Sanjay Singh v. Bikram Singh Majithia
!" # $%
"& '
!" # $%
"& '
%() *+% , %
!" " ## $
% & '( & ") * + & '( & " ,,, ,-$ .(
+
!
-
#
.& " / )
# - +# 0
# 1")
+""
0%
!" /
+ " # #'
' ' % /
" !
" 0+" #( )
1"
"
2 .
!"0 "
/ + " 0+ 3!
# ( '
+#% / (
! " ( -
" 0+")
)#
4 / # +% "
- 5 / "
6&6&6 25 1"
&"##!" 66&") &+
' - 4&"
#- % !
"
##%!
" 0+&/"
"/ )-+#
"
"
- 1 / )) 6+%' - 4 & & "7 &"7
"
) " / )) '!
& 6&)-+# ##%$"! " "
+
"
0+&")
# +-"
"%/ )-+#
"
/ ))
61" "
/ ""/
(#(
-! .
! 1" )#
/ #+%" "%&"9
"
# : # 9
"
"
/
1" -) & " #
;-
# !
$
#
& 3-"
& # "
#
%( - 0-
" !- -
!1 % # &
&"#
!
9
") #
%( &
" !- ( +"#" )#
-
-
##" -
#5))
"' - 4 & " )#!
<" " )#
/
/ " /
"%/
5
=- & ") #
" -
"
)#
:"
# &") / # + "
# >0% +"? +"#"' ' % 41 #"
7( + "
(#) & " #
))# + "#
!
3-"
- 6 & .
!9 ) ))
" -+0 )#
/( & +% 6& " #
!
" ))# ' "
# "0% +"&" ) !
( ))# - 6 .
9 ) )
# ))
" 2% &"#
!
"
))# # 1"
+
! " -# + .!
& " ) #
#
!" )
+%" #
!
!"
9 ) ))# -
6 1" &" #/ ") % =- " )#
4)
! " #" #
!
3-"
# "## !" -
!
)
"
2% )
& "
- " ( +"#") "& &"#
!
" #
"))# # +%") .
!9 ) )
#)) +-" / ##- ( #+#&
"
( " "-# +)!
")
2% )
& "
- . " ") ""#
!
3-"
" ##/") (
/"
# -
!"
"")
+ "
#- "-#
% "
)#% #
&"
"") "
+ "
- " "
))# 9 ) " + #
+% " #
!
" " ) /
##%!
9 ) "% )
-"" #
!
"
" "" ) / )"%
##%) + "- #%
& /"
" / "%"
/ # ! + # "" / "%/" " -
/ (-)
"
)
-") " / &") + "- #% " #9 ) ))#
)) 9 #%6 -
!"# %
)
-"" ) " @""
" )#
" #%+ - "/ 0% +" & # "
% ) #)
( #! 3 !+ " #
!"+( )#% &" ) ( ))# 6
.
! " )
+%"
- 1"
&" " -
!" -
!- & "+
(
"" )#
/ #
"#
!
"
" -
# ")
) -
)) ") " 9& #
!/"
""9 )
))# /-# +##/ /( &" ))# /
##/ " & & & +- " / -)# ##""
!+%"
-
=- &"
- )
" &+ (
!" " ))# 9 ) )) / #
&/"
"/ -##%
!#%) %
" )
&"9 "
)#%
&" ""
#
" )#
" " ( !
") - /
"+
9
"& #%#%"
#)
&") ) .
=- "
!" )#
"+ # - "" #
!
" )# / "" =-
&) #"
)-!
)
+% " #
!
# " " 9 ) ))# # +% " ) -
6 /
# !" " -) &"#
!
)
"") / # .+# . 9 ) ))
!
"
#%&" #%!
+%") " !
"
#"
# ))# & 6&/ """+ + "0% +"1"#
!
"
) # " ") " #%)) &
##&+ "-
" #
!" )#
"#" #!#
!"(
"
.9 ) )
#)) #% "!
"" "+ + " # 1"#
!
-
+ ("") / #/% # + % .9 ) )
#)) /" ( "0% +"/
& -+0 -
"
!) "
'
)
- +% " & ))
" " )
#"
- " " 9 )
" + !
-) "))# # +%"
& "-!" / -##% " /
4 -+& " ) #
))# #%" .
! " +- "/ " -
# " !""
-#
1"
- "
)
+ - " #
-
# ))
! "
+ " #
!
3-"
/-#"(+ /##/ "- "9 )
))# "% #&( " " + -)#
/ ( #+#
1") &" ). " #(
#% # " ""#
!
3-"
/ - # + #/"
##
!/ ""
( -#9 ) ))#
#+% ") - " &"#
!
!
# + %" ) .9 ) ( % "0% +"/
%( &")
& -
!"& .9 ) )) - 6 /-#
##%+/ "
"
" #
!
