Manjit Singh v. Union Of India And ORS










 

 


 




MANJIT SINGH  

   

 #

 $%
#
 &
' 
&
 (




)))))




 !

"#!#$"

% & '" (

) 

"

+) "

$"

% & '" (

 ,,,,, ' 
&
 (*

+ ,-.

)    

"  " ')"## + 

--.
-./

0!


-1" 23

 4$) 23) 5!

()'"

+6&

+'

"'# ' 6 +)"7)"

)  "*)"2 8'
 (#3 !**"

:  ) ("' ( )   '" "

 )" )

 '#" * )"

"##3 ) # ' ( &

+ '

"' )"

 2 ! (""

) ( * "*#3 +)"7)"

(

+"##%

##3% "3"

) "" #$"3"

%;"$"#"!7) 

 

:!

   & 

 (

 ## ((  '

**

  # 7  "'7% $" %"%'

((%*"#%2 '! ' +) " )"&


4-

--<"

)$"!

& & 23

=!

* +))&

+# '

-2-

! "23)'

"

"*#3"7)"

+) (")

"#

+$ )"

8  +) ) 

) ) "2 &"

"7)"

+) " )"&

-4-
-4$) "( ) 

)"

2 '"

)2! !

)"2 &"

# '  !2* )")# ' 5!

! 2  ##)3"

-<$) "( "# '"

$"!2*  23) 

7

()"(

# ' ) ("& )"(

"# '"

$"

!#3!

23)"(( "& 6

28'

(

*) > ("7)"

 +)  !2*  )" > +) )"

 "# 3 !  " ? 28'

@ (*

)!'

)""  ? 28'

@ )

()

 (

* "## ) "7 ) # % ) !+)   )"& 2 "## $  (!

"&

)""'

' "#'

 <
 (
-)"

2  !

"

" "

" 
) (%) # '   *  2# () !6#+"#) (

)!

0 

()"+ * 

#3%$ ))"

&"# ()A) ( ' "# "+ 6 & 

"# " #$"3 "+ 6% AA  "

$" 5!

2 2"

*)# ' ) # ") *

(

"'"

"

)"

2"*

+)("* #3 **2

#3  ) $"#% "## *

 + ( # '  ' "

 )!

5!

2

23) *#* +"+ '3" )A"

+ # '3

(
-- )



 (   " $  # '3  2 !"

3%
-. &   
-B6= B--66(

)3"


-B
-.A#"!C ()"(

# '3 )! 


         

          

 

 

       

-3-        

       

 

  

 



   

 


 ) >+"# ) ( ) # '  $  )! )#    #   ("# ' )

)!

0 

()'

"' " )+ "#'

('

"' (" #$"3 4  )2"  ()"2 &"

 # '3%&"

!  "

$ !2* 

"!)

 "

"## $ +)"* )  

"

" )"&2 " !')

"

""') " 

0!

   .) 

"# !2*  ) '#" *"

$)   (" #    3 #  "

3 !#% )  

 ( #  AD 4C<E (
-.  # !"#  $   %

 &   '( $ ) "  "3    7 ( ) &

+ '

"' ( #" "7)"

 )  ("&  ) "(

$  

$"   (& 

4-
-.$) 23 ) 

  & 

"# A ' "# "

"+ % 

 " #$"3% 

:!

A"

$"

'

  "



0!

 -"

"#

+$ ))"

$  

"" "

) !

) *!+

 --.
-. )" 2  "  '

*# "

'  "(

'

8' +)'#" * '%)  

<   "*

 2)"#(

 ) !+) 

 & 

"# A ' "# "

"+ % 

 " #$"3% 

:!

 )" 2 ( #  $)

 )"& "&

 )" ) " #$"3 9

 )"

!' &   A"

+  # '3%
-- &  A ' "# A  <6
-- 
-.
-- 2 *#* $ ) ** "(('  ) "2 & "

  # '3% F

"# " #$"3 $"   *"

"+ ) &

*"') )

!+))# ' )"2 &"

 # '3$"*

(  & 

-4- ' "#A  <
 (
-$) "

"
$"

!' $) ') * $ ()#+"#) %(

*

()"+ * *)" $"#"

)")  #* ("

) 7  ( ) # '

#3 (

 ) !

0  

( ) + * 6# ' "

)"

$ ))"

&"# ()A) (A ' "# "+ 6 & 

"#" #$"3 "

"+ 6% AA  "  )" & ) !+) +) )"

 0


4-

--< "

 ) '

 "

"7)"

+) 0

 -4-
-4% )  ( # '  '

 2 "## $ () !6#+"#)

")

"# $ () # ' % (

*"

+ 

#3  "7)"

'"  )"

 )  

 "

8   +) " )  #+"# )  ) 3"


-% +) ) "

""

3#+"#) ) >  +) )"

 !2*   "

 "(( "&  )" )3 )"&

28'

)&

+'

"' "* (" "* "!

$

$ #""7)"

+) %" "* "!

)"

2 '#"

"#+"# ) 23#""7)"

+)" "* "!

