High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2449/2020dismissed

Pawan Kumar v. Ram Karan And Others

2022-08-05Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj5 pages

#$%&#'#()**+,-).'/(0*$.1(.'0$ '$"#)2(3,+(1'#,0 )**+,-)',$.%.1(/(-',$. 3$/*/(*$.(4(.'$3

565 0((7,.& 2)-)',$.$3,.'(/,40')890')'%0 :%$;$/1(/1)'(1 <%'

+()/.(1-$%.0(+*/)80'#)'4),.-)0(<(')7(.$.<$)/13$/#()/,.&

$',-(,.'#()**+,-)',$.

''#,00')&( / %/(0#

,.1)+12$-)'()--(*'0.$',-($.

<(#)+3$3'#(.$.)**+,-).'=*(',',$.(/).11$(0.$'$**$0('#(*/)8(/

**+,-)',$. ,0 )++$>(1 ).1 %*$. $/)+ /(:%(0' $3 <$'# '#( +()/.(1-$%.0(+3$/'#(*)/',(04),.-)0(,0*/(*$.(1'$'$1)83$/#()/,.&

!"# #( *(',',$.(/9*+),.',33; #)0 3,+(1 '#,0 /(2,0,$. *(',',$. '$ -#)++(.&('#($/1(/1)'(1"

*)00(1<8'#(11+ ,0'/,-'%1&(

).,*)',.

?$3>#(/(<8'#($/1(/1)'(15 *)00(1<8 '#( ,2,+%1&(9/ ,2.

;).,*)',. ,2,+%,'$ "6$3)++$>,.&#,0 )**+,-)',$.%.1(/ /1(/"6 %+( >)0/(2(/0(1

#(</,(33)-'0$3'#(-)0()/('#)''#(*(',',$.(/9*+),.',33;3,+(1 )0%,'3$/*(/4).(.').14).1)'$/8,.@%.-',$./(+)',.&'$'#(1,0*%'($2(/) -$44$.>)++1,2,1,.&#,0*/$*(/'8>,'#'#(*/$*(/'8$3'#(1(3(.1).'0 9/(0*$.1(.'0$ '$";

#(*+),.',33A0-+),4,0<)0(1%*$.'#(&/$%.1'#)' */(2,$%0+8'#/$%&# ,2,+%,'$ B=1(-,1(1$."

"'#(0#)/(0 $3 '#( *)/',(0 ,. '#( -$44$. >)++ #)2,.& >,1'# $3 " ,.-#(0 >(/( 1('(/4,.(1,.(:%)+0#)/(0'$'#((C'(.'$3BD,.-#(0()-# ,.-('#( 1(3(.1).'0$ '$">(/(/),0,.&-$.0'/%-',$.<82,$+)',.&'#(0),11(-/(( '#(/(3$/(#(*/(3(//(1'#(0%,''$0((7,.@%.-',$.)&),.0'#,4).1*/)8(13$/ 3$++$>,.&/(+,(30 E

! # ! $! % !

# &

"F +$.&>,'#'#(0%,'#(3,+(1).)**+,-)',$.%.1(/ /1(/"6 %+( 3$/)1,.'(/,4,.@%.-',$.

" #(0%,',0<(,.&-$.'(0'(1<8'#(1(3(.1).'0>#$*+()1(1'#)' '#(-$.0'/%-',$./(+)',.&'$'#(-$44$.>)++,0-$.3,.(1'$'#(,/0#)/($.+8 ).1,'#)0<((.-$4*+('(1%*'$/$$3+(2(+$3'#(3,/0'3+$$/ %/'#(/,'>)0 )+0$%.1(/')7(.<8'#(4'#)',.-)0(,',03$%.1'$<($.).8*)/'$3'#( *+),.',3300#)/('#(8>$%+11(4$+,0#,')''#(,/$>.(C*(.0( 0*(/>/,''(.

0')'(4(.''#(*+),.',33#)1)+/()18-$.0'/%-'(1'#(>)++$.#,00,1(>#$ (.-/$)-#(1%*$.'#(0#)/($31(3(.1).'$ ).1+),1)-$%.'(/-+),4'$ 0((7)1(-/((3$/4).1)'$/8,.@%.-',$.1,/(-',.&'#(*+),.',33'$/(4$2(#,0 ,++(&)+(.-/$)-#4(.'

(3(.1).'$ ? %.,-,*)+ $/*$/)',$.3,+(1)3$/4)+ /(*+8'#)',.-)0('#(-$.0'/%-',$.,03$%.1'$<(>,'#$%'*/,$/*(/4,00,$. )-',$.>$%+1<(')7(.

$.0,1(/,.&'#(*+()1,.&0).10%<4,00,$.0$3'#(*)/',(0'#( '/,)+ $%/' 2,1( ,'0 $/1(/ 1)'(1 5 */$-((1(1 '$ 1,0*$0( $3 '#( *+),.',33A0)**+,-)',$.%.1(/ /1(/"6 %+( <8/(0'/),.,.&'#( 1(3(.1).'0$ '$"3/$4/),0,.&).83%/'#(/-$.0'/%-',$.$.).8*$/',$.$3 '#( -$44$. >)++ &&/,(2(1 )&),.0' '#,0 ,.@%.-',$. '#( 1(3(.1).'0 */(3(//(1).)**()+).1'#(0)4(>)0)--(*'(1<811+ ,0'/,-'%1&( ).,*)'2,1(,4*%&.(1$/1(/1)'(1"

!()/.(1-$%.0(+3$/'#(*(',',$.(/#)0)/&%(1'#)''#('/,)+ $%/'

#)1 -)/(3%++8(C)4,.(1 '#(3)-'0).1 -,/-%40').-(0 $3'#(-)0(<(3$/( )//,2,.&)')-$.-+%0,$.'#)''#(1(3(.1).'0$ '$")/((.-/$)-#,.&%*$.

