High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24496/2014disposed of

Inderjeet Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-09-30Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan,Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal5 pages

"#$

"#$ %&'()''*+%,-.%/*0(+%,-

'*+*+%'( '(.1.

*0*'0(20%00%&*-'(.

'.3%&'%*.

! 4 ! 4 ! 4 ! 4

! 6

! 6 ####

('.'%* ('.'%* ('.'%* ('.'%* !( !078+#&/90*'(*-'3'*+*+%'( !( ()1%+%,- 0&0/#..+.*0%*&/90*''%'(08# 0(20%0 !( :0.-+.-*0#&/90*'(('.3%&'%*.* ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;<

# '*+*+%'(0..0+8.*-'09*+%*-'('.3%&'%*41.+%,

0(& 0(20%0 +% -0/+%, 90%9'88'& *-' (',+.*(0*+% 0%

9%7+90882'0='('9*+%80*0*:1(1=.-'*(00%&('+*+%, *-''%*+('071%**-0*-0&>''%&'3.+*'&>2-+7 1.+%, 0(&0(20%0?-'('+%0*'(*>'(''(('&0.

5*-' 0(&5@80*'&0.9-'7'((',+.*(0*+%0%&088*7'%* $">1+8*413*(+38'.*('2'&80*.( ?>'8A3/'(*28+%'@ 07+8+'.%+(' 1(9-0.' 0.+.

%.19-.9-'7'#"9+*+'.09(..

*-'*0*'A'('9/'('&+%981&+%,:1(1=.-'*(0(A-+9-$"B80*. A'(''0(70(='& -'3'(+&(',+.*(0*+%(.19-.9-'7'A0. $ *$ +='A+.'#0.+7+80(.9-'7'A0.80*'&

.'30(0*'82( +%)('# +.*(+9*:08=00%&(A-+9-*-'3'(+& (',+.*(0*+%A0..*+3180*'&>'*A''%$ *$ "

-'3'*+*+%'(>'+%,0 90(&-8&'(A0.'8+,+>8'( 088*7'%**-'80*.+%C1'.*+%0%&.1>7+**'&-+.0338+90*+% 08%, A+*- D '0(%'.* 7%'2 1%&'( >*- *-' .9-'7'. '*+*+%'( A0. 0..+,%'& (',+.*(0*+% " 0* +%)(' 0%& (',+.*(0*+% ""B0*:1(1=.-'*(0 %*-'&(0A8*.*-0*A0.

-'8& .+718*0%'1.82# *-' 3'*+*+%'( A0. &'980('& .199'..18 +% >*- *-' .9-'7'. + '

( 0 80* 0* +%)(' 0. A'88 0. 0* :1(1=.-'*(0 -'3'*+*+%'(31(.1'&-+.088*7'%*0*:1(1=.-'*(0 0%& 70&'*-'('C1+.+*'&'3.+*.7%'2+%('80*+%*-'('* 3% .+,%+%, *-' ('C1+('& -+(' 31(9-0.' *'%0%92 0,(''7'%*# 3..'..+% 9%7+90882 '0='( '9*+% 80* "EE# %& 8(#'9*("#:1(1=.-'*(0A0.+..1'&+%-+.0/1( +&'(&'(&0*'& +..1'&>2('.3%&'%* + '

*-' -+' &7+%+.*(0*( *-' 0(&# ',+.*(0*+% ""B 3'(*0+%+%,**-'80*0*:1(1=.-'*(0-0.>''%90%9'88'&0%&+*-0. >''%&+('9*'&*-0**-''%*+('071%*08('0&2&'3.+*'&>2*-' 3'*+*+%'( A18& .*0%& ('+*'& (+* 9'(*+(0(+ +. .1,-* .''=+%,C10.-+%,*-'(&'(&0*'& 0*%%'F1(' $ 1%.'8(*-'30(*+'.-0/'>''%-'0(& '(1.08 *-' +731,%'& (&'( &0*'& # %%'F1(' #A18&('/'08*-0*(',+.*(0*+%*-' 9%7+90882 '0='('9*+%80*-0.>''%90%9'88'&%*-',(1%&.*-0**-' 3'*+*+%'(-0&/+80*'&*-'*'(7.0%&9%&+*+%.*-' (9-1('

>2 03382+%, ( 7(' *-0% %' 80* 0%& .'9%&82# -' -0& 9%9'08'&*-'+%(70*+%(',0(&+%,&1>8'088*7'%*

%&'(*-'.9-'7'((',+.*(0*+%0%&088*7'%**-' >1+8*413 *(+38'.*('2'& 80*.( 07+8+'.%+(' 1(9-0.'

