'4'/051/<);</,1(&') 3'/'=5(0<0(&<(1=,5)'>(2;)'>)+5(',).;4')01//'2!

&')53+/<2&'2,(&<((&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0&<,4+(5/0+>&< 2'/-(&1=0'):5>':12+/(<);?5(&1+(4)1('0(5/-<-<5/0((&'>1/(5/+</>'1= ,'4+(<(51/! +)(&')(&';?')'-1:')/',3;(&'(').0</,>1/,5(51/01= ,'4+(<(51/! &')'=1)'5(?<0&'2,3;(&')53+/<2(&<( (&'A+'0(51/1= -)</(5/-0'):5>'3'/'=5(05/>2+,5/-4'/051/<);<?<),0(1(&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0 <0<,.500532'(1(&'

01=(&')'-+2<)).',1)>'0,1'0/1(<)50'=1) >1/05,')<(51/!

F'<)/',>1+/0'2<44'<)5/-=1)(&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0:'&'.'/(2; 0+3.5((',(&<((&'4)5/>542'1='A+<24<;=1)'A+<2?1)B?<0/1(<,&')',(1 3;(&')'041/,'/(0!+)(&')5(50&500+3.50051/(&<((&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0&<, 4+(5/<31+(;'<)01=0'):5>'':'/<=(')<0&1)(4')51,1=,'4+(<(51/1=

.1/(&0?<01:')!&')'=1)'5(50+/=<5)</,+/*+0((1,'>25/'4'/051/<); 3'/'=5(0 <0 <,.500532' (1 (&'

0 1= )'-+2<) ).', 1)>'0 5( ?<0

0+3.5((',!

%'=5/,(&<((&')'50/1=1)>'5/(&'0+3.50051/0.<,'3; 2'<)/',>1+/0'2<44'<)5/-=1)(&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0!&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0&<, 3''/0'/(1/,'4+(<(51/1/2;<=(')'25>5(5/-(&'5):12+/(<)5/'00(10'):'5/ (&'!04')(&'(').0</,>1/,5(51/01=,'4+(<(51/5(50=1+/,(&<(1/2; :12+/('')0&<,3''/(<B'/1/,'4+(<(51/(10'):5>'5/! +)(&')(&' (').01=,'4+(<(51/?1+2,,50>210'(&<(':'/<=(')(&''G45);1= .1/(&0 (&'4')01/00'/(1/,'4+(<(51/.5-&(0'):'0121/-<0(&'5)0'):5>'0?')' )'A+5)',! /1(&')?1),0>1/(5/+</>'5/(&').;10(<2'):5>'?<0 4+)'2;:12+/(<);!&';></<(</;415/(1=(5.'.<B'<)'A+'0((10'/, (&'.3<>B(1(&'4<)'/('4<)(.'/(! &')53+/<2&<0)5-&(;/1(',(&<( (&')'?<0/1(&5/-1/)'>1),(10&1?(&<((&'?)5(4'(5(51/')00'):',3';1/, (&'0&1)(4')51,1= .1/(&0<-<5/0((&'5)?50&'0!(<44'<)0(&<((&'?)5( 4'(5(51/')0&<,'/*1;',(&','4+(<(51/5/</,>1.42'(',(&'5)(').(522 (&';?')'>1.4+201);)'4<()5<(',1/<((<5/.'/(1= ;'<)0!&')'=1)'?'

=5/,(&<((&')'50/10+30(</>'5/(&'42'<1=(&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0(&<((&'; ?')')'(<5/',3;(&')'041/,'/(05/(&'<-<5/0((&'5)?50&'0! &'?)5(4'(5(51/')0&<,0'):',1/,'4+(<(51/=1)<31+(21/- ;'<)0!&';&<,<2013''/4)1.1(',<04')(&'(').01=(&','4+(<(51/!+( (&'5)0'):5>'>1/,5(51/50(1(<22;,5==')'/(=)1.(&'0'):5>'>1/,5(51/1=E 1=4')01//'2,5)'>(2;)'>)+5(',3;(&').;(1.</(&'! &'?)5( 4'(5(51/')0<)'-1:')/',3;(&'(').0</,>1/,5(51/01=,'4+(<(51/</,(&'5) 0'):5>'>1/,5(51/05/(&'5)4<)'/('4<)(.'/(?&')'<0(&',5)'>(2;)'>)+5(', ).;4')01//'21=(&'<)'-1:')/',3;(&''):5>' +2'05/(&').',

1)>'0! +0(3'><+0'(&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0&<,,50>&<)-',(&':');0<.' /<(+)'1=,+(;<005-/',(1).;4')01//'2(&';><//1(.<B'<>2<5.=1) 4'/051/<);<?<),0<0<4425><32'(1

05/).;<-<5/0((&'5)0'):5>'

>1/,5(51/0!&')'=1)'5/1+):5'?(&')53+/<2&<0)5-&(2;,50.500',(&' >2<5.1=(&'?)5(4'(5(51/')0!

%'=5/,(&<((&')'50/1.')5(5/(&'?)5(4'(5(51/</,(&')'=1)' 5(0(</,0,50.500',! ! "

>(13') !

+2<(5