High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18262/2020dismissed

Gurmukh Singh Sohal And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2021-02-02Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma30 pages

!"" #$%&%#'%()$*(+!,!-%!).!! !$%!-#'!)%

- -/

)0/1

)!/2 %3,4&)+(5$#&!('(5$#&'&)'&!5#% %3,4&)+(5$#&!5%66(!) &)!

&'( ))) !5%66(!) &)!7+ * +

,-,-& -.-. % "

/&,( # "

,0, **

! #

* # 1

2 * +

23 -.-, % "

,0, ** "

1 1

* # 1 ,

1 "" #

" * " --&5--( *

6 7

+ "

2, ( -.-.8

9:-;! # "$

# " *

< " *

/,3308 =/ ,330>;# " !

* 2 / ,330

* " " *

# " !

* 28-; / ,330 #

# ! $

2.- 2.( 2-& 2-4 -., 24 6

* # "

-( " ,303 ! ?6 +

*:38;5-.,-5* 65* 5*@ 1 -.,- ,2 ,- -.,- # * 5* 6 *

# "

8" :; -A ,- -.,2 8

9 :4; % * 9

" " " !

* 4 / ,330 *

% "

3 -2 -.-.8

9:(; 1 !

" *

" " " ! " *

1 #

9" # "

4.(:

" *

",3(&8 "4- ,3(&;8 = "

,3(&>;

-2 -.-.8

9 :(;

? "

-2 ,.

-.-.

9 :,,; 1 ! ! # "

! !

$ " $

" "

/ ,330 !

* 2 * 28-; / ,330 %

0 ,, -.-.8

9:,3; 1 ! #1 # "

" *

# ! " " " # - B

! #

: 8 ; 6 " *

-2 -.-.8

9 :(; 9

" " " ! " *

9" # "

4.(: " ,3(&

9:(;

4 8 ; 6

2, .( -.-.

9:-; !

2 / ,330#1 $

1 #

0* " "

8 ; 6 #

1 C

( ! #

&:C

# "

2.-52.( 6* " !

8! ; 6

-2 -.-.

9 :(;

" *

" " " ! " *

1 #

9" # "

8,; "

4.(: " ,3(&

9 :(;

" *

# 9

,( .A -.-. "

# "

,A -.,0 " *

01 "

9:(; !

( " ,3(&

5 8!; B

> 9* - 0 6 8 9 -6 0 5 : '0 5 6 +

,A-A&A5-.,3 *66B D B+/ 04&( 04&35-.,( "

& ,- -.,3; ! 5 0 5 ( 7 8,33&; & ** 2.2 ! 9 ; 05 % : 78,3A&;-**-43 / "

: 8 ; 6 ! 1 "

! 1 "

,( -.-. "

,A -.,0 # " " ,2 -.,0 8

9 :&;

" #

-( -.,0

,A -.,0 " -42E *

6 "

( # "

2A ,3(& "

" *

" " *

-& -.-.

% " *

""1 "

! 1

! "

4.( ,3(& " 8 ; 6

" * 11"

-2 -.-.8

9:(; #1 !

A "

6 *

" *

9 1 " !

" *

9" # " *

9 1 (

" * 1 "

9 :(;

-2 -.-. ! "

1 1

# !

8 ; 6

.0 ,, -.-.8

,3; "

A8-; " ,3(& "

1 "

8 !; "

" 1 "

1* " #

1 9

-& .4 -.-.

# !

2, ( -.-.

9:-;

9 1 2 / ,330#

! # ! 2

7 8!; #

1 C

& #

(# *

" 7 "

/ ,330 8! ;

1 "

1 * ! / ,& ,- -.-.

!"#$ % && '( * ,, .A -.-.# !

1 )$* " +,(

% $ %

- +'" +,(

.% $ % /0 < ! ! "

1 "

# "!

"-42E *

6 " :

!"#$ ! "!"$$% & ! ! # $ # #$!# '"" ! " #$ !! !$ !!$"" #! "" ! ( ) * ! # " #!( + ##!(("!"! %& ! !!" !

!!! ! !("! !# ! ! $ ! ! ) ! # ! ( ! !"! !!! !

(20 2A ,3(& " :

0 * 1$2 3&* *($!*$ 4&( & $2 '**

'# # "!

( & 5 '#5 ' '# ! 2&* & 32)*232& / 4& "!