/"" - " # "-#+!
-
) -# 4!
"(+ - "
-
"" #
;-!
9
- "0-
#
/"
#
!"))# #+%") 1"
)
" (
/ #+%") =- ""
-+0 )#
" -
! )
"
1" - !"
/ "
#A? "
" B+?
"
-0-
"#
!
3-"
" )#
B ? "!
"") (
/ )# / " /( &-
!" -
""
!&
!" " ##&#
-
#& ( % !- "
" "
- 0-
3
-
#
"
!- #%"
-
)# / " 1" !
" ) +-
# -
-
! !-
!#% "/
5/-#+)) )
"
!. "
- % " #( "
- )# / " " "!
%# . !
< -) (
! )#
/"
"
- - " ") CD"
#
- & &# / " - " )#
!
"
# / "9
" )#
"!
& .
! !
< )#
& "##9
-) "
" )#
"/
& %& " -+
- "9
"##+ - /
! "##+
+%" )#
"/
# +%"!
# / " ) )
- )
>? "-
E'
% !
& ) )#
/"
""
-"
<. !
<
/"
"" + ( "
- & %& ""
.
&F "##&
/" " -
!)# +% "
/"
""9
"
0-
G ) ) "
- )
!
" - &
=-
" "
#
( ! + +%)# +% - ""
)
""
.
& ")-
!/""
"
-
!
( "E
5 %+ ""/
+ .
E "##&
/" " -
!)# +% "
/"
"" 9
"
0-
E /
"
) (
+% # ' ' 466&/ " -+ >? "
=-
%- -+ >?&"!
%& ""
.
&. ( /
" # / "
# )#
" &
!" "
> %?" )#
"/
" -#"
=-
%
( ! > %? - & " !
)
""
-
!
!& " "##
" )#
&
( % - " " "##+
#%
"
!
") CD5#
/ "
-)
"
")
!
.
! !
< "
-
!
" ))
+ -
&" "##
-"
-
" " - & " ))
+/
&" %
-/
& & ""
.
& -
& -
" - ++ -!" )) + "
") &") & /" # -
" )#
&/ #%
4/#"
")
/ "
! +% " 0-
"#
!
3-"
5
=- &") (
"+ )-#
#% )# / "1"
-
+
/"" " #
!
)# / " " "
(
+ )
!" -
! 5/-#+))
"
!. ) # #/ "
- %!"
&"
'"+ ''
/"& 01-'01 %"
'
"234556789:5;&" -) - "#"
-
! -
#
"
##/
+
-
1" -) - + ("
"" )#
" +
! #%/ /
-)) "
##!
" )#
"(
##/
"" "!
-
!" - # """ ))# "
" " " #/))# +#" 1"- + (""" 9
"
- ##!
" )#
"( &+" # - %&
-)) " /-#"+ -
" )#
-
+
!" " !" " - 5 / - + (""!
# ) "
! ) #
%( + -
! " - "" -##%
-
<"( + -!" %( )-=-
" )#
"
/
#
/
-" -"-#
"##!
" 9
%
+%## %" - 4+#%& & /
&
% "!
-
=-
% -
( ! +
!)
" -
+% "
0-
F , "
&/"
< , 1'
=3>??5748455@ '# A"
/"
<
'
"'
=3>?4B7>:B8@G -#'
"/"$%$ '
" 23>?4:7 4: CB6;& " -) -
" " ) (
% ) "
-)
/" " -
+% "
#0-
"!
& ##" !
=-
" "
#
( ! + +%)# & +% - "" )
""-!" & " )-
!-/"" " / -
!
)
!!
" - 1" -) - "
"
- "
=-
%"
+% / >!? /"
"
E
=-
%E ( %
=-
%" "
# - +%!
- - " / + (" )
=-
%"
+ ( - 1" -) - " "
"
=-
% (
!- &"/
9
/" - & 9
" )#
#
%& / " " ) 9
! " /
& % 1" -) - " "#""
9
+%"!
& ")-
!/""
-
!
!!
" - &
"
+-"
=-
% (
!- D A / $ %'-# $D1# '
23>?497B8>6;&" -) - + ("& " &" )
#/
"
" /" " -
+% "
/"
"" !
9
"
0-
&
%""!
-
=-
%
( ! +
!)
1" -) - + ( " "
( # )- H+0 ( +"
"
&&/ # )#
!
)
! )#
(" -
%"
5/
"#"" ) (
+# ! "!
-
=-
%
( ! +
!)
& " # )#
# 0 5/ "#"" =-
=-
%H
( ! +
! )
)% # % " -) - & /".
=-
%
"
(
/ # %9)#
-#> ? 1" -) - - "#" "
!"- /
"" % =-
/ -# ##+
!)
