← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17178/2018dismissed

Wazir Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-12-18Mr. Justice Namit Kumar29 pages

 

 

     

  

'





'" #$ $

<  $$$$$$

    "*" !  

  $$$$$$

"%   "

     "

 # 

    $$$ 0/ 8-, '

 %

   $

8 $$$9 !&8-&$-$9$8 !$

  

  !"

"# $ :"%%&'  "+

 &

+! %%&' %

   

 %&'   '   ' %!  % (

     %

   

$ $)) % "

*+,"  &

"- .* $

$ ;    " " (        %%&'  8 "(  " && / $  %!   

$$)) " 0   ' "*+1 '

&&1*"

.'

%  "$  $ $ $% !"

% $ :  %

    " & "

  /  %

   *  - '& "

  "

 *   4 "

05*"   

$ 6$

6 - .* <8%""

+ +! "%   = $ / +!

'&(

%

    ' * 

 '"

,'

 



+!(" *+," &

    ( "'& 8"

  !  '

' "

5*  &+ 

 ""+

 '

$;* 8/ ((*" "+

" *  '

 "%   " '  "

'&(

%

    ' *

 '"

,'

  +! ("*+ +," &

    ( "'& 8"

  !  '

"

5*  &+ 

 "$

$ : +

'

"8", +

 %&  %

  8

 %

    1   "%   % % (  "?* 

   !

 )  

 ,    

$$))8   /" % (

  " *+ ," & 

  "

%%  (    %    "

". (  "8 "*+1 '

 %% ,&  ! *+&'  ,'

 ( (("" $: " '% ( (  /"

" *& /$ $ $ $  $

6

 %

   

  ("

,'

 

    "*% *    > > $$

2 "  ,&$ -

  !

" "

 (  8%

    "*+(

 % "

  "

 >$ $

<8 $ $

6 && /

 +! & &  '

 

>$

$

6  % "

  

$ $

28'&(' *  " '"

"

,'

 ( $ $)) >$  $

< &&+ 

 ""*' " .

"' & 

 , !

" "

,'

  

 (  + 

 "  "

   !$  :  " '&( /" ' "

"    '

 +! "%   "

"8 ,    

$ 6$

6

- .*  <8 /'" +

(%*   % "

 %

  $ >$ 

 "

(    + &

  "%   ""+



& / + +!'&( %

   "+

 %% "

$

> 

<$ @  ' *"

&  %

   "*    ' "

,'

    +! %

    "& &+&  +  ' *

 %*% "

 (  "'&   "

   !  , /  &/ &  /+! " * 

   %& #$  

  

    

 % '  8 8/'"+

*% &!"

"

%

   

  #$  

% '

 $ 6$  '  8&  

' * "

&"*  % "

 %

  "& +& + "(""

   * * &!&' "$

* "*+( (

 ,  (  "&" 8

 '"

,'

  +!  %



   '  +  ' *

  %*% "

  ( "'& "

  !$ 2$ 4 ,  &   ' *"

&

  %  " % *"

 ' $ $ :  ""* " /' "

 

 % "

  %

     " /



"

 %

   & +! %

   8

' " +&

&!8 " & +&  +  "(""

  '' *  &!  &' "  /



 '"

,'

  +!

%

     ( $ $))

>$ $

<'+ ' *

 

( "'& "

  !$ $ : '

"  "%*

 %

   1  "

,'

"?

?* 

 !

)

/"% (

"*+ ," & 

  "

%%   (  8 ,    

$$))8 8 " ' (

 8/"(  *&/$ $ $

$ $

6  %

   

  ( "

,'

 

 

< 

"*%  *   > $$

2"*+( (

 % "

   

"

(   >$$

<$ $

  !

 " "

 (  $ )$ -(

&!8  "  ""8   

  * .%&

&! / / &, !

" & % "

 / / %

    ""& " ,'

'

$  $ :  A+&  *% (   *  78 259

91 " $ 

( 

  ) *  '

 

+ "

&'"(  ")8 /&  

   ""* &!  & ' "8  &" && /"#  





 



 

  

    

   

 

  



  !"#$%& 

 '  ()  

      - *  



   

  

 

  

      * 

+  

     

 ! 

