← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1834/2008dismissed

State Of Haryana And ORS. v. Ram Pal

2023-12-04Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

  

 !

"#$%#&##  # #'# (

)*+,-./,0121-3 4 4  +*+,-.*56*3**3/*3-+7,5 4444),.,3/*3+88,99*3+2 :,52;2 *<8*9 444,28-3/,3+ 

#=> ?$@=A"

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

-5 *3 *001/,3+ 0*;2,/ J6 712 5*27 *3/ 3,E91E,3+ /51L13E4 O7,5,*.+,5F 89*13+1..5,28-3/,3+ 7*/ 07*99,3E,/ +7, 2*<, J6 K*6 -. +7, 85,2,3+ 2;1+ .-5 <*3/*+-56 13M;30+1-3F K7107 K*2 0-3+,2+,/ J6 +7, /,.,3/*3+*88,99*3+FR STUVWRR XYSXR F -3 +7, E5-;3/ +7*+ +7,5, K*2 *3 *9+,53*+, 5,<,/6 *L*19*J9,F K7107 7*/ 3-+ J,,3 *L*19,/-.

 

  ! "#$ %  $&

#$$"& # #

 ' #   ( " ")" #

% #!  * #  #+,

* ' ,  "

# #'

'# %#'

#  #+,

$$!

! # 

$ & "! 

" (

"  - '  )#' ' "" %



$  & !  &"!) ), ".  #+,

  /0 1. " ( " ! /0 1

#' (  &#"*#

  /0 12

 322 (  )  '

,"" #   

"

 $# #'" (

$$* ), 

( &&

   ( "*""#' 

&&

$  ),    ), 4#' # #"     15 " 4 6* 

*  # 

"

$ (#""" 

$

!*#" ( " "&&  

#$$"& # #

#  ( " "##'

$$!$ *1& *#  1""

"$ (  '

#' !" #".

#   #" " ")*    " )

( % ""  *&'# 7 '*#"

# ! (!



, # ,  % #! & !

!

 

 22. 

#$$"& # # ( " # ' ,

$ #'

'#! # %#'  %!

$ , 

( ,"

!&

$

&  # " '

 .  ( "

! #  ""&#"

22 #!.

") & , ( " $  ), *.  ( " ' , & ! 

#" #   8

$  , % %!"

#"*#

# &&

" ".28 # ( "# & ! $

(#!

# ! $#+, 3   # &" !

  8 /% # ,. 

(#""  15 " 4 6*  ( " &"#

 "&

 *

$ 

!! #. (! , #   % #!

#" 

#$$ #'  #+,.

" ( ##' 9#

 

% ! )#' # # ! ( " " *#.  "

)    #+,

$$!

#

  

! "#

## 

$%

!

& '!

!

! ' (

! $"' $"

& &'

) *+,-+)) -.)) /+0,1)) 234)) 516)) 71891+)) :91;61) %

 <  =< % '! > $

! #  ?&

!"

% @A!%

! B

 "

 '! ! CB D

((  '!

&

 "

&& $D

"

B D !" " & "   

" B

 ( (" '!

! !"



& && 

! ("  "& & ( "

$" "E C

!  " ' !"?

&

!"

! !  !"& ##&

!



B D & "& "(  

! &

! !  "#



! $ 

!"

CB D

((  #$( $&

! F"#



!

( (

! 





D 

B

E A! !  ( ! !$&

!"

! CB D

((  " & #$( "   "& G& 

! "

&  $ "D B DE A! ? $  (

! !  !" "$"&D



& (# "" "! H "& (

! I& # (

! ! 

?

 

  ?

$ "$ JE =  (

 E K !

!"

% @A! !  !"?

#



! $ 

!"

CB D

((  !" " & "   "$%

! ""

D (

&& "&I& "

 '" $ '!

! "&?$D "((



&& $ ( "&I& "

E C

! # "%

!  $ (

" !"$$ #

 $"D "&

! !  '" 



" &

! # "$ &

D

?

 D



! "$$"

 &

!

B D "(!E L #"M

$"

!"

 ?"

"#"&"

?" !(" ( ! "EN E  



 O! ( > $

! #  !" $"

"

$D  && "& $ &"

&

!  $ ( "$ I



) P4Q4)) Q;1,R18)) 1+0) -S9T;3)) 234)) *+,-+)) -.)) /+0,1)) 1+0)) -S9T;3U) C H< #  

D ?

!"

! (

! $ ( "$ I



  I

 

 

 "

?$D

 ? " "  ( I

E A!  ( "$ I

 !" &  " "

&"$ ( !" 

 D"E '" !$&

!"

% @A! (

!

  

   !

 !  ! 

 "

#

$%

 "$

& !

 #   !' () 

"

%



!$* +%

% ,  *% *' - ) ,*

)% *

""

) , 

)

* + ""&

' () ! !"



   !  *#

#

*   !)

#

!

% ' -

)

,

)#)

!** 

, 

&%



 )  +

*#

)  , 

.& *+  */ ""  

*



 *!   )  + # $

 % , )

* ) &

 

+ ) 

*

 &  &' 0% 

)  

) *  , $  #*

*

1  * !

 1   & + )*

#* 

)2 , ) +

*

+   %  

+%34 5' ()

 )  1  *!&



) *

  ,

2 + *

)

""

 *

 "*! !* + $ * !

*

 "$

) !) #2

)  +,

+ *

 $  

%     ,

 

)  * #

 $ 

) "

" *

' ()  &  

 !

! *

"" 2 $ + * *,

789:;<=66 >8?=66 @AB66 C=<D;@<66 C8E66 F<9G;6 2

5 H  H +%  I+

) "&  ,)

, +$*

* )*

2 J "  

)

 * *#&

,* ),

)  * !

! *

"" 



 , )

)  * #  

) # *

 * #

  2 ),$2 # 

/! +

)  % &

 +' ()  * #   , 



!*

)  * #

) +    *!&

% $ * !' ()  * !





) ! *

""  % ,)

)



,  "!*

*

&%

 1  '4 ' $ 

*

)

2

 *

 

& !

%  

) $ * !

**!*2

)  +, $  !)*

)  "!

$

 

  ! "#$!%& ! ! (!)  *!# $ ++!%  ! ! % !# ! , $ -#,  !)#, $%  ! -.)!% "%)-!# % %! !!

# !. !!#..!$% ! !(,%-!%& / 01213/451675189:/ / ;67<=/ / >?@AB@B>BC/ )+DE !# ! .!E)D !!%  G!DH !# ! !. #(!  G!DH