Vinay Kumar v. Union Of India & ORS
!"
$!%&'()(&"*+"
,$-.(/$
,&(&
!0$1()11%$+
+3141&
&50&
!"#$%&!"'(#&%% )"#*+!
!"#$%&!&% )"#*+!
,,,,
&'
6 , .
21$/$+0%$+ !15
77777 &% )" ,$- .(/$ 5 1$& 5!0 5& 3 5 &8)&)9$&0!100$0
#:;( 9<=+31 %1$)3$&100$0
:;(9 =+?()1/ 05& 5$ %% ! @ * +
A9 5 /1 $/() >+""+ >#A95$)1/%%//0$ 9 -5, !$)1&$/3 !
*
6 , .
21$/$+ $0 %(& 5&) 1 5 &(B/01$13!!15+38)$&2(501
(C$B )) )+ 1$0)$1+ 3$& $0 / %%//0$+ + <+ $/5(&+2% "+1$0)$1 1 53$&$&!02 92 $0&$0&0)311&3! $/5(& ,0$55%$0$0 "<
<:;(9"=+1
&(B/0$?(&!$&!1(& 3$%:!&1 D E= 3$&)$01 3 !
1/$/+$ %/5$3$&/$0$)$&15!($(1&0310$3$! 1 31!+$&13%$(&%0$0"
" :;( 9<=3$&&0(515$&31-1%-! 0$3 ($(1&0-!/2 3 !
<B%0!/1/ 0$05-:;(9*=3$&&(B/0 1$(1&+00 0$0"> :;(9 =+&5501 !15 &5 15$)(&+ +$2%&:$&&!%$+$0 55$= (&+
> +153$&%1$)9&10!($(1&0- 0$3)1 1(! + >+>##A9 1&5&&(B/03$& !(0B&$&!$%-+B($$&50$0 *
" #+1 1$0$)005&1 &($-+1%1$)&+000$0
+30550 ()1)(/+&/0&5($)0- B311(&B$0$03!1$0(50 15&(B/0$ $55%$ 0$0
:;( 9 = ! $/ ! 2 $%%//0$ %&0$!1&$55%$+$%%//0$9 + -5 , 3$& $0 0 0$0 "<
:;( 9
=
&&&&!1&$/3$&$8">
:;(9 "=
<
* :;( 9 <=+ 1 5 $%$0 1 $!/0$%%//0$+B( 3$& &(5&0 %1&13 %$(&%0$0"*
*:;(9 *=$%%(!$!
#!2 :/!%%//0$= (&+
1&$0( &$)&1$$/5-&0$%%//0$3113! &$$0-%%(5$!&0$$%%//0$ %%0)-+1 5 3$& %$0 (5 5$- 5$ ! ! * +
A9 5 /1
- $/() >+""+ >#A9 15&(B/05&$0$0
* :;( 9 =+ 31%1 3$& C%0 ,0 0 0$0
:;( 9 =+ 1 5 3$& 0%0 05& 1 $!/0$/( 15$&&$01&$001)(0 1$1&5&1$$/(&1$11(&B$0 $03!%$B$301$&5$$$%%//0$ %%0) 1 5+ 1 - 5& %5$0 & 1$ ! 3 &5$$ $%%//0$&1$B$0+11$($-+1$&B &(00+31%1+$&%0$B+1$0B0
3$&;%001$&$/$!%01$ % 5%0)& (0 1 (C$B (B% /&& :% !
$(1&0 %%(5$&=%+
+3$0 11$& %//0)$-$05&-$%%5)1&$0!12$B- -)(51$!/0(& 1&!0)31)$0 1&$0(& 1!%1$&$&B/$00$0"# " >:$ 5$)
!15$5B8=+%01$15$$!@ * +
A9%(0B%1$)0+31$&5$3$&" A952? 5 /1 13$&/&5&$$-%%$/15$! 151$11$0B&0)311&3!+311$0B$0 (& <+ $/5(&+2% "+1$0)$1 1B($$& )01%(%$!$%1$10-%$0%$01$00&&!1 $%%//0$$01&3!$01&50&83!/1- B))1$11$0B)311&3!$&1$%%//0$1$0 B $0 1 3! 1 05$/ 1$0 3110 1 $0 %01$)0$/(1)(01$13$&)311& 3! 1(&+ 3$& 5$00 1$ 1 3$& %%$& ! 1
. $(1&A05$/%$/15$!150$!/0 $0+1!+1/5()00&$BB&9$&0
1$1$01$0%(&!15$&+$55$&01 5$5B8$0$!131$1&/$0!%1 &(B/&&&!6 21$/$
0/0-+15&)0B-D2 :
&0% /= (&+
##E:&1D1 (&E= #!1$!&$0
(&50&1$311(&B$0$03!B1$(%G&&%$ 1&$/&$+1$/!1(&&1$B/$0!1/ 1$& !(1B&5($01$B1&1$B)B$55-!$/ &5$$-$%%0)1/$0 )B-!$%1&1$B 0/0&5$$-!$/5(5&& 1&(&1$1$$- $55%$B-311(&B$0$03!$&0)&5$$-5(&($% !(0!C(0%$&5$$ $0&1(&'9 D
!
!1 (&&$&$!15(5&& !
$0C(0%$!15&%&-+31%1&!3)/&'9 "#
$
%
!
%%0)1$!&$0(+!!1&5(&&1$&B $0&%%(5$!$%%//0$!/$531%11 $!&$0(&$$55%$B+11&1$1$&(011 %(%&0%15&0%31/1!1%%(% !&(%1$0%$&!!$(0&+1$/!(% &0%&1$B0/01$B%$%0
151$0 $0 1)/ $%%//0$ 31!!%!/
*$!1$!&$0(&$& $$$%%//0$1$0$$0-B$01&3!$01 %$&3$&%0(01 & !1 (& 3$&$& %$/0B-151$13$& &/?($311&3!$0 1!+1&%$&3$&%0(0 & #!1 (&
3+1&$0$//$0(&(B&$$0$&153$& ($B0/&$1$13$&$-&(%10&5(B313 &(%1%%(/&$%&+/&! ( F!1 (&+5$3$&5$-$B B-15 ( F&;$%0$&(0'9 !
&!
!/!!
1$&!5$%%!&1$B$&!3&'
0 -5!&0% 2$ 2$ %$)-'
1+ $%($7+ 6(/B$+ 1$+ -0$B$0+ $)$+ H(%834 ( & " A95 /
&
A95 /
& " A95 /
& " A95 /
& < A95 /
& " A95 /
, & * A95 /
& < A95 /
, & A95 /
& * A95 /
, & > A95 /
& A95 /
, & # A95 /
& > A95 /
&' (
)
*++,- .
/
0
12,
23*45.%$ ! 1(&+ %$ B &$0 1$ 1 0/$0 $&0 B- 1 &50&!5$!/15105$&&0B-1 B($ C%) 1 %1$) /$0 1 %(0 B !$(0
%%0)-+!0)/135+1&$/&0&/&&0
:"'(#&%% 1 2&% 1 "#*+!
"#*+!
3435.) 67 8 8 59 6: 4;
'
5;
8 8 6=
'
5;