← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24683/2014disposed of

Sanjeev Dhawan & ORS v. Chief Administrator Huda & ORS

2015-09-03Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan,Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal3 pages



     

"#$ $%&'&()  *

+ ,"(-$$./"0"(#/$1'

$#&#&($1'

3$1'4'

/&$ 56&(&'#1"#1#/$1'

$'7(5$(#'

 

  

      

1$'$(#)2 ' &#"8/9&:,15.%"#$0&#/ '4($$#8"41:5.%"#$ 1#/$7$#&#&($1' 1$$7";"9<"(:559:"1<"(" === 

/$7$#&#&($1''$$;"1&# $1#&1"1&#>4"'/#/$5$6"(5

$?#$('&(  $$    '+: : @2  1"&'$5  .&5$  9$##$1  5"#$5  +



A  "

5&1$%#&(##/$1$'7(5$(#'#&''4$#/$ &("9#1"('

$19$##$1@%%47"#&(9$##$1 &(1$'7$%# #/$71$6&'$'0/&%/"1$'4B-$%#6"##$1 #/$7$#&#&("(5 1"

41#/$1  5&1$%#&(  #  1$'7(5$(#2   #  1$ 4(5  #/$  "64(#  

@27"&5B<#/$7$#&#&($1'#0"15'#/$$?#$('&( $$ /$7$#&#&($1'/".$741%/"'$5#/$B#/ 16#/$1&C&("9 "99##$$$'7&#$1$7$"#$51$>4$'#'"(515$1' #/&'%41##/$1$'7(5$(#'

/".$(#$'#"B9&'/$5#/$B"'&' 11"&'&(C#/$&674C($55$6"(5 "B4#

'+ 9"%'/$6"##$1/"'B$$("5-41($5 16#&6$##&6$#$("B9$#/$ 1$'7(5$(#'# &9$"1$79</$15$15"#$5 D

+1$%15$5#/"#9$"1($5 %4('$9"77$"1&(C 1 /"5(&('#14%#&('&(#/$6"##$1"(5#/$($0 5.%"#$  '4C/#  #&6$  #  '$$;  &('#14%#&('  <  "  41#/$1  15$1  5"#$5



+#/$6"##$10"'"5-41($5<$#"C"&(#$("B9$#/$1$'7(5$(#'#

&9$#/$1$79<.$(#5"<:("

&5".&#&(1$79</"'B$$( &9$5

22 ('&5$1&(C  #/$  "B.$  "%#'  "(5 %&1%46'#"(%$': 0$ '$$  ( -4'#& &%"#&(&(#/$1$'7(5$(#'0&#//95&(C#/$%%47"#&(9$##$1@#1"(' $1 9$##$1&(1$'7$%# #/$B#/&(>4$'#&(0$.$1:4# "B4(5"(#%"4#&( "(5#9$".$(16 1C1&$."(%$:0$&(#$(571#$%#&(C#/$1&C/#' #/$ 1$'7(5$(#':& "(< #&'"9'&671#"(##(#$#/"##/$7$#&#&($1'/".$ "99$C$5  #/"#  0&#/  "  .&$0  #  B4<&(C  7$"%$:  #/$<  7"&5  "  5$6"(5  

@2  ( 



   $  &(#$(5  71#$%#&(C  #/$  1&C/#'    #/$ 7$#&#&($1'#%9"&6"1$ 4(5 #/&'"64(#"9' 4('$9  "77$"1&(C  (  B$/"9    7$#&#&($1'  "C1$$'  "(5 4(5$1#";$'(B$/"9  7$#&#&($1'("(5(##5&'7'$ :"9&$("#$:

$(%46B$11%1$"#$"(<#/&157"1#<1&C/#'&(1$'7$%# #/$B#/&(>4$'#&(:

0&#/4##/$01&##$(7$16&''&(  4(5$1"(<%&1%46'#"(%$' /&'

0495'"

$C4"15#/$%9"&6& "(< #/$1$'7(5$(#' /$01&#7$#&#&(&':#/$1$ 1$:5&'7'$5 B<#/$ 990&(C 15$1)2 &!

/$  1$'7(5$(#'  "1$  5&1$%#$5  #  &''4$  #/$  &("9  #1"('

$1 9$##$1@%%47"#&(9$##$1&(1$'7$%# #/ :,$%#1 *: "1#2:

"1&5"B"5&( ".41 7$#&#&($1('"(5 &&! (($?41$ 2&$E$##$15"#$5 +



&'>4"'/$5"(5'$# "'&5$ &&&! /$4(5$1#";&(C(B$/"9  7$#&#&($1('"(5 (## 5&'7'$ :"9&$("#$:$(%46B$11%1$"#$"(<#/&157"1#<1&C/#'&(1$'7$%#

#/$B#/&(>4$'#&(:0&#/4##/$01&##$(7$16&''&(  4(5$1"(< %&1%46'#"(%$':&'"%%$7#$5"(5&#'15$1$5 &.! /$1$'7(5$(#'"1$"#9&B$1#<#1"&'$"5$6"(5" #$1C&.&(C 5$#"&9$57"1#&%49"1'B<0"< $?#$('&( $$/$5$6"(5:/0$.$1:'/"99

22 (#B$$( 1%$5#&99"

#$1#/$$?7&1< "7$1&5 0$$;'/$5$6"(5 '/"99"9'%(#"&(#/$B"'&'47(0/&%/#/$5$6"(5 

@20"'

6"5$$"19&$1"(57"&5B<#/$7$#&#&($1'(#/$$.$(# #/$'"6$(#B$&(C 5($  0&#/&(  "  7$1&5    $&C/#  0$$;'  16 #5"<:  #/$  '"&5  "64(#  

@2'/"99"9'B$1$7"&5  !"#

$%!&'(!)"*+%!$) ),!&#) !&'((!&#+

*#') -.-/0-12 94%;<