Sukhpartap Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another
! "#$$%&'&()
*+,-."/#".*&(0- 1$#&#&($/ 2$/'+' *#"#$+(3"4"(5"(#-$/ 1 $'.(5$(#'
/$'$(#) '*-+4/$$#6"+/758%"#$/#-$.$#&#&($/ /*"+/"86-+/"("77+(3"4 / *&5-"(# $-/"7 58%"#$ / /$'.(5$(# 9 %:.;"&("(# <<< "'$ &' 4$&(0 #",$( +. / -$"/&(0 #-/+0- 2&5$ ($/$(%&(05+$##-$+#4/$", 8&5 ."(5$:&%
=&#-#-$%('$(#;$"/($5%+('$;/#-$."/#&$'7#-$%"'$&' ./$.($5/:
##5">"(5&'#",$(+./-$"/&(0#5">&#'$; /">$/&(#-$.$#&#&(+(5$/*$%#&( / &'/?+"'-&(0
@7/$0&'#$/$5+(5$/*$%#&(' A7@7B7
7A"(5 A 7"#;&%$*#"#&("(5&";"+/+7&'#/&%#:/&#'"/
+/";(#-$4"'&'%:./:&'$7(($C+/$9 5"#$5@
# #-$ ./$;&:&("/> -$"/&(07 (#&%$ :#&( D"' &''+$5 (
A
4> #",&(0 &(# "%%+(# #-$ "%# #-"# "#$/ &(8$'#&0"#&(7 %"(%$;;"#&(#-$ D"'/$%::$(5$5&(#-$>$"/
74+##-$'":$ -"5 (# 4$$( ./$'$(#$5 &( +/# "(5 &( #-$ :$"(#&:$7 #-$ ."/#&$' -"5 $(#$/$5&(#"%:./:&'$D-$/$"#$/( B
7;$"/($5*#"#$ +('$; -"5:"5$"'+4:&''&(4$/$#-&' +/##-"#%"(%$;;"#&(/$./#-"54$$( ./$."/$5(
"(5#-"##-$'":$D+;54$./$'$(#$5&( +/#&(
F 5+$%+/'$D-$/$+.(#-$%"'$D"'"53+/($5#B
@ G$"/($57+(3"4'#"#$'#-"##-$%"(%$;;"#&(/$./#%+;5 (#4$./$'$(#$5&( +/#5+$##-$./$8"&;&(0 /("2&/+'"(5$:&% B # ($$5' (#&%&(0 -$/$ #-"# #-$ "/$:$(#&($5 D"' /$0&'#$/$5 (
@ ( #-$ 4"'&' '#"#$:$(# /$'.(5$(# ";;$0&(0#-"##-$.$#&#&($/"%%+'$5D"'5/&8&(0%"/
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
$#&#&($/I'%"/#-"##-$8$-&%;$%:&(0/:"-$"5 0#5":"0$574$'&5$'7"5:&##$5;>(.$/'(-"5'+$/$5"(>&(3+/>&(#-$ &(%&5$(#G$"/($5%+('$;+/#-$/%(#$(5'#-"#D-$(#-$%"/D"'#",$(&(# .;&%$ .''$''&(7 :$%-"(&%"; /$./# D"' 4#"&($5 D-&%- %;"/&&$5 #-$ "%#+:4/",$"&;+/$ :./:&'$ (($C+/$ 9 ! &$ "&5"8&# /$'.(5$(# -"' 4$$(&;$5 $;$8"(#$C#/"%##-$'":$&'/$.
EF
!"#!$%&%'
(
))
*
( ) )
'
'
( ( ' ( ( (
+ ( (( (
,
- + ./ 1. ( ) %$'%.%' 1/&' $2'%%$'%%/
3 ) 4'
5 (
( 6 , 3 7 )8!)5)6 8%1& * 7
G$"/($5 *#"#$ +('$; ( &('#/+%#&(' /: * ";3&(5$/ *&(0-'#"#$'#-"##-$/$&'(%/''%"'$7( ./%$$5&(0'"/$.$(5&(07 4$'&5$'7(%-";;"(-"'4$$(./$'$(#$5#&;;5"#$"(5#-"#%"(%$;;"#&(/$./# 5"#$5
%+;5 (# 4$ '+4:&##$5 &( +/# ( "%%+(# #-$ ./$8"&;&(0 /("2&/+'"(5$:&% &5"8&#&$(($C+/$9 -"'";'4$$(&;$54>/$'.(5$(# 9 %:.;"&("(# '#"#&(0 #-"# #-$ .$#&#&($/ D"' (# "# "+;# "(5 #-$ &(%&5$(#-"5#",$(.;"%$("%%+(#"&;+/$#-$4/",&(0'>'#$:#-$ .$#&#&($/I'8$-&%;$(#-$;&0-##-$.'&#&((#$5"48$7%(#&(+"#&( #-$./%$$5&(0'4>D">
@7/$0&'#$/$5+(5$/
EF *$%#&(' A7@7B7 7A"(5 A 7"#;&%$*#"#&("(5&";" +/+7&'#/&%#:/&#'"/ +/";&'(#3+'#&&$5%%/5&(0;>7#-$&('#"(#%"'$ &'"&#%"'$/#-&' +/##$C$/%&'$&#'&(-$/$(#.D$/'+(5$/*$%#&( / / ?+"'-&(0 #-$ "(5 ";; %(($%#$5 ./%$$5&(0' &( /$'.$%# #-$/$#&(#-$&(#$/$'#3+'#&%$ (#-$%&/%+:'#"(%$'7&(8&$D#-$5$%&'&((I4;$#-$ *+./$:$ +/#&(H
I7 /9 : +3+ 93 : 0 2 "' D$;; "' #-$ ;"D ;"&5 5D( 4> #-$ #-&' +/# &( H
I $9%: +3+ 93 : 1. ( +'$+; .+/.'$ D+;5 4$ '$/8$5 4> ./;(0&(0 #-$ ;&#&0"#&( %%/5&(0;>7&(#-$;&0-##-$.'&#&("'(#$5"48$7
@7/$0&'#$/$5+(5$/*$%#&(' A7@7B7 7A "(5 A 7"#;&%$*#"#&("(5&";"+/+7&'#/&%#:/&#'"/ +/";"(5 ";;'+4'$?+$(#./%$$5&(0'"/&'&(0#-$/$/:"/$; (#-$4"'&' %:./:&'$7(($C+/$9 5"#$5@
$#&#&('#"(5' &(#-$"/$:$(#&($5#$/:'
!"!" <+5
!"(, = 8 > ?
8 = > ?
8