Union Of India And Other v. Colonel Neeraj Khurana And Another




    
    

  !"#"$%&'&'


   





     (%  )*( ' +
 +
( +
+
 )*( ' +
,
-++

 ! " #"$"% "&&% '#  !"(  )#% (*"%+# ! # #"$"% (*"%' , -----  +
( +
+
 .'/ *0   , #  %#*#"&&)#$ 

,.,/0/0123 ,4 " 56 0 $ * 5"&% )"&7*#%#" )"#2#"'' "8 5"&94 56  +#*#%     ,  #"  5  "&&+  #  5'  '  "5&6

56 )''# "5&6&$'$:/;</;'&'% #) #"#"$ ( 0 "  &"*&"* #  '$ *"&3"$"' ,#& #"#)##

"5&6'=
 

  #"5'  ,% 5#"$#"5#& 58#"5"5&!&"6 (*

"))"(" 56#!&"6(*9 *%#)"'5'' "5&6

 ,'$:/;</;'&'56 &"*)&"* #A )$'# 5"&%* "&7*#%+&#
   

   

& "




  !" "#$% " #A )$' 95& $'

 "&%'

%( ) $%     !" "#$% /10+ 1.** : " '#5$#"*% # '#! *&"&6"#"# "5&6'' 56  ,#"5 $&"6(*"))"(" 56 #$&"6(*%#)"'5'' "5&6   ,56 )''# "5&6'$:/;</;'&'** " #'"*'# *"#"(5"

*" **

 *(  56  #  5"&  +#&  ")  #  $    

,.,/0/0123 ,4 1 >#"(#" &" *&'5## "" #"( )#)##*"'&+##"5&""* < ** '"*#""#$+# ,

'$(*:,/<0/0:%##"

"&"

6  $#"::6"'

(*+## 
' ""&"** '"*#"" #$+# ,A #"$ '*,<,0,BB/% #+"$ *"&&63"$ " +"' '')'$"6*#

"%#5"'+#*#% ,#"5)" #5' ' "5&6     #*&"$' ,*( # '"('#)"' "5&6 " #A )$' 95&

2:4

$' " &%'

%( )*  *"2 "4 #&(" ""

:/%:0" ::'#" A )$"" :/ # *"   #"'

"6 "#"5* "#$'"

&&"C "** "*'$&"6(* # #"( '"& 5)* "6 *$))#"# "

&&"+" "$'*#" "56 # "6#'')'$*# ""5* '"6#(** "#$'"** "* 'A)'"

&&"+"*$5# "'# ! *"&&'* " &D#"$ 5'*$)" #"# "*&  #"(5 * $ *"&3"$" # "** "*'$&"6(*%5#)# * ))#""6*#* +"*"&& '56 #! &D " "#"( 5* +)*$#**&#" # "5&6 $&"6(*'"*% "

&*"'$ '! "

"'$ &"2 4' "")"

#0'# '#! *"& 7" %+#*#"'&&+ =2 4#*"'" "5&6 #5" #&

"+#"3"*&6# #*"#'

"5&6&" $&(*F :0  '#"'" (%#

"*)#6'"& *#"#! *"& 7" #"

)("6"

' %

"*&"&6+##'*# "

"5&6"("&"5&#(** '#"

&&" "#$'"** "*'$&"6(*># ))#)##"'" '"*# "*) #6$*#"*"&&6 " #$  '

A*5" # '#! 

 &<" B'C &$ &'""&6 "6+" %,B.0C%#"

&&"& '

$ " 5'' $ #'"( "5* ' "6 ( *  *   #+ #" # "

&&"  +"  '')  '$  GH"&  I

& 64F"#$'"** "*'#(*% +&&5 $ #"#"

&&"+" #6*"& " $"&* "#$')#(* " "##"&##""D &"*  (* ::     &  10:2"4  '  H"&  &  '  #

 ' $)"J+###*"'"

"5&6 "#&)'$ " "5"5&(*%$$""&+###*" )()# "5&6 "#** """

*&" 5"'& (*K"*((*"" $"& "**  G&"'*"  '  "F  #"(  5

*5 "#"

'3L

"")"

#1 "$"* & 6" # $"&  *#")  &)  '$  #"

 A #"(5#+"'# ""''*

56")%$"*#)% &) " )* #'%# $ +& 5#"#

"5&6  '  #  "

&&"  5  "  *""& **+##(** F ? 5" "&'#$ *"& +& #+#"(# ! #"

*$#**&#"#
 



"  6 0 "5!&&#"5"))"(" #$&"6(* &6#%# "5&6+"" "11;'&'%+#*#'"*#" )  5  " $  "  ")  B?  "  B@ '  #  "

 5D

 )(+#'"*"&%+#(#! #"**

2<4 #"# "+#*#& #("& "'#''*** % "))"(" 56#$&"6(*%#'&)'#  56#
' "*"6#*$$ "'#!

&' @ #%" #& * &'&"+& 56 95&

$' "   !" "#$% 

+' #%% + $2"$ +%"6''*()#$ *%+##"

 )#$ *"&3"$""#$'#K#&*" +" ' '%5J&6 '')" "5&6%& #5' ' "5&6 56 )''#"$"# $ +& 5 #"# "5&6'' "5"5&#!&"6(* &("

""'#A )$+' #%* *"2 "4"" =1 76# '"

"&#"

&&"24 "#J%+##%" ( "&%+# #" "")#")' "" *$ &'#')")$%''

  5  '')  '$  $  "5&6  +#*#   "5"5&"))"(" 56#$&"6(*% & 5)" #5'' ) '''

"5&6    #  "

&&"24  #  +&

*  #"%    #  5"  '  *&"   ,204KB@K2 4 56#!6''*% H($' "% :,/,0//,%#"'"

5'$"

"("&"5&&6"$ * &+#("& '(*%"  "6  #  *")6  '  $  *  & $ #"5( < >#"(#" &" " #& ? >        "6      #  $

2?4 A )$24"  24" #'"&&#"

"& +#*# "#** ' ) '''#

"5&6 " $ %+# " * @ # $"&'#$"+&&5"D '56# )#"+&&"56# 5"& )")"

 "&'# 5' #$%'"6%+#"))"& #

"5&6 F . " #"5"5&   #"  '&"+#"()5& 56# 95& $ ' "+' #%* *"2 "4 B

 )(+#'"*" **$"*'# *" "+&&"#& * &'&"+& +' #%* *"2 "4% *"#$'&*% ,+"$ *"&&63"$ "

+"' '"&& *" +"&6 )#(*%  ,+"' '')'$#
 

  #"5)% #" "5&#"(5"5 #$&"6(*" #  '! *""D"+"6#)#' , *&"$#5'' "5&6 " #"%56 )''#

"5&6'$:/;</;" #& * &'&"+& +'

 #%* *"2 "4 ,/ #")$#"5"  ,,

*%#"5*'"6 (65)  # $   ,.,/0/0123 ,4##5"'# '"*    #  & * &  '  &"+%   
   

       

          

   



 ,0 ** )&6%#+  $ 

2@4 ,:  )"

&*"24%'"6%"    ' / +
( +
+
0   /,
-++

0 343# &.     >## "D)K"

E >## "5&