Hans Raj v. Uhbvnl And ORS

   

       

!"#$#%&'&()*+
* !('!, #"&"&(#- '

.#-'/'

""!-!-0!(!&,1&.&"-!(&2!34&3&"#$!($"5#-' #'6($#(" '

)  74  8 9 48  -#'#("):

-945&(2-!;$<%!"#;-"5#6#"&"&(#- -84(2&!;$<%!"#;--#'6($#("'  5#"5#-"5##6-"#-'1%!1(#='6!6#-3!0>#!11=#$" '##"5#,/$23#("?

 >#-##--#$""5##6-"#--("  5#"5#-"5#,/$23#("'5/1$>#-#6-"#$&("5#$&2#'"? ::

::

48 

4 5# 6#"&"&(#- =!' =-@&(2  !' !(  ''&'"!("  -#3!( (  !

-/67 76'"=5#(5#-#"&-#$(

!"#--#($#-&(23-#"5!( 0#!-' '#-<&%# 5#6#"&"&(#-&'!22-&#<#$"5#!%""5!"<&$#1#""#- $!"#$*
+ ((#A/-#::
;!'/3';*;**B :5!'>##($#$/%"#$ /" =&"5/"&''/&(2!(0'5=%!/'#("&%#-%5!-2#'5##"# '##@'"5#C/!'5&(2"5#'!&$1#""#-$!"#$*
+ ((#A/-#::
5# 6#"&"&(#-/-"5#-%1!&3'"5!" '3#"5#6!03#("'=#-#-#1#!'#$=&"5 $#1!0   #  -#"&-#$  -3  -#'6($#(":$#6!-"3#("  (  

 !($  5&' 6#('&(=!''!(%"&(#$(+*
+ ((#A/-#:: !($"5!"!("5#-'/3 ' ;+*;*+ :(!%%/(" =!'!1''!(%"&(#$(*
+;

<&$#1#""#-$!"#$*
+ ((#A/-#::
 /""5&'(10;';+; :

=!'-#1#!'#$!($"5#-#3!&(&(2!3/("';*;**B :=!'=&"55#1$ /-"5#-;!'/3';D;D  :(!%%/("%33/"!"&(6#('&(=!'

:
:

-#1#!'#$(*
+;<&$#1#""#-$!"#$*
+ ((#A/-#:: &#!"#- 3-#"5!(
3("5'"5#-#"&-#3#(""5#6#"&"&(#- /""5# ;

!(!3/("';*;**B :&'0#"">#-#1#!'#$ 5#6#"&"&(#-%1!&3' &("#-#'"("5#'!&$$#1!0#$6!03#("' ("5#=-&""#('"!"#3#(";-#'6($#("'5!<#"!@#("5#'"!($"5!" "5#6#"&"&(#-=!'&''/#$!%5!-2#'5##"(

 ((#A/-#::  "#-%('&$#-&(2"5##A61!(!"&("5#6#"&"&(#-;"5#'!3#=!'$-66#$; <&$#-$#-$!"#$

 
+  ((#A/-#::
!($"5#-#!"#-;"5#6!03#("'

=#-#6-%#''#$!($-#1#!'#$6-36"10#2!-$&(2"5#=&"551$&(2!'/3 ';*;**B :;&"=!''"!"#$&("5#=-&""#('"!"#3#(""5!"('5=%!/'# ("&%#=!'-#C/&-#$">#&''/#$"=!''"!"#$"5!""5#'!&$!3/("&'( !%%/("'5-"!2#3!"#-&!1!($"-!('-3#-&1!($"5#!3/("=!' $#$/%"#$!'6#-"5#-#C/#'""5#6#"&"&(#-5&3'#1 ((#A/-#:: 5# '!&$!-"&%1#'=#-#'"!"#$">#&(5&'%5!-2# 5!<#5#!-$"5#1#!-(#$%/('#1'->"5"5#6!-"&#'!($5!<# !1'%!-#/1102(#"5-/25"5#&1# 8!-!'=&"551$&(2';*;**B :/""5# &'

