M/S Doon Caterer Railway Catering Contractor v. Union Of India And ORS
!"
#
$" !"#$%& '()*+& *&'+"& )+",!
!+")
%
&'&(&#" '#)# *"+,! & &&'&-.*"+,.
# &# -/ *"+,! $"& *&'+"& )+",!
!+") '
-.
1.2 , & .11"
+"
3, ,$ 3'11&45 1! 6&57* 1.2 ' *( "# + "1 ,.# ,#.+1 "! $
"!72 ,66, 3.&&!&89&:&8;;: $8<&:&8;45& .#3 "
= !
689&:&8;4588&8&8;47& ' >? 12*# = .3 +.&&!&8@&8&8;478<&:&8;4< &&1$
"!= !@ 2 ""
# 11 ,$
"!72 & # .
$ #>!
1" 3 ""
4A&9&8;4<B=
44C$">2#' + 166 , 1 3 * # 1.2* D$ + * D$ " 6!
.# ,# # ? $$1 6" >2# $ 4;&9&8;4< !
!
# = !, ,? #11 ? *#>",1 "& 1! #+#612 3 "#
6 #"#
#,!
! #$%& '" ( ''& #"
)+ .##
3 1 ,2!8;4; $$12"#66> !
#$ , # 1" .1!#
1 , >-, !2 3#,"
$ 1" $ 4A&4&@"4A&8&4!
#
3 1 ,2*8;4;& 1!
# >6 ##", !# "#
.,#113">2#"
1.2>! #E>1$= >2.2!+
'&(& .# ,#. ,+ "
+ 1$$1"#E>1' $ 6 )+ .## $ + !#
3 1 ,2*8;4;. $$1 ,>1#,, "
$""#, !# 1.2 3 3 .1!
, # 66> ! # $" # > 2* >1* !
""
,
2& + 3# ", 1! 13#"#+ 3 $ "#$1"
3 , "*# !#, "+ .# # !
2 # ""4A&9&8;4<=
44& # "
$ .
# 3 "#!, 1$ ## ,! 311#">3 "#$ ! $
"!7 2 112 &&!
689&:&8;;:8<&:&8;45& ## ! > "= .1! $
"!@2 && $8<&:&8;4<& 1 4< ! #
3 1 ,2* 8;4; ,1 12 #
.1.
11>6 !
3#"##1 ,6 $$12!
.16 6 6 =6# "+,>! #=$
2!#, ,& ,""12*#1= 3 " !+ !#$ . $ 8<&:&8;4<&# $ $$1 6">2#$ .12 4;&9&8;4< &&$$ = 61257"2$
#=$
2!#, ,& ,6 $ >! # > ,# !
$ ,1 "
3!)*+&,)#$%*
/0 1 ""# ,,"$ ".# ,#.", ""45&:&8;4<&
# #$ "#- "36""45&:&8;4<$"
B $ C=
58&#, "+ .!# *#$ # 12 "#$ # & +# 3#*# 3*, 1! . 1" -, ,"# ,! B $ C#11#"1 "2> ,1"> #. 1">!,? , 6 ,#+ #$ ,#, ,1 ,$
"!#$ "=$
"8<&:&8;4< " 12>2+
!,
6"
, ##$
, $ & # 1+$ !#- "36 B $ C .# ,##> " "! ,
3#- "36!#"#
1#- "36!#E>1' $ 6 ,B $ C " #!11.
3 6%
!
"
# #
$% &'$'(
)
##
* ( "
+
2
3 "
# )
+
!)%,4&#)#$%* )4) # #
#
&'$'(
# +
#
* ( "
+,(
- -
#
- -
#
!$'!&'$%
-#
# . # #
# / "
# 0(1 2 ! 3&'$3 4*5
6
7
8# #
9
#
-
/ "
&'':&'$3 #
- / "
3612
3 "
)
#
#
#
!)%,4&#)#$%* )')
)/0 )123- 4
56 782- ' '(,&9 # .
$ 1 "
6 " # 1 3# !
3#> , "">2# ,# B $ C&
"
6 "& 11#$"
3$$1 BC1""
$"!&
*&'+"& )+",!
!+")
'(,&
1 ,)2 F## $) 3 "% F## $ >1%