+   

   ,-   - -     

 



 &*      ,,  -$.

  /0.

 2"-4    1 .

!  

     

+      # /          0  1  2

*  !  

 ,

$  $.   .

 "$  *

'2 1 3  4#

-   

 ,, !

  -  ,  2"-4    31 1    

).

  .

   5,6 6 4 *,

  '

2"-4 1!0 1   3

6 

   

 ,7       

/     

        

  7- -    

 !    

  

      !    1-

! 



  !             7 



   



  

+

+ 

!   

"%  

  

   

 

  



  +   - 

  !  



       

!

   

 

 - 

            !        

!     +!     

  

 ! -     

  8

     !   

    -

   * 



 5      

 



 

 

4   

       

   

  

 !  

! 



    -  4  :  - 2"-4   1  

-             

     

 4  

          

 4     !    

        

  *            

      

  

   ""  

    ,,2"-4    31     

    

   

    

           

2 

 

  7             

    

    

  

  !        -  

   +       

    

 8        

  

   

   

       *    

    

-    + !  +   

      !   -             

-     +      

        +    - *!   



   

   





        

  



+   "

  -  



               

 

  

 9 $ ;*   A+&  *%

(   *   

 :

' ,   

       * 5   

;"

#'

(  "&8/& ' "   ""*   &! &' " 

 & 1*(   "  ""* 8 %  %

 % % "

  "( /&& 0

% % ""* "&, $-"

&    ""*

3"%*

' +  ,, ,   "*' % "

  " +

 '

 +! *   ! +! 

 '

   ( ' *  "

 ""*    &!  & ' " "  + '  / 

'

 &'*"

'

 

/ 

'

!"*' %""

$ &!&' "  %

 , (  "

, (!

 

%, ( ( + 

 /'+

 ,  "$- '& <

  "



*    48   " *  

   * 8 /&&   +

'

"

 "/ &&0 /  &/& "

" , *  "

/  & , & $,  5*& !" + '

'&(   1*'

*      .%!   " +& ( $  ,    "   %   % "'+

 &  /  %

   *  - '&

2  "

 *    48!

 " *&+ & / /  " +& ( $- % (

1* " *& (&&!+

'&&  / %  

".( 

"  ( "

!

 "* *'% (  $: * "  "

'

 *& 8 ' * "'&/!"

, "*+"

5* 

8 +*  &

% " 8/ && /" "

%%  %% '

 ' *    %* " /  "

&  '&(  !  *"

&  "

& (

"8 '  '

&! +  

*"

  ''

' * &!  &' "$ -!  /  "&

%" , " ""+ * "*

$- (%& !

/  "&

%"&0

%70&  *%  ( ("&*(+  " /& "* 8

"

, "

 +    &

  ''

' * &!  &' "$

& , % %"  (  "1* (   .

'

+ & /# "4/ -     





-

   



   +

  - 8  

    

       + +

    





   



*

 8  

  

 



     -

 

-              

   

* !   

 

         

  

  *

*    

  !   ! 



    %%4    

  

   



   +

   

  

  "$"""#4   <'

9  & '

  =

, *   *   

; 2 1   3!   ?@ 1



    





 

  +    

!



 3? ,-

   :



!      ;

 

     

- 

 



  !   +   

  !      

 

      !       

   

  



  

   ;

   

         *

-

 

 

 !         

--

 9 "<==== ==== ==== ==== "$==== ==== ==== ==== "==== ==== ==== ==== ">  5  ' * $ !$

 =$ & 21  

; 21    !  

?@ 1

  ( 0

    

 <* !, , 

;2 1

  3  

    -    



 



    

   "# ##>!       

 >>"

"##  ',$;2 1 " 

)   

) 

 !    ( 0

  !    7 

    

*      

      !   3? 

    -     





-





   7           

   -

     A

       -   

-   

-



"<     !  !   *        -    -9 "#==== ==== ==== ====

% 

6 & , '., ',  *  

;2 1 !  (0

 

           

-

   



  ! 