$

$'#" *

!2*  "(( "&  )" ) )"

28'

 ( ) '

"'  

( "

8   +)  "

 " "* "!

 "#

 -E
-4   "# '"

 (

( ) '

"' $" !2*   23 )  

 "( ") " "* "!

  % =!

*  +) 

+) "

"

()( *

!2* 

28'

) ()'

"'

 ("& ( "

8   +)   )! !2*   )" ) "# '"

5!

$" +)#3 '# B #(

) 

+!)") 

   # ) ) ("&

 !25!

") "7)"

+)"

)") "

' 

(

'#

-5- )'#" *

 ##3

)+

)")A !+) 2

2"

*> +) * '

' &  '=!

* "# 3+ & ) ? 28'

@ (*

) $) )"

(!

!2*  "(( "& )")# ' *"32+

. #(

  !2* 

 '"2 & )"*"



2   C )"&)"

#"

#(

' &"

 "

)"&

)

!+))

'!* "&" #"2#

'

E 

5! 3$" "  )'

#(

) 

& $ ( ) ' ( ' '#"! '

"

 ) A"

+  # '3 "

!25! A  !

" #$"3%" $))

 *"

" +"

) ")


4-

--<$"& 

" #$"3)'

#"# (" #

)"*

 ) "(( *" &  (!

 5! 3 $" "# "   "   $))

 )"

 " "

3 #"  

(  *  !+) $"#6 ( ) # ' ) ("& 

") () (")

"" #



)  ( *  ("

#3 !2*  )" "## !25! $"#

+ ) 

)"

2 + ()"

) ( *!

"*G 3# +) "7)"

#3   (!

 ' ( ' 5! 3 $"

"  " $)"$")*"0 *!*

" )'"

+ # '3

 (  23)

" #$"3(

$) '))# ' '

)"&2 + )""# ("

#3!2* )")"(



'"* 

3"


-< '%"

"
 () # '3%$) ') *  $"#6

-6- ) # '  (

 ) 2"#"

'  



 '

*   ) "

( )

- )"%) %#"' # "

'

)8!

+* (

@2# ! *A )*" (
  



   

               

 





 !



""#$%&'()*""

"

") ($) 23)

" #$"3)"

2

' '

 )'#" * ()**2 () ' "

!

) # '3  ) "(

 8!

+* ( 

@2# ) ! * A  

 "# '"2#   ) ("' ( )   '"  '  )" 2

 '  ) "(

 "

"    ) ( )" ) 

& 

( ) A"

+  # '3%
-- $  "# '"2#

@ '

'

 ) "'

( ) " #$"3 23

 + $"# ( ) # '   **2 ( )

 $" )#    2 ##+"# "

 "

2  3 )

2 +'

& !

) # '3% ') * ')" "# 3'

* 

%'"

"7"

32 ( ) ( 
 )'#" *(

7 ("# ' )" 20"*

)"# '"2# # '3)&

+# '

)" #$"3

3% 2 +"#"

+"

"

('

' "#"' & 3%)" 2+ &

"# '"2#  # '3  "

+  & ! *"0 * :"

  '

'

* ' "# =

( ) # '  $  )! 2   "  # '36'

' "#'

 !

)'

#(

 !+) " "

"
 ()A"

+ # '3

)A ' "#'



 )' ( '5! 3%) ("

#3'

' )" +)

& ) !

 

#3(

* 

-7-

"

)")"

"#

'"* 


-<'

( 3 '#"!$) " +) $"#'

2 !* )"&"''

!

 )"2 ') (% '"

2 "

)")  "

3 "#

! 

("

3 +)

23 )

  

"##3%)# ' $"

"##3+ () "

) ( * )3"


--<) 

(

*)"

"' )" #$"3"!)

 ) $"#$  !+)

"* ("

) ( *& ) !+) 2'"*" #



) 

 ) 3"


--< #(  $"#  2 +  !+) (

 ) "

)  ( *% $) ') 

0  ' '
--< 4 9 %) 

)"

"

)"##+ A+ & 23)> +) )"2 ' ()"

'!* %) '"

2

 !*

 (& ("

3 +) " "* "!

%' "##3$) )"(( "&  (" "* "!

  # 5!")"* <  '%'



+ (

*)"

"'"$##% ("& ( 

"#

& 5!") +) (> +)'

 )"& 2

 )  

 '"

 7  +) "

)  " #



) !

)+"

2 ) "2 &"'"

) "'"

* '") "+ ' 

' )") # ' 

)""# 3'

* 

%) '%) '"

2

')# ' "



0 3 (*"0 *!* *

-8- B 

'

 

 )! '"

 2 !    + #" (# ( )# ' $) '))""# 3 !# &   "# *  2#

'



. )  

 "''

+#3 * '

' &

 %)!%

*   18.

## ) 

+ * '##"

! "# '"

% ( "

3% "

 "#

  (






+' 
&
 (.




 
*
"






   $ D)) "7 +6 "

H6 D)) 

"2#

H6