← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1616/2008dismissed

Pawan Vats v. Huda And ORS.

2018-12-17Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

 

     



     !

""## !$% &$'($)*#"

%+$'+$

"       $

$ ,*+$ -* $+""##

$ .

  +,-$* +



"$/+% -* $$"

 .$#'-+$+"# !- $1$)+)$%2+%$#$ +3%# $#    "$+)$'    $'  ,%  2   &$'($)*#"

%+$' $+$4&(+$%2+  $$-  $-  1$)    +  5  $-  &(- 1$)    +  *$   +  .+  6 78-  $ -  1$)

%$2 3

$ ##.+,*##  #$ )$26 :7 :: $##$  -9-;<+ % --9 "+ %+$ % -9-9; "$$

="'

9>+##"$<++)# %  )"? +#'## #%2+$<++

 "#+"%  - -:87; $+"#<+ + %- "$ )'++$'

*#"

  $=  %#  )  $$  %    +  $    +  $# #%2"$*2#' $2-#$'-$ -+ *$- $+## +$$'%'*#"  $= +$<++"#$3%++*$+ "+'#"+#)%6 ##*$+  <+*#$

-+6  $3% +*$+"+"#%#$+$%)% +2 $#$6  8  9

  *  ++  +  "#    =    "    %    -8-7 9#'++"%2+%#)#*$

$2+"#-++#$'"+? %  -- 9 % % $+$<+  6  89

 +$)'+  -8-79;+) $- ##2#-%##* &+% #

  -  +    ""$    #  $  2+%$2"$# $'),++*# @%$+,%$$+%* "$* 9 +&(-:

<+%$+ "#)$2+%<+% "$"$#'*#%$+"%$" @%$<+"$#%+#$## - #$#'

++"+

$#3% 2+) = 

#'$ =2 "'

 )#9> %    A %$+$"#++"$-+

7 "# $3%$ = $=2")%+ #        A    %$+$  "#  +           -8-79;+)*##' ++&(%#  $+#'"'

B >"$% "$#%+ ## #$ '2$ 2##2-+"$'$  #+%

  +  "#2    +  "$-  ## 2  %  $ $  C++$+  -8-79; $2-##2#-%# %# 2+$ +## #$D

 C++$+#+$2 "%$ $D

C++$+@%$+,%$$'+"$%D 

C++$+"#+%#%# +"$%D 

C++$+% )#+"$$ D 

 #

A$$"$*+$-+"#2+$  $$    C  )  ? 2  &%   2+    C  E+ "##$*% 5?

5?



  +  +$  +-  +    +  ?   +$ + '6C)$2% 5?

5?



$+$2+#$%#$+"$-+$# @%$%6 *%$+"#-%6 7 *%$+"#2+-%6 89

8 2+ A* +2%6 9-% 6 $#2$# +%+"# $ $$#$ "*%$+"# 2++++ "%2  )$26  8 9

 ##2#+  

A+$$ $',% "*%$ +"#2+$2+ $#%#+ %%22+)$2)+6 78 )'+$22+$B>"$% #"'

 #%# %++"#+"+? % +%+ %)$%$+"#+ %" )'+"# %+$"$+$#%#+%+ %2   %  %#  )  $*$  )'  +    $  + "#

1#2  22$*  )'  +    ,%2     $-  + +#""#+@%$$F%2-1$)- ++ "*,%2 7   E+)$* $""##@%$$$#*$"$%%$  



         

             

      



  

  

   !""#





 $ %&  ' ( 





  ) *+, ( 

 

 -.(    (   (

9

 &  /+0

        

  1. 

 (  

(    (  (  

 2   (  

   

  ) 

     

  +, &  1 )      (    

3 



(

3

 (  +,

  4'#    (    ) 

3  (  3   (+, (   )  )  

 (    '#  ((   

(   

( 3       3  # 





 

  ( (  (





  

    ( ,#  ((    



     

3   # 



    (  

 (  

    (

    



 3    

# 

  

  # 

   (



      

+, (

  3     *25  6!7 8 5

 9 :

)



 ;!*..*!5 1'"



 



           (

       59:  

    (,# :)   <7   8    (5  !*...51-  3 )  -#  ((

  



 

    ( 

59:        (, 

 



    

3 

   !     