                     



     

     -    

!      ! 

*      

  -  

    

     



 

  +    $ 4 '

 1*(  +!  ," B ' " * 74$# $ 

 

+;"

""'#(#) 8 /&  '

 '&( %

   

' *  " ' "

,'

8   %*% "

 "

  !3%  "    *&    "

,'

 '

' (%&

 

!

""% % % &'!8 &  %

  

* .%& &!

& +!( ("*

 ( ""8 

 

%% '    * $4 "1* *(  8 "+

 &" * # "% /     

B!   !       

   B  %"%<"##> !         

 

   /   !

  -  

    -  !

     @ ! %

6       ! - !

!     

 8 ! 

  

    

    

   -       

   8 0

 !

6& , '.,  ',    * > ?;  21   !  -3 "$ 8        

        ;

    /  2     ">   8          -   

     8  !   !        "> 

*  



 8          -   -  

       0 

        

  "# !        

   

  ?

  -             

    ! 

!   /  2  

  -   -           

   +       

-

 

           

  -  7 +   0 

 

 



 

=

 5 ) #4 " ?

A21  B;$;

;:<, *$>"  <6 *" " A 21"!/ B   # (     . !

  *   $>** *& '

 "

 # )*.. "

A2 1B9 "" 0  !  <*  !, > ?  

  > ?; 2 1    3 !   0

 3 8   !      

!           

    



 4          



  0    

*      

       *            

 C  2    + 0 (

 DD8



!   

 ? 

     -   A        

   "#>< ; 

 "#% ;!     +  - - D9 "

  *

  *

  -!        

  +           @ 8

   !



 !9 >$ :   

B ' "

" * 7 $  

  

 @9  

+;

 "

%'"(  %$8 /& '

  '&(    & ' (   "  '5*"      5*& '   "" &"* # 4  

            

  

 "#% "#># 

 

 - 

-A 7 

  7   

"#% "#>#   

             

*   2+ :

! 





     *      - 

* 

2+2 - E;

 0

       



 

     



      % %> %"4           

     

   

 , 4 #  * 

 

 @9 

 <-  

 

   !  

  -  

    7   

         -     

  

 $2 

 

  2?"        8    

  2?"     

      

  -     "##$ %"

 . 4   !

   

 "%   * 8  + 



   

  -

 /       

          

               8   

  

 -   

       

  

    - 

 > 8         - *  

    +   



       F    

> 

0

 $!:

:<, *$ 



<6 * 

 2 1  

!               $   





    %   0

                8         2   



+!   !       !   

  *      ,- 

                + 8  +       

 

 

      



   + 4.&$   : 

 - ; 2 1  3 C 7<*  !,  

 ; 2 1   3   =

$    *, )#4 ;2 1 !

   

  

  



      !       

     

     

 -  -    0

 

2 $! " +    3? $ 0  

!  

! 

 1

   

-         

  6 /*

; #$ /    

!  

      *

  

      

  7

   7  

       * 

  

      +  6  #$    (; 231      

 G

 7      

     

   

< 

 

 

       -  8 7        

     





    

7  

     

       

   

 

        



  4"> %%$8   

          

%% ! %%4! %%<        /     "8 

!  

-   

    6 

   

   F

   

!  



   !

  

?

! 

-    7   

G   

     

    

        

 

  

        /  

 -       !        

               -       

      $  

 

     #         6

      4% %%$ 8     

 

    

 8         

       %%"! < %%$! * 

%%$  %% 

  /  

   

 G

  - 

 

      6  

       



7              -

   .   

6 

  -      

    

 -         

  -

  

  !

  

9 I,



J            8       ) $, @ 9

  .

   !$

  

;  21 1 !4     8 2&

)! 

  - *  

?

      4"%4 %%$  

      

            

 4    - 

 

  

        !

      

 

 H

   ! 

     %  %%$  +

 

   /  ?

  

  

    3? ""      

     +

  - 

+  

       

     

  -  

  + 

   

 

  



 

   



 

+!       

     -      

    8      -           *     0

  



    

   !      "#$

%%$!  

