High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22966/2016dismissed

Naresh Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli12 pages

-1-

!"!

#$%&& '

"()*+' ,&

- '"*" .

'/## '" ,

#$ 1'& 2 "()*+'.('+34 3

'( !!

'& 1'&#2*'1!535&4 '53'/#6!( 1'&.*'7(18 3""&4 '5'/#3# 1"&)*"(5

0)*'1# (#34 & 1'&+'-!4 288'6534 3# 1'&.(!4 '"('34 3

# &%9 & :(

"! 0'

!" 7 !#8 '

*8( 4!

# !#8 "!# 0'

!#8"'

!#8 #* !#4!'*5 *';&

& ( #'

'"/!#4 !#( + '(#'

*#( 005! 7!5!/

# < :;

!8( !' # # '#"0'

# /!#=# >*!"!!

(7!5!!

5 # 3 %:

'"( '3?(

%@; # "

6( !#( 6' *# ' .

=# >*!"!!

# 3 A< 6" ## *# # &B&B3 !& & + (# / '" 0'!

% #&&<3#" # 7/ !!

'3# !( '(

5#("7

#2 #7/( . #("7

#0!C "! !55 &#4!

"3 0'/ ' (" 7

# + 5'

>*!"!!

# 0'

!#8" (4 50"

-2- & ( !# '0'

# < :;

% ( +!# *# ' 5 *

'5 #8*#!5! !#55/ + !

7/( #"!*!

# # (

.*0'

*' !# ( "

3 6( 7/( 0 D *'("5! 6#( 8*!!#80'!# !05 "!# '

6( ' !# 8!4 " # !' *+"# "3 ( >*!"!!

!#8" # 7 5'

# 50"

!# 4!

+!#8

! !

#0'

%&( # 5*!#8 0'8'0(%%

E*8+ #!"'

* ( !#7 6$ F,& !"

$#$" %

! "

" ! "

! &' !

)

! & " %) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

" "

$#)$! "

! & "

! ) & ,%-."

#$) %

)-. -. , ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

"% "

! !! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %'" ) 0'"

) ' ! "

) ' ) 0

, * 1 1 ! "

#$! "

! & "

" ,"/"!2 "

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ ! !" ! "/ "

! "

) "

""" % ! "

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4"/ "

)! !

' "

& ! "

" ) ( 52 ! "

# " $

-3-

! "/ "( " ! 2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

! & ) 6 %6 ! !" ! "/ "

! "

7 " ) "

& $! "

' "

#$ 2 2 !"

" ,) ( "

) ( "

& $ 4 % % ! ""

% ( !" ! ( "

' " "/ "( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! & ) !"

#$ !"

$#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$ ) %(!/ 9 :"% ) 0( "

! "

' (

#$ ! "

! &' "

) 0 "

#$ + , !"

#$ (! ! "(

") " ! "

! ! )! "

! &" !"' "(!

"/ ( % ""

, !) "! )" )*"

#$! "

! & ( % " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &''

2) "

% % / ( !

! 0( "( ! !"

!" "/ .

-4- %& ( D0 "!!

56 + 7/ ( 0 D *' # 7 "*++'!G !#(

6!#8+##

'+ 5'!/ #( 0'!# !05 " 5! 6#7/( #"!*!

# # ($ :;

# 55 ( "

" 6( !# ( >*!"!!

# 0'

"" ( 7

!#!! 7*( 6'("# 7

### *# *#

A<3 #(

%!& &&&<3( !"# 50"

!#8" #( "+ 6!55 #!#* 3( '36!(( '!

'((

# (" '+!# *# ' ( 0'

4!"!

%& 55 ( "

" 6( !# ( 6' *# .

A<("7

### *# 0'!

%3( 0'

4!"!

% 6 *5 (4 # '!#8 ' 005! !

# # ( 0'

!#8"6!55 #!#* !#'

"3"!

A<("# 7

5 & :7;

( 6 ' F '@ *"

!# 7 6

# 7 ( ( #!#8 # !

%!" '

"-. '" -. 6(! ( + #" ( "

2 50"!#8

>*!"!!

!#8" 7 ( ( #!#8 # !

" +*" 7 *5 !55 & #!#8( 7/3(!

#(7

#2 #7*(

# 6" # '

3 ( 6 *5 7 # 50"

& .!+!5'5/3 !

# (" 7

# 0 7* ( # (" # 7

# 2 #3 ( 6 *5 7 # 50"!#8& #!"

&&#$! 3( $ : ;

" '"( "0

'( 5# >*!'

