← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4020/2010allowed

Sharda Devi And ORS. v. Asmeet Singh And ORS.

2025-11-14Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

-1- 

   

Reserved on:- 10.11.2025



 ! "

    

  

        #  $%# & &&  & #    

     !   "

     #$ %%%% &  & #   & '         (     

    )   *+*$$*&*

(,  -  ' (

 # . /

   

 &00 1  

&233.   4' (

5/     

      

  6 7$ ***8!

 

  - 

1

    *6*9$**3 $  

 



 



 :

  

 )(, ' (

         

:

(   ; ( , & #&& & %  &%

  & + ' 

    !     



(, ' (



 )     (  '  ,  () 

 

 (    )

-26        

      !

   - ,

)    , 

 )

    '  ,  



   7   

  

)  

 )  (

  &%%'  # &  0 < 5(     -  

       Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another () !!*+,&-./011

 ) )

  

       

!

=30

                                                        

                                         !"#$%              &$    !"#' %     '(    !"#) %     

*                  +       

 ),-                           .              

-3-  !%     

/    0   

                  +    

    

            

       

       ),-            ),-     

                          

               

    

* * * * * * 42. *          !'%   !       

 2     %   

  "3!   ")&, &" &)  %        4 "5 &($,   4 "($"$)   4 ")$(',   4 "''"')    4 "$'(),    

      4 "")"))   4 6 )((,   4 5("()   4 )((5,  

-49 < 5( - 

  National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. () !

3+ ,&,4!2 

)

 

&00 &0+! &03 1   &233   )

 !

./            

  >

   

   ?

."/      

   ?

.-/    (

 ,

   ?

./  (         

,  

   

 



 

>

)   ?

.@/       

     )  (?  !, > , '      

 

!

=52. 7   conventional heads      8 0 +     8 &) ,,,           8  "

,, ,,,    8"

,, ,,,       

       

 8 0

1  :   

       

           ;   

    7         

            

-5-     

       

  

     <                      

  

     

  

          

        +           

                   8 ") ,,,

8 ', ,,,    8 ") ,,,  

 

             =         *                           

    

         ",-       *        

> > > > > 59.3 *     ),-                 0     ',     

   $,-      ',),

  +      ),(,

-6-

    ")-  7              

59.4 +      !%    

  ',-             ',  

7 &)-       ',),   ",-     ),(,       

     

        

59.5 /                     $,$&1  ? @     

59.6.

    

1  ? A    '& 0 

59.7

          

59.8 8        

        8 ") ,,, 8', ,,, 8") ,,,

         ",- 

  3 < 5( - 

  #05.00610 .-07%8.8/910 0.06801:: 0. /:1( !

4) 4+ & ;!2 



&0609.0)1-0+  007&/:8)&-0+

-7-

)





      

!

C21 7 =     1 9 

                <                  +       D D     D     D  D     D    D   D

      

            

   

*            

&"

"

Spousal consortium          

        D 



 

      0   D

&"

& Parental consortium             D      



     D

&"

$ Filial consortium               7                     

               

        

               40 

-8-         E                  40              

                                

4? 7                +                       

                                7 7               

         

              D D    1 9 +                       8 ', ,,,           

2 

  )  - )

(++,  (,B&

  @>B&8 



 ) 

 (,

  ,   (



-9-   ,

  -  ++, B  

        ,  @>&8$    A( , )    ) , 

(, .   /) 8 <  -

  

C ;- , ₹   D ) )

 , ,  7 6268!'

  ,  

(,



   ); )    , , *7*+$**3   

),

  )   ) ,  , 

(     

  ,  &*   

 ' (

  @>!6.@A / ( 

      , B!& (

-     , 



  ₹   + ***8! (,

  ( '

   ' (





(

    , B!& ( ;  ,  

,     '



 ,);



5    *7*+$**3@:

,  ' (

 ;

   (   B!&

) 

( ) );

)   , 



 && '

- 



   ,

 

)!

 

, 



     , <)  >

    

,  .@>&8$/

  )       ,        

    ,  

 )    

,;

)

(   , 

   ,   (   



  

-10- &$  )    

      

            

- 





 

 ,    (,   

,  ,

  

 7 6268!

 

@>&8$ 

 

)   (

 

 

 ,



     

  )  



 

)

  

 



 

 >

  )   :

  

   % &  &+  ) ) ) (,< 5( - 

 (    

 

)') *+*$$*&* 

 

  

,  '    !            

  

!

!

Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded &  ,   7 6268!

$    E6*F  $ &238!.6*F 7 626/ +    )    >  &86  & 2$+8!.9 02$G&86/ '   7 9028!.9 02$!& 2$+/     &0 

 ,  && *9 0638!.7 902G&$G&0/ D

 @   &3 &7*8!

@>

 &3 &7*8!

D

 -



  $ 6$ ***8!

 63 6**>6 

63 6**>& /06.-10/8

;<4"<* 4=

/8

<" <!!!=

-11- 

)(,' (

 :00./

1*<;;<* 4= ) ;<4"<*

<" <!!!+ &6   

 

   (,< 5(  - 

Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma ! *;

3, R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation ) ! +" &-./011 !3<   !    

  E2F

   

   

   

     H  &7 '

 - ,! 

     

 

  ) 

 ) ' (

) 

  )     , 

  '' (



 

(   

 

  ) 

 



     8  D     !, .   !- /  (, ' (

   )*+*$$*&*'   8   

 ( ;

  ' (

 &0 

  .

/ ,    

  

 ! "    )&  & #+       B ;

8 !

;

;

  B( I 8#