0.+.#*-'*'(7.0%&9%&+*+%.'8+,+>+8+*2A'('9%*0+%'&+%0 >(9-1('0%&('0&+%*-'88A+%,*'(7.

G?+@-'0338+90%*.-18&>'8%,* '8A /'(*2+%'

@07+820(20%0%82 ?++@-'0338+90%*#-+.H-'(.31.'(-+.H-'(&'3'%&'%* 9-+8&('%&%*A%0%280*H38*+%0%2 '9*(H 8+9'%.'&98%2+%0%2*-'1(>0%0('0+%*-'*0*' ?+++@-'0338+90%*71.*>'09+*+I'%%&+0 ?+/@ -' 0338+90%* 71.* -0/' 0**0+%'& *-' 0,' 70)(+*20**-'*+7'(',+.*(0*+% ?/@%'8+,+>8'3'(.%#-+.(-'(.31.'#(0%2 -+.H-'(&'3'%&'%*7'7>'(.90%%*.1>7+*7('*-0% %'0338+90*+%1%&'(*-'.9-'7'

J * A0. 1(*-'( 3(/+&'& *-0* .133('..+%H9%9'087'%* 09*.#0*0%2.*0,'#A18&('.18*+%90%9'880*+%(',+.*(0*+%H 088*7'%* *-' 80* >'.+&'. ('+*1(' *-' '%*+(' 071%* 08('0&2&'3.+*'& %&'( *-' *'(7. 0%& 9%&+*+%. 088*7'%*# 0% '8+,+>8'3'(.%918&%*.1>7+*7('*-0%%'0338+90*+%1%&'( 5*-'.9-'7'5 *-'.9-'7'5 *-'.9-'7'5 *-'.9-'7'5 .(',0(&.*-'3'*+*+%'(>'8%,+%,*0 07+82# *-'('+.%&+.31*'

-'9+*2:1(1=.-'*(0A0.9/'('&1%&'(0 .'30(0*'.9-'7'0.33.'&* +%)('

-'('A0.%>0(+%.0(

0. .1>7+**+%, 0338+90*+%. 1%&'( .'30(0*' .9-'7'. -'

'7>0(, A0. %82 A+*- (',0(& * .1>7+**+%, 7(' *-0% %' 0338+90*+%1%&'( 5*-'.9-'7'5 5*-'.9-'7'5 5*-'.9-'7'5 5*-'.9-'7'5 /'%+%*-'.-A901.'%*+9'

&0*'& "#%%'F1(' "#*-'3'*+*+%'(-0&>''%9088'&13% *'F380+%0.*A-20*'(-0/+%,>''%.199'..18+%*-'&(0A 8*.(088*7'%*80*.>*-0* +%)('0%&:1(1=.-'*(0#-'&+& %*03382(90%9'880*+%(',+.*(0*+%H088*7'%*'+*-'(%' *-'80*.

