Union Of India v. No 4162344, Ex Naik Bachittar Ram
!"# $%&%!'(
)( *+) ,,
, -
*+) , ,, , )
!"
#$%! !&
! ' '& (# !"
#& ")! &*# !*!'& ")! &! # #!%!& ")! & (#
++++ ,
, -
. ,
# # # ! * & # # - ( !&! (# !
(#
!
./ .0 1.11 2 3 -,4& ! !
# '
!
%
) !'
))
&*#
# )'!%(
,(# !(
!
' *!!''*
$ / 0 $123!/'#
,5
% 1.
,, ,60.!(! (# !'#! *! )#!
(% *# (( )(%7.
.6 ,680
# !( &
,*! - ''
10 .7 ,66.(
! (,/ !! / ! ! *! )#!
(% 7, .7 1../ ) (# &# )
!
' (9!
''24:
# % ( )#!
&# !
' *!!
'
#!;1.<2=,.<4('(
# !
' )'!%(#
*! )
% # &## #!# ! !
' *! # !
(%'!
>
'
)(# )'!%(#
!
' ( # !
' # !# & # !')!('
1.6,(1.,6
( '
!
%
) !' *#)# *!
( # !' "
!
1/ .1 1.1. *# # ) #'
*#)# *! # ,.
.6 1.1.&!%%! !'#! %! !
!
' (
, ! 1.< ( '( ! # # ! !
%'!
# !
' *! )
## #!# !
' *!9 #
'!
:
# !(
,('
( !'))
*#
# )!!
)#!''
!( ! )
# &
)!% !''*
"
!
./ .01.11 # !"
!(#
3!)
# !(
!
!
" #$%&
( ) ' *
*
+*
, - $ . / 01
2
3 4 # /. ! !
!" #
$%&
'
/
'
(%# !( !
!!
2!4& '
!
%
) !'))
&# -( !#!('
!
!# !*
( # '" 3 '$ &!" 4%&!/3 =
( )
%!?
! (( )"
5 )! * &! ('!!) (
% *# #
(!''% ( ! "-@-" ! %
( #
( '& #
''
# !% &
!# !'
!
& #
)% '
& ! ! %
( # )% !!
( !
'#% &!# # !% %!
)
& # ! &# '% #
)!
# )
!'
)!
)%
! %'! &#!)A
&(%&# )'
(## 5
B 3&)! '
!5 . $* 4! 2
3&
"
( $ 6
# "!!!
!#(# "
)! 3!)
# !(
( )
* *
*
+
, -.
/
* *
*
*
*
0
(1&
*
2
3
*
*
4
)
6%(7
) 80""
-
69:. -.
)
*
"
*
3
*
* ;
<
6=-.> -.
!
-
.
0
)
*
-
. -*.
*
*
*
*
* ;
6=-.> -*.
* ?
*
* ?
*
* ;6=-.> -*.
*
8
*
*
*
@ A
3
;6=-.>B
-*.
"
@ A
0""
7C
@ -@ .
(11( 74 ,
7
* :1
3
*
*
)"
!
24(# "
3!)
)'
& # #
'
)'! &#!*# ! !
'
)% !'
! %
(# )% !!
( !
'#% &! *#)##
3 (1.<"
&# &# #! )# !
%
A
"!'
(%# % & # A
!
(( !
' &# ! % ( !
' !
(# )% !!
( !
'#% &*#
)% !'
*#! !
' !A!%(1.<% & % !"
' A !
)'!!(%#
)!'! &!# )! ' ) #! !!
!
'
!
)%
%'!
# !
)'!!
)% 5
# 4
)
6%(7
) 80""
-
69:. # % &# ## ! %!
"- @-" # # )!' ! % !' # !'# ( ! %
( #
( !
'#% ))
& )!'' *# !# !
(#
)% ''
&# ) #
)%
*#!
"
&# ## # !'!(# %& #! *# !
! # & # ))
A ' & #
# ! #! (
!24 (! &!#
%
! A '(#
! ! %
( #
( !
'#%
% !"
' &# (" *% A!
( 2!4"-@-"# ))
&
# %' &! )! & # ! %! - )#!
& # & # )'!%!
)% '
) "
!
' "
&!''# (!) ! ))%!) ! !# ( ))
& !
)' ' )C
&#(
)'! *# # (!
"-@-"# ))
&! A 'A! (%'! ! D# !%
! %'!
,.
#!!%! &#
)% !' (#!(# )'
24#! # )!
!'( !
' # ))
& ' !4# % (!)) !) (# ))
%'! &%
)% )
)!'
! "-!-" #
*# ! *#)# #* &
)% ))'
#% (
)% '
4 (#
!# (&%! !' A '
)% ))'
)!'! &! (% ( %'!
! %'! &!# # !%
!)
!'
,, # &(# %
)!'#'
#!# )'
#!"
)
%
)!' 3!%!(# ))
%!
&##
)% '
&# &# !% *''
#!"
! & # !2!4&#
)!'! A
! !( ))'
,1
"
&!'
)'!
!&#!%! ! (#
)!'! (''*#
' '! *#! - (# EF
)!'2'!
