Balbir Singh v. Haryana Vidyut Parsaran Nigam Ltd And ORS



     




   

!"!

# $ %&& %


          

  
 


   

 

  

  !" #  

$ !" #                &   "  #    '  #  " ( )* +) ,)+-. / 0+12'

"

!"

!  '     '    !         +- )- ,)+-             "    3!)4 ,))*  35 +---*#+667  " "       " "! "#    '" #  "    
30
"      "   "'   8 #"  #  .   "   " " ( 2 "&  # "       #   #      

 !   +66,'   " 

 "   '&  #+664+667

'!  "   (   # 3,6 ++ +66- 35 74*,#+664.9 

  !

 :""
   2'  ;     "  #            3        '  "" '"  #

" "' &  # " #  " 3 <# "   " #             " " 
30
" " !  "  0 # "&'" 

  0 #"&'"   # " "  +667

           '     !    '

    "  !  ##"    !   
30
"  "  !  !     "  '

#  " # 3"   ="#"

      ( #35 *766#,)+> #   "       4 ,))*    35   +--*  #  +667    " " 

< #"      

 ,, )1 ,)+-. / 0+42''   ' '   8 #"    "  

  # 34) ++ ,)+7.

   2 ##!# "?@       # 3  "   #                 #"  !

 !'   #! ' '

     #   0" "" "  +661067  
30
" !  

  " .A;;2      "        "&'  "         A!   " " #  !#  "  

    " "" "   +66,  ( " ' ' (#  '" #" # 3 35 74*, #+664.'

"

" "#+66,  ( 2 < #" $ " #    #         

      #     0"  "  '   "  +667 '

"

 '  "

! "  A "    
30
" .

 

  " "   "  2  '  "

 '#!'       '

'  !"    &

   ""    "    "  "#  "  # # ;  # 3  #( )*+# , #

+ ("

'"& #!

#

#! #

+ ("

<  +664  3  >77  %      "        ;     )4 ,))*. 35 +---*#+667 '" " 2 '

 #' " ' !



                                                                                  

         
     !               "
                                         

                 

   

                                 

             #           $

        %        #  

             &       

  

                        ''          (    #                  ) *            + 3 (  # #" =!= "'  ! ' ,6 )6 ,))6'

#'   !   # "
    

             





 

    !" # 

            $          % %         

         

%        $ &'&(   )   " #    #     !   ;"    ' !    

    (  "            
30
"  #"

 3   ,)+>' #35 *766#,)+>'

"

'#"0 
 "

 ++ ,)+>' #' 
*       $        $                        

   



" #                 



+ "" ,-.

/0+1  ( (2/ % 3, "    ##3  &                    

  

                                                       

 

" #  &     .        

  $ 

 (   

 ##"

4  

      ++!

       *    3      5 

    $0     

                      $  $    

      

  

              & $  

      

  $     8

  

                     + 

 

                           

                    



 

          

       9   )    3 #  #' '  "   # " #       '!

  

  "  #      "0 
 "

 )6 )6 ,)+>  "

#'   ="= 35 +,1)-#,)+> %  "   
                        

 3 "

4  

  

                 *     5



   $    

   (    



8     



 

 + "" ,  ( (2/ % 3, " ##3     
    

  


!"#$%%   #&'&#  (   $  ''%  %'

&&'$

# ')%   ++!$  *  3 $ 5 

  

     

          $    

 $  



& $       

           

    

   : (      .       

 

   $  & $  

              

    $   

 (  (2/%"",3+"

      ;$   *           $  



$    

"

4) :!   "

# '"# ++ ,)+>       !      "

 "     "  #     #  35 *766#,)+> ."  !2

      !       #  #    !" " !         +661067  #         (      

   ? #    ! ,)+>

<    " 
30
 "      "#"          . /  012   )7 )+ +667           !   B##"        

"

     #&?# "#" <      
30
" 

"& 

#  ! " #    " ! "  # #"   "#"  ! " " 

  '#" #  0" "   +661067! '

 ;" ' !  ,))6 #  #.   2 '

   # *766#,)+>

 " #  #"# #"     " "#" #   !''

"

"  " #      "

"#"'"



   ## "#"  "!  # !' #"   

"

    "  ,))6  #       #  ' ! #

'!    # 3   

!       ++ ,)+>  #35 *766#,)+>    '   8 #"    
30
" '

"

 '  # ' # 

3 (   '    / 0+1( '   !" "  #   !   ,, )1 ,)+- / 0+4 '!  "" "     #    

 #' '#'

 &   ' !" ",, )1 ,)+-

   !"'  #'   # #"#"#"# 

-./ 



)

0

 

(

%3  %& $  < 

 & ?  C?   C?