Union Of India And Others v. Tejinder Singh And Another

  
     






!"

#

"$%&%'()



 

       


*) +, *

-
 -- .

+, *-

-
 - 

-*  

  ! 

 " #$

 # %& '"

  (
  

! #)

 "$ )*# +"

!  #+#%$ )*# '"



,,,, -- .

/ 

-

" ""

#+ $"

  "

.

' #$#'"

 #

'"



 #

/0 /1 1/10 2 3 .14$  #  #

  "

 % #

5

 *   #% **

$+"

"

*%#5'

 -'"

#'

# % +##%%+

 $!0 1  $234'0(5

"

6

510 /- -770#'# '

"

#%"

 * '" $"

*

# % '

8249 : 2&.;;

742-.<=4$  24:

> !2&.?@ <42-.

<=424:

  2&.-/0/=4A

 -

+# *"#

'5 0- /@ 1/1/ "

5 ' *"#

$ " # % +  *) %# 

BC/=2&5 4'%'

"

# %    *%#5  '  "

 

  +# *

&5 ")

%   #

10 /7 1/1/$" "

 "#"

# # % +  "

# 

'5%#



 -'%

'# #% #

-@ -1 1/1/ 

  #

/?

/?

1/1-$"

&5 " *

# %  *%#5'

 - "

#' $

 -'%

 

' % #

5

*  #%**

$+"

"

*##*"#%%

"

#' *

"

  $

#%%+

)



 #

/0 /1 1/10 "

 #) #'"

# 

 3#*

"

#'

 

 

   

    

 

    

 

   

     

     

 

    



 

        !"    #!"  !!$!!

  



   

   

  

 

& 

'    ( )

*+,-!

. / 01  )   !!+

     

  





    

   





 



       

 

 (  2 ( -3/(4 

(

   



  ," 



 5 <



%



'5"

#' # 

##

   2#4$ % #

5

*  #%**

  .
' #"#'%

# #"

#+ 

' "&

(#"4"($"& '# !7%&
'04!

;

' *

5#D # ''

*) 6 *# + $ # '%##* '

5 +"

'#%%5 '# ).E.)#5

'"

'

  %$ "

%%

"

#5$

 #"

#% #

$"

%

$##5

'"

*5 ##

'

# %"5 $#"

"

#5 5# 

*

"

# $" %5 "

*#

"

*

#%

*#



# 5%# $"#*F

$'5$"

*%  '""

6



G  3&$*# %

# 
 



   $ 

   

 "

  )#  ## #"  '  "

 #  ) *  # 3#*

"

#'

$)&         6  



7 89:      

      

           



  

   ;

 

       !"      

   

       



  

    

  
<

  1

    ( 

  =    )   $,>  

) %;//81 

?#9 89)          

 

  

 

 

    /

 



   

     

  

       @1

 -1

+89A 893   

   8  

9





 

  ;

  

  )    

 

     

  

   

  

 81

$9

89/     

 

         



     

  

 





  

    

        @1

+89A 89/ 

       

   B          



   B  





      @+89A 89/     

  





  %   

       

 

 

       

C  D 

  

 @+89AE  89/    

C  D   



   ( 

;//

>2 C  8C  = 9  !!  F  ><

  7  2   =

>        ?, $ 

     #!         

   

   

 

   

   ?

*) # 24'"

3#*

*% $ " "

%

*%# $"#+"

# # %

 #%

 #5

'"

*5 ##

'

# %"5 $# +"*" 3  ' 1/ =  ) $ "

$ " " # *" #



)#%

'5"

5$  "



#

'' # %  @  $"

# 5 ' # % #

'"

*5 ##

'

# %"5 $+"

 #%

+"# # %#F#5'1/=5 5 #)   # 

*%##  '5  "

 !

*#%  9# $  #"

  *# * "#"

##

# %

# 

5%#

"

*%##

6

"


<

 1

 ( 

=  )  $,> ) %;//81 

?#9

 "

5 $" ""

# 5#

).E.)"

 "*#%# 5 #%"

#%"'#5

'"

'

# %"5 **

 *#%%+"

#"

#

'"

%%

  * "

+"#

! $" ""

"

#%#'"

 5$  "#  +"

  # 

#  "

$  "  **  F %$  "

  "

  #  "#   ' 

#24    '# $#"



5

# F %'"

    #  #  5

  '  "

'

# %"5 

5 #) %$"

')  +5 F#

' 2#4).E.)"

**

 

"

5% $#  *#  5#.

*"#

$"

*%#5#

 %

 * ) # %  ! $#%%"

'#* #  **5#*   # #    "

    '     "

**

$#

*% %*H

$"'

*%# +"

"

 '# ).E.)"

**

$# F %F#  ' 5%#    # ( "

 #5

 #

   

# 5%#

-/ "##5#$"



#% '"#'"

*% 24"# "

*#

#%' # % "

**

% #4"

5 '#** #* '"

**

5%# $5  

*

!

*#% 9#  ).#.)  " 

  +"  #   +"*"

"+ $

**%



 "5 '

%

4    '"

 

#  "

'$  5#  #%  F %

**%

!

*#%9# $   #  '5     '  5%#     

# 5%# $#"

"

#5

*

#%

-- "

$'"

5

*#%"% "#"

*%

"#)



*

5

*#% 3#5#'"

**

5#

$""

%

 $"

#5 +%%

"#) #    "

#2#4$"

!

*#%9# 

# #' **%

-1

! $#%

*%#

#$"#5# # '"

!

