← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23922/2015dismissed

M/S Mahadev Rice & General Mills v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-12-23Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik7 pages



  

    

   

 

!"

 #$#%&'  ()#))  * ( +(, -, ./ %(  *0   

 !

    

   !! (  #( (/%,1 - 2)3 &'3(%0 (  #( # . ..3 &&)  3, ./  #(  4,%)3 &'3((0  5 6  #(  7,% ((3 &'3((0  "  #( - - ((3 &'3((0  8  #( - &(4%

3 &'3((0  9  !

"    %)) 2   % 0(  1( 0    %    % (0  (( 2 % )):   % 0&&7 ( % 7( !";6   % 2(, & % (/(  0(& 2 ( 0 2 , &( -  5  %

(/(  ) 3<<"=(%(>% ?@2 %0 (  % 0 ( %  ))&  ( %))(  +))2 #%/2(%3 A,) 0,(3 ( B,&%  1%  07 9 6<   % 0 (  &/& 2%1(C,::)) 2()7(%): 77( 1%,  7 &,) D0 &,)   % 7( !!<;!3 1%%  0 2 &.,& /(%)( & && )( ,&23% &2(%    0 & , % &;2(  ( 0(,(& /7 -

2 $ (,: )  & % , ./ -  :.(  (/, 2 - 

( % ()0) %% &) 2&;2( C:.((0 /)7 %, ./'( :  '(77(3%-'( : (:0)7 ))&,:#)) 2)7 -,%)7(%7( !"00 &&1% %1(0 

D,(; %&)7& >&,)(? ), =D'@31%(),%&)7&(/%0(&,(()):  0&&7%#)) %()' D((:%0)7(&, &( E  F- ; DD DD =D'@ E,)(G: :))$:))(1%7)(% (&, ( &$()%,  70(,( 22 7$2  %0(',7(=@ &&)& ),=@ G DD DD  

BB#F#BB- ; DD DD   &,)((:))%))/ &(&()): $0(' ) (2( %&,):7/ %))1 2,    (:))%&)'(,::))&( 72 7 0( 2%0(',7( ),& 2 !5;"  D D &  % ( :))(=@ 1% & 2,( (=@ (  7 %( :))( 2  1%:  0)$,(   (2(& ( (/(  0(& 2 (  &   ,   :/HH):   &$(   ,    ;&)'(7  ( () 2,::)) 2()'7(0( 2 7(0 7(3%)) / &(&()): , ),%:))( (1%:2,( 1,( %&3)(%&,)%  ( & 2 7 ) 2 1%  (  % ( ( % ()' 7(=@&&&/7%'( : (:: :  D D   0)$,($(/( 0 22 % :))(   ,   :/HH):   &$(   ,  

 ;&)'(7  (   1'(3  % :))( )( % &,)% ( &2 7) 21%0 ) ( % ( ( % ()'  7(=@3  &&& /7 % '( :  (: :  :3 % :7 /  &(& (

)): 1%,0(.,&%,:%F$,( $ (/( 0 22 %:  2  % :))( 2  1%:   (/(  1(& % / 0& &%)&&0%:, 1(&%)) /  &(&  &,)(  & %))  /  &(& ( )): 3))%%&0&%1(&&:,   D D

7 :))( &)(& &,)(   ,    ;

&)'(7$  ;07:   )'7 ($0 )7 ( % 0(', 7( %)) / (& &,)( , ) % &0 % &, :, $:, &&,&/7F1%,0& (I J     &,)( ( :)) %)) / 0(:&  & ,: :)) 2(  /%) )2/):))(   )2/) (:))%)) 2%0&&7:))&(:&,)(( :))     3 % & 3 % )2/) :))( %)) / /)C)&  0   &,)( :))( %)) / ))1&  0( % :)) =1%%  ),& % ) &   1%%   ,&@ (  ( (    7 %( 0(7 /7 17  2$) ( ) , ) % % / &    (: %  ( & 2 7$2  G % &%0 (%(%C%( !!<;!

3 %0 (1))&0&&7  0(%0 (3:))&% (0&&73 /,% ,%()&)%C3%(1 , (20  % 0   % 0 (  'C& % .,(&   % ,( /7 17  K  958   !! ( &( 2 % (0   ) (3 1%% 1 ))1&'&(&(&&8 !9 !  00)  B  66 ! 2  % & (&(3  1 0 & , % % (/(  0(& 2 %' / &/7%, ./-K(%, 2(0( 2 %0 (  %(00)/( 2B  5 ! !

%&00)1&0& 9 

! %()' D((:% (&(&&9 

! (&, &(  & ()(3 % &(  (2(& 2 0(: 2 %  #))(  )) % ,: :))& (   0  :(C& % )(&7 / ,/ ))7 :&& /7 , '& (&( && !8 !< !   %  L,  &:0) %0(%,::))&(1%% % #))( %& )(&7 )&   0  :(C /( 1  (' &3 %)) %'/2  /7% (/(( %0(& 20 2/1 %, ./-K(%, 2(0(  &%#)) -  1 %((:   (%F)%,::))&(( (  7 0 (  (23 1 &0  % 00) 1%  )((7 &(  % % /('  :& /7 % )( & - 2)

,&232 %00)) (%: (/,&%00))  %))/  L, ) &%'  )1 G  ): ((&% (/((%

, & 1(&

8 !