&"
!- -#+
#) )
#/")- #%#!#
- -# +
% !")
&/" / " 0-
7 # &
% $
' 1
$/",E % $$'
-''
"23>?4874>:>?;&" -) - + ( "" - + -
" -
! )
+% "!
""
""##!
" )#
- 1" -) - - + (""-!"
# ).
!
=-
+)
"
! &" - +
-
))#
+%"!
"
-
!"
" " -#"
=-
% )
( ! - & %& ) !
" #%&
1 & +$
'/"'/ / "
$ "' 1'"+$
''
"23>?4574CC4?;.
" -) - + ("
+# ! %""!
& + -
!" -
!+% "
0-
&
=-
" "
#
( ! + +%" )# /"" " -
!
!
" - 5/ + ("/"
#
!
- )
&"!
- .
"(
" )#
&" " )#
"/
9
"" " +))#
/"" "
#
+ -!"/-#
- /"" " -
) !
" - 1" -) - "#""
+ "
#)
))#
+%" !
++ "
) - #
!-#
% , A$#/", '
.2>??93:7
3 $17C8?;&#
;-!"
-
"
)
=-
%- 1"#
;-! "" /" + -!"
% " !
" - "
=-
% =-
+"#- /
1"#
;-! " / #% +# ! %
/" " - /
!)# +% "
/"
""!
9
0-
"
+ " #% " !"/
- +%/%" 1" #
;-!+ ("(
" &"#
!
=-
%+
- )
/ / "
"
" !
-+ - #
" - )
/
!+% "
#0-
"!
1"#
;-!- + ("" -
=-
% (
!-
" - ! % " ! "#"" -
- "
=-
%/-#( %/ ""
" +-"
=-
%& )#&/-#
#% +9"- ( / +%"#
;-!, A1, "/"- '
2 456?496?;&/"
" -) - "+ ( -
E'##"""
/"" "
I -
!
!J!
" - '
6 "
!& " !
/ !" " ( -#- #% "/ "
#- 1" + )+%"!
-
<
!"(
" " !
! " ! 7( " !
! " ! " -"&( % "( /"
"" )#
) - ) - "
#&
+ -#- #%0-!1" ) 0-! &/"
"
+))#
##%+
" - !- #% " /
&
9 #%+))# " !
! " ! &" !
H& "
(
-)) " ##!
" )#
#
! 9 #-
(#%
+#+%-
&"/ ##+
-
!
!)
" -
!"
#"-
E 1" #
;-! "
$ AA /"
/1&&, 1'
"2 459C45:9;& /"
" -) - "+ ( - E1" ) "
=-
% -
9 #%#
A #%"
" -"
# ""##!
" )#
A> ?
"
# )# +%" )#
+ "- B>
?
"#
)-
!-/""
-)
" + -B >
?
!"=- )- #% ")
( /" )#
/ "-##(
! % "" - %"(5 &
-
" - " !+ #-#%
# + " "=- /"" " )
"-#+
-!
"
E 1" #
;-!
!#% "# " " !
# %")
"/ " )""
=-
% /-#+
#%/ "
"
"!
1"#
;-!+ (""
=-
%/-#+ #% "#
)-
!-/""
-)
/ - "!
/ -#- #%)) "( & %##) "
)
(
))
!"
( #+#
"
- 1"#
;-!"#"/""
/
- "( /-#+ / "
"
"!
+-"
=-
%
( !
/" " -
+% "
0-
/+/
" /%&+
! % ,"'-/"
'
2>?4B3B7+ 3 $17B64F>?4B + 1498B;&#
;-!" #"
!"- -##-"#!#)
)# ))# +#
=-
% 1" #
;-! "# "
=-
%
( !
#%" +"#+%"!
/" " -
!+% "
/"
""9
"
0-
")-
%
!-"
=-
%
( ! &" ##/
!)
/ "#+( #+#"!
E>?5"!
=-
"
#&"
- "
=-
%&"!
%& ""
.
&. "( /
" >+?5"!
( ! B" %+ "
-!" )# +% - ""
)
& ""
.
> ?5"
+#9 #-
(#%+%"-
&" " "## ##-) " - ) - ## /
9
" "
( !
9 #-
(#%
+#+%" -
"##" + >? 1"
( ! " +
-
"
#
( ! - # . "
( ! (
!- 6>?" ") !
< ! >?'"
!
( ! "
-!"" )# " )
& "!
%"
. & "!
)##-".
"
- "
( !
>?' "#
!"
=-
%
( ! &" !
" )
- )
& "##)
#" )#
- " %
- )
!
" - - " 1" +0 )- "#
!
=-
%H
( ! - "
-/"" "
-
!
!
