High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2391/2015disposed of

Subash Chand Mittal v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And ORS

2018-03-07Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath3 pages

!" "#$%$&'

!" "#$%$&' (

)

(

)

(

)

(

) *+, %,, &-.$!! / "!$!$&"0 1% ,"*&2 +! !"3"0040 !$&5!- &-!,"0% "%4&-"&!% .' .' .' .'6 5.77. 6 5.77. 6 5.77. 6 5.77. 0"%"&!' .0"2"&-"07%,$8-9# !"8

0!,"4"!$!$&"0 .0.""& &% /8-9# !"8

0!,"0"%4&-"&!% 77.8:5;

77.8:5;

77.8:5; ," 4"!$!$&"0 , % & "/"#!0$# #&&"#!$& +" 0$&< =# = (= ) 0 ->"%!$# 4*04%" 3$!, % &#!$&"- / -

7 &?

)8!,"40">$%"% !,"4"!$!$&"03 %$&%4"#!"-+@!,"

$#$ / 0"%4&-"&! &-$&!, !$&%4"#!$&8$!3 % *&-!, !!,"4"!$!$&"0, % +""&*& *!,0$%"-/@*%$&<!,""/"#!0$#$!@##0-$&</@8 409$%$& /0-"0 %%"%%>"&! 8 8(A = 3 % %"09"- *4& !," 4"!$!$&"0 $& !"0>% "#!$& A !,"/"#!0$#$!@#!8

B 0%,0!C!,"#!6D,"4"!$!$&"0

$/"- +2"#!$&% ! !," 409$%$& / %%"%%>"&! & ?

) %4"#$ $# //@ //"<$&< !, ! !," %%"%%>"&! > -" & (

) $% !! //@ $//"< / &- !," 4"!$!$&"0$%&!/$ +/"!4 @ &@#, 0<"% % %%"%%"-+@!,"0"%4&-"&!% 3"9"08 !," +2"#!$& !," 4"!$!$&"0 3 % -"#$-"- < $&%! ,$> & ??

) &-,"3 % %E"-!-"4%$!!," >*&!3$!,$& 4"0$- (- @% 3$!, !,0" !!, !!,"03$%",$%"/"#!0$##&&"#!$&3*/-+"-$%#&&"#!"- ,"4"!$!$&"0, --"4%$!"-!," >*&!#/ $>"-+@!,"0"%4&-"&!% &- !

!," % >" !$>" $/"- !," 44" / *&-"0 "#!$& ( !," #! +"

0" !," 44"// !" *!,0$!@ ," 44" / !," 4"!$!$&"0, % /% +""& -$%>$%%"- 9$-" 0-"0 - !"- A?

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

0$9/*% , 9"," 0-/" 0&"-#*&%"/ 0!,"4 0!$"% &- !"0! E$&<$&! #&%$-"0 !$&!," #!% &-#$0#*>%! &#"%8 > !,"#&%$-"0"-4$&$&!, ! !,"0" $% & "000 $& !," 440 #, !," 0"%4&-"&!% $& &! 409$-$&< 0" %& +/"440!*&$!@ ," 0$&<!!,"4"!$!$&"0 !!,"!$>" 4 %%$&<

$& /0-"0 %%"%%>"&! %$!$% %! !*!0@0"F*$0">"&!$&!"0>% "#!$&

A: ; !,"#!!$%&! # %"3,"0"!,"440!*&$!@ ," 0$&<$%&! <$9"&3,$/" //3$&<!,"40$&#$4/" & !*0 /2*%!$#"0 !,"0$!$% # %"3,"0" !,"/"<$%/ !*0"$!%"/ , %409$-"- >"#, &$%> 0

0-$&< 0" %& +/" 440!*&$!@ ," 0$&< ! !," 4"0%&8 3, $% +2"#!$&< ! !," 409$%$& / %%"%%>"&!> -"+@!,"0"%4&-"&!% &-, % $/"-,$%+2"#!$&%!#, //"&<" !,"% $- %%"%%>"&!!$%$&#*>+"&!*4&!,"0"%4&-"&!%!, 9"<0 &!"- 0" %& +/" 440!*&$!@ ," 0$&< ! !," 4"!$!$&"0=#&%*>"0 +"

-"#$%$&$%! E"& $& //@! %E!,"4"!$!$&"0!4 @!," >*&!=#, 0<"% 0 *& *!,0$G"-*%" "/"#!0$#$!@ ,*%8 E""4$&< $& 9$"3 !," 0"% $- #!% >*#, /"%% !," > &- !" / 3 %409$-"-*&-"0"#!$& A: ; !,"#!#*4/"-3$!, !," #!!, !&440!*&$!@ ," 0$&<3 %<$9"&+"

0"!," $& / %%"%%>"&! 0-"03 %4 %%"-8!,"0-"0- !"-??

)$"!,"0-"04 %%"-0"< 0-$&< !," $& / %%"%%>"&! &-!,"0-"0 !," 44"// !" *!,0$!@ 0","0"+@%"! %$-","> !!"0$%0"> &-"-+ #E!!," %%"%%$&< *!,0$!@!<$9" & 440!*&$!@ ," 0$&<!!,"4"!$!$&"0$&%*440! ,$%+2"#!$&%8+"

0" ! E$&< $& / -"#$%$&8 $& 0"< 0- ! !," >*&! ! +" #, 0<"- 0> !," 4"!$!$&"0 0*& *!,0$G"-*%" !,""/"#!0$#$!@409$-"-+@!,"/$#"&%"" "!$!$&"0$%-$0"#!"-! 44" 0+"

0"!," %%"%%$&<

$#"0& ?

) ," %%"%%$&<

$#"0 $% *0!,"0 -$0"#!"- ! #>4/"!" !," 40#"-*0" $& / %%"%%>"&!3$!,$& 4"0$- - @% %!,"4"!$!$&"0 , - /0" -@ -"4%$!"- 8 8(A = 3,$#, , % +""& #/ $>"- 0> ,$> & ##*&! *& *!,0$G"- *%" "/"#!0$#$!@ ! 3,$#, !,"0" $% ">4 !,"!$# -"&$ /&!,"4 0! !,"4"!$!$&"0 $!,!,"%"+%"09 !$&%8!,"40"%"&!4"!$!$&$%,"0"+@-$%4%"- :77.;

:77.;

(

)

(

)

(

)

(

) ,"!,"0%4" E$&<=0" %&"-

"%= ,"!,"00"40! +/"

"%=