← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22311/2016dismissed

Kulwant Kaur & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-11-11Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi18 pages

     

!   ! 

!# !

$%

& 



    



 

  '&  ( )'

 * '* * ')+     





    !!!!

'* * ')+ , )-     "

 

#$%#&'()

+,-  ./ 0 1



  2 



+ 

3$ 0 "   

       



   

           

+4

  

 

  "     4

  

              "     0               

    

  

+4



   

5 

   

   "

 

.

     

*

  .  "

  6        

    

+4

  .  37'#89'4



   "   

 .     

     

 "    

 

    .   . .   . 0     "      ""  

0 " .  

+4



  

     + "   

 

" 

.: "';  

 

#&7'99# )

+'-    

  " 

   .

.  " .      <  



 .

   

+4



      

  # ,



.  

=

)> 

   -

 '9,#  )? @    -        ',7'99A )

+$-      

+A

      

".



"  " .

"  

; 



 

#7'&'997)

+%-     4

 

     

5          .

;

  0  1

      

 #&9#&&# )

+(-1 

   ; .  ;B3##%(#&&$      . 1 /  ;  

''##&&$  



=.  @. ; 

''##&&$ 

. 

.  



 

#7'&'997)

+%-.  .  

 "  

'$C

  

" 0 "

 B

/ 0 1  



   2 

 

+ 

 3$  "

 )

+,-  

   77#&'(  )

  +7- 5 "  

  3$   

 

     ; .  

 =

      " 

  .



. @. ; 

'9 " !#.# # / 0 %1%*#  # / 0 %23 ,*-456

.  

''##&&$  . 1

/ ;  "

  

  0 "

  

       "

 "      



'$'&#&'%  . ;     

  6      ,+%0#  #  # /  0 % 1% 0

 77%%

2

0#8!%

2

0#8# / 0 %-2 

  "

   

)

+%

+(-  "

.       . 

+4



  

    

.  .       



. "; =

'9('

)  . 



-    .    

  "  "

  .   "

     "



      

.  " 

    

 

" "" 



" 

;          

 

  . .  6  

 

  

.

 

 

    

     

 #7'&'997  )

  +%-   .; 



 

#&9#&&#)

+(-  .;

 01



 

.

    . 1 / ; 

''##&&$  ";B3##%(#&&$2



     

#7'&'997)

+%-

 .  " #7  .0



+

   



           

        

     

    

    

  



  

     

           



      

! "

   

 

     

#    

 

    

        $

    

      

     

%  

           &&% '   &    '

#

&() '  #

&*( &*+ &*, &** -..

-.& /

#

) '  #

)0- &( &)%&1&%-(-1&*--*&-&+,&, -+0-  &&% '   &  

 /2

1...03      

&)     

   

 

         

6      "

               .   ;

  0  1

      

 #&9#&&# )

+(-

 





    

 .  "$#  .0



+

    

        2 

  

        2 "

           

   8

  !

 



0

#         

        

    

$     

 

  9      

 

  

 

      :

:     :    











    2 

 

 

    

 

 



 

   ; . ;B3##%(#&&$    .  . 1 / ; .  "  "

+ D"; #

--1% -..(  < =

# >

$

$   

;    

?

" 

 

    

;    

         

>

203 @ > A && -..( 203 @7

   

.     "

''##&&$  .1 / ; .  @.  ;



 .; . 

<        

#7'&'997)

+ %-

 

.  

  

 

 

5  

 

+4

  

    

      "  

 

  ""

 

''##&&$  .1 / ;   . 

  " .  @. ; .      .0 2  

    

. 

     *   

 

 /   "

      

        ""



 

"      

 E 



 "   

'$

 

          .  1  /       ;  

''##&'$ /

" 

 .

     .   

.  

 

  



 <

. .



. @.  ; 

'9 "  !#.# 9$#% ,%:;#-2    .     

" 6 .



. @. ; 

'9 " !#.# 9%$#% )

-2



+

; 



  

      

; 





  

    $  --%    

 

  



 

  



   

              

"





      

  "

 $  (-                     



    "

 $  --%  

  

 

      



  





          

  









 



  $  (- 9

 

        "

    

  $  (-





      

 

 

 

 

 

    

    



 B   

 

  

 

    

    



  9

 



    

    



 

 '       

  

   

 

      



 

 ' 

     

"

'





  

B 



 ' 



  

  

  "

 '



  



    

      

   

 

     $

(-

   



 

 



  $

(-

C  

          "

;

  '

 

         

 

    

   



  

 

 



 9  

9     6  .

  

 .    @.    ;   .   1 /  ;  

    

        .    

 .   

  



   <  1 / ;   "        

0 "   

 

  

 

   

.   .   . 

 .



  





      6

 .1 / ;

 . .  0 "

.

   "

    .   " 

.        +

.     ".

 . 5   .

  

.   

 6   .  0 .; 

    . @. ;   # :

$  /#1%

 /#2,<-*46 

.

. @. ; 

$%

$(        



+ D(1

?      

 



   #

 

      

 

 

 

   

  

 $  &+& "  

 





     

(%

; 

   



     

$   



 #

 

    



      

  '  / 

"  / @

    --

  



  

   



  

 

  



     



"

:  @

   

  -,E%F 9



 

 "

 

  

           

     



  

#

 "

     

 

   9   

;   

 

:  @

  

 

                 







        ; " 

"

 .

    "

    ',7'99A)

+$- .



+4



  

 

.         

)

+%

+(-

 

   "  

"

 

  

.  

 . 