-A901.'A0.%*+%('80*+%*-0/+%,0338+'&( 7(' *-0% %' 80* -' +731,%'& (&'( &0*'& # %%'F1(' #90%9'88+%,*-'(',+.*(0*+%*-'80*%*-'>0.+. *-0**-'3'*+*+%'(-0&0338+'&(7('*-0%%'80*08>'+*+% .'30(0*'.9-'7'.#0..19-#90%%*.1.*0+% -' 98'0( >)'9*+/' *-' 9%&+*+%# A-'('>2 0% '8+,+>8'3'(.%+.%**.1>7+*7('*-0%%'0338+90*+%1%&'( 5*-'.9-'7'5 5*-'.9-'7'5 5*-'.9-'7'5 5*-'.9-'7'5#+.*-0*03'(.%>'8%,+%,*0 07+8290%%* 0/0+8 718*+38'H&1>8' 088*7'%*. 9%7+90882 '0='( '9*+% *'%'7'%*. 0* 9%9'..+%08 (0*'. . % *-' ('8'/0%* &0*'.%A-+9-*-'3'*+*+%'(-0&.1>7+**'&-+.0338+90*+%.( *-'*A.'30(0*'.9-'7'.#-'&+&%*A%0%280*1%&'(0 '9*(H8+9'%.'& 98%2 88*7'%*.

>*- 0* +%)(' 0%& :1(1=.-'*(0907'*-(1,-+%0&(0A8*.-'8&.+718*0%'1.82 .3'(38'0&+%,.%('9(&#+*-0.,%'1%9%*(/'(*'&*-0*0*'( -0/+%,('70+%'&.199'..18+%*-'&(0A8*.#*-'3'*+*+%'(-0. %*31(.1'&-+.088*7'%**-'80*0* +%)('0%&-0.%*'/'% &'3.+*'&0.+%,8'3'%%2 +%31(.10%9'*-'('030(*(7*-' +%+*+08'0(%'.*7%'2H0338+90*+%071%* -'('C1+.+*'&'3.+*.

7%'2A'('70&'%82+%('80*+%**-'088*7'%*080*+% -+.0/1(0*:1(1=.-'*(0 8'0(82#*-'('A0.%+%*'%*%*-'30(* *-'3'*+*+%'(*9-'0*0%&&'(+/'0%20&/0%*0,'0&1>8' 088*7'%*

$ '+%&*-0**-'3'*+*+%'(A0.9'(*0+%82('7+..+%%* -0/+%,033(09-'&*-'9%9'(%'&01*-(+*+'.(90%9'880*+% -+.(',+.*(0*+%0%&088*7'%**-'80*0* +%)(' A'/'(# 90%9'880*+%-+.80*0*:1(1=.-'*(0%0991%*.19-803.' A18&>'1%&182-0(.- !( !078+#8'0(%'&91%.'8-0.70&'0 .*0*'7'%*&1(+%,*-'91(.'0(,17'%*.*-0**-'3'*+*+%'(+. ('0&2 0%& A+88+%, * .1'( ('+*1(' *-' D '0(%'.* 7%'2H0338+90*+% 7%'2 70&' 0* *-' *+7' .1>7+..+% 0338+90*+%(*-'*'%'7'%*.0* +%)('

'+%&.19-.*0*'7'%* *>'0+(0%&099'3**-'.07'

% *-' **08+*2 9+(917.*0%9'.# A' +%& *-0* *-' 3'*+*+%'(#A- *-'(A+.'>'8%,.* *-' 9%7+90882'0='( '9*+%#+.%**-'>'%'+9+0(20&1>8'088*7'%*0%&%'+*-'( &+&-+.9%&19*('8'9*0%2.19-+%*'%* %/+'A*-'0>/'#*-'A(+*3'*+*+%+.088A'& -'

+731,%'&(&'(&0*'& #%%'F1(' #+..'*0.+&'

088*7'%* *-' 80* +% C1'.*+% 0* :1(1=.-'*(0 .-088 .*0%& ('.*('&+%-+.0/1( '*+*+%'(#-A'/'(#A18&>'8+0>8'* &'3.+**-'1*.*0%&+%,&1'.#+0%2#+%('.3'9*.19-80*08%, A+*-+%*'('.*KED3'(0%%17A+*-+%03'(+&1(A''=.(7 *-'&0*'0&'70%&+.(0+.'&>2*-' 0(& "

'*+*+%088A'& ? 6 @ ? 6 @ ? 6 @ ? 6 @ ?

@ ?

"#$

"#$ ! ! ! !

-'*-'((''(('&*'3(*'(L?

'.H @ -'*-'((''(('&*'3(*'(L?

'.H @