M/S S.K Industries v. State Of Haryana & ORS

   
    

     
    

     
    

     
    

  











 


  



 !

"#   



 !

"#   



 !

"#   



 !

"# !$% & '()%*+,-%*.+)/.,*%0+0+,-*+.,1-%.

&)23+.3+23

-*,*,'-+ -+%)% *3*-3+43'33'(*.-+%

-%0'(-'*%
! 5
! 5
! 5
! 5 

 ! 
 7  

 ! 
 7  

 ! 
 7  

 ! 
 7 """"
 
  
 
  
 
  
 
 









 ! 
 

  

 

 ! 
 

  

 

 ! 
 

  

 

 ! 
 

  

 +-%-'* +-%-'* +-%-'* +-%-'* !+  3(31"(183*-+*.-0-*,*,'-+ !+ 3.)9 -1,'/." -0)*4(183*--'-+39" 3+43'3 !+ :-%.,'.39"(183*-+  ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;<  

  

"  

  

"  

  

"  

  

" ','()%*+,3909*3(52-3%)+,'/#%= 2*+% 399**-( **.-0-*,*,'-+5,+2' >3%+-%)2-(1,(-+(-+(3*-(   03%%-(?4*.- %*3*- ,8-+" ")+/3''*.- /+)'(    ''58'%*+)8*,'

  *3*)*+4  300-39  .31,'/  ?--'

0+--++-("  *.-  +-%)20*,'  +(-+  >3%  %-*  3%,(-  ?4  *.- (2,',%*+3*+"   "  )+/3'  ,'  *.-  9,/.*    +(-+  (3*-(  @ .-+-1,%,'0-*,*,',9-(?4 )'(-+-8*,'@ ABC*.-3+43'3+?3' -1-902-'*)*.+,*48*"D@@.3% ?--'399>-(?4*.- +,'8,039-8+-*3+4*1-+'2-'*3+43'3" >'3'(
)'*+4 93'','/ -03+*2-'*"+-%0'(-'* "1,(-

 +(-+(3*-( *.-+-?4+-%*+,'/*.-+(-++-%)20*,' 03%%-(?4*.- %*3*- ,8-+  -*,*,'-+5,+2%--:%3>+,*8-+*,+3+,*=)3%.*.- ,20)/'-(  +(-+  (3*-(   "  ''-E)+-  @"  03%%-(  ?4 +-%0'(-'* , - -1,%,'39)*.+,*4 -3+'-(8)'%-9300-3+,'/'?-.39*.-0-*,*,'-+ >)9(  %)?2,*  *.3*  *.-  00-993*-  )*.+,*4  , -  (2,',%*+3*+"

 ")+/3','*.-+(-+(3*-( @"''-E)+- ".3( %-*  3%,(-  *.-  +-%)20*,'  +(-+  %)?F-8*  *  0342-'*    ()-%" -E*-'%,'  --  -*8  3'(  .3(  /+3'*-(  3  0-+,(    '-  4-3+  * 8209-*-  8'%*+)8*,'  3%  39%  *  %*3+*  822-+8,39  0+()8*,' +2*.-(3*-(-9,1-+40%%-%%,'*.-09* *.3%?--'

8'*-'(-(*.3*3*-+%-**,'/3%,(-*.-+-%)20*,'+(-+"*.- 0-*,*,'-+.3(+-0-3*-(94300+38.-( *.-,8-+-%0'(-'*

, - %*3*- ,8-+" ")+/3'+(-9,1-+40%%-%%,'

*.-,'()%*+,3909*"?)*)*%.--+.3+3%%2-'*"0%%-%%,'>3% '*(-9,1-+-(  .,%9-(**.-,9,'/32-+84300-39?4*.- 0-*,*,'-+  (3*-(    @  ?-+-  *.-  (2,',%*+3*+"   "

)+/3'%--:,'/(,+-8*,'% +/+3'*0%%-%%,'3%39%+ -E*-'%,'*,2-+8'%*+)8*,'3'(*,209-2-'**.-0+F-8*
3*-/+,83%%-+*,'23(-?4*.-8)'%-9,%*.3**.-2-+84300-39 0+--++-(>3%*+-3*-(3%3+-1,%,'0-*,*,'3'(*.-+-3*-+"*.- 0-*,*,'-+5,+2'13+,)%(3*-%>3%,'+2-(*.3*%)8.+-1,%,' 0-*,*,'>)9(?-0%*-(+.-3+,'/,'()-8)+%-  8)2-'*% 0938-('+-8+(3*''-E)+-% @" D" 3'( .31-?--' 3(1-+*-(*%)?%*3'*,3*-%)8.3%%-+*,'

*,%*.-83%-%-*)0'