    

 4    

 -   

 +    

2 

"

8 

4"4 %%$ 

  

 !     



  

 



      

   

  

 "4   

   

  

  

      

9 #    !

   

       !

 

    

  

 - !   -     

   8

   -      

                

      !  -!   

 !           -   

 

    

 

  

     *    

 

     

 

H1

@       @ #$  

 @9;  21 )

    

       0 0

+ K F &

)!     - - 

     

!      

 

      

   

    !    

  4  

   

  

  

 

 

 -     

  

 "% 8 

  

 

  +0

+K F  !   8

 -        0

+ K F !    +  0

  4=.

 :  -   

;3214<

 

3  E; : F &

)!   



       

        9   

 -    

       



  



      

   

     

     9 "" -  .   '  ; 

  .

   '

  

 *

 ', ,$ 6,     '

 -   $'9 D

.

.

    

(  .   

(

 *  $.

  $ '

 

'    $ 

 9

      '  $,, 

$., 

 "

   

   !L2@6F

&

)! .

    

 ,

  , .    .

    



 9  $    ,  *   

, ,'  "4.

 

 9  <$ : ," B ' " * 7=,, :   -  

+;"

'"()$$8" &   (%& !

' '&( 

,"

%!"'& 



 ( 

 '

 "+

 '

,

 %! "'

&  

 +! (%& !



  &"

) !

"$ : & , %     ( "1*(  8 ""* # "<8         





    

 

-    

 ;$%%?"%$%%  

   0 .!



 > %% H

 !  -

 # %""! ! * 

 #  8 !  9

     



6$ : "

' ""* " /

 '"

,'

"' * +&

   ( "'& "

  !"   " " *  



3   % 4&  $  

  

   

 '

 '

' 

'  " &"*

#   

     

         



  2  # 1

   !    

- -    20



 

  0 :





 



   

-

 4%#    *  ;*    - 0  &;-  2 ) ;! "##9 &

 '  ;()  ; $

 ;    

  2 

- - :

  -!   

  

  

  "%  %  !

   

 2 2 ;$ ;

 3? 73 /,*9,  =  "', E &") ,-  :

   -       *, '

,  '





 "% 

!   



    "%       

    :

 

  



 :

 - 

                               





 



) 

 4""

"##$!

! 



 

    3? )    

 7   





!

 ) 

7

-    



!

) 

7   -

 

    

    !     

   



 

  4""

"##$!  

     !  

    2     

 & ) ,-  :

   -       *, '

,  '





 % 

!   



   

%       

    :

 

  



 :

 - 

    

 

                   





 

  4""

"##$!

! 



 

    3? )    

 7   





!

 ) 

7 7 -   



!

)  

 7     -

 

    

     !        

  





 

 

4""

"##$  

     !   

   

 2     

-   2   

         

    3H

  ! F4 *,  '

, 

'

F 

  

   

     :

  

    2 + :

 

B

 

  

 :

  - +        

 







 

 



  

   

  

*       

    

   2  

       

7 



 

         2 C

  

-  ;$    

   2     

 

  

8 

 -     ;     7    

 9 9

  

2  "%           

(0

 

   G

   ") " '   &

)    H 1

 +      &+

  -)   4(  #$ *,H 

 

       



     8 +       (0

   <*@6 4$H

 &

)!   

 - + !   3? "%8    - +  

*

 



  

       7    



    

      

   

*

              

    

     - 

     "" /       

*

   - 

 

             !      

 !

    0    -   C   M 80



   

 &

)!  

?@ 1

  7       

 

 7       

          



 

    @! "##  "  E ! "##%       :

           - 8     

    ;*  K 0 + 

 , 

 <""#% %

       



#"#         2  0     

   :

 

 

     

  "

   

  

  

  <""#%  :



7!;* K 0         .         -  1

!        

  

?@ 1  +

  +!    

               

 

 

        



      

   

       0 :

 8  

-  +     3 5  

   ??"##!      H        0

 :

   ! H    !  

     



    

 -          

!     0   , !      ,  

!