4&1..1GEH'
!' )'
E
,7 # ( &#!
*
%
*# %( "
)'
&*# !# % ( '% (#
# % &#!( ! '%! %
)!' 3!%!
%!
"-!-"## !'#&#!
)!% )
%
#%! D*# %
)!% !
#!# *! ! %!!
"
& !' A
%
&(%# (!)!#! &*# # !
)!!' 3 - (# &! D# (&# & ## ''% ( #
!? '!) & "-!-" # !)"
#% ( %'! &*#
&#%! ))'
#!# (#
!# *!! A '(#
# % !
!)#*!!
)!%
#
%'!
,> !
&!' A
!#
(%# ) &*# #
)!'! & !'' )
%!?
!'
)"
! )
!')# )?&!)'!' ! ! # !
(# &# # %' % ( ! (%
)!'
)#A & # "
' # ')? )#!
) ) )& *# (%&!# #
)!% )
"
&(#
%' % (!' '!' &#
%!
)% ))'
A!
# (&# A # ! '% !?
'!) &!# *!)
!' *
( %'!
!
)%
(%!) (%'!
!' &(# ! %'
)#A !# !
(! '% !? '!) &#
)!'! ))
&'
!
!))'&#!# ! !#
%!)
(! & # %! # '% (! '# !% &!" ! ()
'!' # A !)"
)D # (&
) ( (%'! & *'
!!''
!
!* ''))'
)!'! &#!!)"
)!% )
(% ! (( )"
)!!'
) ) ) *#
# *'
!'( !
' ,/
* &*#
!"&# A
3!) ) (# &!
)!% )
%
)!' !
#
! &# "!) !)) !!0# ' ('
!% # 2!4
3!)
# !(
92
!) F (16 (16
)G2
)G2
0) @ A
*
(< (1(1 -) 8
)0H
. !
)G2
0
( I
(1(1 JF"//@
*
*
(1&
2
)G2 #
K =9= 4
5"F ==9=
!
<H L"/4 /
F F4 =6H(:== #0(
(% F* ((
6 )
(1(('
,=
!
(# ) !'#!!# % (# ! '% !? '!) !#
)!% %!
%( )'
2!4
)'!
B 3)! '
!5 . $* 4! 2
3 " (
)!'! & #!% *#)##* & (
&
)% '
# % & %!?
'%! ( &#
)'!!('!*5
2!4#!#
# !
%#!# ) (# *!! A '( ( & A
(!"!
' *
"-!-"#
# ## %
!
# !
"
# %
)!% )! # * &# )! "
) )#! "-!-" #
& !# ( )
'
# !
%& !!'' !' )!! !'#
)!'! & !
'(#
!"( !# &# #
%' % (# ! ( ')?)#!
))!!') ) )#A 24&*#
%!
)!% !"
#!# ( # !% '&
)!% )
(%! )
!'
)(!%' # "
&#
*!!' A
!
# %
)!'&#!# (!* ''(%
!!# *!!)
!' !
)!% # !
)!% ! %'!
,0
* &! !
(2!4& )' #!#!
)
!
(%! !#!"
)
# 3 2!4 !
' & ) "
# %2!4#!
'
&#
&# )!
"
* #!
# (# %
)!' ! & ! 3!)
2!4 )' & #
)
)!
!
# !''(%
!&
#
#
(# )!
! A '(! )
!'
) (!%' # !' & A
)'!
! (% (%'!
!
& A
)'!
!
)%
(%'!
,8 "
&# #!
#!# 24 ))
*#'
)!% (%
( !# ! !) ! !& ) 3 %! ! # "!
'!&*#)#%!?
# (# 24!
!) ! !&
!(# A '#!!)#&B
! (%# (%'!
)!%
(# %'!
) A &# '!)?(#
3 %! ! #
'!& )! # ))'
&#! (# (# 24#
#))
! !) ! !&#
&#
!
)'!
)% !
! (%'!
,6 # &) %(# 5
3&)! '
!72
3 4! # /. ?
$ 8 69*# &!
)'!!%!
# 3 & #!#
(( ((&!# #!
)% *
# ))
'!' !'#
!
( ! #
)!%
#
( #
? A! # ! ((
%!
#(!" 1.
H"
# * )
)'!!('!*%!
"
) 2!4%!?
#
)'!!
! 3'!('!* %&
&# 3'!('!* %&!%!
"
)2!4!' %!?
#
)(
("-!-"#
( ))
&&
&!' '
))
&#!! %
?# ! (# *% !%!
&! #!& # (''
)%'
&! '#
&
)"
( !&(! &(
'! ! '!)# 1, # ( & # ! ( #
( ( # ! ((& %(# "
)2!4
!'
))
&!' (( (%! ''
!' ! A
#
%'
0 3# 3!" 4%&!/3
!( %!#&#( % # * ! *# "!!
"
&# !% %
# %
&!!
'
!
!'
))
&%!!
! !((%
1>
(!' *#!'' !')!24&(!
5,
, -
5, , )6
%!#%!
4 4 3&7 1%'283 &!' # ( &8!
4 4 33 7!3 ( &8!