'# 3( .*0'

*'(" '! 55/ 7"

'4 ( D0'

#0!!#( +!#0'

-5-

" # !# 5* "!

# !#

*'&(!"'

>*!'

!"(( + *#6" 6(! (("7

D05!# !# & (( '!#8

+ *#6 *5+ #(( + *# !" + 4!575 5# 6# ' # ( 6 *5 7 !" ('8

75!8!

# +2 0/+ ##!#(

# "* ( 0 '"

# ## 7 0 #5!"

' (

*5 !# +2!#8( 0/+ #&(!5 '

''!#8 .

#%:;3%:;3 %<

A< # +0'!#8 ( + 6!( ( 0' + '!0'

4!"!

#"!& &.

#B#A

%3 0 D *' (" 5'!

( ( #5/ #"

#0/+

# !" +2 0/+

!# " " 0 ' .

# %<

A<& 4 # ( .*0'

*'(" *'( ' 5'!

( 0/+

#("7

C *# #%:;3 >*!'!#8*( '!/ ## 7 #5!"

'# #0/+ "( + *#("'

+!#*#0!* '

*"5 07/ 5# 6# '& 5'!

/ ! *'( '3 ( .*0'

*'("

*'( 7"

'4 (!

5# 6# '(" !5 '

(!8( #( ## 5!+(( 6"# 0!( + *#& :;

(!5 '

!#8( 0'

4!"

% 0'

# < :;

%3 ( .*0'

*'(" 5'!

(!# "

'0/+ #("7

+ 7* # "! 3 5!7!5!/ 0/ + *# 5 #8 6!( !# ""*7"!""#!

'+E '!/

( 5!#8"

/ '" '+ 3 #*# '(

-6- (" 0! 5# 6# '"" #(

! !

' 5# >*!"!!

# *# ' .

# <

A<&

8'!#8( "!3!("7

# 5'!

E*8+ # (

' ( (!8( #

63 ( / "( *5 # (4

"! 6!( ( =# >*!"!!

# '!#( '

"*'/ '!#( *'6!( +E '!/

5#( 5!#8"3+ #!#8( 7/!

!6"

"! !##/

"6!('

+E '!/

( 5!#8"3 ( (!8( # 6!55 #

63 7* !# " *# ' .

# %<

A< 6 *5 7

>* & :

;

8'"( +

2!#80 #3( .*0'

*' ( 5'!

( '6!#8

!#>* " '

'C+ '#*+ *5+ #(0(/"! 50 #("7

#2 #&( 56 6!('

8' 4 "!#8

5#(" 8!#7

! ' ( 5( #("7

#2 #*#

A<3( 5#4 ""!#( . #( ## 7 #/!4 "!#8 '50"!#8& :

;

(!5 +0*!#8 ( 80 0 '!

/ '" 7 6

# (

6' # ++

%3 #/ !# '!+ '"*7"!"!#8!" D 5* 6(! (+ #"( D 5*!#8( !# '!+ '3( 0'

>*!"! 800 '!

H/ '"!"# ( 3( 0'

4!"!

#<:; ## !#4 & :8;

( #@75 *'(" *'( ' 5'!

>*!"!!

5# ( '5!

# (55 #8 #( >*!"!!

# 6" *0( 53 6(! ( + #" ( 0'

!#8 "

# 5* 3 (

-7- *+7'

55 0'

# < :;

% ## 7 !#4 "!

"# '

4!4 "5 #!+ 7''

5!+"& :(;

# 0' %%B3 ( #@75 *' (" + ! 5 ' ( ( 0'

4!"!

%!"+ # !#4 7/ (

! !'!

" !& & 5# 6# '" 6( 6

( !+

!""*#

# ! !

# *# .

A<&#/"*7"

>* #0*' ("

'3 ( '6!"

3 ## !#4 0'

4!"!

<:;

%& <& " 0 ' ( "

'( 7/ ( 0 !!

'3 ( !" 6# ' !#

05 + "*'!#8H">&/"!& &H1'5" +0'!"

!# )("' & CCCC3 BCC "!* 1*G *57#8'3 ("!5 8('!#!"'! +*#8'&( "!5#6" >*!'

7/( .

'/# ('

*8( '7# " 0'+ # 7/ !""*!#8 ! !

#" %&H&H # &H& *# ' .

# < # .

=# >*!"!!

