Ram Narain v. The Jhajjar Central Cooperative Bank Ltd And ORS



   


 

   


  

!"# $% #&'('$) * *  !+ !,!')














-!..!,
#)",!/
$$0#,!"'1#

!)2 3"4* !)4 $"-#,(




 

   5 3 *

6


6 6      

   



   

  



  

6 6 

*

,!/ 
  


!
"

 "
##$%##&
 
' 

(







) 


 



 * +

 "% 

,-,.#,&
/ 
0,



!1 
2 

3 


 02
)

 
 1
 " 
""

 "
!




 
!+
 
 -,#,4
+

!
" 





  # 
! 



  
 
 



)

) +



5  1%6/0'"


 02



)


 
 +0 
!1

2


 
+ 

/ 
0
 ##,##,,
 

) 

 +
+ 


)

! ! 


/ 


 +0 

 
) 
 +
 





) +""1

""+""1
+


 
 
5+
)
)





  




!

!1


!1
 +



! 
5  
  



 

"


!



  +0 

/ 
0#


"


 +0  
4,-#,,



"

""


 +
"""
+ 
   

/ 
0-

++
3 


 0 2


6* 1
7

* 


 +

  )

8 1
5
' "
'0 
2
5
5 
' ' 
" 
:&4
 
""

95
5 
" 
:&49   

/ 
04

.,#,#

6* 1
7

!

* 1
 


++
3 


2 
(


 

* 1
 


!


+ 


 1

 + 

 +

 
+ 




!






  

-,,4#,#

/ 
0$

)0 
)




"
#&-

(



5
5 
" 
:&4


)
 


)1

"
!

 


 
 
   
/ 
0&


"

"1


  
)0 

-,$#,#
(

"1


 
"
"+

" 

6* 1
7


"")

 
  
)"  +







!1


""

 


 )


+
1
 1

 

0/

)

  !1

2


)
"")

 

"
 
8
"


 

"1
 +


"



)

)

  "

 1



 
!


)

+


2
)
)

  "


  
 +" 1

1
  

.##,# 

/ 
0.

)








 )


 


  +
 +

5
,



8

8 1
' 
5

:.;
 
""

9

 :.;9


+



 

1


 
&-,,,,%0
"+)
   <
$=


"


  
  +

 / 
0:

 1

 +


  
 + 
- 7

  
  +

"1

 
 )
 
!1

2
+ 


""


  
  
 



* 

!



+ 

!
 " 
 "


 

!



)
 
 
  +

5



)0 






 

6* 1
7

!

 

 

)
 

"
+


)
 
!1

2


* 1  
) !1


!


* 1
 
 
)

  "
  

"



 
 

)0 





 
)


"

(

)1

 " 1
 +
 
"
#&


5
5 
" 
:&4
) 

! +

1 "+"
" 


 

 


"
#&

#.
 
5
5 
" 
:&4

)



6
""




"   "


  


 

!




"
#&

#.



5
5 
" 
:&4 ; (



-,#,4


 
 +

+

 
8) 
"1

/ 
0, 
,-,.#,&



" 

!
#>
1 

 "
)


 !1

2 

3 


2
) !1

)



 

 


"
-#



5
5 
" 
:&4
 !??"

!
@ 
) 

 

8) 
 

!





  
 "

/ 
0,




 "
)



!1
 +
"
-#


5
5 
"  :&4
4 

"

  



1
#,&


 #.,.#,&



)



!1

'0 
2



' 


)
"


 



)"
 

 +
 

,-,.#,&

1 $ A 
 "
 +

!"





 +



 
 



 


+
  )
1
!1

' 


1
#,&
""


 "
!

""


!
+




""
8
!



  

 
 "
)
1


)
!


 0 2


"1


 "
!



) )


!1

2 
8
!





 
) 
 +
 

,-,.#,&
/ 
0,

!



)  1

")



)

! 


 


")

!

 
 + 

!



'
(

5
5 
" 
:&4  


  


!


 +
@

   
B 

 


 

"


! 

"
#&
"
#&-
 

"

+ 

 


"
#&;
 

"


 
8

!




""+
+ 

 

)

  "

 +
"


 
 +


+

 




"
""+
!

 


  

+ 

 



 

!



+  


"
#&-


#&;


5
5 
" 
:&4
""






"1
!
!1




)0

9


  +
 

"

2

"





1  



  
"
#&
""


  

"1
) )
+
!1





)0 

)

 
!

!1

2 
8
!



 

"1 
 +


  
"

!





 +
 
 
 

-,#,4
) 

  0   " 
 


 

2


)


#> 1
!1
 +
"
-#



5
5 
" 
:&4
)
"

) 

)

2


 1

 
8
!



 
)

 


1
  





1
 *


!1


+

1
 
!1

2 

  
"
-# "


!
 
!1

2 



""


1

 "


  
"
-#
8
!

"
-#

!
  "1
)
 






1

!1


 1 )


!



  
 

  



! 
 
 


")


 
"
-#


5
5 
" 
:&4 )

 

 

 1
 

 
8
"


! 

