Chiman Lal v. Union Of India And ORS.
!"#$ !
%"&' (% )%*#+,#$ !
-.% /%
')'
" 0%% 0-'
'1 '
' (2 3).2%-%4% ,3 0&%5- 2 .6-%,0&%,"-1 7
8 %9 -1 ':'%0& - '% -);- ' '''% % 2% %;, % <'%, 3&7 , -% 0;%-=&-% ;># $'1&"0?% : '"-%)" $$@7 %&-% 0#!! '1&"0 '"-%)"
$$$@7%&- %%) ;
#,$$$@7 5-&- 5 0. B0 0 "
0%0$!
C% 05-&-51%&0 -&)'0*"- 1 000%0
C 1%''0 ?*-2,)0-%0%, '& 2% '%, % 0 %' :1 ; 5 - 0'
% #!
1%''0?*-%?7. 0), .'5-",-
'% 0%% 0'%)-'%?;%0%&%'1 )7# "-31&"0% :'81'" "'&%0'9 )',#$
D#E ?"" &-"%&'.%*?.%0
D>E - 1 -%' % '.% "%&* " .% )"%&) ; "? '-'5-&-'')%0%%%,'&2% '%, ) 4%?% 0-)'"- 1 '')%0%)0-%0%,'&2% '% --5%') ;
".-"%&* $A $!
C,-1 5%'"&?*:0 %110" % '.?*51' ',5-5:
5 &. %'% 0= ''"-
%% 5%'& " 0%?%'. ?) :5- 5 050% * '&%1)" 0%*'
-:0 %11'& %&05""-1 % 00.% 00%% '."
$&"%' ;-1 %
>! 0%0 $ $!
C ;%0 ; - 1 F' :0 %11 ; 5%'
;'0) 03& '>C @ $C>CA7
DAE -%5'%-1 F'",-'5"%% ;0
$&". %% '5-&-51%0-:0 %11'
+ $!
C5-"):
50;, ".% % 01.'' "-1&
&1 " -% % '. %.) , - 1 5%' %'0
$!
-1&&)0%'-:0 %11' #$
C% 0; &0 !,++,$$$@7".-.5-&-5%'%1%"-% '.1%0?* -1 F'"%.* -&* &)0'%')." #,$$$@7
&) &*" $$@7% 0 $$$@70 . % ,?'0' +$> @7
'- ) 0'G $$$$ 3%'% 0 $$$$
D E 2% ., $!
C,-&) &* '" $$@7%
$$$@7&%'0?;% 0 .'"- '')0?* % -1 .0% %11&%
C" -%'"-&%'-%.) &0".-:0 %11'%'%&)%* ? ;0-.
-% 02,)0-%0%000%0
%'0%')." #,$$$@7&.1' ; ) &*% 0";
&) &* ')10% "%)"-1 -1 - .0 % - %11&% $C
C "50 ?* '& 0 %11&%
$#
5-&-5%' )%*%50% 01.'' 5%';% 0 -.01'-?%
0 &) &* ' -0 . % %) " $$@7% 0
$$$@75- '0% 0%'-%-' '
&)0?=&-% ;05-- 5 '@;% 0 -)"2,
)0-%0%1%''0-00%0
1. ;-1 =&-% ;-'1&"0?% : '" $$@7% 0
$$$@70 . % , %) ; #,$$$@7". '% -1 %110 '1 > #>
-' ;-"-'%00% ');-=&-% ;"-'1&"0?% : '
-0. '%% 00% ""&" '% 0% %<'%,3&7 ,-% 0;%-, -5,000%0#A $> 4&0-1 F'%11&%
-1 -%".%0 % -1' % $!
$A
%&&0% &5-3& A8>9"-31&"0% :'8''% "
/%?'9&,#$ ,"50?*. 00%0 !
$A
DCE - -' %?7'%0 1' % 5%' 1 0 ;, - " 0%, 2 '* " % & '')0 0%0
=&'"'15') 03&
8 9%05-3&
"- 31&"0% :'8''% "/%?'9&,#$ ,?* 5-&--31&"0% :'81'" "'&%0'9 )',#$
-%? 1.);%0 -1 ')1 )#"-'#$
)' ')11"-'&%."=&-% ;"-0. B0&) &*
'
D E -1 * ; )1 -%"'%0 %;%
.0-)"% 02,)0-%0%5--%'1%''0-00%0 #!
?%0 & )*"'1)'00%0
, -?*0& ;-%)-' - '0% 0%"=&-% ; " - &) &* ' :1 ; 5 - '1 " 0%0
- 1 %110 - ' % : " 0%
>
5-%&1*"-01%''0?*2,)0-%0%?)" 0 ;
'1 '-,- '% 51 -%'? "0
D!E '-"%&'5)0'1%:"-.'',-1 '% &."&&).'% &'
.%7"%&,-%11%'? 0-? " " 0%0 %05--0'1%''0?* -')?0 %)%)0-%0% -'"%) 3 &5-% &%0 )1 -'1 7?% :%-''%;,50 =1''% *" %5'
.',%-0.%111%0'1'"-'51 5-% 0& '1 '
#A& '0-%?7. 0&%."
-1 -;-"1%%7#8%9"- 0%0
%05--0'1%''0?*-2,)0-%0%% 0%:% %111% 0&' 5- %10"5. -'".-0%"& ;%&"0 &1*"-'0 D+E 00%&&0 ;*
!
"
#$ #%&'
!
"
() ()*+) ,- ./) *0 )1 )*/ 0 () ())+0
23) )*/ 0