!5=

D,(;"@1(& 2,: 53883636<6$;  

! 3  % :,  07/) /7 % 0 (  % , ./ - K(%, 2 (0( %0 (&&) /. 0 , &(- 5%

   % & /.  0  %   /  0& /7 % )( &

&& )( ,&2 &%:((: &&% (/(( 

00)   F  9!

 !"0(((&/7%0 (2 %&(&(% /  0& '& (&( && !



!" ,0%)& 2 % (&(  (: 2 /C%&0,% (/((  B( & , ) ( % 0 ( % '%: )7 (2,& % %  %(0  )) 20&&7%0 ( .,& & %  &    % )7 % % 0&&7 %,)&  / ))&  % &,)(, (3, ., & ( 2,0 %(2%%#))(((7 /,   K%'%(&)( &, )(%0( & & :( % 0(  0   %  ?/) -,0(: ,(    .,&2:  (0(& 

"

#&(   &,( +  -) ,%(7   & B:& = !!@ " - 55 D: &%D0( >:, &,(:/,7(32%(1%%:,  (?00( 2 - 6% ( )7&7: -:)) -) &

))(7 &,() &(C 2 3<< %,( &% % 1(& >&,? %  '(7  : 23   &(   D  :7 %' &( : 2   ((1: 23%1(&>&,?:7:0(D& &)&/)2 ()/)7  1&( D%:,  /&/ >&,?

31%%:7/('(&/7 %/ %)&%))1 2 E5 %1(&M&,N%'(7: 23 &(  D:7 %' &(  : 2     ((1 : 23 % 1(& M&,N :7 :0(D& &)&/)2 ()/)7  1&( D% :,  /&/M&,N31%%:7/('(&/7 % :,  %   / ):&  M&,N  & ('(/) /7     :7 :: / ) '(& /7 % D0(  M&,N  % D0( M:, &,(:/,7(N))1&/7%D0( M2%(1%% :,  (N, &(,/; =@- 6<< :,/ (0(&C0 2%0,(0 &/.

<<  &0(' 3 0(,)()7- 35 &" : & %D0( & &(' /2' ((&: 2%1,)&&%1%)0,(0 & /.

  <<   -,/;  =@  -  6 0('& % % :,  &, (: /,7( 2%( 1% :,    ( ),)&  (& 1%%0(' - 5 &"%))/('(/)/7 %,00)((:%/,7(/717,(%(0(& 2, &( 7 )1(%:/ 2 (  5   % (2,:    ( , ) ( % /,7(  0&3 % 1,)&: %1%(%/,7(%(&:&0, (0 2& ,00)& ( (' ( &(& /7 % ,00)( ( &0,& % )/)7:C07: % %,00)(%))%'(0,(,% (:&7(('(7:, &,1(&2&,00)&( (' ( &(&, &((2,)(0(&,( &(%:, &,&.

 = @- 6  DD DD

59  % 2% ,(3   % :0,2 & (&(3 %1'(3 %)& % D0( M:, &,(:/,7(N1,)&/:, &:&/ &, 0)  & ,(): 2 &1% &:&&,:,   0& /7 % /,7(3 % 0('   -    6 ) 2 1% %( 0(' << 1,)&/00)/)  %0  2%,(  %/,7(%))2&/(% (/7%,00)(3%(1

:, &:&/&,()&:,  &3%((3%(1

L, &)7&07:  &(( %&0,%F , &(,/; = @- 611%,.,(& DD DD "!  K &&,)0%( 2%2%,( % (0(  0, /7 % 2% ,( ,0  % D0(  M:,  &, (: % /,7(N  )), ( % (   && /' 1%% 1

& (0 G  % ( :))(  2'  0&&7 ( ,: :)) 2      0&&7 0(,(& /7 % F& (0(    & ( %( - 2 $  (,: ) & (,&%#))((%)) 2 ( :))( &,) %&)'(7(  72(, &1%'(3%-31%% ,( ))71)) /)2 :  ,00)7% , &(% 0,/) &(/,  7:   %((3 C0 2   '1 %  D  & % 0,(0%)73%&,)(1)):  )731%%&&:&)/)7 &%(23/, ),&0( 1%%0 2&,07/)%F& (0(    & ( - 2 $  (,: )   % &    ),=D'@%/2' 1&( &0,(0,) (0( % &   )):     &   ),  =@3  (0(&,& /'3 :C % 0 (&,)(3%)&,00)7,::))&(%F& (0(  & &$(%- 2 $ (,: )   % (&( 0& /7 % )( & - 2) ,&2   % 1( 0 )&/7%0 ( 8 !

9 ! %/ :&&3()7 B  66  !  !8 !< !  &)( B  5 ! !

!  )&:&%%0 (%)&%:))&( 0 :(C, &(

(&(0&/7%)( &- 2)  % %,3 )7%L,   % :,   )  (3 1%%   / &  / 1 0 2 /( %

(/((  (:    ()( (&(0&/7 %,(   %  %% 0 (%&0&%:))&((:%0&&7 (,&  &0, %((3%0 (&,)( F(,%&,)3%(0  (.,& 1%%)& 2,(%(&)'(70&&7, ))(% ( &,   '1%/'31&  & 7:( %0( 1( 0 %:(& 2)7&:&          !

         

#!       

        !! +:)      

#!