  !   7-

      

-   

;4%%% ;<$%%   - 

  $  

   ;<"%% ;$4%%

 "

    8  H  

    

  "?$?"##%!-

         8  



    

    :

            

  ??"##!- 

  

       , 

!      $%% $    ;4%%% <$

> 

 

              ;<"%% ;$4%%! 

      %N



  - "

  

  

   

 

       7-

      :

  -              

 $  

"

  

  

                

%N 

 

 !         ;* K 

"#% "# # !

   

 !   

  

   

    *   

 

  "

   

  8  +

  +  

 

 

   7 

  5     5   5

   5 





    

 

  ??"## "?$?"##%! 

 ;* K    

 

    -     

 "

  

 #?"?"# 

       

   

   ,      2 0 0    

  

  8

 +

  +   -  ;*  K ! 

!   5 8    

 

- 

      0

 , ! ? !

< 

2  /

*   &

  1 

) ;!"#>% 3?



  



-  ;

; 



           

  

    

  

;          

 

   



!       

 "#%   "#           

   -   



    :

 

  ? ?

"##  "?$?

?"##%!   

!  +

 +   

   

  



- 

;

 ;!

7   8  

  ?"

?"#>#

     



 ;* K +   ,  

"

#% 

8 

 7-

         

 

,  



 "   <

    

-   

     

  

       

  +      ;<%%

   ;<%% ;""%%

                          



 

6 

  

 

      0 ;



 

   

   - 

    

     

 

    



     8



     

  -  



  

! 

!    

 

   #?"?"#   - ;*  K  

 

             

 ;* K 

  

  0

 !

!   2  0   

 

  

 ,   0   

     



     

           :

 

     



   8  





 ; *  K     



  

   2 2  0    +           

;* K  



   +  



 

  

 

#?"?"# 

   

  

         

 

  

2 

  

    :



  ??"##   

 "?$?"##%

 

 +

  + 

! 

!    

    5 "

 

 @9  

  - *  

;21 ) IA21 B  

@9

 =

.#$ :..,  

 A2 1  B!    ?

@1

 

   +

    

 > ") " '   &

)      

 

   

          

   

-

  ! 

A  !

   ?  

 

  "4   

       1  *    

     

  -  

   

 #A"      O*!   

 



  -  

 4  

  8   F   F  -  



 

               



   





 #A"A 4    -        

!



*

   



    

  

 

   1               

 -      

 

  

 

     

 



 !   

 F#A"  

  F

F 4  

   F! 

 

   

- 

 F#A"   F

F 4    F  -

!           

  

     

7   #A"      

4         

  

     

  

 

        H

    -!

  

     

 A

 

   

 #A"A 4        

 

  

   -      

  

  

*

 9 ""         -  1

+  

 "$@ * ='*&

) "

 O  0 @     $ #$H &

) )!

     + !   3? <4H

     -!  3? &) 8  

      

 





A

*?

A

      

       

       

 B         

        -

  0:

:





&)8          

  

 

  

A 

*?

 

 A"      "%A %  !   

    7  



  

  >!"##  &)0  !

                 0   0 

     2

   0  

   

A

* *

A

    . 

  

  

 

 

             

-   

9 2$ 4, / 1*(  "

 A+& *% (  * 

     G

   ") " '  ; 21  )

D  @9 

 /, '

 '  5    

  <*@6 4 4$  

; 21  ) C ,"  B ' 1*(  "

"  *   "$@  * *  

  

 @9

;21) C

@9 

  ='  *  

;  21  ) 3  &  B ' 1*( 

"  *   $  #$ $  

  

   

; 21!4  ; '&( %

       (  "'& 8 "

  !   ' "

5*  & + 

 " +! ' *     ' "

,'

   +!  %

    "  ( +& & $:

8 &'

%&'

+!

! &  ' *"

& 

) 

%

     '"

& #$ $ "*%"

&&! ("%&'

$ $ 4 , /  + , 8 % "

   %

   " "(""

  '' *

&!&' "&"  (  "$ $  %%&'   "8 !8 &" "

 ""% "

$ '  (   $ $

<

$$ 

"% 03 "  # "3=  



%  +&  # "3=