← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2870/2009disposed of

Gurdev Singh And ORS. v. Ut Of Chandigarh

2015-09-22Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain9 pages

 

     



 

  

   !"#$

%& &"

 ''((

#"

)

*""

"+,& %"&  '  !" #$%&' ()*+,' -').+#/ & -" ."& .

(,$

"#/ & .")  "%,#,."0" '$

%&,#, .".& $

%& ,#, ."-& 1 ,#, .".!"+,#, ."2 &3!1",# "."3& 1 ,#, ."*' 3!1"4#,# ."$%&!,#,



 ."0" '$

%&,# .".& $

%& ,# ."-& 1 ,#,



6 ."-& 1 ,#,



 ."7

&($& ,."'8$&"1, ."-$ ,# "&)*& %"&



 ."7

&($& , ."'8$&"1,

"&)*& %"&



6 ."-$ ,#, ")*& %"&





-').+#/ &0  *&

""/ ((

'  ((/

%''( 9"

%  

 ,

6,

,

 ,6 , 6 ,66 ,66 ,6

6

6,6 6 ,6 ,   , ,  , 6  , ,





, , ,6, ,  ,  

  6, ,   6,  0  666,  ,6,, , ,6

,6   ,

,6 6 , , 6  ,

10  , , , 6,  ,  6 6,  ,  6  ,   11,  1   , 6,

,

, ,   ,6 , 6 ,

, ,

120   , ,

,

 130  140 #/ "

:92  

;< ;<, ;<, ;< 1, "

:92   ;<,;<, 6;< 110 1"

! 11

  =+ 

(

%  ''(     "

:92

,  &  (  "

8

% & 1

"&5!

,/&" 9+

(

%  ''( ,  &  )

 *""

"+,  & %"&, 

8

%  "!

&"  6 ="

(+,&  "&# 



,

!!

& 5!

,  &",>& >,&& %"&1

" !%&5!

"8 1"(

!

((% ,09 6 , ( 6 "

!

((%.!( ,09 6 6,)

*""

"+, %"&, 

%!' < !

"

(" &"(( !

"6" -& 

 &/

! 

 *& 5!

((" &",>&(("># /"    6

6

&1"8#(! ((8

 ((%  @, , ;:'"" ,, ;: "%

(,&  ((%.!( @ ,  ;:'"" "((8

 ,

;:'"" "% "

1!18

(,& 

/ &&/" ((",&(

(92

A " ,&("

!" 9(/"1

&1"8#(! & "5!

 9&& # ((% @ , ,6 ;:'""

6     &" 

   

6, 

!  !

"

$ & 5!

,  &",>&>,& %"&1

" !%&5!

" 8 1"(

!

((% ,09 6 , "'(

#('1

(!

%&'"#

 !

&(B(-!

B$&("

"+ 

1( ,

"  (( !



 /

!  

*& 5!

((" &",>& (("># /"   6



&1"8#(!

&5!

@   , , 6;:'""   ,,

;:'""

"1((#((  (/(+

%( " ' #(+

/ && /" &((",&(

(92

A " ,& ("

!"9(/"1

&1"8#(! @ ,

;:'""     &" 

   

, 

!  !

"

$ & 5!

,  &",>&>,& %"&1

" !%&5!

" 6"

!

# ((%.!( ,)*& %"&, "

"! !

"1& %"&- &8!(

 &/

!    

  *&     5!

 (("   "  &",  >& (("># /" 

6



&1"8#(!

&5!

@

;:'""

/ &&/"

&((",&(

(92

A " ,&("

!"  9(/  "1

  &  1"8  #(!    &  5!

"  (   @  , ,

;:'""  *& /" &#9 1'!% 

&'"   ''(

9+9&&'" 

 "

!

( !91 && (:

 ,  CD-6     CD-6,  9&     6

     (:   6

,CD-6,

/& &"'"

%"# !  .!(  ,"%

"&"1 '"

" &

! 

&,&#9

((+ "9+&("

 !"*& (

" ' &"

" % "16, ,6 ;:

;:'""*&"( / &&"

(   1((, " % "18 68 *&

 9

 "



(  



'!*&1'

&5!

 "# 9



"1 &" & %"&

/(('(

 +0"(+ +(

( ,/& &/ 5!

" '(

#('1 .!& (: " # (9(9!

&"" ( " "





"!