?-.39*.-0-*,*,'-+*.3*,*,%'94' , - *.-(3*-

03%%,'/*.-,20)/'-(+(-+?4+-%0'(-'* 3*''-E)+- @*.3*,*?-832-3>3+-*.3**.-+-1,%,'0-*,*,'.3(",'38*" ?--',9-(?4 3/3,'%**.-+(-+*.-(2,',%*+3*+(3*-(  @ *.3%?--'3+/)-(*.3**.-0-*,*,'-+>3%'-1-+0)* *'*,8-3%+-/3+(%*.-+-1,%,'*.3*.3(?--',9-(?4  )+*.-+2+-"  ,*  .3%  ?--'  8'*-'(-(  *.3*  *.-  0-+)%39    *.- ,20)/'-(+(-+>)9(",*%-9"+-1-39*.3*3','+(,'3*-(-934 (34%,',9,'/*.-+-1,%,'0-*,*,'.3(?--'8'('-(>,*.)* -1-'  3'  3009,83*,'  %--:,'/  8'('3*,'  *.-+-  .31,'/  ?--' ,9-( -+  8'*+3"  9-3+'-(  8)'%-9  300-3+,'/  +  *.- +-%0'(-'*53)*.+,*,-%>)9(+--+*
93)%-%3'(*.- 399*2-'*9-**-+(3*-( "''-E)+- "3%0-+>.,8.*.- 0-*,*,'-+>3%+-=),+-(*8209-*-8'%*+)8*,'3'(,209-2-'* *.

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

# 31,'/.-3+(9-3+'-(8)'%-9+*.-03+*,-%3*9-'/*." >-  3+-  ,'89,'-(  *  +-23'(  *.-  23**-+  ?38:  *  *.-  -1,%,'39 )*.+,*4+03%%,'/3'+(-+3+-%.

 9-3(,'/%'+-8+(>)9( +-1-39*.3*3*-+*.-0-*,*,'-+.3(,9-(32-+84300-39(3*-(   @  %--:,'/  (-9,1-+4    0%%-%%,'"  *.- 
.,- (2,',%*+3*+" A-/39
-99C" 3'8.:)93.3(%-+1-()0'*.- 0-*,*,'-+  2-2  (3*-(  B B  *+-3*,'/  *.-  %32-  *  ?-  3 +-1,%,'0-*,*,'3'(.3((,+-8*-(.,2*)+',%.*.-+-=),%,*--- ,'+-/3+(*.-+-* --G$5>3%()94(-0%,*-(1,(-(-23'( (+3*  (3*-(   B  ,'  31)+   
.,-  (2,',%*+3*+"   "

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

 *.,'/.3%?--'?+)/.** )+'*,8-?49-3+'-(8)'%-9300-3+,'/+*.-+-%0'(-'*%* %.>*.3**.-0-*,*,'-+.3(?--'()94%-+1-(3%+-/3+(%*.- +-1,%,'  0-*,*,'  ,9-(  ?4     3/3,'%*  *.-  +(-+    *.- (2,',%*+3*+%-**,'/3%,(-*.-+(-++-%)20*,' '(-+  %)8.  0-8)9,3+  8,+8)2%*3'8-%  3'(  *  9-31-  ' %80-+/+,-13'8-">-%-*3%,(-*.-+(-+(3*-( 3* ''-E)+-  @  3'(  +-23'(  *.-  23**-+  ?38:  *  *.-  -1,%,'39

# )*.+,*4  +  03%%,'/  3'  +(-+  3+-%.  3*-+  3+(,'/  ()- 00+*)',*4.-3+,'/**.-03+*,-%8'8-+'-( *,%+-=)-%*-( *.3*%)8.-E-+8,%-+-58'%,(-+3*,'?--E0-(,*-(3'(",'3'4 83%-"8'89)(-(>,*.,'30-+,(*>2'*.%+2*.-(3*- +-8-,0*3804*.,%+(-+ 998'*-'*,'%3'(%)?2,%%,'% >,*.+-/3+(*+-%)20*,'*.-,'()%*+,3909*,'=)-%*,'3+- :-0*0-'

*,%)+*.-+893+,,-(*.3*>-.31-'*-E0+-%%-(3'4 0,','>,*.+-/3+(**.-23,'*3,'3?,9,*4*.-2-+84300-39 *.3*  .3(  ?--'  0+--++-(  ?4  *.-  0-*,*,'-+  3'(  *.- 0+34-+%$8'*-'*,'%+3,%-(*.-+-,'

@ -*,*,'(,%0%-(,'*.-3?1-%3,(*-+2% A  7 C A  7 C A  7 C A  7 C A 

  

C A 

  

C A 

  

C A 

  

C    
 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 

 

 

 

 

 !

"#

 !

"#

 !

"#

 !

"# ! ! ! !

*-

*-

*-

*- .-*.-++--++-(*-0+*-+JA -%$ C .-*.-++--++-(*-0+*-+JA -%$ C .-*.-++--++-(*-0+*-+JA -%$ C .-*.-++--++-(*-0+*-+JA -%$ C