%(%#-(#$;-#'6($#("'5!<#6-$/%#$(&1#"5#=-&"&(2'5-"!2# 3!"#-&!16--3!';-/((&(2&("'#<#-!16!2#';'/>3&""#$>0"5#6#"&"&(#- !($$/10'&2(#$>05&3;=5#-#&(5#5!'3#("&(#$"5#C/!("&"0;!3/("!($ -#C/#'"#$-=-&"&(2%#-"!&(!3/("!($!1'3#("&(#$-#%<#-!>1# !3/(" "&''&2(#$>0"5#6#"&"&(#-5&3'#1(*
EEEE!($
 EEEEE 3'""5#3!-#*"5#%#3>#-!($0#!-("3#("&(#$!($'3# "5#3!-#"5#%#3>#-!($0#!-("3#("&(#$ "5!'>##(!-2/#$ (>#5!1-#'6($#("'"5!"'&(%#"5#6#"&"&(#-5&3'#1'/>3&""#$"5# '5-"!2#3!"#-&!1&(5&'%("-1!($-#C/#'"#$-=-&"&(2%#-"!&(

::

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

110 ;'"!"&(2"5!""5#'#=#-#>"!&(#$>0%#-%&(->0/($/#&(1/#(%# 5#-#-#;"5#61#!>#&(2!(&11&"#-!"#6#-'(&'("!<!&1!>1#5#-#-#; "5#-#%<#-0##%"#$!'6#-"5#-#C/#'""5#6#"&"&(#-$&$("-#C/&-#"5# 6-&-'5=%!/'#("&%#5#-#-#;"5#6-!0#--$&-#%"&(2-#'6($#("'" 6!0';*;**B :&'$#%1&(#$ =;%3&(2""5#6!03#("$#1!0#$6!03#("';&"%3#'/" "5!""5#6!03#("6#('&(;%33/"!"&(6#('&(!($ =#-# -#1#!'#$(+*
+!($*
+-#'6#%"&<#10&#!"#-!$#1!0!>/"
3("5'5#61#!-#'6($#("'&'"5!"!%5!-2#'5##"=!'&''/#$""5# 6#"&"&(#- (

 ((#A/-#:: !($"5!""5#'!3#=!'$-66#$ (

 
+;!"#->"!&(&(2"5##A61!(!"&(;<&$#-$#-((#A/-#::
 5#-#-#;"5#6!03#("'=#-#6-%#''#$1!"#-(

:+:

  !3    "5#  <&#=  "5!"  &  "5#  %5!-2#'5##"  =!'  &''/#$  (

;"5#'!3#=!'-#C/&-#$">#$#%&$#$ #A6#$&"&/'10 5# $#6!-"3#("%!(("@##6"5#'!3#6#($&(2-!>/""5-##0#!-'!($"5#( $-6"5#'!3#5#-#-#;-"5#$#1!0#$6!03#("';"5#$#6!-"3#("&'"># 5#1$  -#'6('&>1#   8&(%#  "5#  $#6!-"3#("  5!'  @#6"  "5#  !3/("    "5# 6#"&"&(#-;"5#-#-#;"5#$#6!-"3#("&'1&!>1#"6!0"5#&("#-#'"5#-#-#; '"!-"&(2"5-##3("5'-3"5#$!"#-#"&-#3#(""5#6#"&"&(#-"&11"5# 6!03#(";-#'6($#("''5!11>#1&!>1#"6!0&("#-#'"!""5#-!"#F6#- !((/3("5#$#1!0#$6!03#("'3!$#(*
+!($+*
+ 5# &("#-#'"("5#$#1!0#$6!03#("'>#-#1#!'#$""5#6#"&"&(#-=&"5&("5-## 3("5'-3"5#$!"#-#%#&6"%#-"&&#$%60"5&'-$#- (<&#="5#3!""#-; "5#6-#'#(" =-&"6#"&"&(&'6!-"10 !11=#$ 

48   

*+
* ',@' 5#"5#-'6#!@&(2 -#!'(#$ ) #' 5#"5#-#6-"!>1# )