9 ) * ($ "" # ! """ ! * -

! )"" ) // ! ! ( ! # !# !-0$ ) * ! # " #!( # + ##!(("!"! + & ! !!"! !! ! * ! ! ( "! ! # ! # $ ! * ! 1!*! """ ! &2# * )"") // !#! !

( "!#$* 3 ) * ! * # ! ( ! !"! !!! * ! # !# /.4!

!! ! #5$! "5##"$!* ! " $ ! $ " " % 67 ) 8 ! $ # 9 : ! *

! ";" "!7 #!

10 $!*7# #! !7 ! !$! !!7" #6 7 #!! " !!<"# !! ##! !!! !!# (!) / - !" 1!*! ! #" ""##! ! ""##!- ! !* %6 &,7&

% ,&& '# * , &$ '' 2 '# '# ,&,#

' ,2 && &/., ' ' !& & && &

08 "!

)1!" - !# " !!" : 4! ! ! - ! * ! ! "! ! ! ""# - !" # !!!" !=" 1! !- ! !!"!"!! ! !""!

11 $ ! - ! " ""# ! *" "! ! ! 1! !#$# 3 1! ! # ! " ! !" " # $ ! "" ! ! 5" ## > 1! ! ! ! ! *" !*"" "!" ! $ ""!!*, 2 / ,330 " :

/*8 .! $ ! ! ! ; " ! " 8 ! $! $""#" % 1! *"" ! !! ! *?'$&! ! 4"# !"!#!+ ""# ! &2# 0$ )"# $! : -# 4+ 8 ; 1! 0; "!$ 8 !; 1! & )" ! *'$&! + 8!;

( 4!*'$ &! : 8! ; 91 ""#: " # ! ; " # :

12 9 :1!8! !! $ $"! ""# ! $ $ ! $! "! 1!"! ""#!#!# ! ( 4 ! ! ! *"" 6 *$ !$(** 2& $3&* 2 "! & <

1 *

" " " " "

( #

9 1 " *

" "

-& -.-.

,( -.-.

" -42E *

6 "

( 2A ,3(& " # " *

"-42E *

6 !1 " 1

! 1 #

" "

? D9

( F

G# "

#1"

2A " ,3(& :"

8,; "

2A ! *

8-; "

( ! "

8,; "

! 1

1* " "

# " "

* "

,( "

2A8-; ,3(& "

1 1

1 "

" "

$ !

" * - 0 6 "7 " # 7

# #

-- ( -..A#

# "# 7 " ! #

-4 ( -..3# 3#

4 -.,. #

" # ""1"

" #

" -42E *

6 $ !

" ! : @1! )

! * 7 - ! ) ! ! " ! "$$1!" ! !" !" ! # " ! 1! " !!!" #

14 ! "$ 7 (-!) !(6 "$6 ! # ! "$ ! !!& A & B ! B // " ! *"" ! !# !" !"$! ""# ! ! !#!! ""# 7! ! # ! !$ #"!""# !&A &!#!

! "$ -# B B ! "5 ! ""## 5!$ ! # 5!! $ ! #< "$ 7 ! !* !)!B// ! !#! !"$ # " # ! "$ ! !!!!"!""# ! !

& ! 1! !! ! *"" ! "$ ! ""# ! B ! B // " # ! # ! *""!"$! # - ! ) " !! ! ! # 1! $ ! ! ! !! !#!"$+ !! ! ""# ! ! #"!+!&

15 A &! !#! C ! $ "$ ! 6! "$6)

! *7-!))! !""#* ! <" ! B // " ! ""# # ) ! ! *""!#" ! "$ ! * B ! B // !! ! # " ! ""# ! & A

&#!C!!" ! *""(! $!"$ #56!"$6 ! !! ! "$ ! 5 + ! " ! # 2!!-# B ! B // ! !""##5! $ < # # ! ! !! # 5!! $ ! #< "$ 1! # !!! !!!"$ !!"$ ! 1!

! !! (# ! *""!# " # ! "$ ! !" #" !D$"$$ "$ !$4 $ "$ (# ! *""B!B// !<"-!)" ! #"!

16 ! !!!"$! !$ 5# ! ""# ! &?A & ! !!1! " # " ! # )

! * -!) ! 6 $6 ! # 1! ! " ! # (# 1!"$ * # ! *""B !B// "$! "$ # " $ "$ C!! !"$ " !$! " !*7" ! *""!"$ ! ! " " ! # ! !""# 7!

