← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24362/2014allowed

Sarbjit Singh Dhami v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. And ORS.

2024-01-04Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda13 pages

   

 



  

    ! "# $ %& ' ('  "%&%)&* $ %&+ '

' 

,-"./01 ,0&23

3-40  1010%& "

5,'

)&/-.

,1-1 %6 "

%"7%"-10%& 81$'-&$ %13 "!

 !7%&$ &1!



( 

-"0&$ "

,0&23  1010%& "

5,'

)&/-.

,1-1 %6 "

%"7%"-10%& 81$'-&$ %13 "!

 !7%&$ &1!

 +  9 8 '

,

:

   

   

            !"#

$$$

:

 ;

'

% &  '(                 

   

       ")!*+,-*!*.%+ / '

   

*

   **-1**2  "

 3     



4( ( *5 .5 *.%+/!-  %.6  ! '(7          ")!*+,-*!*.%+     (      *5 .5 *.%+ /!2 *.6  !8(     ")!*9:.-!*.%+   ((  



  (     ( (  

          (      ;  %*  6       <    (   (  /!- ,

& (

( 

*:

.% %522 ! '(7 '

'  =  0     #       

       =(  .* %% %5:% 

 7 >



 *..:

&  7 >!( =( ,% ., *..5 (( 

 !8('

' = # 

%5 .5 %529 

  =( %552 &    =( ,% ., *.%. (( 

+

        (!%+ .* *.%,/!%?( : ' = 0 =

 ?( %52%

 ( ( !

   



@++-   '    

 ! 

> (       !

        #&   AB7 &  (!*, .2 *.%,/!*/ (  !

    

       (AB7    7    (       (( ?

*...1!    &  ((   7 "=(C A4   =4 >  4  ( A

    (('     4

 &     (  

.+ %.

*.%, *.

%* *.%, (       ((   =4

> '

( 4

B%* .* *.%+/!,  

     &!,  



      *9 .* *.%+  

   4

    ( 4   3  4  /!,(   (        =4

>   (   ( 

4

&   *% ., *.%+ /!+ 4   &  





8 %+1*..9/!9 

 (  !

     1    4    ? *...1!( 4    A   

8 -2!*..-/!9 

  (     !

      

  #&            #& 

  ( 4  *5 .5 *.%+ /!-  8 *  ( (    %.6                =     (      *5 .5 *.%+ /!-   ! (  ( (

'(/ ( 

#    (! %+ .* *.%,/!% .+    !  (  ' =  ( (          ?* *D E  DE"B

*3 (

F 7 0 "

<

      





*01 $ -1  =;

5%> 8;



        (      *5 *.%+  /  !-   

 8 * (%.6   .9    (  #

-

&         '(  A F  "

 3



"

 !



 "#

  $!

%&& "'

()  * !'

+  ,  

, - .$

/  !

 0- "++- ,

1

2* 34

4-  

 5 

  *   ( )  &* !

   6  





 !

 67 28 7* 3'# 9#



 

 :-; ;5 .

 

   67 172  ! #   





 !

 67 %217 %%2

#    %% %* *.%9  4    *5 %.

*.%,



4 ?( %,% '  =  0   =

         ?(   %52% (=( '(7  ")!*+,-*!

*.%+  =(8( ")!*9:.-!*.%+

"

4               (       .2 %% *.%,%% %% *.%,%:

%% *.%,   

      *5 %% *.%,/?!* 

   :

#     (4  4         (       

         4

    (      ?      4

>   (4  

(     (   "

  

 

#   (



 ( ((   (  %.6   .9      ' = 0  =(=?( %5-9

  ?( ** (

 (   ? * *  ' "?(  

   .+  4     &           ,% ., *..5    ,% ., *.%.           (    %:

.* *..5     4  (  %+ .* *.%, &   .+ 

&     (

 ( 

 



#    ( **-1**2 "

 3     4     

 ("

            ( !(   &     '(  A F   "

 3"

!< 

 

    =$ !

 8 ()  & * !.

 0  < 

 

 !

%%8(&)  1%  !

 '   .$

    !

 67 %71 %.

A(  (       

=

%%

&4        (.+  

( (    

 (%.6   .9 '   (    

    !"

    

  ,% ., *..5               (    %+ .* *.%, /  !%    ?(   :    '    =  0  =

 ?( %52% (  ( !

     8 @!++-   '    

 !     #&   AB7 &       

           (        (        ? *...1!             ((            %.6  .9



%*

   !           1' (((  3 

.+     ( %+ .* *.%, 3  (  (

    



(



   

 ' 

       (

               (      

 

 (           

(

3  

 ,% ., *..5    (     ! (   ( 

    

  .+    8  4   (  

  ( 3    

   ( ( (   8       (   "

  (  

   '    

    ((

 3      

           ( (

 %,

&A F  "

 (0- "++- ,

 

%%%G.  > .



 ;

/  ?

   ( (    (  

           

                  ( 

  ?(

?

!

   

            

     

    

  

 

 



      

   



                    

 

         

 

           

             

 

     !

"

#$

   

   

  

    

  

 



      

      

 



   

  

 

 

  

    

     

%+

&A F  "

 3   

'   

 () @ &%   (

                

     

    '                    (      (

  (('  

  

?( '( !

 G%    

     & '



 &

() 

  

     

 

 

*

 

    

  

 

  

 

+        

*     

  ,

         

     -   

       

   

      

 

      



  .          

                

  

  

           

     



/

      

       

         

     



                   

*    

,

    

  

   

  &

()      %9

&"

   4  



   

 (

(! 

     (")8 *259 *.%- %* .5 *.*,  !9#

  @ 

  4

+

  A * - 

 !!

01  ,  

  

       

  

 

   

 +      



 



 

  



   

     23 !2 2!01

    

 

  



4     

    !

0!

2!01 

 

   

 

20 !3 2!0$ 

    !

0!

2!01     .



 



   

0$   

  

   

 



     

         5           

  

 

 

 

     

  



      



+   



   

 

6 

 

   

  



4   



  

   





   

  







      

      

 

    



   

     



    

4          

  

 

   

+  

   



    

 

20 !3 2!0$ %-

3  '(  (  1 

   &    4(  ( *5 .5 *.%+  %.6     .9           (    (  

 #          !"

               4 (  (4   4  3  (  



 

 '(            & 4          ( .+ 

 (  (           (  ( /!-             (        &   ?* *  ' "?B

!33



%?   3     ((  (    %2

    ?  * *         '  "    ?      !

0 "

")!%,%,+!

*.%9H$

  

 0- ++-

+

  A

"

!  .+ ., *.%- &    !

 02

 

 

   

 0 0!

2!02 -.70

  8  +  

9     9      

   



  

 

 

.   '2 2:;,'

,  

    

    4 

       

  -   

    

  

  

  

   

     

        

 

            

  

      

  ,  

    7



    

   

     

 

-  

  4  

 



4   

  21 !

2!0$  -.  72         

  '2 2,'

%:

   



4    

 

A I  "

  "

 (

  ( ? '  

 



   (                

 (         

       

 ((

   



%5

@(               (     *5 .5 *.%+ /!- ")!*+,-*!*.%+     %.6       .9  (  *5 .5 *.%+/!2")!*9:.-!*.%+   *.6        4

&    

      .:  

    

*.

& 

  

*%

  (                  *% DJ  E

:

  -&)-"@ ;

   

6

49 

%

  9 < =96 %

 

< =96