← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2519/2009disposed of

Mahipal And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2026-05-05Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

! " #$%$&  ! " #$%$&  ! " #$%$&  ! " #$%$&







 '( ) '( ) '( ) '( )      # ( " # ( " # ( " # ( "

        ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

            (- (- (- (-





          B   %*(  %*(  %*(  %*(    , , , , +!  +!  +!  +!  (+ (+ (+ (+     0011  0011  0011  0011  ) ) ) )(+ (+ (+ (+  0  0  0  0  #- #- #- #-     %- 

 .'*!&$+ #! /!+ .'*!&$+ #! /!+ .'*!&$+ #! /!+ .'*!&$+ #! /!+ $& $& $& $& % >'

=4 >  3 & 4("4 5 CCCC $&4& 1 $&4& 1 $&4& 1 $&4& 1 /!+  /!+  /!+  /!+  6 7  ,

88 4 



: G A9 A9 

9: 9:;  ; 3?    8 > = 88 8

<=2

>1>?  1



<= 1  @ 

3>54

  3? @ 8   

6 7  '5 5   0 14  11?   3 1    

 9;  : 0  

1 ( &= ?4 "=?

   #=E #=E #=E #=E 8 

3 D D D D 697  ' 15  ?4   0 

4   1    35

4 =     >=    ? &

4 #111 @4 1 % 4 (  "==? 8  <=  > >   

:   9  = = +AB * <= 4 A D

AE

AE

AE

AE0>15 0=3 31 0=04  815 54 F   =   "=  +=3 E +0  

A0 = +

35* <=#11     D *#E      0    

8 ?

?4 358 @ > 1= <= 1  H 4 42K0



# 1

1? 11 =53   0> =  A 6A7  (     35 *#4

>@  =  + ; A4   8  3 0  15 11

 #= >  

9; :4 1? ?8  80 0 H 442K0



?

 <=  1 8?0  >=  >11 ?&

4 #11  @43  ? 11  =53 2  

>= =   A  ??>  4  0 1   0    1  #!  #!  #!  #!  +- +- +- +- (J!+ (J!+ (J!+ (J!+ '! * '! * '! * '! *  !  !  !  !%%!**+2*( %%!**+2*( %%!**+2*( %%!**+2*( 7

0=??

 

1 =1

=38 1  #=

1  @ 

=   1 

 !I% %K  >    1  1

=  >= >11 ? ?

 1 : 2K  0 

42K0  7 *

=1 10=

8?

03

 1

11

 

= = +A

A4 0  :  4 = 31 > 00

 > 8

8   1 

<= 3 001 

!I%K  <

?1548 @> 1==? 3 K 

>=      ?=8  3   3

21   '! * '! * '! * '! *  !

 !

 !

 !!+%(! !+%(! !+%(! !+%(!+- +- +- +-K 6B7 %  41 + =1= =38  0 35 1   #= 3  =000   01

?

>  > 1 31     = =38     1  # =

1

5

 8 @ > 1=  I>       442K 0   

>= 4 1  = 8

=0 5

8 1 1  ?=8 3   3  0 2+  ( +#$++  ( +#$++  ( +#$++  ( +#$++  (!+ "- (!+ "- (!+ "- (!+ "-K 6:7 

  >   1  =1  0   ? =? 11     03@  6;7 



  =8  

 0  4   1



 !I%K  >    1  1    1  :  2K 3 0 

42K0   31 =0 0=0 

8 

8 @> 1=  80

>= >11

? ?

4   <=   0    1   

  >=  >11 ?& 4#111 @41% 4(  8   =4     1  

 !I%K     3    0=0   K 8  8 @ > 1=     3



 >  

= 7   35     =3   01  8 8 @> 1= 

 ==8 40 

3101  5?

?

1 31>

  ? 5   8 @> 1=4 #==1

3L=  ? 80 8153   L=4=8 8450 1 =80  7    ?154  80=?

 0   #= 3? 3    00    8  1 > 1 31     1 = 8 8 @> 1=HRs.

K ?

442K0  > =   

? & 4 #111

@4 1 % 4 (  8 11

  7  8?=  3

  



8 0 ? 

AK"4A K" A K"

  0

? <=

4  35*

<=

 > 1= == =2=311 

35  !

!I=>!?4"==? 8  0 

7  *

+ =1 3  31 00#=   5=0 0018 5 0 ==2=311  > 35* # 5=3<= ? 0 <= 7 

 = =8 4    5 = =0018 5 3 0  3 35  *#4  05    8 3 =001  

 1?<=

8= 80 = =0

   =0   0  9

5 8 

   0  

   4=0018  05 8 5  30 830



 ?00=5  ?1   8 8

0  05 5   97  * 05  3 



  *

<=#11 1   5 801  A7  # <=154  >     =8

  3>4 11

10

 

  0

7  J >  1   2 > = = 15 I0  

12K 3L

 1?

1?

1 >3  801

4 5 5  11 3  135  @ I =    0  35 8>? 000  001 3 1

!I=?#= B7  11 0 ? 001 4 54  11 1 0 /!+ $& /!+ $& /!+ $& /!+ $& &$("!

&$("!

&$("!

&$("! 5





 4     B B @         2 2 J J 0 @?2   ) 0 31 )