  "


+
/ 
0,
) 
"
-#
)
  !1

2


 



)"
)


   
 "
 "





1

!
"1


   
 

  
""



*



! 


8
!



)1
+
/ 
0,

"!"
 !

 
!+
)

 1

")
& A 
 "
 
!


 ) 
"


 "
-#



!

"+)
"
#&


+"1


 
  + 



* 1
 
/ 
04
 "

"!"

!

:


 
!1

' 


+ 



! 



 + 
!1

6* 1
7





""

  +

  

 +
 
 
+ 

) 
   
 

""1
 
8
 


"1
/  0#
"
!1




 
)0 






  




6* 1
7

)

+ ""1
/" 
"








 




!
 /"

"

"


)


 






1 "!"1


""+
"

  
 "1


!




 6* 1
7
"


!

 


 +

!
  


)



1


6* 1
7


  

" 




"+



"1
)
)
"
!1


 
 
)0 


  
  

* 1
 
"

  "

"!"

!

 


+  . 7



 

  
" 
 "

 +

!"


2
!






"
  

"
 
)




"
#&

#.


5
5  " 
:&4

 




 

""



 
 

@
 

!



+ 


 "
#&
8)
"
-#
)
 
"



 

 
!



!





"
#&

#.

 5
5 
" 
:&4

  



+ 
 "

2
)

)

)


 
"
-#
8
"


!











5
,




:.;

  +


 


"1
)
+
!1




  

  +


 

)
 
!1

2


 
)








5
,




:.;
8
!
 
2
)
)

)


 
"
-#


6* 1 7


!

 


 +
+ 



  
""





)

 

"
"!"1

)
 

!??"



"+)


 
"+ 
+


2 



"!"

1

  
 8
"



!

 

 " 1
 +

) 
 + 


"

"+

+
)
)
"


 

  
 
!
"



!

 





)

 




"
 




"


"!"

1
 
)


*


 
&-,,,,%0
8
!













 


)



 )
  +

)
+


  : (

 

" 
 "


  ,  
 



)
 

!
  
  

)




 +0 




* 1
 
  +
) 
 
+ 



!





 



)0 

)








)1

"

!  


 
 
8
"



)0 

!
  
)



 +

"1

"

#&

#.


5 5 
" 
:&4
""



)





 5
,






:.;

  +

)


" 
 

 
)





  

/ 
0, 
!



!1

 +
"
-#


"
#&

#.
   
+
 



 

 
"

" #&-



#&;



"
#&
#&#
#&-
#&;

-#
 
 

 0


          

                 

                

        

 ! "

" " #$$    

   %&         

   ' (
      %&   

# )     #      

         %&

*          

  %&          

    #   %&  

          

 &  # +       %&

 !&        # ,

-            

 %&     

.,   

,   *" .  

      "     %&                      "

/#"

 

      ," 

, 

 *"    

    ,   0  1     #  

 -  #  #       #      # ,     %&

2#       

        #3 2#       &        , 

     , #   , &  #    , &  #   



 -         &

+ #  #       %&

& !    +        %&    ,,  &  ,,   %&     0 455/

 ,  &  ##       

      %&



&                    %" 
  #/    ! 

 (   
  1   

  ,,  

.#    ,  ,   ,   

       6 

 7   &"        # 

%

   #   %&  '      !

 2              %&"       

 9&    
   %& 

          ,    #   





 

          

   

         /  *   

#
         %&

)  ,      %&"   #   ,  

 .             

 %&     ,          #  0  1     # 



,  * #      *

 

  #         %&    ,         

    ,   0  1    #  

&    8     

    

:   





  .          #               , 

      #     %&


  - /     

 %             



, 0,     

, 9

, !

, ;           

   





  .         #   

   

    , 

  

 -  "  /                

# ;             4<:       



 



 %&   ,      & 

     #     ;

# !   

    #  

;              

          

9

                  #       ,  #   

       

   8  

       #  %& # 





0 ,  ,   ,/  #   



(, ; #

 .      

=      (+#
/9  .

"  0

!    #            # 

 .       

  ,    %&     

 %&  #    &

# C"
"+
)

 
 +
 
!1

"   "





 " 1
 +
) 
 + 








* 1
 

)0 
 )





""

 


 

!




" #&


  

"
-#
"


!
 
"



 

  "


  
"
)"
)

"   

 

@


"

!
  
"
#&
#&#
#&-
#&;

#.


5
5 
" 
:&4 @
"


 

+ 

 



  
!



"
#&-

#&;
 "1

+  
/ 
0,

)


!1

2

@ 

 !??"
!1


) 

 

)

  

1


  
  


"
#&-

#&;
6  ) 
"





" 
 "


 02

  
!




"
#&-

#&;
""

  

'  )"
"







)

#>
1

 
" -#
"

!
 
!1

2



  "


  



 
"
-#
)"
)



 
!0 "


"
 !
 



 
6


+"1


" 


"
-#

 !
 



 

 



 +

"


1 )

"1

* 




1

1
1!"
 2
!1

"1



!

8)

  "

 / 
0,
)"
)





!