      $ :+ ' (         !                    

 2 





     

 

  

       #  (     ( (       59:           # 

 

   :   )  59:            ) ( (       

  )         ((   

 ((  -.# 



   

 (   &  ( # 

  %  

( 

    E+"##2 ++,%2  2*)'$F%2-1$)+==+$+ @%$)' '#2$2%#$""#"$'2++ ) "-+ "%2,%2 $")'$F%2- 1$)) 

22$2%#$""#-+ +*""$)$+@%$+$%2+%#

A+*+$#$%#$+"$)22 +$%2++$$

G$%#$+""##+++  ")+ ++$+%#+$2 $#'"'

-- +$$ +"$

$2+ -++ #* $ $ +    $    +      3%    %#    ")#'  #*$ "+ A #' ++"# *""# +" #*$+

E+$ *#"

+ $ E+"#%#)+#$")#$#'"'  $%#)+$2$ +

++$+-#$%#$++ *+ #'$*$+$2% *)'#$%#$ +""##2+,%$+*#@%$$$' +%)$$%$9+&(-+$$-+%

  #  )'  +  "#  $*    )       +  $  #

6*$+#   #'  +  "#  +  "  +  ##  )##'-%+- #)#"'$+#'"' - +++)$2+#'+$2$ +$ E+$3%? "'

+*2)")'+"#$+)2#$*$   %$ +$

$+$2+$*#22+$%2++ $$-  A    +  +  ""#  #=  $  A  +  -  ""##    !$2###+)+3%-$+$ ++"%$+$ $2###.+, .+,-$2# ##  +    +##2  +  $         ##  #%2++%#$"'

+#$ % #%2+#% +$2$$B >#'"' 

E+$2###+*2-"#   !)2 $$+$2###")#'$+$##2$ +##22+$ +##   #'-+ $2###+"#'9>+# %$ 2  %    ";"  )##'

 &$'  ($)  *#"

 %+$' ,%# 2$+2$$ > )#  "'

      %#    )  %  +  +    5* +$ -9+&(-:

# +#'$$ )$,%$@*#@%$"$*2+*+$  ?"$#'"$*+-*$'$$"$$%)' +/*$ $$$"$%)'+%+$'$ $%$++##)#+##)3%'

: %$+$#2#"$2 %)#+@*#@%$ +##+*,%$$'%$"$2$" ' $+2H ++)=")'' %+$'   " $  )'  +    $  +  $%#  $  $2%#   +$%$

E+$$-%+"$*-+"#%# ")#'=,%#$*)' '#2*#%$$$# +2$*  +"$+2$$"'

$ "$%#$$%$+$-"#+##2+#% 

$2$+#$%#$+""## +++ #* $ $ +  $+ 3%%#")#'#*$+"+ +$ *#"

+$-%+$$' ' 2+2 E+"#+$# %#"2+ ## "$+%#2$) +##&( 6 #+$ %+++ #*$ $ +  $+3%%#")#'#*$ "+ ++2"$ &(# #

2$2#=*#"

+$+# +*'$#* 2$2+,%2 $$"%)'

#$  %#  $  + ""##  +      +$  #2- +$ &( "$'

G$$F%2-1$)+$2+$""#+

 $2+#'$#%"+# #  

           





       !  "           "#  

    $$ %  E+#  ###+&($#'+$2"# $ B  >  ##;+ $$   )%  "' +# $ %2$$ + "'

# )   +  "$  E+  +  )    +#      &   '

!        ()  *+   "

       , -  , + - $$ +$  + ) )$* )'  *  .+    +  @%$  +    ##    ++#  + # "$ % "###)'&(+$"$* +$+2%#%$ ++ $'$+%+$'

##"#%##'*#"$+####

*$$ $#'+2$%+ +$ %##' *#")#+##$$%

E+$$-A' $+"$""#    ' $  %$)+ #2#-*#  ## $ ,%2 ")'+$F%2-1$)

E+""# $2#'

   .$,  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*  "&#

 '# !+,

 "&#