#"" #! !!!"$ "#! !"$!$ ! 1! ! *"" $!"$ 7 ! " <" ! ! ! ! "$ ! ! # ! ""# ! "! ($ 1! !

# B!B// !#"! ""## 5!$!"$ ! # 5!!$!#< "$ 7 ! $ # ! ! ! "$

17 # ! "$ !! ! ""# " ! & A & ! ! ! !"*7" ( # " !!! ! * ! ) 7 ! " !"!* # $!$ # #! ! ""# ! * ! # " ! "$ $ !!1!" #" " ! ! "$ *!# !"$ "!

""#"! ! " ! ! & A & ! 7 ! ! " ! *#(# # 5$!2!"$7 5!("!7!"$!

E FFG " ! ! $ $ !!!!!#"! ""#!* ! & A & # ! 7 ! "$ !

E FF/ ""#!* "! ! "$ ""# ! "$ 5!!1!&A &!"$ !# ! !"$! 3 FF ! "! "$>""#!* ! & A & !

-7 # # ! -$H$ ! 6!6(-

18 ! ) " ! "$ !! ! "$ ! ! ""# & A & 5 !""$ !! ! ! ) ! "$ !!&A&7 "5 ! "$ ! # " ! !# " ! !!"$7 ! -$ H$ ! $! ! ! ! !#"! !! ""# "!"! !"$ !!&A & 5 1! $ !# !-$H$, % !

$ !

" * 1 "

" " " " "

6 "

$ !

" # "

" "

,2 " ",3,,# " "

( ,3(& " "

6 "

! # "-42E *

" *

# "

! 1

( ,3(& "

" *

0 1

2A8-; ,3(& " "

# "

! 1

1 * " "

# " "

* "

,( % "

" -42E *

6 "

( 2A ,3(& " # " *

6 "

.4 .2 -.,0 # 1 1 "

-( -.,0 @ #! ""

# "

,A -.,0 # "

# "

"-42E *

6 "

( 2A8-; " ,3(& 6 ! # " *

" -( -.,0# "

# " " "

-( -.,08

9:A;# " : +

" "

" *

% #"

/ #

-( -.,0 ,, 1

# "

, 0. 89" #

-3 # C ;

" *

" &A % # 9" # "

"1 "

-( -.,0

# "

"1 <

-( -.,0 *

-& -.-. "

! 1 7 + 1 #

-2 -.-.8

9:(;# # # "

1 # : # "

" */6$:,3

# # !

-2 -.-.8

9:(;

3 ?

-2 -.-. 8

9 :(; 1

: # " *

# 9

-& -.-. "

" *

! "

4.( ,3(& " ! 1 "

! 1

4.(: ,3(& " !

-2 -.-. 8

9 :(; 1 "

" *

9 1 !

2 ,330 #

1 ! 2 "1 "

2 1 *

# " !

9 1 ,.

" "

-2 -.-. 8

9 :(; "

1 1

-A ,.

-.-. # " (

-2 -.-.

0 ,, -.-. 8

9 :

,3; D!

2, ( -.-. 8

9 :-; ! # "$

< 6 "

" 1 1 !

1 ?

-2 -.-. 2, ( -.-. ! #

1 "

11 !

"--& *

* 9" 9

1 "

" --&

! "

@ #! # # 9" "

9" 9

1 # " --& "

" 9 1 # 1 #

6 "

* # "

# # "

" "

1 # ,, %

1 "1 "

2.- 6*

# 1 !

! " ?

" #

# 7 #

,- 1 "

1 *

6 "

,& ,- -.-.;# :

)

I; # ! # * " ! $!" ! " ! "$#"

I)!#< ! # < ( # !! !" # " # ! 0$ - 1! $ $ C! $ ! ! D=# )(*)$!'-$!= !!%

1! -> ) ! &)$ !" # < # ! ( # " # )

I; ! * -E"! -! * ! -! 1# ! 85 * 1! ! - #!$1! ! ! ! " ! " !" !$!$ #( !$ #) !!$!! # "! #!! ;J #2 ! !!$ ! )05!" *!-K * !! ! " #2 ! # # ! ! ,

C! $ ! " )

I; # ! * . 8! ! *&!

