M/S Round Dee Clock Securities v. Union Of India And ANR










 

 


 




 !"

!

#


         

 





   !  $

 %&
$
 '
( 
'
 )




*****
"# Mr. Tejas Bansal, Advocate for Mr. Sanjiv Kumar Aggarwal, Advocate for the petitioner.

Mr. Rajiv Sharma, Advocate for the respondents.

$$$$$ ( 
'
 )+

, -./ % & %'()*!+! ,*

-

. )%+)!'/01234+',)'&%'+) ')5+'%4)% *6!'!
728
2.9 :+#0;'!' )+% '6 %'! ( +4% ) 34 +', ) !,  %  !  *' ' '6< )  7/07/7.
# '*4&%  = 7> '+<,*'<4(?!+'4'%(+''&%,%%'? ( !,*! (6 %  ! ?! * *6 !'! 721
2. :+#2;
 '!,+*' '4(%'*))% ,! %'% &''&'!!%,',) ?!4,+6?,   )), '! !'* <  '6'' '' ?! * !'!

-2- 2

2(6% ! 
 ,','4<&''*4! (& % ' &%,% %' ( ' !! '*4&% % '!  :+#;%'(?'!,',&''**6'&'!!)' ! )6'/%&?/%'<&'?+'**6:!!')82
2- ,*'<!%'% &'<'3' '6<)<%*6&'4 %,+64+'!' %')<<+<&'4):!(6% @ )<<<'!%'<&'5+!( '!%+4%%A'3

,,+!@'B ),' -!'!22
2-/''<!< &'<'!% '6<)A+ ,/0-1?!&%,%<<+<&'4 & ):! ) ,%!+* < *6< '! % ),' &' <'! ' *,'(*&)22
2 '!?6&'%')+!(6% @ %' % &'4 ( '!  % ,+6 4+'! '  % '(?#'! ),' %  %') <'! '6< ) % '' &) 22
2  82
2-  % ,+6 4+'! ! *6! &% %  ! 
 '! '! % '' (** '4  % (+  %  ! 
 
22-
2-   *6 &' %&? ,?! )<  ! 
 &%(6  &' ,?6!%' % '6< <'!  % ,+6 *&'!(+'')<% !

)<22
2 82
2-&'' %@'B)!' ),'!'!22
2- '!%'!?6+!(6% !!'!
2

2-%  & ,'**! +   ! + %  '? ) !,+ '!  +!'! % <%!*46 ' ,(!  % @'B ) !

),'+!(6@?<)!''?!% '? )% ,',!% !#)),'*'!)<!'(+% <%!*46),'64+%,'*,+*''!%''*&'%') 

2-,*'<4%'!'<+

-38  *6  (%'*) )  ! %' ( )*! &% %  ! ! +! '6 +,% *'(*6 '6'(* (6 %< ' % &'  ,,') ,? '6<)(+''**4!*6+!'3(6% &''* !+%'%)<'%4'!&' (6% ! 
% ,*')6%'%<%!*46 '! !(6%<&'',,!',&%%@'B ),''! %'!?6+!(6% @'!%'<'3&,<<!(6%  %<*? %  ! %+ ,' ( %*! *'(* ) '6 '6<<'!(6% &%+%,+*'&%% !


%6%'?'* ,),'**6'?!%'%')'!' ,&'!+*6 (+4%() '?)% &%')&'!,',!%  !% !%'?%+! +!%*'(*6<(+ % (+ ,*'< '! (6 %   )+% +(< %' '  *'+8
)% 4<5+/,'%'6! +&%,% <'+*?!(&% '/%'<5+!()! * '('  ( ' ! (6 %  /   '! ,  ) +,% '('''*( ,(!&''*'?!%'?&)% ! +!5+))',?*?!%  '!''(' ,*'+%'?4('4!(&% '/%  &+*! (<'''(*   %'? %'! *'!

 ,+*9; ' '4  (%'*) ) %  ,? ''!%'?4%+4%%!,+<' !!'*4&% %'  1 ?!)<' +'*)%'(?%'&%*%,*'< *!4!(6% 4'!4%(+''!(+!(6%< %,+64+'!! *6!%4%) ),'+!

-4- @?<)!'''*%'!?6+!(6% @ ,'6 '! '! ! (6  ! 
   %' % '! ),' &'  ' *,'(*%<'' !(6% '!%'''+* )+!(+<)%!+(6% ,+64+'!/ %*'(*6,'()'!+ % ! 
 - % *'(*6 (4 ! +! '! ' '(' ,*'+ %'?4 ('4!(&% '<),.)% (' '!,*' ,/00-/%,,')&+ %! +!5+))', . %    ',,!4*6 !<!  %  %'**/ %&?/ ( ' *(6  '3 ,+  % '*'? <!6 '?'*'(*%<',,!',&%*'&,*'<%!+






,( 
'
 )/
   
+
!

#






 
   C%% '34'!

D  C%% '(* " D