" - E %)%)>:B56)>?49& # * $ " # /" - &
1-A1'
*& +%#
;-! "
- 6&" )#
9
"
# : . - &79 # 9
"
/
1" &"!
- -
1"#
;-! "/( "#& &"" !
" -
=-
%"
# +
) ")# - "" )
" -
! / "-##/
"-) - 1"
-
-) / & "#
;-! #+ /"%"9
/
## "
=-
%& )
+%" -) -
-# > ? %)%)>?>C?)>??6& # "$'
,- '
/" # & . &#
;-!"
- #/ "" )
=-
%- 1"#
;-!"#& &"
=-
%-
"+ "-!" / % " - # ( +% "
#0-
"!
1"#
;-!
# -) "#/# /
, A$#> ? + ( "9
" )#
/
& %&-
/"
# .
! !
< " &" !
"#
=-
%
( ! + +%)# %" )
/"" " -
!
"
) - 1"#
;-! "#" .
! !
< &" !
!)
/-# - " +) ) +% " !
" "
.
"#
=-
%
( ! " -
!
! 1"
=-
%" /+ +# ! %
/" " -
)# +% "
/"
""!
9
0-
/-# " - "
=-
%H
( !
% ( /" " !
" . !
<
9
!" )#
"
/
& %&- 1" #
;-! " "# " 9
" )#
/
& (
! - &
+=- + -+ - "
=-
% =-
-
1" #
;-! + ( " )
" & /
"
"!
"#
=-
% "( "
( ! +- " " / + %
" )
!)# +% "
0-
1" - "
=-
%
( ! "/(
-+" + & &)
" / 1"#
;-!" "#"9
" )#
%/
- -# +
=-
=-
%- 5
"
+
"" #
;-!"#" -
!
" +-
+# 5 %"/( + ""( % #
;-! # / " "
- !
%)%)45546)>?49& # E- $1 '
/" - $
*. 6 1"
&"#
;-!+ ( "" )#
" 9
&) "
#&/" /
5 "( /" &"#
;-!. "#/# /
-# > ? "#"" =-
=-
% -
"+ -##% )# / " "!
" "
#
=-
" 1"-!"" "(+ + !- % # .
#
% "9 ) 9 "
=-
%"
)
%&/&
- # (
!+% " 0-
"!
&"
- / #
"# !""0-! " -) -
-# > ? D A > ?5
" /
&
/ # " /-#+
-
"!
& ")-
!/""
-
!
!!
" - &9
#%" )#
+-# "
/
5 -# > ? / !
##%)
-"
=-
% (
! &"/
# 9
/"
&9
" )#
#
%&/ " ) 9
!/
& % 1" & "!
))# "
" +%"/
" +%" )#
&) - %( & %&/"
#
!" #-
" -!"!
-) !
" - & /-#+ -
9
"
) )
- 2 ""
)# -) "!
"" "-# !+% - " & # % - &/"
#
=-
!
" ))#%
!"
" ! '
##&" /-#+" '))#
") "!
/"
" -# ##" "#
!
=-
%- - "))#
- +
)) "
!)
5/-#+
% ) "!
/ !""( " ! (
)
+
"( %(#- - " - 5 /-# - "!
" """! "
-!"
"
# )# + "
&
#-
! " " )#
"
/
" "&
& - "
-
!
/ -) !
" - '
-+%" -) - &"!
/-#(
)"
0-
"! +% "
+ =-
9)
)
"
" + " -
"
5
"# !"" #!#)
)# ""
)-!
-
! /-#"(+ #"
# " "#
!
3-"
.
- " ) #
% ( " " + " ! /" " )#
/ (& & 8 " %& "
" 9
"
# : # "
"
/
1"#
!
" " )#
#+%" " " "
/
1" -) & " " ))
# " ) #
%( &
& +#
""' - 4 " ' - 4 " )-+#
" "
!
!" &+%-++
! "
-! . / "
" "
)- 1"#
!
" # / ""
-"
/ 0-
)-=- %" E
'( "/" -#
" )#
" " "#/=-+%"#
-
# " )#
&
) ( " " / ))
)-+#
" )#
-#" )# & /-#!
(0-
"- ## " )# 1"- "(
!
"
# ##" ) &" #
!
- " -
# 1" -
! # #%
))#
+%"#
!
3-"
## #(
- / -#%
+%"
+
!)
1"
- "
"" -
! / )
- )# / ""
=-
" / ( # " "
- %) (
1"- &"
-
" !
-
")
/
!
/ "" )-!
)
+% " #
;-
# !
$
#
& 3-"
&
# )#
4 4 ) !
/ !-
+#
" =- "
!" -+0 )#
2"")
!#%
+" "## ( 3, % * :"" ).
! K :"" ) +# K