&"  </ !"&" !91 &



,& &#'( "" (: ,CD-CD-6, &/

#(! &(

"!

,9 "  "&5!

&" $(:,CD-,/ "%

" 

" (

"

 , ,

;:# /& & 8 1"( / (

#"%'"

  

;:'""

&"# !  ((%  '!"3&!"7  (:

,CD- ,(  ((%  '!"  3(  1 !"

%    8  / (      #"%  '"

    ,

;:'"" '"

%&

(:

(  "1

%'" $(: ,CD-6 -:6

, "  1  (  "



 /& &  "  CD  - ,  CD  -     CD  - " ' #(+  7   (:,  CD  -          

,  ( 1 !"

%68 61"(  ((% / (

#"%'"

 , ,,6;:'"" 

67  (: ,CD - CD-6

,( 1 !"

%8  8    1"(  / (      #"%  '"

      ""     , ,

;:'""," ' #(+ ((%"!*&'!"'  "/& & &( / ", 1(+, 

%!' < !

"

("-& :<<<, (

&/ &&( /



!

"

E *&( &!(( 99

/ &&' #('1 

 &&"& ,("

!

( "&)

*""

"+, %"&, !91 &  (: '"! ""9+ &( ""(#  " 1(('( "&(

&"

  #   *&"  (: ,  CD-6    CD  -6    ;

,"9 " &#"

%&(+9 "9+& ("

 !" "&" && /""%

"2!

'"

&

! 

&/ &# /28 !'&'"



&""# $1 (: " ( "

'(/&"&"/ ("+/((#('9



"&$!8& 8*&(("&

&1'

8

#"% (: "%

" 11 (+'"

%&

! 

&0 !"&" !91 & "& 5!

,/& &/ 8

 %

(&

1!

/ %" 9+&(("*&("

 !"& 11  ((%( +

"

% "(  5!( + 

(& 

95!/ &'(

"</ 1"(+!

# < !''" &

"%!1 "( / '(!' 2!%1 &

!"

 



     



/0"(

</

!"&" !91 & "(+9! +"&" ",5!

/

""

  !  "     $!"

+  "

 # ((%  0((  .2"   =&( ,/&"

&/

!

 6

"/& &&

!"



6:  

     

,    ,&

&1'

@,6

;:'""=&&( "1'"9( &&", &(

5!

9+ & (/+(

  &

'( %""!''"&& %"&</ ( &( "( "  5!

"  "  

"!   "&9 (   9!"  (

 1 "& (!1/(("

   < " '

&  "

9+("

!

( )

*""

"+,& %"&,("

!

( !91  & # & 9 '"!9+)

*""

"+,& %"&,

&/ +'" / %

(,&"

8& &"

&

# -F $+9 ",-/"



; , &&

  "1&2

# ((%  '!"3&!",.!( ,=&(   "!

9! (1" &( / && &( / (#((&" &

%/ 9!&( 9

%(/(+

%"0 ,&5!

" &!(9

& 1"  0"("

!

( "&'" , '"!

&"(# " """"  "1&

'( # (9( "",&( &(

# <

(9+ &" (/+(

 "119(3(8

 (   &5!

" (  / "( "5!

" (   ""&9 ( 

(

 "  &   1 "  &  (9!"  ''"&    &  (   "1 %"&

/ 9+( %""!"&"( "5!

((% .!(

&/"

!

+"

 

"&5!

"&'!"' , 1(+, "&9 (  9!"(

& /

!  

 &

!"# "" # '

'"(+

       

 !'&(  &  /"    &  ("

     !"  

1'

 @   ;: '"  5!"  +"  "  &  (   5!

"  #

&

""&9 ( 

9!"(

,&

!"# "" # '

 '"(+

 

6   



"#  # !$    %% !       

  & /" 1'

@ ;:'" 5!"+" 6 *&( &#" ""& ((/

%

  "& '!"' 

1

:

& '& ()

 % *

+ 



%%

 %



  - 

 - !

  CD- %% %  #.

 /0&1! 6,,

;:

, ,,

;:

()&234 ((1 )''(0!

-#< -8

  6  .

12" "&(9

 1&34!  ,

;

:

,,6;:

CD-



 '!"3&!"  3G. , ,

;:

;:

 CD-





3

,,

;:

,

;:

 CD- 6



3:H.



;:

6, ,

;:

 CD- 

 ;6" &"!

  8 (  / 9!

