High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24743/2014dismissed

A.K.Gupta v. Central Administrative Tribunal & ORS.

2016-01-14Bench- 4,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal10 pages

! "

#

" $% ! % $% ! !

!

"

#

!& $%&

'

()(*+(%, - .

/+01

(2(%+((* - . /341

+,(%+((*- . /%(1

()(*+((5- . / %01 67 ' 8

6 ' $+&

'

'7 '

9 '#7

:

#8 8

;;

"

! ' !

<

8

'' ; ;

' "

! ' +%(0%322

!

;

'=

' # # -

'1 > # # !

# <

' 8

'

' # !# 9 '#

'6' 7

' 9 '#

9 #

/8/

'

<

' 8

6 '!

/

!

"

#

'

9 '#

88

#

88

.

' $*&

9

#%,7

<!

6 # 88

8 67 88

'

8 !

88 #

? #

!

'

=

8 7 6 '?

'7 (%%+%330

7 - 03((/+((/)*((16

8 ? !

#

?

/8/ ! #(3(%%335 !?

# # 7

> +0(3%333 8

=!

# 7

##''

#8%333 +((+8 88

!

67

#

# 7

#

# ! # (%(%+((%

68

# ''7'

67 @ <

! #(2(%+((* #8(%(%+((% 8

4

! #(2(%+((* $,& !

67 A!

B "%0%+) # +((* ! !

8 6 6

<

7

? 8 ! #(%(%+((%

++%%+((0 '

8 # !

67 <

7()(*+((5

!' 6

7#

$0& 7'

'

%)(2+((5 ;

! # (2(%+((*

# (%(%+((% #

? # ;#8

# ! #8

' 67 ;>

' 6 ' ;#8

88 +((5+(()>

' 6

#8

#

#'

B "%%22

%0(%+((26

(2(%+((* +,(%+((* ()(*+((5 ! !

#

'8

6 ' 6

A8

+,(++(%( 8 !

9

# 6

#'' ! # (24(3(%%335-

# 1!

= !

'' 9 #

8#

7 '

!

# @<

67 =

7 #

+,(++(%( $5&

+0(*+(%( "

7

+3 #'

B "5%(* # +(%( # 6 '

+,(++(%( # ? C ! ''!

%*(*+(%+

6 ' 9 # 7

'8

6

7 6

! A

8

!

6 6 '

'

# <

"%3%,) # +(%+ <!

<:6'

%2(*+(%* # 8

6

8 ! 6 #' 67 76

8 67

<

%*(*+(%+ $)&

8 '

8 6 '

8 # 8

67 <

%*(*+(%+

6 '

6 ' 8 #

'8

!

'' 8

()(*+(%,

!

6 #'

$2&

'

'#

' 8

' $3& 8

'7

# <

' 8

;;

"

! ' +%(0%322

(+()%33+ = '

/8/

'

# <

' 8

' ' 6

7 !

6A

! 6 88

> 88

# 88

67 7

%0%%%330 9 '7 '

(%%+%330# # # <

' 8

7 # 03((/+((/)*((4/ ! !

67 ! 7

A

/8/

<

8

$%(& #

A 8

# # +0(3%333 = # /

# ' #

8

=

8 '

%, 7

6

<

'8

! #(%(%+((%< 9

! !

?

8 ?

8 $%%& # /

#

/8/ #<

'8

!

'

'7

(2(%+((* = !

67 7 # <

D 8'7B '# /

'

/8/ # <

8

!

/

/8/ <

8

! # (2(%+((*

! # (%(%+((% !

' 6'

# #' ! '

<:6'

.

$%+&

'

!

!

8

7#'#''

'6' 7

#%,7

(%%+%330 $%*& 8

'7

!

8

(%%+%330

# 8 #

(%%+%330 '6'

#

#!

'

8 #8

# (%%+%330 ' # '

67 !'

#8 (2(%+((* (%%+%330 !' #

'7 ## 7#

'7 /

# 7

+((*

?

!

7

# 7 #

6 # 67

'

/8/ 7 $%,& ' ##

67 #8 /

#

# ! # (%%+%330 !' '

8

'! 67 ## 7 #

;# 7

8

67 # /

7 !' A'

'

7 #

!' 6 A 7 '

8# !

''7

6'

$%0& E # 7 '

'8

!' #

'7 7

' '

8

# '

8 # C/ / C

67

!

8 #

'

8 6 '

'7 # 7 '

;

#6A 6

67

# #8! #8

8 #

< 8

# '# 7

#8

# +0(3%333

?

?

'' 7

+((2 ! ! !

#'

'

8 6 ! 7

#8

'#

.8 #8

##'

" '

#

# 7 !

#'

. '

6 6 ' /

# ! # (2(%+((* !

9

7

8 8 67 8 #; %((*+(((!!

6A

7

! 67

88

'

!

8'

'7

!

6A

!67

88

7!

7

! $%5&

68 8

6

%,%++(%0 #'

## '

'

= ! 67

'

6

7 # 88

/

! !

!

'

!!

%,7

'

# ' !

'6'

!

!

'6' 7

6 7 88

#!

6 88

! 88 7# 7 '

'7 = ## 8 (%%+%330

'

/8/ # <

8

#

'

/8/ # <

'8

$%)& 8

#

# 88

!

!

# '6'

#

/8/ # <

' 8

!

?

67 88

8 ?

'!

8 ! 8

# /

! # (2(%+((* 8 '

# )

# '7 /

!

/8/ <

8

! # (2(%+((* $%2& /

#

6 /

!

# #

A

8 #

6

!

'

?

8 # 9 '#

## '!

#

## '!

#

'

'7

'

8##.

# 7 7# 03((/)*((4/

6'

$%3& ! !

6 ' A #

#

8 7 #8

# >#

!#

' !

#

6 9 67

$+(& ' # /

/8/ '

7 6

! #(2(%+((* # ' 6

67 8 '

'

# B # ! 6

''7 6 # 8

'78

! % '()'*+ &

#