Balwan Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"
# $%&%!' ())
* +, *) - ./- ,
!"
# $ % & '(
%! !" !" & )
**** ./- ,0 ) 1,2 '
+ ,!-
" ((./((0
,1"
"
2
'3 (4(46 7 839 :
$" ;
(
< "
:
/" (5 (4() :
$ "% " ;"
=
- ,>, 6=-
,
$" !
!"!
:
" "
,
!
!"
:
:
"
+:!
"()
"
- ,?
" (440
@+
" (440A9 1
:
!
"
'3 (4(4 7 839:
:
:
!
":
"
+: "()
" (440 # "
!"
)
< "
" (5 (4()
< " :
& ) :
"
:
:
":
"
+:
& ):
:
"!:
"""
1
:
" (3 444/8! & ) 7
,
"
:
:
"
!""
:
" #
" :
& ) 7
< "
: :
:
$
$ (3 444/8 :
, !
:
""
!
:
& )
" :
& )
.
+ ,
"
:#
+
!
" (5 (4() "
8
!
" #
$# %
&
" %# " '( ) *(
" "$# #
$# +,-./012 "3 3-4-5
-67..7-4-5
"# $ %&'
& ( () * ) " ((" "
+,
" - ".
(/0 + # ,2,+,58/6
-5,41,-4-5 (*
(& (
'( "$# #
-6,..,-4-5 # (*
9 # $
: !
# # $ # * $
# " '( ,,; #' !
# <&=' !# ##( #
( '( &
# # >) 7.5?/7 -4-5 # # $ # &
#(
# , ! # # #
@ )76! #
!
" # $ ( , ! # #
& #
# #
A A $ &
$
# # #
# # B # $ # (
&
#
# D
)
E
-44/, %# #
& #
, %# #
,( $
D
)
E < -446,%# &
#$# # #
) -4.0&
# # #
D$ # " # &
# E 3
,%# &
&
4.,4.,-4-5 $ #
A
# # #
# #
#( (
# #
A
!
" , #
7 9 #
:7 ! (
&
/ D
)
E
-44/
# &
D
%(
E ,)
# # D
%(
%(
< 5 # " D
)
E < -446# (
" # #
# ,
$
%( #& (
$3 $ ( # " ( $$E
,
-5
(
&
# # E (
# E ( $ #
( 3
,
-5 #
, 1.
2 23
" "
"
" ., # E #
#
#( $ # # (*
#& # (
( #
# & #
#
#( #& ( (
# # (
& # %( , -, # E #$# &
# # $# &
(
$ # # # $# # $ F( $
# $# , 5, C E ( # $#
(7
.!
-!
( A #( #(
# $ @ (7
.!
0,G & ,; #; #
$ H(
2 # '( @ #( &
# &
# &
# D
)
E
-44/, ,$# &
, %# &
# * $
:7 G,,,-0,%# ( (7
-!
-5 (
#
%#
# %( # *
# &
# # $# 7 7,
# (
# &
# & $
$# &
G
$# ,C # ( # #& # & # ##( A ( & "$#
# %( # &
# & # E # # #( ( # # ($
# E ,%# %(
# E
-44/ #& # # &
@
# E
,&
# (
# $#
,,,G # &
# ( #
&
#
D$ # " ( $
) -4.0&
-8,40,-4.0 ( # A # @
. 5 , .!
)
&
3
( $( $
3
( E 3
-! &
3
( $ E 3
5!
( ( # '( "$# ( # * $
-5,4.,-4-4 )+,1/11 -4.? <
#; ) *(2 #
# * $
-5,4.,-4-4 >)
+,/4--4-. "
2 # ;
<
# # " , #
#
#(
( #
D$ &
#
D$ ( # &
) -4.0
# ## &
# ( A
(& , "
# D
%( # &
& &
-5
#
( # ( #
D$ &
* $
-5,4.,-4-4
<
#' !, ! (
(& # &
$
#
D$ # " ( &
) -4.0( # &
( # A # @
. 5( '(
# <* &+ < & * $
-5,4.,-4-4
)+,1/11-4.? <
#; ) *(2 # ,%# * $
#( # #
( $ >) +,/4--4-. "
2 # ; <
#( # &
#
'( "$# # , # &
( $ #
D$
) ,%# #
(
# & # D
)
E
-44/#
.6,4.,-4-5 #
D$ # " #
$ &
) -4.0 # @
. 5 $# # * $
-5,4.,-4-4 <
#' ! &
$$ * $
,+ @ # $#( @ '( "$# >) +,.4- -4-.48,4-,-4-1,C # #
&
# D
%(
# &
-5
, ! (
#
D$ # " # &
) -4.0 # &
& +
-8,40,-4.0
# (
( # #& ( &
) @
. 5 @
$* $
-5,4.,-4-4 <
#' !,&
$ >) +,/4--4-.! #
* $
,%# #
D$
# A $ &
@ #
#
)
# <
#' !,
%# 9
A
'( "$#
, 37
!
" #
$#I
:!
"
+:
!" !
! "()
"(440!
:
D:
, -6 ) - .
'% 7 .&) 7
89 :
!66%&&%!' ;
'< =9;9 ;> '
%& ;%$ ?
;&) ; 8!; #
& 142 - 53 (3 "
:
"
+
"
"(4'3 :
:
,8 "
,
<
:
!
$"
!"
"
!"
"
1
" !
-) .
'% 7 +& & 1&98;
! "
:
"
"
"
+:" !" !
! "()
"(440
:!
8
# "
!" """
!
:!
""" "
" (5 (4()
'3 (4(46 7 839
"8 69 1:
!
"
(
"()
" (440:
"
+: # !"
#
# """
" (5 (4()
69 1" "
" !
& )
!
:
:
:
!:
"""
"
69 +
# :
,
:
$
$ (3 444/8
& )
,
" & )
:
:
& ) ?
!
& )
6!9 +
" !
$
$
"
(3 444/8 "
:
"
4C 4C (4((
1 " ,
" :
:
"
+:
"
+: "
"""
7 :
()) 1./- ,2 D #A
# # A $3
:7 J 3+ # # ( :7 J 3+