# 3A<

7/6' &B&B

'( 0*75! 0*'0 #+ 5/3 0+ ## !5!G!

5# "

#!53 ++ ' !5 '

' .

' % # < 8('!& " 0 ' ( 0 !!

'3 ( #!'

0 !!

' !" "*''

*# 7/ +#/ '

#!5 7*!5!#8"3 ++ ' !5 "75!"(+ #" 5!2 "( 6'

+" &#( 5#6" *55/ "'

#!5'

( !+

!""*#

! !

#*# #<

A< # / ( . 0'

>*!'

' 5 #8 6!( '5# 6# '"!# 55*"!

#6!(( '!#0'!4 #!G '"& ( !!

'("+!#!# "#(( !"!#0

05 !#>* "!

#!55 #("# '

#/ #!#5!

-8- >*!'

5# +( =# >*!"!!

# 0'+ #3'/#&#4!

"! "( (" 5!+ (( >*!"!!

#0'

!#8">*(!" 5#"(557 5'

"50"

%& H& #'

"*7+!""!

#"+ 7/( !!

'31'&#2*' 1!53 5 '# !!

#5 4 '53 00 '!#8

' .

'/#3(" # (( 0'

#0 !!

#!"">*'

5/ 7/ 0'!# !05 "5! 6#!#

# $# (*"3("0'/

'!"!"+!""5& (""*7+! (( # #!

'7 !#8!#0(/"! 50

5#!"+ '!5 """(

5#6"2 #4!

G#+ ( &H &B&B&5"

3"'

8'"( #!!"(!" # #!

#(( + *#

#6"*5/ !!

'5 #86!( '5# 6# '"6(! ( "#""*7"#! "( !!

'("

0' ##( !5 '

*# #A

A<3( 7/"

2!#8 #(# #!# ## (" '

+ *#

#(# # 6!( '

2("'# &BCCC:HB;3:A;3:A;3+!#:H;3ABCC:B;3C :H<;#BCC:B;&(!"!+05!

"(( !!

'(" ( ##

# !# #!

#55/& # 5!/

"! "*7+!""!

#"31'&1!5("4 ( #5/ # !"+!""( 0'

6'! 0 !!

# " #

#!5 '

>*!'

# !#4 2!#8 .

# < :;

% (" 7

*5 !55 & *'( '3 ( (" "*00 ' ' %&&B 0""

7/ ( '

#" " (4!#8 7

# # +*!

# # & H<< <&B&< 6" # !#

4 *'

! !'/ 0'+ # !& & '/# '7# 0+ *( '!/# '!#85/5#!#>* "!

#"#"4 " !#( .

+ 55 # *+7'# "& 5"

3 " '

8'" ( # ! !" (!"

-9-

# #!

# ( ( + *#

# 6" *5/ !!

' 5 #8 6!( ( ' 5# 6# '" 6(! ( "#" "*7"#! + ( ( *

5 6' + *#

#!'

>*!'

5#!& & "&3AB33C3+ *#

"&B3AH3A3AC"#" !"7*'"

5# 6# '"# *'( '3( !!

'(" !5 '

*# ' .

# A

A< "

2!#8 #(# # !# (

#&(!" 5 '5/!+05!

"(( + *#

#6" *5/ !!

'3( ( ( ## 0( + *# # # 6 ( ## 5!+ ( # # 6" 0! (!+& # 5!/

"! "*7+!""!

#"3 1'& 1!5 (" 4 ( #5/

# !"+!"" ( 0'

# 6'! 0 !!

# " #

#!5 >*!'

# !#4 2!#8 .

# < :;

% ("

*5 !55 & & '(4!#80 '*"

05 !#8"

(( # "!#80'!

" #'

'!#8( !' # #!

#"36 (4 ( "!!

# # 5* ( + '(#!"">*'

5/ 7/( 0'!# !05 "5! 6#7/( .*0'

*'!#( "

# $# 0'/

' 5!+!#850"!#8

>*!"!!

#0'

!#8"

'4 "'

#!#4!

6!#8'

#"$ ; ( *8( ( 0 !!

' (" # ( ( !" !# *5 0(/"! 5 0

5# !# >* "!

#3 ( '3 ( "!4 '+ #!"# #75 !#4!

!# '0'

F0(/"! 5 0 #@ + 7/ ( 0 D *' !#

# $6( !#( #@75 *' (" '! 55/( 5(( 6 '?0 #@*"

!#(

A< (" "+ + #!#8 " (

?0(/"! 5

-10- #@*"

!#.