"" "+
  
<
#
=

!


  


  


*
)





!


(

)


 +


" 
 "


2


  
 )




)


5
,





:.;
)


 



)

"








 &-,,,,%0
)


  

)"



  
 )

 

 
8) 

 +
 
!1

"   "


2


 !"


!


 " "1 
)










 




  

)0 

!+





5
,




:.;

"1


)
 
+ 



""

  
 )



!
 

)

2

 

  
1







)

)"
+


 +


5
,




:.;


+

  

!1  +
"
-#


5
5 
" 
5



/" 
!

!1

' 
6
 ) 
"



+
  / 
0,


""1
"
)
+ 

1




   

 1
"

!


@ 


  
 

!


2


* 1

 6* 1
7


)0 


 

"
)





8





)

"


2


 


 * 1


"+"

!

 



 

-,#,4 

)

#>

1


"
-#
)
 
)
)"
   !
""1
  !"


1

")


)"

  +

  

"
#&

#. - C


)

""1
 
)

 +0  
/ 
0

"


 +

/ 
0#
8) 
   "



* 1
 

)


 1

 
 
)"
)
 

6* 1
7


"1






 
 + 



 
D
  


   !

 
)

!

!1

6* 1
7

)""
! 

 1

 


+



6* 1
7
*
""

  +




"1
)
)
!
!1


 / 
0#
'  

!

!1
)1


!"
 


 0























' +

"1


 +



+ 





!
  
5
 
5+
  !1
+

5+
2
  ;,,,,%0



 E-&,-


!

 + ,##,,:


 

" 1
 

E
!

 


" 

 
 

5
 
5+



"




(


 1 5

5+
  



/

 
8 
E;
5
& 

++

  
( 2 + 
!1
  +

 


+ 



!1 E$;4,
)

 


 


++

" 


 ;,,,,%0
 ,##,,:



#
D 

!
 #
 
5+

 
!
-&,-


 ###,,:


)
+
5 E$&$

###,,:
 8 
  
C"
+
8  

 
$#,,,,%0
)

  
  



+    



E-,;






!


 

2 


 
!1 ) 


"

!
  
+ 

5

E  
E-&,-

 5  1%'" 

+ 


 E-,;


 

+ 
!
+ 
+
!1
 
5+
(


)1
(



1
 




1
 +

 1

  -
7

!

 +

!1 -
7
,4,#,,
2 
+  +

 1

 

 5
8 
  
+


 ;&,,,%0


E-&,-
 
 
;&,,,,%0








E&,:;

,4,#,,   




!  5

E 
5  1%'"


  +


(
)
 

 


 ) 



'%
52
% -&,-
5
 
5+

+ 5
8 
  

* 
   +
8 
  
+
 




 
 87


 

 
"
 
 



  5+

!

87




 

  

 
(


)1
(
  


 

 1



 /




 




8 
   + 
(

)1

(

 
1
 




!1  +

 1


 

9

;
7
,&,#,,
 +
'* ;
7
,&,#,,
5

5+ E;..-;


E-&,-
 


!


) 1

 
#4,,,%0

! +
8 
  


 




5
5
+


*
;..-;

 5+

)
!1
 +

 1 #4,,,,%0


++

 


5

E  *
(


 1

*
 5  1%'"



+  


/

 


E
 
)

 

+


+ 1
5
5

5+

 8 
  
(




!


 
"  1

5

! 

)

+
)

+
8    
(

)1
(


+ 1
 


 4
7

,#,,
 + 4
7
,#,,
"

 '*
E;..-;4

 

2


)
+ E-&,-

1

 
4,,,,%0 8 
  



+ 
!





5 

*

;..-;4

 "


)
!1
 +
 4,,,,%0



++

  1



5

E  *
(


 1

*
 5  1%
'"



+  



/+

 


E
 
)

 

+


+ 1
5
5

5+

 8 
  
(




!


 
"  1

"

! 
 )
+
)

+
8    
(

)1
(


 1
 


 ; 
  "


  
  
)"
)






  












 + 
8)
  1




+

/"

"+
 1
)


!1


!
)


)
  


)

 )
)

1




/"

"
21

 
 +

  
/"
+
!1



!


!

:






1
 +
+ 

  


+ 

)""
 * 1
 

 "

 



!

 

"+
 "
 

 
)




 


  
* 1  
!

" 
 "


 02

 +

"

-# )
 




"
#&

  

!


 1

  


!

 


6* 1
7


 
(

)   )
* 1
 +
) 


+ 



"
#& 

) 





"+"



 

 
)


 + 

!

" 
 "


 02

"1  +


"

-#

)



"
#&



  

! 

 1

 

"+"1


  
* 1
 
)  +


' 


"!"

!

 


  
+  4 (
)


  


   

   

"")

+
 

,-,.#,&
/ 
0,


)""


* 1
 

.,#,#
/ 
04
 
 !1

  
*  
 02

 

1
""

 "
!
 

 




 
"+)
  
<
$
=
 
)
""
!



)

 




 
1 * * 

6 6  &

 C
 +  F %E C
 !"  F %E