Shavinder Pal Kaur And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS





 !

"

 #$% $&

$!'$$ $

$&$!



 (


 



 & ) ** + , ,

*- &.*  /-

,,,**- 0-1

2 ) 134  /- ,,,,!5


 

6178 61-  /-

,,,**- 0-1

2 ) 134  /- ,,,,!5

9
 9 

-4/3 61-  /-

,,,**- 0-1

2 ) 134  /- ,,,,!5


 :

 

1-/- 61-  /-

,,,**- 0-1

 2 ) 134  /- ,,,,!5

:
 : ;

2/.*- 7 61-  /-

,,,**- 0-1

2 ) 134  /- ,,,,!5
!$+

<%=

!, # 2 

$!2!$ 2

  

   

      

 
 "

"

"

 

 #  !  $

 

%


'  ( )  %

!   



 

 !"

#

%

"

& '#

() #

# $# # **+!** 

 ./

)  )  )



  

 .0 .1 1//2 - 

! 

  



*

*

9 3     

% '4
& 125.6&1/.7 

) #



",-./#

  

*   

  $

.78/    .785

% *    !



 



  $



() - 
  $  !

+   * ./

  # .0 .1 1//2 

 *


+   * ./

*! 1//2 9   !* 

!  %

 $

% *      

 *

+ 9   !* 

  



$ (   $

.78/

*



* ./



  



  9    !*



() - 
  *

 +



   * ! #

    

$ $ 

!

  #





 

  % 

 *   





% $ %  % :  

 

+ ) ;   % %

 *        % <



 !

   !$

  =$

    

*   

 $ *    

$



$ 



# * 

! % %  $ $

$



  



$

3 

 $ %$ * *   



() -



$ ./

)  !

: )

   .0 .1 1//2   ! 

 ! 

  *  

+ (  $  

!  *

*  %     <

    $ 



$ 

$ $

!   * < *  !

 0 !*  # ,  



"(

,# #

# $# #*!* !*    * >/ 6/



# 

 

 % 

$ *  *

! )  +    *  $ 

?

 $ 

& @>0 There are some of the employees who have not been regularized in spite of having rendered the services for 30-40 or more years whereas they have been superannuated. As they have worked in the work-charged establishment, not against any particular project, their services ought to have been regularized under the Government instructions and

 even as per the decision of this Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka & Ors. v. Uma Devi 2006 (4) SCC 1. This Court in the said decision has laid down that in case services have been rendered for more than ten years without the cover of the Court's order, as one time measure, the services be regularized of such employees. In the facts of the case, those employees who have worked for ten years or more should have been regularized. It would not be proper to regulate them for consideration of regularisation as others have been regularised, we direct that their services be treated as a regular one. However, it is made clear that they shall not be entitled to claiming any dues of difference in wages had they been continued in service regularly before attaining the age of superannuation. They shall be entitled to receive the pension as if they have retired from the regular establishment and the services rendered by them right from the day they entered the work-charged establishment shall be counted as qualifying service for purpose of pension."

$

   

,  

- 

$ 

     !

$

 $ 

   +

 $  !

 !$ *   A$ !  

  <   

** 

%

 !$

  !$

      *   % % $  $     $   

! 

 %$  

    *

+    %$  !  $

#

  %$   $ 

  

!  %  %$ 



!  

  $    *

 %$  !  $  *

!  %

 

 *



!  

 ( : <  

  


 *    /. /. 1//6   $ 

A '!

  3 * 

 !

 /. /. 1//6 



%$ 

.78/  

/. /. 1//6



  = 

2,!0 "!* * #
/ 34

",-./#

# $# # *1!* *



 

 

 

/. /. 1//6 )

;

   $ 

;
 * 

 !  /. /. 1//6   * $ 

   ;
 *

 !  /. /. 1//6

$

   

,   

 -

 !  *

 

( 

    +$

$



$ 

*! *  ;
 *

:  /. /. 1//6 %$

 $  

 & *

 

,  

- 

 

 



  $ 

*

  %$





*! 

*

:$

 %$

 $   *

$

   

 9   *

  <

 

  *  

 

$ 

$



*! *

 !    

 '  * 

 $ 



   

       #17> ?

$!2!$ 2

 

# &