*#%9# '%%+"



% %# +&"# . '"

I

!

*#%2!%#

4$1//1JI%   #% *% I

-0 "

' $"#

+

5

+"

 5'

*% $+"

#"

5 ' %5 '"



"

5$"#' # %5#5

*#% 3#5#

5#

).#.)""

#%"$"#

*

 5

 "5  # (  +"

  5  

#

"#"

+## 5##

! $ #%

5

$'5"

'#*#"# $+"

"

 #*##% 3 . '"

$# ("

 '$" $""

%%5 '"



  #D  %#* $  ).#.)  "

 #*)       "5  '

5%# $+"

$"&5#**%

"#"

 '

 #"

+## F %'"

  "

5 # #*"+## 

"



5%#

-C #

$#%

#"

'5"

* $+"

"

!

*#%9# #%%*

5#D

#%

*) # *

#%*"

*D$#*%#%# # "

# '"

$" " 5%5 ' # '5

*#% *"F $  "  ) %  "

%*D  *"# 

*  * *$ +"

'5$#"

"

*

! $'"

5%5 '#% %#%$"

5#

**%

F#

"

'$" F "

# %5 #D

%#* $#"

+#*

#% +

  '

5%#





# 

 '5#* '5%#

&#%$'"

# 5%

*"F #"

#

'# %5 #D %#* $" !

*#%9# **

$% # #**%$"#"

# #"

5#*

'#  "

5#  "  %5 '#  %"

#5$#)# '*

%#%"

 F #*)

*( "

'$

 * ' '5%# +% ##%% # #+ %%**% !

*#%9# $"##*) 

 

 *

 '5  #  ''

*)  *##% 

*  * * +"

"

+%

#%' # %  -<

+ $+"

#)$"&



3#* * '"

$#

*

5

*#% #





# %   #  

#
 9 :2&.;;

  # %( **

  "

#%"  %'

 %

 $ "

#     #

  5%# # %   -;/0/( !9(!9( !

(!

(

  #

 1/ !#1/-7

 :

> !2&.?@ <4  
 :

  2&.-/    '

**

#9# #&# 2
4     #*

  "

  #     #

5%#    #  

##C0$&"# '



!

*#%''* 1//@ -;

 # '"

*  #%"##"

5 '"

# %5 #D %#* #"



5#

 5 '"

*% 2#4

*%#

G  3&*# %

#
 



   

 !

*#% 9# $"#5 +"*""+ $ ' 

$

%

"

5$ 5#D  %5#   '  $  "

*%##  '  %#+    6

  2#4  "#

"

# 5"#"

* '"

+## F %' ' $

'#)#

+

).#.)"

 " ""

5

# "

% # )



"

5

 *#    "

    + $  "

 #  *#  )

#

* *"# ).#.)"

$#"

'*

%

 5$ ##%%#% *## 

#%"

!

*#%9# $ #

 %'"

#)'

 #" $  " "  5%5   '  "

#  '   %*D  *"#

*  *##%  * *   *"F 24$  +"

    5# 

#)

"#"

 '"

"

#5  %$

*

'5# *

#%

*'#5%" ! $

+##%

#

"

5

*#%$"# '#+ %%'5

##"

+##*

#% #

 "

#



# 5%#

-?

+ $# # '2#4$ *% "#"#

   *

   #     

 '5  #     #  "#)

*

"

3 2#4  #

%$*  )



 52#4"#

%

  $"

$" &*#

) + "#

"

'"

5

*#%

# $# 3#*

2#4 &*%$"

*

*#

#

"

#%%'5

#$



"

"



'"

*#

# F %'# *

#%

* '#5%" &#%$

*%#

# '5 '5%#

#

$

*%#



# 

'5%#



  -@ ! $  " "      #

 "

  "#  "

**

+"% 

 '5

'

  #"

# #* # #$ *  3 5# # "

)#

%#$+"*"5#D "

 '"

#  #* # #$

#'"

 F %"##*"$G 

  #  '5  "

    '  5%#       

#

'"

5%#

* F

%#*D'"

3 5# # "

%#$  *#" &**%

$"# '"

 '"

 

"**

# #* # #$"

   #   

*%#

  

 #

   

#  '5%#

 -7 "

$*  5'"

6



 3&$*# %

#   

 !"B 

  # $ % & '

+"

$#

*%##5#

"

3 $"#"

'' ''$#"

"#

+

"

**

%#%#%"



#

'

#  "

 ) 

   "

    

  '  "  

D  F#  "

#  ''

5#

"'#) 1/ )   "

+  *  "

*%##  '  %#+  5#

  *2#45#D "

*%##

# 3%#'%#+  5$"

$"

3%#'%#+ 5$#5#

) * 2#4#%5#D "



*'



').#.)"

'

   %  **

$  $    $  #%  %  "

**

$"##5 

D"

# '"

+5 # 5#



$# "#$"

'%% *5% $# % 

$



  *) '"

#$'#$'

%## %#*"

1- "

' $  "

#  '  "

'  '  "

 #  ''$ 5'"

) *2#4

 #% **

$#%  ''

'5#%%

#%# 

"

%( 1 45"4 '# !7%&
'04!



#' 5#"$"&' 5 "

+  # +" )## #5  5

"

5



$##

% #

 #% **

$5##

# #''5

1C



'#% +"#%% #%*#24$'#

-- .   - 

-*

 5#"5# 7"!7"4 &:" 2%(3;4" &'("5 "&;'

7"!7"4 4":'4! <1"

"&;'