B2= !!%

E ) 66 ! ) "" !! # !-; " - ) !)1!! ! # ! - *"" 1! KK ! " ! ! ! 1! ! 6 <6 66 $ ! ! 66 # )

> !

24 * 7 B ! $ ! !" !! #$ # $ ! ! *"") ) ! )

> ! * ! 2$" ! DK# -" * ! # ! ! "" !! ! ) $ !$ 66 # 2# # 7# *" ! """ ! #"# (!" (!# ,

1!! " !($! 2 # * 8! ! -" * $!2 L!

" *"" ! )7B />E -* >>/ ! <!$ ! # - F ! " *"" ) /> " &" )"# ! - !

&! 1! "!$! ) /!* ! # < 1! < !# !D=#)(* &! -$! L! -" M 4 !

25 $ ! ! &! &! ! !%

37!; " !" ! ! ! ! ! # " 7 ! !" !!!" #@,

3 L$ ! # ! D=# )( * # !.8!!* ! !#!! "# "! ! "" ' E F F # ! - *"" $ ! $"" !$ ! $?# ! * * '$ &! ) # ! / F # # F F $ " #2 ! " > F F . # 3 7 ! * ( 2 )

>!*!$ !!" " $$ ! $ "1!#2 *!7N )!*7# !E ! * )"" // ? ! !$ ! # !! ! " <" " ! #! $ " !!# !!"! "5$ ! ! !

26 $$! ) !* !!" # " !" #!"!! !

> 1!2 "#! #" ! ! 25$"1!<" 2!"! !!< ! !! !$ !#2" #$ ! ! 7 ! !" " !# "! $!#2 $$ ! # $ ! ! ) ! #2 ! # " 7 !

!" 2 < !$ # $ ! " 5 # $ " , ,2 1 !"#

&&'& .

! 1 " 1 * # ! :

F ."B !/E B !! #!! " 8 1! ! " 8 ! !"#C " # ! $ $ ! ""# " # ! - ; " !

27 !"# ""#-! * 85 * " 2 ! !!"! !!!" !#" $$ "! !" !!< !2" )# !! $ ! $" ! $ " 8 !! ! 4 G/ F # ! * 7 " ! !!" 8!#B!/E *>E!4//3 8! ! # ! 7 ! 3F F )( B? !# ! " ! GE F )( B ?

# ! B$ ;**"" 7*!- ; " &2# ! GFG F)(B ?# !; " &2#<$$ !!$($ " # # F ! J$ # F D ! ($ !! # ! ! " ! # #$!!!*!$ !! $! G F !! G/ F # ! * ." ! ! ! ! ! " ! * !!!" " " !! !

! $ C

28 # !"! !! #$ # 7 ! # ""# ! = $!# # # ! - ! $" ! !$ GG F )( B ? ! ! ! ! $ "$"8# GG F- !! ' F/7 -# 'GFG F7/:/ ! " 5 " F/ *< !

" " 8 ##O=! )"$ ! 5 $" ! ! GFG FB ? !" "5! FE F$""#$ ) ! F/ GFG F ! ! " ! # # 5$BG !*B //F !! " 8 ! # # 5$ B !/E B1!/E B!

F ! &2# ) / !! ! * 85$ 7 " ! ) ( 1! ! ! "$ ! B

8 !! "5 1! J " # 8 A FE F&

"# # (?!5 - GFG F $ J$

29 # !!# B/ # D !$"# 0* !" 1! $" $$ $ " $ #2 FE F & 3 ! "C!! "$#2#$ 5$ !*8 ! "!### !B/E 1! !B !! " !$ # ! *

! !!!! 5 # ! $ " 8 .! ! ! /E $ $! " ! /E/B#" "" $#2 3 05 !$"!! #" $!" "!#$! ! "7"!$! !! ! # ! ! - 8 #$!$ #$ 7 !

# "! # > ! ! ! # ( B ! " "# "# B 4&B // )B -! 7 !"$ !"#""#* &! !# !$ !!! $! ##!.! !!

30 ##"$!?! ! "! !2 !2!# $, ,4 " "

! # !1 H "

! # ! "

6 "

! 1

,0 ! # !#

% #

8* +

,-,-( -.-.;

59"

2, ( -.-.8

9:-; ""

1 !5%66(!) &)!!('(5$#&'&)'&!5#% +(-'& +(-'&

*6 C!!5$? Q C!!B# Q