 

 3##%(#&&$ . <  





" 

 .

  



" . 

    

 

"  . 

       ; "     

"

"

    

. 1

/ ; .

0 

'99$   ;B39%('97A , #7 #1%

! $  # $0#.#%, =-2    '99$ =:$&,  <  .1 / ; 

 E  



.  

.  

.

.   )> 

    -'9,$   

. "; =

)" - '9('6  . 1 / ;  #7 #9%$#% )

- .   .

 1 / ;  #>/ * ?0# / #

0 1%

!

 ;7

 77%%

2 :

>#=# / 0 %2 ,-  ,-

  0 .;  #7 #9%$#%



#>/ * ?09%$#% )

- . 







  

  #7  # $0#.#2  +# >#2   0%  :2  !%$ '

@#1% 77%%

:?#

!%

2:?#

24,- 

,$-46 <   "  #7 # $0#.#2+# >#9$#%

)

- 1 /  "   # @#1%*# #.# ## /

0 %2<,4-  ,$-4   F/  "  ; 

%0# A

%0#)#1%* $ #.2  #.# #233<,4-

 ,$-<    " '$'&#&'%  .; +%0#  #9%$#% )

-.



 .  

  " 

 <    " ; 

#7  #9%  $#%  )

- #>/   * ?09%  $#%  )

- 

#7 # $0#.#2+# >#9%$#%)

-  .

"   ;   "

'$'&#&'% +%0#  #9% $#%  )

-   

     





.



.1 / ;   # @#9% $#% )

-   .     





'$'&#&'%  .;  +%0#  #9%$#% )

-



+ D 

     

                

      

 

        

            

   !

"#

$%&$ #

   

    ' (    

    $%)&*)+          

  ,

    

 

(       

  -.

.../*

  

    

  $%+-#

       

 

      

        !

"  #

 $%&$  (

 0

   

 1                  

                

     2       3 <                          



+4



  5 

5

 .  .

              . "  .; <  

  

 .  

0 "  .  " .    

)

+%

+(-

 

      



. 1 / ; 

''##&&$ 6  . 1 / ;  #7 # $0#.#2+# >#9% )

- 

 "

   0 .  1 / ;  #7 #9%$#% )

-

#>/ * ?09%$#% )

-   .  

.    .

     6 

.



. 1  /    

 9  '&  '% 

 '(      "     #7 # $0#.#2+# >#9%$#% )

-   

."

     



+

C  "

        

    

@ = '

= '    

  





  D  " ?  E/ F $

&*%&    $

# * &**&

2   

  



       '



  $

  

    



     2 -E999F      /  $

&**+

   

       3            

    $

?   

   

> C 

 "

/  2  D

@

>

"    -.&- E-F /"/ E"F %-(



   

  

     

  D  " ?  E/ F $

&*%&    $

2 



  > C 

 "

 2

/    D

@

>       &**( ?@ (.,

 

9  

 /  2!   E F   <

&(

;       $

    ?  EH /

/F $

&*,(   D  " ?  E/ F $

&*%&

 

$

H $       

" ?  $



9

 " ?  $

    I  

   I  

     $

 "

        

     

      

    

  '



     

    

  

    

     $

    I  

;    



   

  

   

2        

    

     2 , $

  

  6

   =

@   

> C 

 "

 ! " #$  %

&'  (  

    $



   

  

        

    

  %.

 

    

J9

C  !   E F 

/   !   E F

 

 

 



A C   )  *"  +  #$   ,& ' -.

  

   

  9

7   $

    



     2 -E999F

     /  $

&**+

 

  

C  K   E2 F 







$         

  



 8!

8 !

     ?  EH /

/F $

&*,-   < D#1  G<     * 

5  ****** ) -  ? @  

 

  

     

 



 

 

.

 . "

 

 )-    "

 "



 

 +   



 " . "

 . "H

)-

 " *  . "



. "  .   

  H ****** )-?.  @

 . " "

 0   5 . .      4

   5  .    

 



.5 "

5

  < .       '9%$

    

  . " "

=    1    

 

 @/

    . .

; 

/

 . 4

 I ; 

  /&0 '

 



 3       

    

   

  I  



  D  " ?  E/ F $

&*%&

A C    

> C 1  2"34  5 ** 6+ 7

* 8  0  %&%' %$ 

   A C



      9          



       ?  EH /

/F $





      9     

  D  " ?  E/ F $

&*%&

     



  

  

    ?  EH

 /

/F $

2 



   D  " ?  E/ F $



  

     A C

> C 2

/   ! /  2!   E F     

  

   '

   I  

  

  

?    

  

'

   I  







/  ? !   E F 



  C  !   E F <

  .

'$'&#&'%  . ;  +%0#  #9%$#% )

-      

  . "  

   .     

  

   .

0 ''##&&$  1 / ;  

  <    

   

.* 

  

     .  "

  "

      







 0     .  J. ;   #/7#:%:

/## # # /#

0 1%*#

#7 #/:# / 0 %2,-*5 <            .     

.       "  "  

.          



+7  

   

  6"

  . 

 " 

 "

       .         0 "  * 

    

#7'&'997)

+%-

   

    

         F 

  

0

  

 .  .

     " .   . ""

 )

+,-

 "  

;  *  "     

  ##(8##,;  <

 1 "  



 

 " .

"  ;



"

  ;  " 

 

  

 

 .       

;      

   

.   

 

.

  3    . 

 

   .



   



 

  

  ''''#&'( , '* * ')+- $'

2 

! ;   '0  L0# ;   < L0#