(

% "!!" ,

;:

, ,,6;:

 CD-

 6

.!(

8



;:



;:

CD-  6

.!(

68

6,

;:

6,

;:

CD- 

"! 8

,

;:

,

;:

CD-6 

"! 3.

6,,

;:

, ,

;:

 *& (: ,CDCD,'"!9+&)

*""

"+, & %"&, &#  "

%&(+ 9 "  9+ & ("

 !" 9(/, /"D! ( &( &"  ( '""

    " CD& CD- CD-6 ,'"

%((1

 .;

)''(0!

%-"

# " "

,&

1" "(#  "&" &&( '"

%&"

( "

"1&5!

"!

2 #  & <*-"8, %"&  *&  "  ("+  /((  '(

     #('  $(:, CD- ,'"

 1(('( ;6" &"! 8 (( %/

"!!"(

&9 ((% $(: ,CD- CD-6%

" "(#  & '"

"(( & (/+$ & %"&

,/& &/ 9

%!

 11" ('!"' < 1+'

/!( 9 '("(  !' (: ,CD- ,- -, "&" && /" "%

"2!

:61 9 "&

! 

 &(1 & 1"!9,& /"( 19'" ,/&" "1

& " (:

"

(!

%"( "1 +,&!%&"!

%

( "!' / '

 &,''" (+ &/ && /"%"%

"2!

"# 

"(

%& %&"1'

  $(:,CD- ,/& &/ "%

" 

, 9 

"9"( 9(' #  "&" &%

&

(:

9!97  " (:,8

/ (,,

;:, #"% '"

 ,

;:'"" </ "1

%'" *&"

 1%' +" 1 9/ &"%

" " (:

! 

&

<

" @I

%"  "& " %',&1!

&((1!  ,

;:'""*& 1 &((9&1'

"& " ,D' "%

(,& 1 !"

68

((%.!( 8 1"(

((% '!"

3( *&(  &

5!( +

91'"/ &&'(

<

('"'

(/& "1(9!+"/ (( '+ 1'"

 %

(,&"8& ,/& &

9

%' "'(

,& ,&1'

&"  "# 9

(

"C"( "( & 1'"

 '(/ ''( 9+&

!"

 

  >   !'"

    <  # /    1+   "   

!

, 

 1+  '

,  & 5!

"# 



 "# 9%" 1'

@ ,

;:

'"" "&'(

,/&" /& && 9 (



%

(,& 9+&((",&1!

1'

9+&("

 !"

!'&(    " &( 5!

"# 

&

6

 "

,& 1/ "+" 1 "1&"( "5!

/& &/ ""

!# 

& 



"

%& 1%'9/

&/5!

" @I/ &!1!( #

/!(9 " 9(<

" @I'"

!1/ &!1!( #



   ,

;: "&%''"

 +"1 9/ &/ 5!

,&1'

1 6,

;:*&( &  (   5!

"  #  

 !

"  $      &     

6"%" 1'

@6,

;:'"" "&'(

,/&" /& && 9 (

 %

(,& 9+&((",&1!

9+&("

 !"

!'&(   <  " &( 5!

"# 

 &



 "

,& 1/ "+"

"1&"( "5!

/& &/ ""

!# 

"

$ & 

6

"

%& 1%'9/ /  5!

, 

"   @  I  / &  !1!( #  

  /!(  9 " 9(<

" @I'"

!1/ &!1!( #



 6,

;: "&%''"

 +"

9/ &/5!

&  1'

 1    6, , ;:,  /& & 

 "!

  

   6, ,

;:*&( 5!

"# 

"

$ & 

 "%" 1'

@  6, ,

;:'""  *&  ( &((  (   9   (    ((  &  !"+ 9

# (9(&1!

"&

   "&"

1 9#,&''( "

'   * !1!':

 &( 5!

"# 

&

"&( (1'

@   ,

;:'"" &'(

,/&" /& && 9

(

 %

(,& 9+ &((",&1!

9+&("

 !" &((9'+9(

 &( 5!

"# 

&

6"&( (1'

@  6,

;:'"" &'(

,/&" /& && 9

(

 %

(,& 9+ &((",&1!

9+&("

 !" &((9'+9(

 &( 5!

"# 

&

"&( (1'

@6, ,

;:'""

 &+ &((( 9 ((( !"+9

"1 &'"#

&     2 &=

( #

?!%  "'""