*)/'$3'#(*/$*(/'8$3'#(*+),.',33).1/(0'/),.,.&'#(4<%''#()**(++)'(

$%/'#)0/(2(/0(1'#(0),1$/1(/<81,04,00,.&#,0,.@%.-',$.)**+,-)',$.

!()/.(1-$%.0(+#)0)/&%(1'#)''#('/,)+ $%/'#)1)**$,.'(1)!$-)+

$44,00,$.(/'$,.0*(-''#(0%,'*/$*(/'8).1'#(0),1/(*$/'9..(C%/(

? ";)+$.&>,'#'#(0,'(*+).-+()/+80#$>0'#)''#(1(3(.1).'0$ '$")/( /),0,.& -$.0'/%-',$. $. *,++)/0 %*'$ 3,/0' 3+$$/ ).1 '#$%&# '#(/( ,0 .$ (.-/$)-#4(.'$.&/$%.13+$$/<%''#(-$.0'/%-',$.)<$2('#(&/$%.13+$$/ 0#$>0(.-/$)-#4(.'$.'#(*$/',$.$3'#(*/$*(/'83)++,.&,.'#(0#)/($3'#( *+),.',33 --$/1,.&'$#,4<$'#'#(*)/',(0#)2((:%)+0#)/(0'$'#((C'(.' $3 BD ,.-#(0 ,. '#( -$44$. >)++ <%' >,'# '#,0 (.-/$)-#4(.' '#( 1(3(.1).'0/(0*$.1(.'0$ '$"#)2(-$2(/(1'#(>)++'$'#((C'(.'$36 ,.-#(0 (*/)80'#)''#(,4*%&.(1$/1(/1)'(1"

<(0(')0,1().1 '#(,.@%.-',$.$/1(/1)'(15 *)00(1<8'#('/,)+ $%/'<(/(0'$/(1

#(*/)8(/,0$**$0(1<8'#(1(3(.1).'0/(0*$.1(.'0$ '$"

$.'#(&/$%.1 '#)''#(-$.0'/%-',$. /),0(1 <8'#(*+),.',33*(',',$.(/,0 -$.3,.(1 $.+8 '$ '#( *$/',$. $>.(1 <8 '#( 1(3(.1).'0 $ '$ " ).1 )--$/1,.&'$#,4'#(-$.0'/%-',$.#)0)+/()18/()-#(1'$'#(3,/0'3+$$/).1 >#(/()0$.*+),.',33A00,1('#(/(,0.$-$.0'/%-',$.'$%-#,.&'#(-$44$. >)++ (#)0 )/&%(1 '#)' '#( )**(++)'( $%/' #)0 /,&#'+8(C(/-,0(1 '#( )**(++)'( @%/,01,-',$. ,. (C)4,.,.& '#( <)+).-( $3 -$.2(.,(.-( )0 '#( ,.'(/,4,.@%.-',$.>$%+1-)%0(,//(*)/)<+(+$00'$'#(1(3(.1).'0

%/,.&'#(-$%/0($3#()/,.&#(#)01/)>.'#()''(.',$.$3'#(

$%/''$'#('#(*#$'$&/)*#0$3'#(>)++)**(.1(1>,'#

6"?B )0..(C%/(9-$++8;).1*/)8(13$/1,04,00)+$3'#(*(',',$.

3'(/#()/,.&'#(+()/.(1-$%.0(+).1-$.0,1(/,.&'#(4)'(/,)+ $./(-$/1*)/',-%+)/+8'#(+(2(+$3-$.0'/%-',$.>#,-##)0/()-#(1)<$2('#( 3,/0'3+$$/'#,0 $%/'3,.10'#)''#(*+),.',33#)03),+(1'$(0')<+,0# ! -)0(,.#,03)2$%/ #(1,0*%'(/(+)'(0'$)-$44$.>)++).1)--$/1,.& '$*+),.',33)04)++*$/',$.,0<(,.&(.-/$)-#(1<81(3(.1).'0).1,'-).<(

3,.)++81(-,1(1$.'#(<)0,0$3(2,1(.-('#(/(3$/()''#,00')&(<)+).-($3 -$.2(.,(.-()+0$+,(0,.3)2$%/$3'#(1(3(.1).'/(0*$.1(.' (0,1(0'#( 3)-'0).1-,/-%40').-(0$3'#(-)0(/(2()+'#)',.-)0(,.@%.-',$.)**+,-)',$. ,0)++$>(1'#(1(3(.1).',0&$,.&'$0%33(/,//(*)/)<+(+$00 %/'#(/) *(/%0)+$3'#(,4*%&.(1$/1(/0#$>0'#)''#()**(++)'( $%/'#)0-$.0,1(/(1 '#(4(/,'0$3'#(-)0(,.)*/$*(/4)..(/).1'#(0)4(1$(0.$'0%33(/3/$4 ,++(&)+,'8$/,4*/$*/,('8

(0%+').'+8'#,0 $%/'1$(0.$'3,.1).84(/,',.'#,0/(2,0,$. ).1'#(0)4(,01,04,00(1

%&%0'

%+)', $% #('#(/ (*$/')<+( (0=$ #('#(/*()7,.&= ()0$.(1 (0=$