%&( . '#+ # >*!'

" ( 5# # '6" '#*+

2!#8 0 # 6(! ( !# ( 0'

!" 7/ '

'!#8 0

G#+ ( & H &B&B 0*'"*# 6(! ( 1*!

# & H<< <&B&< 6" "# !

!# 4 *'

! !'/

0'+ #& ( # !

5# 6# ' '

!#" (

5#3 ( !" '

"0""

'3 # "* (

"0""

#*'

'(!"7

!# #7 (5

6# '!& &. &.!# #("7

#2 #7/

'!#8 0

G#+ ( & H &B&B3 05

'(( !"!#0(/"! 50

5# !" (*"3 ( 7/ '

& 55 0 # ("

# '

!# 7/ (!+3 ! !" #5/ " '

"0""

' # # "

6# '&" #"

#!5"

5!+!#850"!#8

>*!"!!

#0'

!#8"8

"& 7; " '""0

#!" '# 3!!""0 !

! "#

#"(( #+ *#6" *5/ # 6" + 4!575 5# 6# '" !# 5*!#8 ( 0 !!

'& # ' "*7"#! "+

(" 7

# + ( +E '!/ + *#

5 #+ *#6"!"7*'"

5# 6# '" *05 6!( ( ( ( 0 !!

' (

!5 '

*# #A

A<"

2!#8

#(# # !# ( + *#

#& (!" !" "*

! !

# "( 6(( #6"*5/ 3 # ( 0 !!

' (" (!+"

( # # '

-11- "+ 3 6(! ( ( !" 5!7 '/ '

& # ! !" "

3 (

# #!#8 # /0'

" '!7 !#.

% 5"

" # (*"3 " #

#!#8 # !

" 0'

" '!7 !#.

%!" *5 !55 3

+!#8 ! !

50"!#8 0'

*# ' .

# < :;

% ## 7 !#4 & .!#

#!#8 # !

"+ #!

!#.

% !" *5 !55 3 " 0

5# "#" 2 # # ( # "#" *5/ 3

3 # 5'!

# " '

8'" 50"!#8

>*!"!!

!#8" #7 + !#( "

(#& B&

0'!#86

5!00'

0'! '

' # #!

1'& 1!5 ( ( . >*!'

' ( 0*75! #+ 5/

0+ # # *!5!G!

5# "

#!5 # ++ ' !5 .

' % # < 8('!& ( 0*75! 0*'0 !" (!

7/ '6!#8C00'

4!#8( 5/ *05#&"0 '( 5/ *05#0'

>*!"!!

#!#>* "!

#3( 5#!#>* "!

#!"4 '/+* ( #!5 (!

0*75! 0*'0 #!

"( 05##!#8

housing board as per the layout plan& (4 #"!

(!"0'

'8*+ #'!"

7/( '

#"#6 '

!# +05 8'

#6!(( "+ " (!"!"#!+0 '# ' 2 0!#+!#6(!5 5!#86!(( "

'!"!#8 *

>*!"!!

5# (!

0*75! 0*'0 #! !" ( . C!" *( '!/ 6( !" !# ( " 0 "!!

# !

7 * *!5!G!

5# >*!'

3 '!(4!#87

#4 " !#. & A& " "

>* 5

7 !" *""!

# # !# 4!

56 "*++'!G !# 0' %%

# 0+ # *( '!/ :"*0';3

-12- !

! 55/ ' (4!#8 '

( !# ( "

!# (#3 '

>*!"! '!

/ '" !" # +05 3 >*!"!!

# 0'

!#8" "# *0( 53 0 # "#" 2 #3 ( 75!8!

' 0/+

# "#" !" ('8 # 5"

#"!

'!#8 ( ( 5# !# >* "!

#!"4 '/+* ( #!5 (!

0*75! 0*'0 36 (4 ( "!!

# ( 5(!#( !#"# "

3( . (" *55/!" ('8 !"

75!8!

#>*7 (( #!#8 # !

" *''!#8!#.

% # ! 7 !#8 "

3 ( 0'

# 0 !!

# + '!" !"+!""5 # ( 3( !#"#0 !!

#!"!"+!""

& & 4!#8 !"+!""

+!# 6'! 0 !!

#3 0 #!#8 005! !

#3 !

#/3 5"

( "+ & .*" >* 3 !

#/3 "#" 4 & :

-.) ; . :

==;

7'*'/%3 #E ( '"0 2!#8C'

"C ( ''

'75 "C