← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26742/2013dismissed

Balbir Singh v. Haryana Power Generation Corp. Ltd And ORS

2016-02-08Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan11 pages



      

  !



" #$%&'%()*

 

  

  

  





%'+"  ,-  .  ..

 !"#"! $%&' 

 !!  

%&'   !

%&' 

 ()*   ++++   .. *

 

%   



  

, 

)-.-/)/ 0&

1234   -3.-/)) )56-/)) 0&

127 2)/4%%     

 

'   " 

  

                 

     

&

 81 

"

9

' " :    %    

        

    

    ;

  8

    )7<)=7.  >

)7.-//-% " &

8



,          

   &!?8         

 )53-//6% 

 2 0&

12)4  

:@ -  

"

2? 7--//6   

'

A8(% '



 



    ,

" 

$%







 '' -   "

2)    

    

  

"   "



 

 ?   $ "   B 

 - 



   

    ,

" 

$ C

2)

 

 7--//6 :  "



 

)-=-//60&

12-4  $



, >      , % "



 

)3=-//=0&

1254

     

   '?  

 

 

8

 $ 

:@ 

  '

' :

"   "

  



  

  (

 "  

  $ "    

,

" % ,   "" 

'

$  2       

        

)7)--//=  0&

1  2.4         "

  

    

)-)-/)/0&

12<4 & 



 "  '

" 

%

'

  

,

"  $

 

   

% 

 '

 )-.-/)/0&

1234 "



 

 ' 

& 

,    2   :  



% 

'

-3.-/)) 0&

1274 

  



 

  "

  '

      )56-/))  0&

1  2)/4   )5      

     &

  

  )5=)==/       

 

     

   

 :

   "    

 

  %        

           "

 : '  



9



"    &

  81  '  8

  '

     -33-//=  0&

1  2))4%         

          

   

  

  

   " '% "    $  ' " :

 '  " &

 '

.)-/)-0&

12)-4  

 



 "   "%

9

 "%  9 '

-3))-/)- 0&

12).4

  %    %

 2    

 

  9  

   9 

 "

 

 

 5)<-//3 0&

1 2-)4   

 "



  







?

 

)-.-/)/

 

 '   )).-/)) ?"" %  %  

              &

  

  " '

 .)-/)- ?'   

    2$   "  #"  ! $    

  

    

 "

 "

4  

       

 1 

'  



?  2 

    

%D"    '

 "%       

  

     % 

       "



%&88"      



 

 

  &        &

  & %         &

  &       

   



4  &  

 

   )=6)=65  0&

1  2)=4%





   "

  %' 

  



%  

 '    "   &        %            &



 



2 "2" %  %       '

         



"





 

  

& ' %    "

  

4:







    

'

   "2





  



 

)5))-//=0&

12)<4 '4  :





 '  $   "

             

 



 



   

9    

 &       

 

  

%   1 



 

"  

   

   

%  D"           



  :

 &

8

% %  



D" 8'

 %

  

 "   

%



   



   1 

% 

'

 

 

 %



'  & 

  9

  

%               -6--/)/ 0&

12)64 '   2 



    '

 "

   

--3-//5 





B"

   $

C

2? ??% 

  

 





 

    &        %     "        

    



 

"       

          

  

  



 ' %

  

 

)=6)=650&

12)=4%'

" '



 

5)<-//30&

12-)4&     

 

%              "

  

        

   

    

 

    :  

 

 '  

 

"

 

 E " 

  

  

*

% 

  

 

 1

1  "%  " 

   

$   

%     "          

'



" 

9

 "





'





 :     



     $

 &



> %



 





 ""

 

 )=67 32)-2)=7-%





 '  :

 





& )=7. 2

,    >  

, % "

  32=2)=7. : "

   

 

   

)=7527. >&()57 )==)

&"

 ':  %! ::   )3232)==5>&()57)==)% 

     

 

       ")=7527.:

    E

 :,  "   

2 

 

 F )=752 7.

    ?   " 

 

$   

 

1

1  ">

% " 

'  

 

 "



 " 

  "

  ?  " "

  

                   "

      

 "

   "

'G 



         

  E: "            "     9    ' & 

%

   :   

?  '     

   

     

 

 

       

    

!

    "   # 

     

$ % &    %       '    (  )   ( (  )             



    

      *   $+     ,  )   -          (   (                  .

  

 *   $ 

          /  ,0    1 

2

.

 341 / 

5,%6

 7    85)22&  ',

 #     





      

   

      

   

     

    



 

 

      

  

 /         #       

      

   

   

 

      

  /  -  

                 

               

               

  /  ,

   

 9   

     # 

                    #  $    

           *      

         # 

 

 *      

  

  

             

  ,        

   

    

        #  

   



  

     #    *   

         

      



    

   

  

   

                                    

     

           

:      ,



                  $    

  

   

    



    /

     



 



      :   



  / 

  

       



   

   

  

      

/   

  

            ;     

 #    

 /



     

     5

7      &       <                   

 #  +

      

      

    

         

     

    .

           

    *      *               



   

 / -

           



       %        .

        



      

     :            

   ,       ,   !    

 ,       

2   + :

 9"

 "



"  



  $



'    "

9

 " :    98 

  '

    8

  08  4    "   

 )=3<%

 &



 



2 "2"  "$     

  

   

  





 :9" 

   

    '/%.0123044563#.7'7# &1/'$%  88

!

.     '%$93.'2'%56 &1/'$.7'7#4#:7%0:07('%9*

'70'4'* 88

. ) !

 $ "

       ?

<:)

"

= 57  ,  

)=65   "



)=73%'  

    '

 $  



 

  " ' ?



 "

   '  

 %  $)=65 

 $    % 

>  )=    57 

  ""

  )=7.: 2 

 "

 '

)=7= : ,   





)==)% ,      '

! %)==5 



  



; %)==.    : % 

"



 H    

?

   "

%       )=7. 

 

    

     "

9

 " " :



  

 "



   %"

2    -//6% 2 

 )53-//6 

  )/.-/)/ !'% 

          

      E  " 

 <  =  

  

' "



  

%    "

  

 : 

 

 '    '

 )-.-/)/        )).-/))    %    

    

 &

  

  "'

 .)-/)- : %?  "

  " 

 

' "

9

 " 

 

#$%&'%()*     .. !